Fill out the form to get a free trial:
1Institute for Computational Medicine and the Department of Biomedical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University
Fill out the form to get a free trial:
A methodology to estimate ventricular fiber orientations from in vivo images of patient heart geometries for personalized modeling is described. Validation of the methodology performed using normal and failing canine hearts demonstrate that that there are no significant differences between estimated and acquired fiber orientations at a clinically observable level.
Keywords: Bioengineering, Issue 71, Biomedical Engineering, Medicine, Anatomy, Physiology, Cardiology, Myocytes, Cardiac, Image Processing, Computer-Assisted, Magnetic Resonance Imaging, MRI, Diffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Cardiac Electrophysiology, computerized simulation (general), mathematical modeling (systems analysis), Cardiomyocyte, biomedical image processing, patient-specific modeling, Electrophysiology, simulation
Vadakkumpadan, F., Arevalo, H., Trayanova, N. A. Patient-specific Modeling of the Heart: Estimation of Ventricular Fiber Orientations. J. Vis. Exp. (71), e50125, doi:10.3791/50125 (2013).
Patient-specific simulations of heart (dys)function aimed at personalizing cardiac therapy are hampered by the absence of in vivo imaging technology for clinically acquiring myocardial fiber orientations. The objective of this project was to develop a methodology to estimate cardiac fiber orientations from in vivo images of patient heart geometries. An accurate representation of ventricular geometry and fiber orientations was reconstructed, respectively, from high-resolution ex vivo structural magnetic resonance (MR) and diffusion tensor (DT) MR images of a normal human heart, referred to as the atlas. Ventricular geometry of a patient heart was extracted, via semiautomatic segmentation, from an in vivo computed tomography (CT) image. Using image transformation algorithms, the atlas ventricular geometry was deformed to match that of the patient. Finally, the deformation field was applied to the atlas fiber orientations to obtain an estimate of patient fiber orientations. The accuracy of the fiber estimates was assessed using six normal and three failing canine hearts. The mean absolute difference between inclination angles of acquired and estimated fiber orientations was 15.4 °. Computational simulations of ventricular activation maps and pseudo-ECGs in sinus rhythm and ventricular tachycardia indicated that there are no significant differences between estimated and acquired fiber orientations at a clinically observable level.The new insights obtained from the project will pave the way for the development of patient-specific models of the heart that can aid physicians in personalized diagnosis and decisions regarding electrophysiological interventions.
The computational approach is becoming central to the advancement of the understanding of the function of the heart in health and disease. State-of-the-art whole-heart models of electrophysiology and electromechanics are currently being used to study a wide range of phenomena, such as normal ventricular propagation, arrhythmia, defibrillation, electromechanical coupling, and cardiac resynchronization1. However, for the computational approach to be directly applicable in the clinical environment, it is imperative that the models be patient-specific, i.e. the models must be based on the specific architecture and electrophysiological or electromechanical properties of the patient's diseased heart. Simulation with such models will aid physicians to arrive at highly personalized decisions for electrophysiological interventions as well as prophylaxis, thereby dramatically improving cardiac health care2-4 .
Creation of realistic cardiac models requires the acquisition of the geometry and fiber structure of a patient heart. Fiber orientations determine directions of electrical propagation and strain distributions in the heart, and therefore acquiring them is essential to cardiac modeling5, 6.With recent advances in medical imaging, it is now feasible to obtain the geometry of a patient heart, includingstructural remodeling such as infarction, in vivo with high resolution using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) technologies. However, there is no practical method for acquiring fiber structure of a patient heart in vivo. Diffusion tensor (DT) MRI7, 8, the only technique to acquire fiber orientations of the intact heart, is not widely available in vivo due to certain limitations 9. A brief description of the previous efforts to translate DTMRI to the clinical setting can be found elsewhere 2. Though methodologies such as rule-based assignment of fiber orientations offer alternatives to DTMRI, these methodologies have certain serious limitations 2, 10. Thus difficulties in acquiring cardiac fiber structure in vivo presently impede the application of electrophysiological and electromechanical cardiac simulations in clinical setting. The objective of this research was to directly address this need.
We hypothesized that ventricular fiber orientations of a heart can be accurately predicted given the geometry of the heart and an atlas, where the atlas is a heart whose geometry and fiber orientations are available. Accordingly, we used state of the art techniques to develop a methodology for estimation of cardiac fiber orientations in vivo, and tested the hypothesis in normal and failing canine ventricles2. The central idea of our fiber estimation methodology is to exploit similarities in fiber orientations, relative to geometry, between different hearts in order to approximate the fiber structure of a (target) heart for which only the geometry information is available. At the heart of our estimation methodology is the registration of the atlas geometry with the target geometry using large deformation diffeomorphic metric mapping (LDDMM) 11, and the morphing of atlas fiber orientations using preservation of principal components (PPD) 2, 12.The diffeomorphicproperty of LDDMM guarantees that the atlas does not "foldover" itself during deformation, thereby preserving the integrityof anatomical structures. Figure 1 illustrates the processing pipeline of our methodology. The protocol text section §1 describes the various components of the pipeline by demonstrating how the estimation can be performed for an example patient. The numbers inside some of the blocks in Figure 1 refer to the corresponding subsections under section §1 of the protocol text.
We evaluated the performance of the proposed methodology by quantifying the estimation error, and measuring the effect of this error onsimulations of cardiac electrophysiology, by computationally simulating local electrical activation maps as well as pseudo-electrocardiograms (pseudo-ECGs). Due to the unavailability of human hearts, the performance evaluation was conducted using canine hearts available from previous studies 13-15 . The estimation error was calculated by means of inclination angles 16, followingthe tradition of histology, where angular measurements are performedon tissue sections that are cut parallel to the epicardialsurface. Since the anglebetween the fiber direction and epicardial tangent plane is generallysmall 17, 18, the information loss in describing a fiberdirection entirely using its inclination angle is insignificant. For the computational simulations, image-based models were built as reported previously 19, 20, and cardiac tissue in the models was represented based on established mathematical techniques and experimental data 21-25 . Sinus rhythm was simulated by replicating activation originating from the Purkinje network26, and ventricular tachycardia, by an S1-S2 pacing protocol 27. Pseudo-ECGs were computed 28 and compared using the mean absolute deviation (MAD) metric 29.
1. Fiber Orientations Estimation
2. Measurement of Estimation Error
3. Measurement of the Effects of Estimation Error on Simulations
where σbis the bulk conductivity tensor which is calculated from the bidomain conductivity tensors as described by Potse et al30; Vm is the transmembrane potential; Cm is the membrane specific capacitance; and Iion is the density of the transmembrane current, which in turn depends on Vm and a set of state variables μ describing the dynamics of ionic fluxes across the membrane.For Cm , use a value of 1 μ F/cm2. For σi in normal canine heart models, use longitudinal and transverse conductivity values of 0.34 S/m and 0.06 S/m, respectively. Represent llon by the Greenstein-Winslow ionic models of the canine ventricular myocyte. Decrease the electrical conductivities in canine heart failure ventricular models by 30% (Figure 9).
where X is the ECG waveform of the simulation with estimated fiber orientations, Y is the ECG waveform of thecorresponding simulation with acquired fiber orientations, X is the mean value of X,Y is the mean value of Y, and n is the length of X and Y.
Figure 11, A-C displays streamlined visualizations of estimated as well as DTMRI-derived fiber orientations in normal and failing hearts. Qualitative examination shows that estimated fiber orientations align well with DTMRI-derived ones. Panel D illustrates, overlaid on the geometry of heart 1, the distribution of error in normal hearts' inclination angles, averaged across all five estimates. Panel E shows the mean distribution of error in failing hearts' inclination angles, overlaid on the geometry of heart 1. Note that inclination angles have values between -90 ° and +90 °, and therefore, the estimation error ranges between 0 ° and 180 °. Panels F and G present sections of tissue from the distributions in panels D and E, respectively. This highlights the transmural variation of error. The histograms of errors in panel H suggest that most myocardial voxels have small error values. About 80% and 75% of the voxels have errors less than 20 ° in normal and failing ventricles, respectively. It was found that the mean error, averaged across all estimated datasets, and all image voxels that belonged to the myocardium, were 14.4 ° and 16.9 ° in normal and failing ventricles, respectively. The mean error in the entire myocardium, in normal and failing cases combined, was 15.4 °. The mean 3D acute angle between estimated and acquired fiber directions were 17.5 ° and 18.8 ° in normal and failing ventricles, respectively. The 3-D angles are comparable to the estimation errors.These results show that inclination angles of predicted fiber orientations are comparable to those acquired by ex-vivo DTMRI, the state-of-the-art technique.The standard deviation of error across the fivedifferent estimates of the fiber orientations of heart 1 was only 1.9 indicating that the variation in estimation quality from oneatlas to another is small.
Figures 12 and 13 present the simulated activation maps of one beat of sinus rhythm activation in normal and failing ventricular models, respectively. Models with estimated fiber orientations produce activation maps very similar to those of models with acquired orientations; the earliest epicardial activations occur at the same sites, and the directions of propagation match as well. The overall mean difference in total activation times between the acquired and estimated fiber orientation cases in the normal ventricular models, averaged over all estimates and all mesh nodes, was 5.7 ms, which is a small fraction (3.7% on average) of the total activation time. Figure 12C demonstrates that pseudo-ECGs obtained for sinus rhythm simulations with models 1 and 3 have identical morphologies. The MAD score between these two waveforms was 4.14%. On average, the MAD score between sinus rhythm pseudo-ECGs with each of models 2 to 6 and model 1 was 10.9%.In simulations of sinus rhythm with failing ventricular models, the mean difference in total activation times between models with acquired and estimated fiber orientations was only 5.2 ms (3.1%), while the mean MAD score was 4.68%. These results indicate that the outcomes of simulation of ventricular activation in sinus rhythm in normal and failing canine ventricular models with fiber orientations estimated with the present methodology closely match those with acquired orientations. In particular, presence of heart failure did not diminish the accuracy of the estimation.
Figure 14 shows simulated activation maps, in apical views of the ventricles, during one cycle of induced VT in the heart failure models, and corresponding pseudo-ECGs. Simulations with acquired and estimated fiber orientation both exhibit similar figure-of-eight reentrant patterns. The ECG morphologies corresponding to estimated and acquired fiber orientations were in good agreement. The mean MAD score was 9.3%. These results indicate that canine heart failure models with estimated fiber orientations can closely replicate outcomes of VT simulations performed using acquired fiber orientations.
Figure 1. Our processing pipeline for estimating ventricular fiber orientations in vivo. Click here to view larger figure.
Figure 2. Geometry and fiber orientations of the atlas ventricles. (A) The epicardial (red) and endocardial (green and magenta) splines, and corresponding landmarks (yellow) overlaid on an example slice of the atlas image. (B) The atlas ventricles in 3D. (C) The atlas fiber orientations.
Figure 3. Patient ventricular geometry reconstruction. (A) The epicardial (red) and endocardial (green and magenta) splines, and corresponding landmarks (yellow) overlaid on an image slice. (B) Patient ventricles in 3D.
Figure 4. Deformation of the atlas ventricles to match the patient ventricles. (A) Superimposition of ventricles of atlas (magenta, see Figure 2B) and patient (red, see Figure 3B). (B) Patient ventricles and the affine transformed atlas ventricles. (C) Patient ventricles and LDDMM-transformed atlas ventricles.
Figure 5. Estimated fiber orientations of the patient heart in Figure 3B.
Figure 6. Segmentation of canine hearts. The epicardial (blue) and endocardial (red and magenta) splines, and corresponding landmarks (green) overlaid on an example slice of a normal canine heart.
Figure 7. The acquired and estimated fiber orientations of heart 1.
Figure 8. The acquired and estimated fiber orientations of hearts 7-9.
Figure 9. Left panel illustrates the computational mesh generated for the models of heart 1. On the right, the action potential curve of normal canine ventricular myocardium computed using the Greenstein-Winslow model is displayed.
Figure 10. Pacing sites of the simulation of sinus rhythm and VT, as overlaid on the geometry of heart 7. E1E2 illustrates the lead vector used in pseudo-ECG calculations.
Figure 11. Validation of the fiber orientation estimation methodology by comparing estimated fiber orientations with DTMRI-derived orientations. (A) Superimposition of DTMRI-acquired fiber orientations (greenish yellow) and one set of estimated fiber orientations (cyan) of heart 1. (B) Acquired and estimated fiber orientations of heart 7. (C) An enlarged portion of (B) showing alignment between acquired and estimated fiber orientations. Note that the streamlines were generated at random locations within the myocardium for visualization purposes only, and so their exact positions are irrelevant. (D) Distribution of mean estimation error in normal ventricles. (E) Distribution of mean estimation error in failing ventricles. (F) A section of tissue extracted from (D). (G) A section of tissue extracted from (E). The colorbar applies to D-G. (H) Histograms of errors in normal and failing ventricles. Frequency denotes the number of voxels having a given error.
Figure 12. Results from simulations of one beat of sinus rhythm in normal canine ventricular models. (A) Activation map simulated using the model with acquired fiber orientations (model 1). (B) Absolute difference between simulated activation maps obtained from a ventricular model with acquired fiber orientations and that with estimated fiber orientations, averaged over the five estimates. (C) Simulated pseudo-ECGs with models 1 and 3. (D) Simulated activation maps from ventricles with estimated fiber orientations (models 2-6).
Figure 13. Results from simulations of one beat of sinus rhythm in failing heart models. In th e first column, rows 1-3 show activation maps calculated using models 7-9, respectively. In the second column, rows 1-3 display results of simulations with models 10-12, respectively. Rows 1-3 in the third column portray the absolute difference between the activation maps shown in the first and second columns of the corresponding row. Rows in the fourth column display simulated pseudo-ECGs from models in the first and second columns of the corresponding row.
Figure 14. Results from simulations of VT induction with the failing heart models. Rows 1-3 in the first column show activation maps during one cycle of reentrant activity in simulations with models 7-9, respectively. Rows 1-3 in the second column show activation maps corresponding to models 10-12, respectively. Rows in the third column illustrate pseudo-ECGs from models in the first and second columns of the corresponding row.
This research demonstrates quantitatively that, in the absence of DTMRI, myocardial fiber orientations of normal and failing ventricles can be estimated from in-vivo images of their geometries for use in simulations of cardiac electrophysiology. The proposed methodology is demonstrated with in vivo CT data, but it is equally applicable to in vivo MR images of ventricular geometry, addressing the lack of ability to directly acquire patient fiber orientations. It is thus an important step towards the development of personalized models of ventricular electrophysiology for clinical applications. The methodology can also be used to estimate the fiber orientations in ex-vivo hearts with high resolution. This is especially helpful when acquiring sub-millimeter resolution DTMRI images is difficult or prohibitively expensive, due to the very long acquisition times.
Our electrophysiological simulations suggested that activation maps were not very sensitive to changes in fiber orientations. More importantly, we demonstrated that effects of fiber estimation errors on gross electrophysiology were insignificant at a clinically observable level by means of the MAD score of the pseudo-ECGs. The MAD metric was suitablebecause it has been utilized in clinical studies, to compareECGs of reentrant activity and paced propagation for localizationof the organizing centers of reentrant circuits 29. A MADscore of less than 12%, a threshold that our results satisfy, implies that the two underlying propagationpatterns are clinically equivalent.Note that the similarity of propagation patterns will translate to low differences in mechanical activation patterns as well, as reported experiments show that local electrical and mechanical activation times during sinus rhythm are highly correlated. In summary, our research will facilitate ventricular simulation studies of any species in health and disease when it is not feasible to acquire fiber orientations using DTMRI. In particular, the proposed methodology paves the way for patient-specific modeling of ventricular whole-heart electrophysiology (and possibly) electromechanics based only on in vivo clinical imaging data. Simulations with such models may ultimately aid physicians to arrive at highly personalized decisions for therapeutic interventions as well as prophylaxis. Incidentally, our results indicated that the performance of the proposed methodology was independent of the choice of the atlas.Accordingly, for the purposes of this study, a statistical atlas 17, 31 may not be required.
The current study has some limitations. Firstly, human heart image data were not available to us, and therefore theproposed estimation methodology was validated with imagesof canine hearts. We expect that the methodology will accuratelyestimate fiber orientations in human hearts as well because,just as in canine hearts, fiber orientations relative to geometry have been shown to be similar between different human hearts 17. Also, we tested our methodology in normal andfailing hearts only. It would be important to test it under conditions such as myocardial infarction and hypertrophy, where fiber disorganizations are known to occur32, 33.
No conflicts of interest declared.
We thank Drs. Raimond Winslow, Elliot McVeigh, and Patrick Helm at Johns Hopkins University for providing the ex vivo datasets online.This research was supported by National Institutes of Health grant R01-HL082729, and National Science Foundation grant CBET-0933029.
|LDDMM||Johns Hopkins University||http://cis.jhu.edu/software/lddmm-volume/index.php|
|ImageJ||National Institutes of Health||http://rsbweb.nih.gov/ij/|
|Tarantula||CAE Software Solutions||http://www.meshing.at/Spiderhome/Tarantula.html|
|Canine images||Johns Hopkins University||http://www.ccbm.jhu.edu/research/DTMRIDS.php|
You must be signed in to post a comment. Please sign in or create an account.