12.10
Indeterminate Structure
Indeterminate structures refer to structures where internal forces and reactions cannot be determined using only the equations of static equilibrium.…
In an indeterminate structure, the static equilibrium equations cannot sufficiently determine the internal forces and reactions on it.
Consider a wobbling table with four cylindrical legs, each having a cross-sectional area of 1 cm2. The length of three legs is 2 m, while the fourth leg is longer by 0.50 mm. When a mass of 300 kg is placed, the legs are compressed, and the table is level and no longer wobbles. If the Young's modulus of the wooden legs is 1.3 x 1010 N/m2, determine the magnitudes of the forces acting on the legs.
Recalling the Young's modulus equation, a relationship between the elongated leg and the shorter legs can be established.
By balancing all the vertical forces acting on the system, the force on the elongated leg can be obtained.
Comparing the equations of the elongated leg and substituting the values, the force on the shorter legs can be determined.
By using the force equation and substituting the values, the force acting on the elongated leg can be obtained.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What makes a structure indeterminate?
An indeterminate structure has more unknown forces and reaction forces than static equilibrium equations available to solve them. Standard equilibrium equations alone cannot determine all internal forces and reactions. These structures require additional equations based on material properties and deformation to find all unknowns, making them common in engineering for efficient, complex designs.
Q2: How do you solve forces in an indeterminate structure?
Solving indeterminate structures requires supplementary equations beyond static equilibrium. The force method, displacement method, and flexibility method are common approaches. These techniques use material properties like Young's modulus and deformation relationships to create additional equations. For example, relating compression of different legs using Young's modulus allows you to solve for individual forces on each support.
Q3: Why are suspension bridges indeterminate structures?
Suspension bridges are indeterminate because they have more unknown forces than static equilibrium equations can resolve. Cables suspended between towers experience tension while towers experience compression, creating complex load distributions. Advanced analysis techniques are required to determine how forces distribute through the cables, towers, and bridge deck under various loading conditions.
Q4: What role does Young's modulus play in analyzing indeterminate structures?
Young's modulus quantifies material stiffness and relates stress to strain in structural members. In indeterminate structures, Young's modulus enables you to establish relationships between deformations of different components. By comparing compression or elongation of structural elements using their Young's modulus values, you create additional equations needed to solve for unknown forces that static equilibrium alone cannot determine.
Q5: How do cantilever bridges exemplify indeterminate structures?
Cantilever bridges consist of anchored supports with a central span supported by cantilever arms. The cantilever arms experience bending stress while supports experience compressive stress, creating multiple unknown forces. This complex stress distribution makes cantilever bridges indeterminate, requiring advanced analysis to determine how loads distribute through the structure and ensuring safe, efficient design.
Q6: Why are multistory buildings considered indeterminate structures?
Multistory buildings have loads from each floor distributed to columns and beams in complex ways that exceed the number of available equilibrium equations. The distribution of forces through interconnected structural members creates more unknowns than static equilibrium can resolve. Advanced analysis techniques are necessary to determine how each floor's weight distributes through the support system.
Q7: What advantages do indeterminate structures offer in engineering design?
Indeterminate structures enable efficient, cost-effective designs by distributing loads across multiple load paths, allowing them to carry large loads with minimal material. Their redundancy improves safety and stability. However, this efficiency requires more advanced analysis calculations and techniques to determine internal forces and reactions, making design more complex but ultimately producing stronger, more economical structures.