anticancer-metal-complexes-synthesis-cytotoxicity-evaluation-mtt

Anticancer Metal Complexes: Synthesis and Cytotoxicity Evaluation by the MTT Assay

Titanium (IV) and vanadium (V) complexes are highly potent anticancer agents. A challenge in their synthesis refers to their hydrolytic instability; ...

The Hebrew University of Jerusalem

We recently introduced a new class of bis(isopropoxo)-Ti(IV) complexes with diamine bis(phenolato) ligands that possess antitumor activity against colon HT-29 and ovarian OVCAR-1 cells that is higher than that of the known Ti(IV) compounds titanocene dichloride and budotitane as well as that of cisplatin. Herein, we elaborate on this family of compounds; we discuss the effect of structural parameters on the cytotoxic activity and hydrolytic behavior of these complexes, seeking a relationship between the two. Whereas complexes with small steric groups around the metal center possess high activity and lead mostly to formation of O-bridged polynuclear complexes with bound bis(phenolato) ligand upon water addition, bulky complexes hydrolyze to release all free ligands and are inactive. Slightly increasing the size of the N-donor substituents probably weakens the ligand binding in solution, and, thus, rapid hydrolysis is observed, leading to a lack of cytotoxicity, supporting the requirement for ligand inertness. Replacing the two isopropoxo ligands with a single catecholato unit gives a complex with a different geometry that exhibits slower hydrolysis and reduced cytotoxicity, suggesting some participation of labile ligand hydrolysis in the cytotoxicity mechanism. A crystallographically characterized O-bridged polynuclear species obtained from a biologically active bis(isopropoxo) complex upon water addition is inactive, which rules out its participation as the active species, yet suggests some role of the particular steric and electronic requirements allowing its formation in the activity mechanism. Additional measurements support rapid formation of the active species in the presence of cells prior to O-bridged Ti(IV) cluster formation.

Synthesis, characterization, cytotoxicity, and hydrolytic behavior of C2- and C1-symmetrical Ti(IV) complexes of tetradentate diamine bis(phenolato) ligands: a new class of antitumor agents.

Bis(isopropoxo) Ti(IV) complexes of diamino bis(phenolato) "salan" ligands were prepared, their hydrolysis in 1:9 water/THF solutions was investigated, and their cytotoxicity toward colon HT-29 and ovarian OVCAR-1 cells was measured. In particular, electronic effects at positions ortho and para to the binding phenolato unit were analyzed. We found that para substituents of different electronic features, including Me, Cl, OMe, and NO(2), have very little influence on hydrolysis rate, and all para-substituted ortho-H complexes hydrolyze slowly to give O-bridged clusters with a t(1/2) of 1-2 h for isopropoxo release. Consequently, no clear cytotoxicity pattern is observed as well, where the largest influence of para substituents appears to be of a steric nature. These complexes exhibit IC(50) values of 2-18 μM toward the cells analyzed, with activity which is mostly higher than those of Cp(2)TiCl(2), (bzac)(2)Ti(OiPr)(2) and cisplatin. On the contrary, major electronic effects are observed for substituents at the ortho position, with an influence that exceeds even that of steric hindrance. Ortho-chloro or -bromo substituted compounds possess extremely high hydrolytic stability where no major isopropoxo release as isopropanol occurs for days. In accordance, very high cytotoxicity toward colon and ovarian cells is observed for ortho-Cl and -Br complexes, with IC(50) values of 1-8 μM, where the most cytotoxic complexes are the ortho-Cl-para-Me and ortho-Br-para-Me derivatives. In this series of ortho-substituted complexes, the halogen radius is of lesser influence both on hydrolysis and on cytotoxicity, while OMe substituents do not impose similar effect of hydrolytic stability and cytotoxicity enhancement. Therefore, hydrolytic stability and cytotoxic activity are clearly intertwined, and thus this family of readily available Ti(IV) salan complexes exhibiting both features in an enhanced manner is highly attractive for further exploration.

Different ortho and para electronic effects on hydrolysis and cytotoxicity of diamino bis(phenolato) "salan" Ti(IV) complexes.

A series of Ti(IV) complexes containing diamino bis(phenolato) "salan" type ligands with NH coordination were prepared, and their hydrolysis and cytotoxicity were analyzed and compared to the N-methylated analogues. Substituting methyl groups on the coordinative nitrogen donor of highly active and stable Ti(IV) salan complexes with H atoms has two main consequences: the hydrolysis rate increases and the cytotoxic activity diminishes. In addition, the small modification of a single replacement of Me with H leads to a different major hydrolysis product, where a dinuclear Ti(IV) complex with two bridging oxo ligands is obtained, as characterized by X-ray crystallography, rather than a trinuclear cluster. A partial hydrolysis product containing a single oxo bridge was also crystallographically analyzed. Investigation of a series of complexes with NH donors of different steric and electronic effects revealed that cytotoxicity may be restored by fine tuning these parameters even for complexes of low stability.

Major impact of N-methylation on cytotoxicity and hydrolysis of salan Ti(IV) complexes: sterics and electronics are intertwined.

A nanoformulated trinuclear hydrolysis product of a bis(alkoxo) salan-Ti(IV) complex shows high antitumor activity, which identifies it as an active species in cells. Additional highly stable mononuclear derivatives also show high activity, when formulated into nanoparticles, thus evincing that biologically friendly Ti(IV) can provide high cytotoxicity with controlled biological function.

High antitumor activity of highly resistant salan-titanium(IV) complexes in nanoparticles: an identified active species.

Nanoparticles of titanium(IV) complexes of phenolato ligands were formed and evaluated for cytotoxicity toward human HT-29 colon cancer, murine T-25 lymphoma, and murine HU-2 multidrug-resistant (MDR) cells. The nano-formulation, besides increasing the complexes' shelf lives, is particularly efficient in overcoming limitations in solubility and cell-penetration, thus enhancing biological accessibility; large complexes that were inactive when measured in a non-formulated form showed marked activity when nano-formulated. For active and accessible small complexes, the effect of the formulation was negligible. Most complexes showed similar activity toward MDR cells and their drug-sensitive analogues, further increasing their therapeutic potential. An exception is a particularly hydrophobic complex, which is presumably more accessible to interaction with the membrane ABCB1 (MDR1) transporter active in the multidrug resistance of HU-2 cells. The most efficient compound is a mononuclear complex of a single hexadentate ligand, combining particularly high activity and hydrolytic stability with accessibility aided by the nano-formulation. 

Anti-proliferative activity of nano-formulated phenolato titanium(IV) complexes against cancer cells.

Titanium(IV) complexes exhibit high potential as anti-tumor agents, particularly due to their low intrinsic toxicity and cytotoxicity toward cisplatin resistant cells. Nevertheless, Ti(IV) complexes generally undergo rapid hydrolysis that previously hampered their utilization as anticancer drugs. We recently overcame this difficulty by developing a highly stable Ti(IV) complex that is based on tetra-phenolato, hexadentate ligand, formulated into organic nanoparticles. Herein we investigated the activity of this complex in vitro and in vivo. Although inactive when tested directly due to poor solubility, when formulated, this complex displayed (a) high cytotoxicity toward cisplatin resistant human ovarian cells, A2780-cp, with resistance factor of 1.1; (b) additive behavior in combination with cisplatin toward ovarian and colon cancer cells; (c) selectivity toward cancer cells as implied by its mild activity toward non-cancerous, fibroblast lung cells, MRC-5; (d) high stability and durability as manifested by the ability to maintain cytotoxicity, even following one week of incubation in 100% aquatic medium solution; and (e) in vivo efficacy toward solid tumors of human colon cancer cells, HT-29, in nude mice without any clinical signs of toxicity. These features support the formulated phenolato Ti(IV) complex being an effective and selective anti-tumoral agent. 

Highly Stable Tetra-Phenolato Titanium(IV) Agent Formulated into Nanoparticles Demonstrates Anti-Tumoral Activity and Selectivity.

Octahedral titanium(IV) complexes of phenolato hexadentate ligands were developed and showed very high stability for days in water solutions. In vitro cytotoxicity studies showed that, whereas tetrakis(phenolato) systems are generally of low activity presumably due to inaccessibility, smaller bis(phenolato)bis(alkoxo) complexes feature high anticancer activity and accessibility even without formulations, also toward a cisplatin-resistant cell line. An all-aliphatic control complex was unstable and inactive. A leading phenolato complex also revealed: 1) high durability in fully aqueous solutions; accordingly, negligible loss of activity after preincubation for three days in medium or in serum; 2) maximal cellular accumulation and induction of apoptosis following 24-48 h of administration; 3) reduced impact on noncancerous fibroblast cells; 4) in vivo efficacy toward lymphoma cells in murine model; 5) high activity in NCI-60 panel, with average GI50 of 4.6±2 μm. This newly developed family of Ti(IV) complexes is thus of great potential for anticancer therapy. 

Article	Year
Synthesis, characterization, cytotoxicity, and hydrolytic behavior of C2- and C1-symmetrical Ti(IV) complexes of tetradentate diamine bis(phenolato) ligands: a new class of antitumor agents. Chemistry (Weinheim an der Bergstrasse, Germany)\| PubMed ID: 19156656	2009
Different ortho and para electronic effects on hydrolysis and cytotoxicity of diamino bis(phenolato) "salan" Ti(IV) complexes. Inorganic chemistry\| PubMed ID: 21214265	2011
Major impact of N-methylation on cytotoxicity and hydrolysis of salan Ti(IV) complexes: sterics and electronics are intertwined. Dalton transactions (Cambridge, England : 2003)\| PubMed ID: 21874187	2011
High antitumor activity of highly resistant salan-titanium(IV) complexes in nanoparticles: an identified active species. Angewandte Chemie (International ed. in English)\| PubMed ID: 22961758	2012
Anti-proliferative activity of nano-formulated phenolato titanium(IV) complexes against cancer cells. ChemMedChem\| PubMed ID: 24677761	2014
Highly Stable Tetra-Phenolato Titanium(IV) Agent Formulated into Nanoparticles Demonstrates Anti-Tumoral Activity and Selectivity. Molecules (Basel, Switzerland)\| PubMed ID: 26473816	2015
Specific Design of Titanium(IV) Phenolato Chelates Yields Stable and Accessible, Effective and Selective Anticancer Agents. Chemistry (Weinheim an der Bergstrasse, Germany)\| PubMed ID: 27320784	2016

Sigalit Meker

Biography

JoVE Journal Publications

Other Publications