1.10
测量不确定度：阅读仪器
计数是没有不确定性的测量类型，前提是要计算的对象数量在此过程中不发生变化。这样的测量会得出准确的数字。例如，通过对纸箱中的鸡蛋计数，可以准确确定纸箱中有多少个鸡蛋。同样的，所定义的数量的数字也是准确的。例如，1英尺精确为12英寸，1英寸精确为2.54厘米，1克精确为0.001千克。但是，由于所使用的…
根据规定的数量进行测量 或者对不同物体的直接计数 可以给出确切的数字。例如，一打香蕉就是正好 12 个香蕉。同样地，纸箱里的苹果也可以直接进行计数。然而，其他测量并不精确，并且由于测量过程的局限性而具有 与之相关的不确定性。比如一个参加 5 公里赛跑的赛跑者。评委们用一个简单的模拟手表 和一个数字手表来记录完成时间。模拟手表读取的完成时间 为 25 至 30 分钟，因此，评委们估计时间是 28 分钟。只有第一个数字"2"是确定的。最后一个数字"8"是 25 到 30 之间的估计值，因此是不确定的。另一方面，数字手表 的读数是 26.25 分钟，前三位数字 是完全确定的。完成时间可能在 26.24 到 26.26 分钟之间，但肯定不是 28 分钟。在实验室环境中，数字天平 可显示多达六位数的读数。读数为 10.1241 克表示 前 5 位数字是确定的，但最后一位数字是不确定的。但是，数字仪表上 显示的所有数字都要进行报告。相反，在读取模拟仪表时，最后一个数字必须进行估计。一个 50 毫升刻度的量筒可能 每一毫升都有标记。测量读数取决于估算 弯月面处的液体体积，弯月面 是量筒内液体曲面上的 最低点。如果弯月面位于 42 和 43 的标记之间，则液体量大于 42 毫升 但小于 43 毫升。测量值应在两个标记之间进行 估计；因此，体积的读数应 精确到 0.1 毫升。在这种情况下，弯月面更接近 43 毫升 的标记，因此这个数字可以报告为 42.8。另一个人可以估计体积为 42.7 或 42.9 因为最后一个数字不确定，但是测量值 应始终报告到最后一个不确定数字。
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: Why do some measurements have uncertainty while others don't?
Counting distinct objects or using defined quantities produces exact numbers with no uncertainty. For example, a dozen bananas is exactly 12, and 1 foot is exactly 12 inches. However, measurements derived from instruments like graduated cylinders or balances have uncertainty due to practical limitations in the measurement process and the user's ability to read the instrument precisely.
Q2: How do you read the volume from a graduated cylinder accurately?
Read the volume by observing the meniscus, the lowest point on the curved surface of liquid. If the meniscus falls between two markings, estimate the volume to one decimal place beyond the marked divisions. For a cylinder with 1-mL markings, report volume to the nearest 0.1 mL. The last digit is always an estimate, but it must be reported to indicate measurement precision.
Q3: What's the difference between reading analog and digital instruments?
Analog instruments require you to estimate the final digit between marked divisions, making it uncertain. Digital instruments display all digits with certainty except the last one, which represents the instrument's limit of precision. All numbers shown on a digital display must be reported, whereas analog readings depend on the observer's estimation skill.
Q4: How does instrument sensitivity affect measurement uncertainty?
More sensitive instruments provide measurements with smaller uncertainty ranges. A standard balance reading 5.74 grams has uncertainty of ±0.01 grams, while a more sensitive balance reading 5.743 grams has uncertainty of ±0.001 grams. The additional decimal place indicates greater precision and reduced uncertainty in the measurement.
Q5: Why should you report all digits displayed on a digital balance?
All digits on a digital display represent the measurement capability of that instrument. A digital balance showing 10.1241 grams indicates the first five digits are certain and the last digit is uncertain, but all must be reported. This practice communicates the full precision of the measurement and prevents loss of information about what the instrument can measure.
Q6: Can different people obtain the same measurement from an analog instrument?
No, different observers may estimate the uncertain final digit differently. When a meniscus lies between 42 and 43 mL markings, one person might read 42.8 mL while another reads 42.7 or 42.9 mL. All estimates are reasonable since the last digit is uncertain, but measurements should always be reported to that uncertain digit to show measurement precision.
Q7: How does measurement uncertainty relate to accuracy and precision?
Measurement uncertainty arises from the device used and the user's ability to read it. Understanding uncertainty in measurement accuracy and precision helps explain why different instruments or observers produce slightly different results. Recognizing these limitations is essential for proper data reporting and interpretation in scientific work.