Initial efforts to prepare clavatadine A enlisted a traditional, indirect approach to guanidinylation from a suitable amine precursor, which in this case was a terminal azide. Central to this effort was the union of the two halves of the molecule to construct the carbamate moiety. Unfortunately, all attempts to realize an azide reduction in anticipation of a planned late-stage guanidinylation were unsuccessful.25,26 These setbacks inspired the pursuit of compound 7, which could be prepared in a single step by direct guanidinylation from commercially available materials. Though this method had been used in prior total syntheses, in this instance, a direct approach circumvented a critical impasse encountered amid myriad attempts to install the protected guanidine functionality into an advanced synthetic intermediate.27-29
The application of this direct aminoguanidinylation approach began with the preparation of the known N,N´-di-Boc-protected guanidine 7 from Goodman's reagent (6) and 1,4-butanediamine (5) in high yield.3,6,30 The terminal amine of protected guanidine 7 was converted into the reactive isocyanate 8 by exposure to triphosgene in a bi-phasic solvent mixture.3 In the penultimate synthetic transformation, the electrophilic isocyanate 8 was treated with 2,4-dibromohomogentisic acid lactone (3) to form the central carbamate linkage in compound 9.3 Finally, tandem lactone hydrolysis and guanidine deprotection occurred under dilute acidic conditions to provide clavatadine A (10) in 93% yield.3 The overall yield for the entire four-step synthesis (longest linear sequence) is 41-43%.3
For each chemical reaction described in the protocol that was not conducted in aqueous media, the use of high-purity, moisture-free solvents was critical. Some of the reactive intermediates formed during these transformations likely react with adventitious water, leading to decomposition. Although Goodman's reagent (6) is commercially available, its substantial cost and relative ease of synthesis made its preparation a reasonable choice. Again, minimizing moisture by distilling each reagent and painstaking temperature control were critical to its successful synthesis, as stated in the published procedure.11
Despite the expediency inherent to this direct approach for the synthesis of biologically relevant aminoguanidine-containing compounds, there are limitations to this method. Using different amine protection groups is possible in this direct guanidinylation method, but the overall success will always depend on the chosen protecting group strategy. Principally, the selection of aminoguanidine protecting groups requires substantial forethought, because the masked guanidine must remain intact throughout every subsequent synthetic step. In addition, the advanced target molecule must be able to endure the conditions and reagents required for guanidine deprotection at the appropriate time. In the synthesis of clavatadine A (10), acid-sensitive Boc groups were used to protect the guanidine, which necessitated the avoidance of reactions that required or created an acidic environment. In this case, the need to employ acidic conditions to hydrolyze the lactone was optimal due to the fact that acid is a convenient means to cleave Boc carbamates.31 Although clavatadine A represented an ideal template to showcase this approach, direct guanidinylation should be amenable to the preparation of many other natural and non-natural organic molecules. To this end, efforts are underway in our laboratory to prepare several non-natural analogues of clavatadine A as part of a drug-discovery program to develop a reversible and selective, natural-product based inhibitor of human blood coagulation factor XIa.32
What makes this direct method potentially better than the traditional, indirect approach is that it can shorten an organic synthesis route by multiple steps, removing the need to protect and deprotect a terminal amine multiple times before installing the desired guanidine functionality. Though traditional, indirect guanidinylation methods are effective, such as that illustrated in Looper's recent total synthesis of saxitoxin, the inclusion of extraneous steps in a synthesis is time-intensive and can potentially lower the overall yield.33 Moreover, the value of direct guanidinylation was highlighted in a recent total synthesis of 1,2,4-oxadiazole-containing natural products phidianidine A and B. This total synthesis was two steps shorter than the synthesis reported one year earlier by Snider and co-workers.4,34
In the future, the direct guanidinylation method needs to be expanded and tested on different aminoguanidine-containing scaffolds, inescapably, toward the exploration of varied guanidine protecting groups. Clavatadine A and phidianidine A and B both used Boc protecting groups to mask the guanidine functionality. The next stage in the refinement of this method would be to try the same reactions with different protecting groups to see if higher yields can be obtained.4 Recent work by Pfeffer,35 Looper,36 and Nagasawa37 suggests that a variety of aminoguanidine protecting groups in addition to Boc, such as Cbz, as well as derivatives of Cbz may be enlisted. Another approach would involve the use of two different protecting groups on the aminoguanidine scaffold. Judiciously chosen masking groups with orthogonal reactivity may enable the aminoguanidine to survive reaction conditions that cleave one protecting group while leaving the other intact.38 In conclusion, the direct guanidinylation method used for the total synthesis of clavatadine A and variations thereof may be used to synthesize newly discovered guanidine-containing natural products and designed pharmaceuticals.39,40