7.6
Vertical Marketing Systems
A Vertical Marketing System (VMS) is the distribution channel arrangement in which producers, wholesalers, and retailers collaborate as a unified syst…
A Vertical Marketing System or VMS is a channel structure that aims to achieve economies of scale and increase cost efficiency by uniting producers, wholesalers, and retailers into a cohesive system.
There are three main types of Vertical Marketing Systems: corporate, contractual, and administered.
A Corporate VMS consolidates all stages of production and distribution under single ownership.
For instance, the fashion brand Zara uses IT systems to manage the in-house design, production, and retail operations to control every stage of the supply chain.
In a Contractual VMS, independent wholesalers and retailers collaborate through contractual agreements at various distribution stages.
Ford exemplifies this as it licenses exclusive dealerships for product distribution and establishes a contractually coordinated distribution chain.
Lastly, an Administered VMS is a distribution system where one dominant member, usually a manufacturer or retailer, coordinates and oversees the activities of other members due to its size and influence.
For example, Walmart acts as the dominant force in the value chain because of its high purchasing volumes. This enables them to negotiate lower prices from suppliers.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Business videos
Q1: What is a Vertical Marketing System and why do companies use it?
A Vertical Marketing System (VMS) is a channel structure that unites producers, wholesalers, and retailers into a cohesive system to achieve economies of scale and increase cost efficiency. Companies adopt VMS to improve coordination, reduce duplication, enhance quality control, and strengthen bargaining power with suppliers. The unified approach ensures consistent customer experience and brand messaging across all distribution levels.
Q2: What are the three main types of Vertical Marketing Systems?
The three types are corporate, contractual, and administered VMS. Corporate VMS consolidates all production and distribution stages under single ownership, like Zara's integrated design and retail operations. Contractual VMS involves independent wholesalers and retailers collaborating through formal agreements, exemplified by Ford's exclusive dealership network. Administered VMS features one dominant member coordinating others through influence and size, as Walmart does with suppliers.
Q3: How does a Corporate VMS differ from other VMS types?
A Corporate VMS consolidates all stages of production and distribution under single ownership, providing complete control over the supply chain. Unlike contractual and administered systems that rely on agreements or influence, corporate VMS eliminates intermediaries and coordination challenges. This vertical integration allows companies like Zara to manage design, production, and retail operations seamlessly through integrated IT systems.
Q4: What advantages does an Administered VMS provide to dominant members?
In an Administered VMS, the dominant member—typically a large manufacturer or retailer—coordinates channel activities through its size and influence without formal ownership. This structure enables significant bargaining power with suppliers. Walmart exemplifies this by leveraging high purchasing volumes to negotiate lower prices, reducing costs across the distribution logistics and supply chain while maintaining coordination without full ownership.
Q5: What are the main drawbacks of implementing a Vertical Marketing System?
VMS implementation presents significant challenges including potential conflict and power struggles among channel members, particularly in contractual and administered systems. Individual members may experience reduced flexibility and autonomy as the unified system prioritizes overall efficiency. These constraints can limit independent decision-making and create tension between centralized coordination goals and member interests.
Q6: How does a Contractual VMS structure distribution relationships?
A Contractual VMS establishes formal agreements between independent wholesalers and retailers at various distribution stages, creating a coordinated but legally separate system. Ford demonstrates this model through exclusive dealership licensing arrangements that establish contractually coordinated distribution chains. This approach balances coordination benefits with member independence while maintaining clear contractual obligations.
Q7: What factors influence a company's choice of VMS type?
Companies select VMS types based on industry characteristics, market conditions, and specific business goals. The choice depends on whether the organization prioritizes complete control through corporate ownership, flexibility through contractual agreements, or leveraging dominant market position through administered coordination. Each type offers distinct trade-offs between efficiency, control, and operational autonomy.