Name: concrete strength testing: tension vs. compression
Uploaded: 2024-11-07T14:48:31.000Z
Duration: 1 min 30 s
Channel: JoVE

La relation entre les résistances à la traction et à la compression du béton n'est pas directement proportionnelle mais étroitement liée.
La résistance à la traction augmente plus lentement que la résistance à la compression et est influencée par plusieurs facteurs, notamment les méthodes d'essai, les dimensions de l'échantillon, la texture de l'agrégat et la teneur en humidité du béton.
Les essais de tension directe sont difficiles en raison des problèmes de préhension de l’éprouvette et d’évitement des charges excentriques, ce qui les rend rares. Au lieu de cela, les essais de flexion et les essais de traction par fendillement vérifient les performances sous tension indirecte.
La plus grande taille des échantillons de laboratoire pour la tension directe signifie qu’à mesure que le volume augmente, la probabilité de rencontrer un point faible augmente également, ce qui peut conduire à une défaillance.
Les agrégats concassés angulaires améliorent la résistance à la flexion par rapport au gravier arrondi en raison d’une meilleure liaison. La forme de l'agrégat a peu d'effet sur la résistance à la rupture et à la traction directe du béton.
Le rapport de résistance à la flexion par rapport à la résistance à la compression est également plus élevé pour les agrégats angulaires, en particulier à des résistances à la compression plus élevées.
L’humidité du béton a un impact sur la résistance du béton ; comparativement, le béton durci et stocké à sec a une résistance à la compression plus élevée que le béton stocké en continu par voie humide.
Bien que la relation entre ses résistances à la flexion et à la compression soit également affectée, les résistances à la fendillement et à la traction directe restent constantes.

relation entre la résistance à la traction et la résistance à la compression du béton

Relation Between Tensile Strength and Compressive Strength of Concrete

Le béton est un matériau de construction fondamental et il est essentiel de comprendre ses points forts pour les projets de construction. La relation entre ses résistances à la traction et à la compression est complexe, ce qui montre que même si ces résistances sont liées, elles n'augmentent pas au même rythme. La croissance de la résistance à la traction est plus lente et est affectée par divers facteurs tels que les méthodes utilisées pour les tests, la taille et la forme de l'échantillon, la texture des granulats utilisés et la teneur en humidité du béton. En raison de la difficulté à réaliser des essais de traction directe, qui impliquent souvent des complications pour saisir l'échantillon sans introduire de charges excentriques, des méthodes indirectes telles que les essais de flexion et de fendage sont couramment utilisées.


 Le type de granulat a peu d'influence sur la résistance à la traction directe et la fissuration du béton. Cependant, l'utilisation de granulats concassés angulaires entraîne une plus grande résistance à la flexion par rapport à l'utilisation de graviers arrondis, en raison de sa capacité de liaison améliorée, même s'il est moins efficace en traction. La résistance à la compression reste pratiquement inchangée par la forme ou la texture du granulat. Par conséquent, le rapport entre la résistance à la flexion et la résistance à la compression est plus prononcé lorsque des granulats concassés angulaires sont utilisés, en particulier à des niveaux de résistance à la compression plus élevés. De plus, les conditions de cure et de stockage du béton, en particulier les niveaux d'humidité, ont un effet prononcé sur ses résistances à la compression et à la traction, ce qui fait de la gestion de ces conditions un aspect essentiel des essais et de l'application de la résistance du béton.

Relation entre la résistance à la traction et la résistance à la compression du béton

La relation entre les résistances à la traction et à la compression du béton n'est pas directement proportionnelle mais étroitement liée.
La résistance à la traction augmente plus lentement ...

relation-between-tensile-strength-and-compressive-strength-of-concrete

Education

Enseignement

JoVE Core

Civil Engineering

Génie civil

Unit 1

Unité 1

Strength of Concrete

Résistance du béton

KEY TERMS AND CONCEPTS

TERMES ET CONCEPTS CLÉS

concrete strength testing: tension vs. compression

Concrete strength testing compares tensile strength and compressive strength. These two properties are related, but they do not rise at the same rate. Tensile strength usually grows more slowly than compressive strength, so the balance between them changes as concrete gets stronger.

Several factors affect tensile strength measurements. The test method, specimen size and shape, aggregate texture, and moisture content can all change the result. Direct tension tests are difficult to perform because gripping the sample can create eccentric loads, which makes the test less reliable.

For that reason, indirect tests are often used instead. Flexure tests measure how a concrete sample bends, and splitting tests measure how it breaks under pressure. These methods give useful information about tensile behavior when direct tension testing is hard to carry out.

Aggregate type has little effect on direct tensile strength and splitting tensile strength. However, angular crushed aggregate can produce greater flexural strength than rounded gravel because it bonds better. Even so, crushed aggregate is less effective in tension. Compressive strength is mostly unaffected by aggregate shape or texture.

The ratio of flexural strength to compressive strength becomes more noticeable when angular crushed aggregate is used, especially at higher compressive strengths. Curing and storage also matter. Moisture levels during these stages can strongly affect both compressive and tensile strength, so careful control of storage conditions is important in concrete testing and use.

Concrete Strength Testing: Tension vs. Compression

concrete-strength-testing-tension-vs-compression

tensile strength considerations of concrete

tensile-strength-considerations-of-concrete

How Cracks Limit Concrete Strength

Concrete tensile strength is limited by tiny cracks inside the material. The cement paste itself can be much stronger in theory than it is in practice. In real concrete, the measured strength can be up to a thousand times lower than the theoretical value. These small cracks help explain that gap. When a load is applied, stress rises at the crack tips. This idea is described by Griffith's theory of brittle fracture. In brittle materials, cracks can grow quickly once the stress at their tips...

behavior of concrete under compressive load

behavior-of-concrete-under-compressive-load

Concrete Failure Patterns Under Compression

Concrete failure patterns under compression show how the material responds to different kinds of direct stress. These patterns help explain concrete’s structural integrity. Under uniaxial compression, where force acts in one direction, cracks often form parallel to the load. These parallel cracks come from local tensile stress, which is pulling stress that appears perpendicular to the compression direction. As uniaxial loading continues, angled cracks may also appear. These cracks are linked...

porosity in cement paste

How Cement Curing Changes Porosity

Cement curing changes porosity in the hardened paste. Porosity means the void spaces inside concrete. These spaces affect both strength and durability. When water and cement react, hydration forms a semi-solid paste that traps water in different ways. Some of that water becomes combined water. It makes up about 23% of the cement's dry mass. Other water stays as gel water, which fills very small voids called gel pores. Gel pores account for about 28% of the cement gel volume. The...

total voids in concrete

Concrete Voids and Strength

Concrete voids affect both strength and permeability. They include gel water, capillary pores, and entrapped air. In hydrated cement paste, gel water is held within the cement hydration products. Physically entrapped or adsorbed water also supports the hydration process. As cement hydrates, the space needed for the products from a cubic centimeter of cement is estimated to double. Capillary pores are the open spaces left inside the hydrated paste. Their size depends mainly on the...

pore size distribution

Concrete Porosity and Durability

Concrete porosity and durability depend strongly on pore size distribution in hardened cement paste. Capillary pores are much larger than gel pores, and in partially hydrated cement paste they form a connected network that lowers strength and raises permeability. Higher permeability makes concrete more vulnerable to freeze-thaw damage and chemical attack. The risk also depends on the water-to-cement ratio. A higher ratio can leave more space for capillary pores to remain open. As cement...

microcracking in concrete

How Concrete Cracks Before Failure

Concrete can develop tiny cracks before any outside load is applied. These microcracks usually form at the boundary between coarse aggregate and hydrated cement paste. They often result from small volume changes caused by stress-strain differences, heat, and moisture movement. At first, these microcracks stay stable. They usually do not grow much until the concrete reaches about 30 percent of its ultimate strength. As the load rises, the material can begin to change more quickly. When...

water cement ratio

Concrete Strength and Water Balance

Concrete strength depends on the balance between water and cement in the mix. This water-cement ratio is the weight of water compared with the weight of cement. It affects strength, durability, and how well concrete resists environmental stress. Abrams’ law shows that less water usually makes stronger concrete. Water is still needed for hydration, which is the chemical process that binds water and cement. It also helps the mix stay workable and compactable. Some water must be absorbed into the...

aggregate cement ratio

How Mix Ratio Changes Concrete Strength

The aggregate cement ratio changes how concrete performs. It is the weight of aggregate divided by the weight of cement in a concrete mix. This ratio affects strength, workability, and durability, so it is an important part of concrete design. A higher aggregate cement ratio makes the mix leaner. Lean mixes have less cement paste to coat and lubricate the aggregate, so they can be harder to work with. At the same time, they may increase strength because the concrete has less total porosity, or...

transition zone

Concrete Transition Zone and Its Porosity

The concrete transition zone is the thin region where aggregate meets cement paste. It has more pores than the surrounding material, so it is usually weaker at first. The bond around the aggregate comes mainly from Van der Waals forces, which are weak attraction forces between particles. When concrete is compacted, this zone often has a higher water-cement ratio near the aggregate. That extra water can form thin water films around the coarse aggregate. These films increase porosity and help...

relation between tensile strength and compressive strength of concrete

Concrete strength testing compares tensile strength and compressive strength. These two properties are related, but they do not rise at the same rate. Tensile strength usually grows more slowly than compressive strength, so the balance between them changes as concrete gets stronger. Several factors affect tensile strength measurements. The test method, specimen size and shape, aggregate texture, and moisture content can all change the result. Direct tension tests are difficult to perform...

fatigue strength of concrete

Concrete Fatigue Under Repeated Loads

Concrete fatigue describes how concrete can weaken or fail when loads are applied again and again, even when each load is below the material’s strength limit. This property matters because it affects the durability and service life of concrete structures. In materials science and engineering, fatigue is a key reason concrete may not last as long as expected under real use. Concrete can fail in two main ways through fatigue. Static fatigue, also called creep rupture, happens under a constant...

impact strength of concrete

Concrete Impact Resistance in Real Use

Concrete impact resistance matters when a material must handle repeated blows and sudden loads. It is important during pile driving, where concrete piles are driven into the ground. It also matters for machinery foundations that experience impulsive loads and for precast concrete parts that can be damaged during handling. Impact strength is measured by checking how well concrete absorbs energy from repeated impacts. A major sign of serious damage is when the concrete does not rebound after...

abrasion resistance of concrete

Concrete Wear Tests and Surface Durability

Concrete wear tests show how well a surface can stand up to abrasion and long-term use. Abrasion is the wearing away of a material by rubbing, scraping, or contact with moving solids. This property matters because concrete surfaces can lose material under vehicle traffic or when solids carried in water brush against them. The transcript describes three tests used to measure concrete abrasion resistance. In the revolving disc test, three plates rotate against the concrete, and silicon carbide...

reinforcements in concrete

Steel Bars in Concrete Structures

Steel bars in concrete structures help the material carry both compression and tension. Concrete is strong when it is squeezed, but it is weak when pulled. Rebar, or reinforcing steel bars, is placed inside the concrete to handle those tensile forces. Steel is a practical choice because it has a similar coefficient of thermal expansion to concrete. That means both materials expand and contract in a similar way as temperature changes. The steel used for reinforcement is usually made by a...

fiber reinforced concrete

Concrete Strength with Added Fibers

Fiber-reinforced concrete is concrete that includes added fibers to improve strength and durability. It uses hydraulic cement with fine or coarse aggregates, plus separated, non-continuous fibers mixed through the material. These fibers can come from steel, glass, and polymers, as well as natural sources such as sisal and cellulose or manufactured sources such as polypropylene and Kevlar. Steel fibers are often preferred because they are strong and tough. They help concrete resist cracking and...

prestressed concrete

How Concrete Is Preloaded for Strength

Prestressed concrete is a construction method that preloads concrete so it can handle more stress. High-strength steel strands are stretched before or after the concrete is loaded in service. The goal is to put the concrete into compression. That compression helps balance the tension the structure will face later. By reducing tension, prestressing helps limit cracks in the concrete. It can also let a structure carry greater loads or span longer distances than conventional reinforced concrete.

ferrocement

Ferrocement Mesh and Mortar Design

Ferrocement is a construction material made from dense layers of mesh or fine rods covered fully in cement mortar. It is a form of reinforced concrete, but it uses mesh instead of the larger steel bars found in standard reinforced concrete. This structure gives ferrocement its thin, flexible form. The material is built from wire meshes and a mortar made of cement and sand. The mortar is usually mixed in a 1:2 or 1:3 ratio. The water-to-cement ratio is kept between 0.40 and 0.45. This helps the...

non-destructive tests for concrete strength

non-destructive-tests-for-concrete-strength

Concrete Strength Checks Without Breaking It

Concrete strength can be checked without fully breaking the material. Two common methods are the rebound hammer test, also called the Schmidt hammer test, and the penetration resistance test, also called the Windsor Probe test. Both are used to estimate the strength of existing concrete. The rebound hammer test measures the hardness of the concrete surface and gives an indirect clue about strength. A spring-driven mass moves inside a tubular housing and strikes a plunger against the concrete.

key terms and concepts

Explore how concrete tensile and compressive strengths differ, why indirect tests are used, and how aggregate type and moisture affect test results.

Concrete Strength Testing: Tension vs. Compression | JoVE K12

JoVE Core Civil Engineering provides a foundational exploration of essential construction materials in civil engineering, focusing on bricks, stones, steel, wood, and concrete through easy-to-understand animated videos. This collection covers the properties, manufacturing processes, and practical applications of these materials. Additionally, the accompanied science-in-action videos demonstrate the research experiments performed in laboratories.

civil engineering

Concrete Strength Testing: Tension vs. Compression

Description

Transcript

Tags