Here, we describe a pre-clinical large-animal (porcine) model of orthotopic heart transplantation that has been firmly established and utilized to investigate novel cardioprotective strategies.
Fifty-years following the first successful report, cardiac transplantation remains the gold-standard treatment for eligible patients with advanced heart failure. Multiple small-animal models of heart transplantation have been used to study the acute and long-term effects of novel therapies. However, few are tested and demonstrated success in clinical trials. It is of critical importance to evaluate new therapies in a clinically relevant large-animal model for efficient and reliable translation of basic studies' findings. Here, we describe a pre-clinical large-animal (porcine) model of orthotopic heart transplantation that has been firmly established and previously used to investigate novel cardioprotective strategies. This procedure focuses on acute ischemia-reperfusion injury and is a reliable method to investigate novel interventions which have been tested and validated in smaller experimental models, such as the murine model. We demonstrate its usefulness in assessing cardiac performance during the early post-transplantation period and other potential possibilities enabled by the model.
Fifty-years following the first successful report, cardiac transplantation remains the gold-standard treatment for eligible patients with advanced heart failure1. Although ischemic times of up to four hours are tolerated adequately, an ischemic time of greater than six hours is associated with inferior outcomes2. Primary graft dysfunction remains the principal cause of early morbidity and mortality following transplantation2,3. The causes of primary graft dysfunction are multifactorial and include the use of marginal organs, recipient pulmonary vascular disease, hyperacute rejection, and ischemia-reperfusion injury sustained at the time of transplantation3.
Multiple studies have investigated novel methods for donor heart preservation to reduce the incidence of primary graft dysfunction4,5,6,7. It is common practice to assess new techniques and treatments in murine models of ischemia-reperfusion injury or heterotopic heart transplantation. Additionally, small animal models permit survival models and long-term follow-up to investigate the development of rejection and cardiac allograft vasculopathy11,12,13. However, most of these strategies fail initial clinical pilot trials or never reach this stage. It is of paramount importance to evaluate new therapies in a clinically relevant large-animal model for efficient and reliable translation of basic studies' findings.
The porcine heart is often considered the most anatomically similar to the human heart when using large-animal models. As such, it is an ideal platform to perform cardiac surgical research. However, there are several important factors to consider when using a porcine model. First, the tissue is typically described as fragile and friable, especially in the right atrium and the pulmonary artery, being prone to tears14. Additionally, the pig heart is considered sensitive to manipulation and prone to arrhythmias, which is why one should routinely administer an anti-arrythmetic to each animal at the beginning of the experiment. An important anatomical difference between the porcine model and clinical heart transplantation is the left hemiazygous vein in the swine which drains directly into the coronary sinus. This has to be ligated during the recipient procedure to avoid continuous bleeding. Finally, the porcine model is very sensitive to ischemia, but it is still appropriate for acute studies in heart transplantation15.
This manuscript describes a pre-clinical large-animal (porcine) model of orthotopic heart transplantation that has been firmly established and utilized to investigate novel cardioprotective strategies5,6,8,9.
The institutional animal care committee approved all experimental protocols and animals were treated following the “Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals” prepared by the Institute of Laboratory Animal Resources, National Research Council, 1996. Male Yorkshire pigs (40–50 kg) were used to perform the orthotopic heart transplants (animal size can vary according to the investigators discretion and experimental goals).
1. Donor Procedure
2. Recipient Procedure:
3. Graft Assessment:
This pre-clinical model has been used successfully since 19945,6,8,9. Table 1 demonstrates representative results from pressure-volume relationships and echocardiographic parameters taken at baseline, and 3 h post-transplantation in a set of 5 experiments. Although we see a decrease in myocadial contractility following transplantation, this was not statistically significant.
Figure 1 shows representative pressure-volume loops collected from one experiment at the same time-points. During "steady-state" assessments (Figure 1, top row). volume-dependent parameters are recorded, such as maximum and minimum rate of developed pressure. Volume-independent parameters are obtained by intermittent occlusion of the IVC. With this, the volume of the left ventricle progressively decreases and different relationships can be calculated. In the middle row of Figure 1, we see the end-systolic and end-diastolic pressure-volume relationships being recorded, which represent the relationship between the end-systolic or end-diastolic pressures, respectively, with the corresponding end-diastolic volume. In the bottom row od Figure 1, we see the recording of preload recruitable stroke work, which is the relationship between the stroke work and the corresponding end-diastolic volume.
Finally, as seen in Figure 2, various other metabolic (e.g., lactate levels and pH) and functional parameters (e.g., cardiac output) can be measured with this model to test different hypotheses.
Figure 1. Representative pressure-volume loops in a steady state, during Interior Vena Cava (IVC) occlusion, and relationships (preload recruitable stroke work). (A) One experiment at baseline. (B) One experiment following 3 h of reperfusion. PRSW = preload recruitable stroke work. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Lactate and pH trends during the heart transplantation protocol. Following reperfusion, there is a significant increase in lactate and decrease in pH. This can be managed by maintaining adequate perfusion pressure with proper volume replacement and vasoactive drug use. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Baseline | 3 hours post-transplant | p-value | |
Pulmonary artery catheter | |||
Cardiac Index (L/min) | 3.7 ± 0.8 | 2.8 ± 0.3 | 0.485 |
Pressure-volume analysis | |||
PRSW (erg∙cm-3∙103) Max dP/dt (mmHg∙s-1) Min dP/dt (mmHg∙s-1) |
62.1 ± 7 2500 ± 425 -1537 ± 238 |
53.8 ± 10 1815 ± 410 -1427 ± 317 |
0.841 0.309 0.547 |
Echocardiography | |||
LV EF (%) LV FAC (%) RV FAC (%) |
47.3 ± 3.0 53.8 ± 3.6 39.2 ± 1.3 |
37.0 ± 4.2 46.4 ± 2.9 32.8 ± 3.6 |
0.095 0.222 0.309 |
Table 1. Representative pressure-volume relationships and echocardiographic parameters from a set of 5 transplants performed at baseline and following 3 h of reperfusion. Data presented as mean ± standard error and compared using the Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test. EF = ejection fraction. FAC = fractional area change. LV = left ventricle. Max dP/dt = maximum rate of pressure change in the left ventricle. Min dP/dt = minimum rate pf pressure change in the left ventricule. PRSW = preload recruitable stroke work. RV = right ventricle.
This manuscript describes a large-animal pre-clinical model of orthotopic heart transplantation. Various small animal models of heterotopic heart transplantation have been successfully used to study the effects of novel treatments to improve organ preservation and decrease ischemia-reperfusion injury11,12,13. Additionally, small animal models permit survival models and long-term follow-up to investigate the development of rejection and cardiac allograft vasculopathy11,12,13. However, most of these novel therapies fail in or never make it to clinical trials. In order to facilitate and streamline clinical translation, a reliable and clinically relevant large-animal model is needed.
This protocol was designed to investigate different treatment and organ preservation strategies to prevent or decrease primary graft dysfunction and ischemia-reperfusion injury. As mentioned above, this model has been used since 1994. Authors previously demonstrated the beneficial effects of hypertonic saline infusion in the donor8 or recipient9 prior to organ procurement or implant, respectively. Furthermore, authors investigated different preservation protocols and strategies, such as the use of donor shed blood infusions during cold storage6 and the effect of insulin supplementation into the cardioplegic solution5.
The major limitation of the technique described here is the short-term follow-up. A long-term survival porcine heart transplant model would be resource-intense and involve high-costs. The procedure described here focuses on acute ischemia-reperfusion injury and is a reliable pre-clinical method to investigate novel interventions which have been tested and validated in smaller experimental models, such as the murine model. In addition, this technique can easily by adapted for longer-term follow-up experiments. This would involve adequate heparin reversal, animal decannulation, adequate hemostasis, and chest closure.
The porcine heart is often considered the most anatomically similar to the human heart when using large-animal models. As such, it is an ideal platform to perform cardiac surgical research. However, it is important to note that the tissue is typically described as fragile and friable, especially in the right atrium and the pulmonary artery, being prone to tears14. Additionally, the pig heart is considered sensitive to manipulation and prone to arrhythmias, which is why magnesium sulfate must be routinely administered to each animal at the beginning of the experiment. An important difference between the porcine model and clinical heart transplantation is the left hemiazygous vein in the swine, which drains directly into the coronary sinus. This has to be ligated during the recipient procedure to avoid continuous bleeding. Finally, the porcine model is very sensitive to ischemia, which seems appropriate for acute studies in heart transplantation15.
Recipient management following transplantation can be challenging at times. It is important to revise all anastomoses and ensure no bleeding. A particularly troublesome area is around the posterior pulmonary artery. As mentioned above, the porcine tissues and fragile and can easily tear; if this happens, the surgeon can quickly go back on CPB to correct the issue and attempt weaning once again. Ventricular fibrillation usually occurs during initial reperfusion; if this does not resolve with simple defibrillation, pharmacological interventions, such as 2 g of magnesium sulphate or 1 mg/kg of lidocaine, can be administered and a following defibrillation should be applied. Normal sinus rhythm can be easily achieved in under 3 min.
This procedure requires at least one trained surgeon to be performed; further, 3 to 5 experiments are needed to optimize the protocol within each research group. Additionally, the team should allocate one member to exclusively perform animal anesthesia and recipient management as needed (e.g. inotropic support). Due to the important considerations regarding the porcine model described above, the following steps are critical in this procedure: anesthetic induction and intubation (important to avoid prolong hypoxemic periods), cardiac manipulation during assessment, cannulation for cardiopulmonary bypass, and right atrial and pulmonary artery manipulation and anastomosis. However, as these are routine steps performed in clinical practice, they should be carried out with care and attention to detail. Consistency and repetition will lead to an optimized and reliable model for various uses.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors have no acknowledgements.
Amiodarone | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Angiocath 20G | BD | 381704 | |
Calcium Chloride 1g/10ml | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Cardioplegia solution | This should be chosen at the investigators discretion. | ||
Cautery Pencil | Covidien | E2515H | |
Central Venous Catheter double-lumen | Cook Medical | C-UDLM-501J-LSC | |
CPB pack | Medtronic | Custom-made cardiopulmonary bypass perfusion circuit. | |
D5W 5% 250ml | Baxter | JB1064 | |
DLP Aortic Root Cannula/stabber | Medtronic | 12218 | |
DLP single-lumen venous cannula (24F or 28F) | This should be chosen at the investigators discretion. | ||
Dobutamine | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Electrode Polyhesive | Covidien | E7507 | |
EOPA arterial cannula (17F or 21F) | This should be chosen at the investigators discretion. | ||
Epinephrine | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Eppendorf Tubes, 1.5 mL | Sarstedt | 72.690.001 | |
Gloves, nitrile, medium | Fischer | 27-058-52 | |
Heparin 1000 IU/ml | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Ketalean (Ketamine) inj. 100mg/ml, 50ml/vial | Health Canada | Requires health canada approval | |
Lidocaine/Xylocaine 1% | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Magnesium Sulfate 5g/10ml | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Midazolam inj. USP 5mg/ml vial/10ml | Health Canada | Requires Health canada approval | |
MPS Quest delivery disposable pack | Quest medical | 5001102-AS | |
NACL 0.9% 1L | Baxter | JB1324 | |
Organ Bag | CardioMed | 2990 | |
Pipette Tips, 1 mL | Fisherbrand | 02-707-405 | |
Propofol 1mg/ml | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Rocuronium | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Set Admin Prim NF PB W/Checkvalve | Smith Medical | 21-0442-25 | Intravenous infusion pump line. Researchers should choose infusion lines compatible with the infusion pump available at their facilities |
Set Intro Sheath 8.5FRx 10CM | Arrow | SI-09880 | |
Sofsilk 0 wax coated | Covidien | S316 | |
Solumedrol 500mg/5ml | Purchased from institutional pharmacy | ||
Suction tip | Covidien | 8888501023 | |
Suction Tubing 1/4" x 120" | Med-Rx | 70-8120 | |
Suture 5.0 Prolene BB | Ethicon | 8580H | |
Suture Prolene Blum 4-0 SH 36 | Ethicon | 8521H | |
Sutures 2.0 Prolene Blu M SH | Ethicon | 8523H | |
Sutures BB 4.0 Prolene | Ethicon | 8881H | |
Tracheal Tube, 6.5mm | Mallinckrodt | 86449 |