Presented here is a method to blood feed ticks in vitro via an artificial membrane system to allow for partial or full engorgement of a variety of tick life stages.
Ticks and their associated diseases are an important topic of study due to their public health and veterinary burden. However, the feeding requirements of ticks during both study and rearing can limit experimental questions or the ability of labs to research ticks and their associated pathogens. An artificial membrane feeding system can reduce these problems and open up new avenues of research that may not have been possible with traditional animal feeding systems. This study describes an artificial membrane feeding system that has been refined for feeding and engorgement success for all Ixodes scapularis life stages. Moreover, the artificial membrane feeding system described in this study can be modified for use with other tick species through simple refinement of the desired membrane thickness. The benefits of an artificial membrane feeding system are counterbalanced by the labor intensiveness of the system, the additional environmental factors that may impact feeding success, and the need to refine the technique for each new species and life stage of ticks.
Tick-borne diseases strongly impact the health of humans and animals across the world, being responsible for more than two-thirds of all vector-associated illness in the USA from 2004 to 20161. Additionally, case numbers have been growing in recent years, with more people and livestock being affected by ticks and their associated diseases2,3. While there are likely numerous causes for the upward trend in case numbers, the changing climate is an important factor3,4. The predicted ongoing increase in the number of tick-borne disease cases underlines the need to develop new tools to investigate the relationships between ticks and the pathogens they transmit.
It is known that ticks undergo changes in physiology and gene expression during feeding and that these changes play a role in pathogen transmission5,6. It may be difficult to perform studies that examine the effects of full and partial feeding on pathogen transmission and acquisition using animal models, particularly in situations where rodent models are not susceptible to infection by a particular pathogen. For example, Anaplasma phagocytophilum Variant-1 strain is naturally transmitted between Ixodes scapularis and deer but is unable to infect mice, complicating tick infection in the lab7. Artificial feeding systems can also be applied to help study pathogens such as Borrelia burgdorferi via the use of transgenic mutants that have gene deletions that inhibit transmission or infection8. Using an artificial feeding system helps researchers isolate the genes' role by allowing infection or transmission to only occur on the tick's side, thereby isolating any host response that may confound such studies.
Similarly, some life stages of ticks involved in disease and animal transmission may not be induced to feed on common laboratory model species. Ixodes scapularis females, for example, must be fed on larger animals, typically rabbits9. While often accessible for laboratory experimentation, the administrative and husbandry requirements of using rabbits exceeds those of small rodents and may be prohibitive for some laboratories. Other tick species, particularly those of veterinary concern, must be fed on cattle or other large animals that are not practical to use in most laboratories. In vitro feeding and infection methods, such as artificial membrane feeding, provide alternatives to using large or exotic host animals.
Additionally, the use of an artificial feeding system allows certain analyses that may not be possible with traditional animal feeding methods. One such example is that, by separating the blood source from the feeding mechanism, examination of the role that different hosts' blood may have in B. burgdorferi transmission becomes possible10. This examination of host blood and the role blood itself plays in the absence of the host immune response is an important factor in being able to understand pathogen transmission cycles and one that artificial feeding systems are able to help answer11. It also becomes possible to quantify the exact transmission numbers of a pathogen during a feed rather than just examining transmission success and establishment in a host8,12.
Some of the first artificial feeding membranes made for hard ticks were made out of animal skins or animal-derived membranes in the 1950s and 1960s13,14. Due to the biological nature of these membranes, there were problems with both the production of new membranes and shelf life. In the 1990s, fully artificial membranes were developed that utilized a backing of netting, paper, or fabric with silicone impregnation15,16. Silicone was ideal as its physical properties mimic skin's stretchiness and slight tackiness, along with its bio-inherent nature. Building on this, Krober and Guerin, whose work this technique was based on, described a silicone-impregnated rayon membrane feeding technique for the artificial feeding of I. ricinus17.
Refinement of the methods for I. scapularis, a closely related species, has led to notable differences in the hardness of silicone used in membrane impregnation, the recipe for membrane production, dimensions of the chamber, and the attachment stimulant. While the refinements reported in this study have resulted in similar membrane characteristics as those reported by Andrade et al., who also developed a silicone-based membrane based on Krober and Guerin for use in I. scapularis, there is a difference in the silicone impregnation steps, which allows the flexibility to utilize this protocol for immature life stages of I. scapularis15,18. This study also describes additions and technical alterations based on repeated use of this method, best practices that result in a successful feed, and troubleshooting of problems that may arise. This method has been used to feed all active life stages, infect ticks with pathogenic bacteria, and expose ticks to multiple dosages of antibiotics19,20. While the artificial membrane feeding method shown is for I. scapularis, this method is readily adaptable to other species of ticks with minor modifications in membrane thickness.
1. Preparing the tick membrane chamber
2. Setting up the tick feed
3. Maintaining the feeding ticks by changing the blood every 12 h
4. Antifungal treatment
NOTE: Perform only when fungal growth is seen on the membrane. Fungus is likely to form on the blood side of the membrane if the feeding is of sufficient duration. The first indication of fungal contamination is small (1-3 mm) flakes of coagulated blood visible on the membrane. When fungal contamination is noted, antifungal treatments can prolong the duration of the experiment and improve engorgement success.
5. Re-adhering detached membranes with cyanoacrylate glue
NOTE: Perform only when membrane detachment is noticed.
6. Making phagostimulant
NOTE: Perform at the end of a feed or before a membrane feed has started.
A successful feeding depends on whether a partial or full engorgement is desired. Successfully fed I. scapularis turn a shade of gunmetal grey for adults and detach on their own from the membrane. However, if they are at least pea-sized, they may be detached from the membrane when finishing up the feeding. For immature stages of I. scapularis, the size for fully engorged ticks varies, and because, unlike adults, they do not exhibit a color change, detachment is the best way to determine if a tick is fully engorged. See Figure 3 for an example of how nymphal I. scapularis may look during a feed. Adult I. scapularis ticks take 1 week or more from attachment until they start detaching from the membrane; nymphs often detach approximately 5 days after attachment, and larvae start detaching ~3-4 days after the first attachment. Feeds may continue for as long as one wants to maintain the twice-daily blood changes and as long as mold has not started to grow beyond what antifungal treatment can control. Partially engorged ticks have to be manually detached from the membrane.
Immature ticks (larvae and nymphs) that detach from the membrane on their own almost always successfully molt into their next life stage, and assuming that they have engorged sufficiently and are of a large enough size, even those that are detached manually from the membrane at the end of a feed molt. Female ticks that have turned a gunmetal grey during engorgement usually successfully lay eggs. However, unlike natural means of feeding, membrane-fed engorged females produce smaller egg masses and are of smaller size than their naturally animal-fed counterparts. Results from a recent experiment that fed I. scapularis larvae from eggs through nymphal engorgement and molting can be seen in Table 1. The resulting nymphs from the initial larval feed were fed 2 months post-molt. It is important to note, however, that this experiment had deer organ homogenate added to the blood, which may have had detrimental effects on the tick feeding success.
In another experiment, 60 female and 60 male I. scapularis ticks were placed in four feeding chambers (30 sex-matched ticks per chamber) and the female ticks were allowed to feed to repletion. These ticks originated as the offspring of engorged females collected from hunter-killed deer. The mean egg mass weight and range, in addition to engorgement success numbers (number of females who laid eggs post-engorgement and -detachment), can be seen in Table 1. Egg mass weights for I. scapularis are highly variable in the literature, but ticks previously collected from hunter-killed deer from Minnesota produced egg masses with a mean weight of 77 mg (19-147 mg)22. Tick mortality is low using the artificial membrane feeding system; ticks that do not attach and feed mostly survive the process, raising the possibility of attempting further membrane feeding experiments with the survivors.
This method has been used to infect nymphal I. scapularis with a variety of tick-borne pathogens, including A. phagocytophilum Variant-1, which cannot use traditional rodent infection methods7. Infection of the ticks by bacteria was confirmed with qPCR, and while all nymphal ticks that successfully fed were positive post-feeding, depending on the bacterial species, infection would or would not persist transstadially19. This method also has been utilized to feed female I. scapularis ciprofloxacin; the successfully fed ticks showed a comparable knockdown of bacterial symbiont levels to injected ticks20.
Figure 1: The tick membrane chamber. (A) Ceramic-coated stand base covered with plastic wrap. (B) Lens paper taped on to plastic-wrapped base. The blue rectangle is the squeegee used in panel C. (C) Lens paper after being impregnated with silicone. (D) Chambers attached to the silicone-rayon membrane. Each 4 in x 6 in lens paper sheet can accommodate six chambers. (E) A completed chamber with the silicone-rayon membrane. A detached silicone-rayon membrane is shown on the right. (F) An assembled completed chamber, with an O-ring secured on it. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Setting up the tick feed. An example of how a set of four chambers with adult I. scapularis will look once everything is set up and before it is placed in the water bath. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: An ongoing feed with partially engorged Ixodes scapularis nymphs. The black or brown dots around the attachment sites (see label A for example) are the frass that can be collected during and after the feed to make the phagostimulant. Partially engorged I. scapularis nymphs are seen attached on the membrane (see label B). A husk of the engorged larvae molt can be seen by label C. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Number of starting ticks | Number of successfully engorged ticks | Egg mass average mass in mg (range) | |
Larvae | 2 hatched egg masses | 150 | N/A |
Nymphs | 150 | 24 | N/A |
Adult females | 60 | 18 | 42.5 (5.3-77.8) |
Table 1: Tick engorgement numbers and egg mass weights. Larval and nymphal engorgement experimental conditions had deer organ homogenate added to the blood in addition to the supplements used in this protocol. Adult female engorgement experimental conditions were as described in the protocol above. Successful engorgement was defined as either engorged ticks that successfully molted to the next life stage or engorged females that successfully laid eggs.
Artificial membrane feeding of ticks provides a useful tool for a variety of experimental procedures, but is not likely to replace animal feeding for all applications. Maintaining large colonies of ticks at all life stages without animal feeding is generally untenable. Instead, the artificial feeding system is valuable for other purposes such as infecting ticks with pathogens not supported by model hosts, evaluating the impacts of controlled dosages of compounds or microorganisms on the ticks in a simplified feeding environment, or rearing small colonies of ticks that rely on host animals that are not readily available in the laboratory8,10,11,23,24,25. Compared to traditional animal feeding methods, artificial membrane feeding is labor-intensive and presents challenges15,24. It is for these reasons that artificial membrane feeding is not a replacement for traditional animal-based feeding methods and instead allows for experiments that cannot be done with traditional animal feeding.
Maintaining hygienic conditions both in the feeding chambers and the tick colony is vital to avoid fungal and bacterial contamination. However, when using artificial feeding to expose ticks to pathogens, penicillin/streptomycin/fungizone (P/S/F) supplements should be avoided from the blood to avoid killing the pathogens. Tick exposure to ciprofloxacin in the blood can completely eliminate Rickettsia buchneri, the ovarian endosymbiont of I. scapularis, from a subset of F1 progeny, while routine P/S/F addition to blood does not have this effect20. Transovarial pathogen transmission studies were not performed using this system, but no changes were noted in the fecundity of engorged females in antibiotic-exposed versus control experiments. Rapid initiation of feeding and engorgement of ticks avoids many of the issues associated with fungal contamination; for this reason, the system tends to work more easily with larval and nymphal ticks, as they have shorter feeding times. Periodic treatment of contaminated membranes with antifungals such as nystatin can prolong the time available for engorgement by a few days. It is also important to use ticks that have been molted for long enough to be eager to feed. Larvae are ready 2 weeks after all larvae in the egg mass have completed emergence, but nymphs and adults fare better if used at least 10 weeks after molting.
This method has shown comparable tick feeding success to using laboratory animals, with typically 30%-50% of female and approximately 50% of nymphal I. scapularis completing engorgement, comparable to the engorgement success of adults fed on lab rabbits or nymphs fed on mice or hamsters19. Similarly, other studies using artificial feeding chambers have reported a 45% engorgement rate for I. scapularis females and 72% feeding rate for nymphs10,18. Meanwhile, for Ixodes ricinus females and nymphs fed via an artificial membrane, engorgement rates were 71% and 58%, respectively25. Therefore, results can be variable depending on the system in use and the tick species investigated.
Membrane thickness is an important factor in feeding success; thinner membranes are less able to seal around the tiny holes produced by tick probing and attachment. After feeding begins, more moisture gets into the chamber, which can lead to wet conditions, the liquification and subsequent redrying of frass, and mold. It is therefore important to produce membranes at the maximum thickness tolerable by the tick species and life stage's hypostome length that is to be fed (see protocol steps 1.1-1.4). Nymphs of I. scapularis and Dermacentor variabilis feed on membranes between 90 µm and 120 µm thickness, while adults feed on membranes up to thicknesses of nearly 200 µm. The adult I. scapularis hypostome is 500 µm in length, while nymphal and larval hypostomes are ~100 µm long, which proves sufficient to penetrate a slightly thicker membrane15,26. Rayon lens paper on average is ~50 µm in thickness and membranes made from it have a minimum of 50 µm thickness; however, as stated above, thicker membranes produce better results. Larval feeding membranes work well at 80-100 µm in thickness using a very light unryu paper (10 g/m3). This irregular mulberry paper is laced with relatively thick fibers that provide support to a membrane that is very thin in places, allowing ample larvae attachment sites.
Based on the recommended membrane thickness and chamber sizes, it is best to limit the number of females in adult feeds to a maximum of 20 females (ticks are placed in chambers in protocol step 2.7). More females risk overcrowding the attachment sites, as the ticks tend to attach very closely together, which can compromise membrane integrity in the local area and increase the risk of a leak, as well as slow the feeding rate. For nymphal ticks, the maximum numbers are much higher and no significant detrimental effects are noted, even when feeding 50 nymphs per chamber. Since counting individual larvae is not reasonable and no overcrowding issues were noted, a one-half to a whole egg mass per chamber is recommended for ease of setup. Whole egg masses comprise of ~1,000 or more larvae, and over the course of a feed anywhere from dozens to ~200 engorged larvae may drop off from a single egg mass. Additionally, larval ticks that do not feed tend not to die and can potentially be rehoused for a later feeding.
Other plastics have been used to produce the feeding chambers, of which polycarbonate has been determined to be the most durable and non-reactive. Other plastics, such as acrylics, are sensitive to cleaning solutions, which can cause crazing and breakage, especially at the cut ends of the tubing. Polycarbonate holds up well to exposure to bleach, ethanol, autoclaving, and ultraviolet sterilization.
While ticks in a chamber may eventually bite and attach to the membrane due to the heat stimulus of the warmed blood underneath, additional stimuli in the form of chemical phagostimulants help speed up this process (for the recipe, see protocol step 6). For this study, the use of tick feces that have been dissolved in water is ideal due to their ability to be preserved at -20 °C for long periods. They are also easily renewable, as tick feces can be collected from subsequent feeds. Naturally, the first membrane feed may not have access to the suggested phagostimulant of tick feces extract and can be performed without it to help produce it for future feeds. Additionally, alternative phagostimulants may be used, with other studies having success with different chemical or mechanical stimuli such as hair or hair extracts15,24.
Artificial membrane feeding provides additional tools for researchers working in tick and tick-borne pathogen biology. It is affordable and simple, but also labor-intensive, and will likely require some preliminary testing to optimize for their desired application and tick species/life stage.
00-10 Hardness Silicone | Smooth-On | Ecoflex 00-10 | Trial size from Smooth-On Store |
00-50 Hardness Silicone | Smooth-On | Ecoflex 00-50 | Trial size from Smooth-On Store |
30 Hardness Silicone | Smooth-On | Mold Star 30 | Trial size from Smooth-On Store |
6-well cell culture plates | Corning Incorporated | 3516 | |
Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) | Millipore Sigma | A1852-1VL | Used to make an aqueous solution of 3 mM ATP that has been filter sterlized via 0.2 micometer filter |
Bovine blood | HemoStat | DBB500 | Mechanically defibrinated; 500 mL is usually sufficient for one experiment |
Clingwrap | Fisherbrand | 22-305654 | |
Filter Paper | Fisherbrand | 09-790-2C | Autoclave and let cool before using. Can use Fine quality instead of medium too |
Fluon (aqueous polytetrafluoroethylene) | Bioquip | 2871 | Available from other sources such as https://canada-ant-colony.com/products/fluon-ptfe-10ml |
Glucose | Millipore Sigma | G8270-100G | |
Hexane | Millipore Sigma | 139386-100ML | |
Lens paper | Fisherbrand | 11-995 | 100% rayon |
Nystatin | Gold Biotechnology | N-750-10 | |
Parafilm | Fisherbrand | S37440 | |
Penicillin/streptomycin/fungizone | Gibco | 15240-096 | Or equivalent generic with concentration as follows (10,000 units/mL of penicillin, 10,000 µg/mL of streptomycin, and 25 µg/mL of Amphotericin B) |
Phagostimulant | Made in House | Collected from prior tick feeds | |
Polycarbonate Pipe | McMaster-Carr | 8585K204 | Cut to 45 mm length, 1.25 inch outer diameter, 1 inch inner diameter. Cutting requires a chop saw grinding wheel. |
Rubber O-rings | McMaster-Carr | 9452K38 | 5 mm thick, 1.25 inch inner diameter |
Soft touch forceps | VWR | 470315-238 | |
Super glue | cyanoacrylate glue | ||
Unryu paper | Art supply stores | mulberry fiber 10 g/m2. Purchased at Wet Paint art supply store, St. Paul, MN, USA |