9.15
Bioequivalence studies: Biowaivers
In certain scenarios, in vitro dissolution tests can replace in vivo bioequivalence studies. This is particularly true when a drug product, though ava…
In vitro dissolution testing can be used instead of in vivo bioequivalence studies under certain conditions.
When a drug has the same ratio of active and inactive ingredients across all strengths, in vivo bioequivalence testing for the lower strengths can be waived—provided the highest strength passes dissolution and in vivo tests.
Comparative dissolution tests are adequate to indicate bioequivalence when a strong correlation exists between a drug’s dissolution and bioavailability.
Most drugs, like immediate-release tablets and capsules, lack such a correlation and require in vivo studies to establish the bioequivalence of the highest-strength dosage.
If lower-dose-strength products show similarity in active and inactive ingredients, only a comparative in vitro dissolution may be needed.
The FDA permits waiving bioequivalence studies for products where it is self-evident, like solutions for parenteral, oral, or local use, provided they have identical ratios of active and inactive ingredients as the reference products.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: When can in vitro dissolution tests replace in vivo bioequivalence studies?
In vitro dissolution tests can replace in vivo bioequivalence studies when a strong correlation exists between a drug's dissolution and bioavailability. Additionally, the FDA permits waiving bioequivalence studies for products where bioequivalence is self-evident, such as solutions for parenteral, oral, or local use, provided they have identical ratios of active and inactive ingredients as reference products.
Q2: What conditions allow bioequivalence testing to be waived for lower-strength drug products?
Bioequivalence testing for lower-strength products can be waived when the drug maintains proportional similarity in active and inactive ingredients across all strengths, provided the highest strength passes both dissolution and in vivo bioequivalence tests. If lower-dose-strength products demonstrate substantial similarity in composition, comparative in vitro dissolution may suffice instead of full bioequivalence studies.
Q3: Why do most immediate-release tablets and capsules require in vivo bioequivalence studies?
Most immediate-release tablets and capsules lack a strong correlation between dissolution and bioavailability, making in vitro dissolution tests inadequate to establish bioequivalence. Therefore, in vivo bioequivalence studies are necessary to demonstrate that these drug products achieve comparable systemic exposure and therapeutic effects as reference formulations.
Q4: What is the minimum bioequivalence study requirement for oral solid dosage forms seeking biowaivers?
For oral solid dosage forms, at least one dose strength, typically the highest strength, must be supported by an acceptable in vivo bioequivalence study. Once the highest strength demonstrates bioequivalence, lower-strength variants may qualify for biowaivers if they meet proportional similarity and acceptable in vitro dissolution criteria.
Q5: Are generic modified-release products eligible for bioequivalence biowaivers?
No, generic modified-release products are generally ineligible for biowaivers. These formulations require full bioequivalence studies because their complex release mechanisms and absorption profiles cannot be reliably predicted from in vitro dissolution data alone, necessitating in vivo evaluation to ensure therapeutic equivalence.
Q6: What specific criteria must be met to grant biowaivers to non-biostudy strengths of generic immediate-release drugs?
To grant biowaivers to non-biostudy strengths of generic immediate-release solid oral dosage forms, the FDA requires conducting an acceptable bioequivalence study on at least one strength, demonstrating proportional similarity in active and inactive ingredients, and providing acceptable in vitro dissolution data for the strength seeking the biowaiver.
Q7: How does proportional similarity in drug composition affect biowaiver eligibility?
When a drug product maintains the same ratio of active and inactive ingredients across all strengths, proportional similarity is established. This similarity is a key criterion for biowaiver eligibility, allowing lower strengths to avoid full bioequivalence testing if the highest strength passes required dissolution and in vivo studies.