Aedes aegypti mosquitoes infected with Wolbachia are being released into natural populations to suppress the transmission of arboviruses. We describe methods to rear Ae. aegypti with Wolbachia infections in the laboratory for experiments and field release, taking precautions to minimize laboratory adaptation and selection.
Aedes aegypti mosquitoes experimentally infected with Wolbachia are being utilized in programs to control the spread of arboviruses such as dengue, chikungunya and Zika. Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes can be released into the field to either reduce population sizes through incompatible matings or to transform populations with mosquitoes that are refractory to virus transmission. For these strategies to succeed, the mosquitoes released into the field from the laboratory must be competitive with native mosquitoes. However, maintaining mosquitoes in the laboratory can result in inbreeding, genetic drift and laboratory adaptation which can reduce their fitness in the field and may confound the results of experiments. To test the suitability of different Wolbachia infections for deployment in the field, it is necessary to maintain mosquitoes in a controlled laboratory environment across multiple generations. We describe a simple protocol for maintaining Ae. aegypti mosquitoes in the laboratory, which is suitable for both Wolbachia-infected and wild-type mosquitoes. The methods minimize laboratory adaptation and implement outcrossing to increase the relevance of experiments to field mosquitoes. Additionally, colonies are maintained under optimal conditions to maximize their fitness for open field releases.
Aedes aegypti mosquitoes are responsible for transmitting some of the most important arboviruses in the world, including dengue, Zika and chikungunya1. These viruses are becoming an increasing threat to global health as the widespread distribution of Ae. aegypti in the tropics continues to expand2,3,4. Female Ae. aegypti preferentially feed on human blood5 and thus tend to live in close proximity to humans, particularly in urban areas where populations are most dense. Through this close association with humans they have also adapted to breed in artificial habitats, including tires, pots, gutters and water tanks6,7. Ae. aegypti also readily adapt to laboratory environments where they can be maintained without any special requirements after being collected directly from the field, unlike some other species in the Aedes genus8,9,10. Their ease of maintenance has seen them studied widely in the laboratory in a broad range of fields, ultimately aiming to control the diseases mosquitoes may transmit.
Traditionally, arboviral control relies heavily on the use of insecticides to reduce mosquito populations. However, there is increasing interest in approaches where modified mosquitoes are reared in the laboratory and then released into natural populations. Released mosquitoes may be modified genetically11,12,13, biologically14,15, through irradiation16, chemical treatment17,18, or with combined techniques19 to either suppress populations of mosquitoes or replace them with mosquitoes that are refractory to arboviral transmission20.
Wolbachia are bacteria that are currently being used as a biological control agent for arboviruses. Several strains of Wolbachia were recently introduced into Ae. aegypti experimentally using embryonic microinjection21,22,23,24. These strains reduce the capacity of arboviruses to disseminate and replicate in the mosquito, diminishing their transmission potential23,25,26,27,28. Wolbachia infections are transmitted from mother to offspring, however certain strains induce sterility when infected males mate with uninfected females22. Wolbachia-infected males can therefore be released in large quantities to suppress natural mosquito populations, as recently demonstrated in other Aedes species15,29. However, since Wolbachia also inhibit arboviral transmission in Ae. aegypti, mosquitoes can also be released to replace native populations with poorer vectors. Ae. aegypti infected experimentally with Wolbachia are now being released into the field in several countries using this latter approach14,30,31.
Wolbachia-based approaches for arboviral control rely on a sound understanding of the interactions between Wolbachia, the mosquito and the environment. Wolbachia occur naturally in a broad range of insects, and the strains introduced into mosquitoes are diverse in their effects32. As new Wolbachia infection types are introduced into Ae. aegypti24, it is necessary to characterize each strain for their effects on mosquito fitness, reproduction and arboviral interference under a range of conditions. Rigorous experimentation in the laboratory is therefore required to evaluate the potential for Wolbachia strains to succeed in the field.
Open field releases of Ae. aegypti with Wolbachia infections can often require thousands to tens of thousands of mosquitoes per release zone to be reared each week14,30,31. The success of initial releases can be improved by releasing mosquitoes of a large size to maximize their fecundity33 and mating success34,35. Mosquitoes should also be adapted to the conditions they will experience in the field, however long-term laboratory rearing may cause changes in behavior and physiology which could impact field performance36,37,38.
We describe a simple protocol for rearing Ae. aegypti in the laboratory using basic equipment. This protocol is suitable for both wild-type and Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes, the latter of which can require special attention as some Wolbachia strains have substantial effects on mosquito life-history traits39,40. The rearing conditions avoid overcrowding and competition for food to produce mosquitoes of a consistent size, which is critical for vector competence and fitness experiments, and ensures that the mosquitoes are healthy for field release41. We also take precautions to minimize laboratory adaptation and inbreeding by reducing selective pressures and ensuring that the next generation is sampled from a large, random pool. However, laboratory environments are distinctly different from field conditions, and long-term maintenance under relaxed conditions could reduce the fitness of mosquitoes upon release into the field37,42,43. We therefore cross females from laboratory lines to field-collected males periodically, resulting in colonies that are genetically similar for experimental comparisons and that are adapted to the target field population39. The methods do not require any specialized equipment and can be scaled up to rear tens of thousands of individuals per week for field releases. The protocol also prioritizes the fitness of mosquitoes within and across generations, an important consideration for insects destined for establishment in natural populations. The protocol is suitable for most laboratories that require maintenance of Ae. aegypti, particularly for experimental comparisons where a consistent quality of mosquitoes and relatability to the field are important.
Blood feeding of mosquitoes on human subjects was approved by the University of Melbourne Human Ethics Committee (approval #: 0723847). All volunteers provided informed written consent.
1. Larval Rearing
NOTE: Mosquitoes are held at 26 ± 0.5 °C and 50-70% relative humidity, with a 12:12 h (light:dark) photoperiod for this colony maintenance protocol. These conditions are similar to the average climatic conditions in Cairns, Australia and within the optimal thermal range for Ae. aegypti survival and development44,45,46. High temperatures can result in the loss of Wolbachia infections from mosquito colonies and should be avoided47. We maintain at least 500 individuals per population to minimize inbreeding; maintaining colonies of a smaller size can have fitness consequences [Ross et al. unpublished]. Under these conditions and assuming adequate nutrition, the average generation time is 28 days (see Table 1).
2. Adult Emergence
NOTE: Larvae will begin to pupate from five days after hatching if well fed and the majority should pupate by seven days after hatching. Adults will begin emerging approximately two days after pupation if maintained optimally at 26 °C (see Representative Results). Larval development is typically unaffected by Wolbachia infections when ample food is provided23,39,49.
3. Pupal Sexing for Outcrossing
4. Blood Feeding and Oviposition
5. Egg Collection and Conditioning
Day | Step | ||
0 | Hatch eggs | ||
1 | Count larvae into trays | ||
7 | Transfer larvae and pupae to colony cages | ||
17 | Blood feed female adults | ||
21 | Begin collecting eggs | ||
25 | Finish collecting eggs | ||
28 | Hatch eggs |
Table 1: Overview of the Ae. aegypti colony maintenance schedule at 26 °C. The timing of the female blood-feeding and the hatching of eggs is flexible, but long durations at these stages should be avoided, particularly for mosquitoes infected with Wolbachia, in order to minimize mortality. Following this schedule minimizes selection against mosquitoes that are fast or slow to develop or mature at all life stages, provided that larvae are fed optimally.
Figure 1: Equipment used for rearing Ae. aegypti in the laboratory. (A) Plastic containers used for hatching eggs or rearing larvae with volumes of 500, 750 and 5,000 mL (from left to right). (B) Trays used for rearing larvae at a controlled density, usually 500 larvae in 4 L of water. (C) 19.7 L and (D) 3 L cages used for housing adults. A density of 25 adults or less per liter should be maintained to provide sufficient space. (E) 35 mL cup with moist cotton wool provided as a source of water to adults. (F) 35 mL cup with sucrose solution provided through a cord or dental wick as a source of sugar. (G–H) Cups filled with larval rearing water and lined with an oviposition substrate of sandpaper or filter paper (G and H, respectively). (I) Zip-lock bag used for storage of sandpaper strips or filter paper. Black spots on sandpaper are mosquito eggs. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Lateral (A) and dorsal (B) views of pupae and adult Ae. aegypti (C) demonstrating their sexual dimorphism. Males are positioned on the left and females on the right in each panel. When optimally fed, male and female pupae are distinguished by size; females are larger than males (A) and have a relatively bulbous cephalothorax compared to males which have flatter sides (B). Male adults are easily distinguished from females under all rearing conditions, primarily by their plumose antennae and long palps. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Four day old Ae. aegypti eggs under different conditions. (A) Intact eggs on sandpaper strips maintained at a high (> 80%) humidity but without any visible moisture. Hatch rates should be above 90% for wild-type Ae. aegypti if maintained correctly. (B) Eggs that hatch before being submerged in water (precocious hatching) are distinguished by a detached egg cap and visible larva. This indicates that the sandpaper strip was kept too moist. (C) Eggs that are dried too harshly may collapse, and are clearly visible by their concave appearance. If the sandpaper becomes stiff this also indicates that the eggs may be too dry. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4 demonstrates the effects of suboptimal nutrition on the development of Ae. aegypti larvae. When containers are provided with 0.25 mg of food per larva per day or less, the development time increases for both males and females, and is less synchronous than in containers provided with 0.5 mg of food. If adequate food is not provided throughout the duration of larval development, this could have an adverse impact on the maintenance schedule. Slow-developing individuals are at risk of being selected against, blood feeding may be delayed, and there is a higher risk of adult mortality before reproduction occurs.
Figure 5 shows the wing length (an estimate of body size) of Ae. aegypti adults reared under a variety of nutrition regimes. Wing lengths of both males and females decrease substantially and become more variable when nutrition is suboptimal. Uniform body sizes are important for experimental comparisons as body size is positively associated with fecundity, and large mosquitoes are expected to exhibit greater fitness under field conditions33,34,35.
The effects of Wolbachia infections on the above traits are described in other studies but generally there is little to no effect23,39,49.
Figure 4: Cumulative proportion of Ae.aegypti (A) females and (B) males developing to adulthood under different food regimes at 26 °C. 100 larvae were reared in containers of 500 mL water (a larval density of 0.2 larvae per mL), provided with different levels of food (see Table of Materials) and scored for their development time. Only larvae that survived to adulthood were included. Error bars are standard errors, with n = 4 replicates per treatment. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Wing length of Ae.aegypti (A) females and (B) males developing under different food regimes at 26 °C. 100 larvae were reared in containers of 500 mL water (a larval density of 0.2 larvae per mL) and provided with different levels of food. A subset of adults was then measured for their wing length by using previously described methods56. Error bars are standard deviations. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Following the protocol presented here for the maintenance of Wolbachia-infected Ae. aegypti should ensure that healthy mosquitoes of a consistent quality are produced for experiments and open field releases. In contrast to other protocols that prioritize the production of mass quantities of mosquitoes (see reference57), the methods are focused on maximizing their fitness, both within generations by implementing relaxed rearing conditions, and across generations by minimizing inbreeding, selection and laboratory adaptation. This protocol is also designed specifically for Ae. aegypti with Wolbachia infections but should be suitable for any type of Ae. aegypti. However, it is not suitable for rearing mass quantities (in the order of millions per week), which can be necessary for sterile or incompatible insect releases that require high numbers to achieve population suppression57,58.
There are some critical steps that should be followed carefully. It is important to feed the larvae optimally and avoid overcrowding for the duration of their development. This will ensure that the mosquitoes develop synchronously and are of a consistent size. Special care should also be taken when conditioning the eggs; larvae can very easily hatch too soon or eggs can desiccate if the oviposition substrates are too wet or dry, respectively. At all steps in the protocol, we recommend allowing enough time for as many individuals in the colony as possible to complete each stage. Selection against individuals that are slow to develop, mature, blood feed, oviposit or hatch will likely lead to the loss of genetic variation.
We note some further considerations for the maintenance of Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes that are not described in the above protocol. It is possible for Wolbachia infections to be lost from laboratory colonies, and we therefore recommend that colonies be routinely monitored for their Wolbachia infection status. We use quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR)49,59 to test at least 30 individuals from each Wolbachia-infected line every generation. If any individuals test negative for the appropriate Wolbachia infection, colonies can be purified by isolating as many females as possible from the affected colony and then using progeny from infected mothers only, to found the next generation. The cause of the loss of some Wolbachia strains from laboratory colonies is largely unknown, but could be explained by the failure of temperature controls, as high temperatures can cause the loss of Wolbachia infections47,60.
Colonies and experiments may also become contaminated with individuals from different lines if care is not taken when rearing. Contamination can result from careless pipetting of larvae, mixing up batches of eggs, mislabeling cages or incorrectly sexing pupae in crosses. Special care should therefore be taken when handling colonies with different Wolbachia infection types. Thoroughly clean any oviposition cups, rearing trays and cages before reusing them, clean out pipettes before handling each new tray of larvae and clean the mesh each time when transferring larvae and pupae to other containers. Furthermore, inspect fingers for eggs when handling sandpaper strips and use fresh paper towels when drying each strip, ensure that adults are the correct sex before releasing them into cages, and deal with any escapees quickly. Taking these precautions should avoid most contamination, but colonies should still be routinely monitored using diagnostic assays59.
Female Ae. aegypti require a blood meal in order to lay eggs, and laboratories around the world provide them in a variety of ways, from membrane feeding systems57, restrained animals61 and, to a lesser extent, artificial blood62. However, mosquitoes with experimental Wolbachia infections often perform poorly on non-human blood, and may exhibit reduced fecundity and hatch rates, and incomplete transmission of Wolbachia to their offspring63,64,65. Maintaining the receptiveness of females to human odors is also important for mosquitoes to be released into the field, and feeding them through membranes or other animals may compromise this ability37. We therefore opt to use the forearm of human volunteers for this colony maintenance protocol, though other methods are required under some circumstances. Blood should be supplied through other means when working directly with arboviruses, and care should be taken when colonies originate from field populations with high viral loads as transovarial transmission of arboviruses may occur66. Human volunteers should also not blood feed if they have recently visited arboviral endemic countries as there may be a risk of transmission.
Our maintenance protocol aims to minimize laboratory adaptation and selective pressures, but there is room for improvement. Leftwich et al.42 provide further recommendations for maintaining the fitness of mosquitoes for open field releases, including the use of more diverse and natural larval diets, reducing the density of adults in cages, and providing a complex environment. These considerations may enhance the fitness of Ae. aegypti to a greater level, though currently there is no evidence of fitness changes due to laboratory adaptation under the maintenance protocol described here [Ross et al. unpublished]. Some additional measures may not be feasible for laboratories with limited space and resources, but are nevertheless worth investigating. Maintaining large population sizes, avoiding major selective pressures through rearing protocols and implementing periodic outcrossing to field mosquitoes should help in ensuring high fitness of Ae. aegypti for open field releases. The principles involved in the approach can be applied to rearing other disease vector species for release to manipulate or suppress natural populations.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We acknowledge Heng Lin Yeap, Chris Paton, Petrina Johnson and Clare Doig for their contributions to the development of our colony maintenance methods, and three anonymous reviewers for their suggestions which helped to improve the manuscript. Our research is supported by a program grant and fellowship to AAH from the National Health and Medical Research Council and a translation grant from the Wellcome Trust. PAR is a recipient of an Australian Government Research Training Program Scholarship.
Wild type Aedes aegypti | Collected from field locations in Queensland, Australia, see Yeap and others39 for details | ||
w Mel-infected Aedes aegypti | Provided by Monash University. Refer to Walker and others23 for information on the strain | ||
w AlbB-infected Aedes aegypti | Provided by Monash University. Refer to Xi and others21 for information on the strain | ||
w MelPop-infected Aedes aegypti | Provided by Monash University. Refer to McMeniman and others22 for information on the strain | ||
Instant dried yeast | Lowan | Stimulates egg hatching. Found in general grocery stores. Other brands may be used | |
5 L plastic tub | Quadrant | Q110950 | Used for hatching and rearing larvae. Other products may be used |
Fish Food (Tetramin Tropical Tablets) | Tetra | 16152 | Provided to larvae as a source of food. Web address: https://www.amazon.com/Tetra-16152-TetraMin-Tropical-10-93-Ounce/dp/B00025Z6SE |
Plastic containers | Used for rearing larvae. Any plastic container above 500 mL should be suitable | ||
Glass pipette | Used for transferring larvae and pupae between containers. Web address: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/10Pcs-Durable-Long-Glass-Experiment-Medical-Pipette-Dropper-Transfer-Pipette-Lab-Supplies-With-Red-Rubber-Cap/32704471109.html?spm=2114.40010308.4.2.py4Kez | ||
Clicker counter | RS Pro | 710-5212 | Used to assist in the counting of larvae, pupae and eggs. Web address: http://au.rs-online.com/web/p/products/7105212/?grossPrice=Y |
Rearing trays | Gratnells | Used for rearing larvae. Web address: http://www.gratnells.com | |
Nylon mesh | Used to transfer larvae and pupae to containers of fresh water. Other brands may be used. Web address: https://www.spotlightstores.com/fabrics-yarn/specialty-apparel-fabrics/nettings-tulles/nylon-netting/p/BP80046941001-white | ||
Cages | BugDorm | DP1000 | Houses adult mosquitoes. Alternative products may be used. Web address: http://bugdorm.megaview.com.tw/bugdorm-1-insect-rearing-cage-30x30x30-cm-pack-of-one-p-29.html |
35 mL plastic cup | Huhtamaki | AA272225 | Used to provide water or sucrose to adult mosquitoes. Other brands may be used |
35 mL plastic cup lid | Huhtamaki | GB030005 | Used to provide sucrose to adult mosquitoes. Other brands may be used |
Cotton wool | Cutisoft | 71841-13 | Moist cotton wool is provided as a source of water to adults. Other brands may be used |
White Sugar | Provided as a source of sugar to adult mosquitoes. Found in general grocery stores | ||
Rope | M Recht Accessories | C323C/W | Used to provide sucrose solution to adults. Other brands may be used. Web address: https://mrecht.com.au/haberdashery/braids-cords-and-tapes/cords/plaited-cord/cotton/ |
Plastic cup (large) | Used as an oviposition container. Any plastic cup that holds 100 mL of water should be suitable | ||
Sandpaper | Norton Master Painters | CE015962 | Provided as an oviposition substrate. Alternative products may be used, but we use this brand because it is relatively odorless. Lighter colors are used for contrast with eggs. Web address: https://www.bolt.com.au/115mm-36m-master-painters-bulk-roll-p80-medium-p-9396.html |
Filter paper | Whatman | 1001-150 | Used as an alternative oviposition substrate. Other brands may be used |
Latex gloves | SemperGuard | Z560979 | Prevents mosquito bites on hands when blood feeding. Other brands may be used. Web address: http://www.sempermed.com/en/products/detail/semperguardR_latex_puderfrei_innercoated/ |