P-IA hydrogels grafted with ECM-derived oligopeptide (oligoECM) or ECM with different elasticities were prepared by following the reaction scheme, as seen in Figure 1A, using different types of oligoECM (Figure 1B). The elasticities of the hydrogels were regulated by the applied crosslinking intensity (time) (Figure 1C). P-IA hydrogels grafted with vitronectin-derived oligopeptides, which has a storage modulus of 25.3 kPa (24 h crosslinking time), supported the long-term culture of human iPS and ES cells for over 10-20 passages. Particularly, P-IA hydrogels grafted with a joint segment (P-IA-24h-VN1G) or a dual chain (P-IA-24h-VN2G) supported the pluripotency of human iPS and ES cells, which were prepared with a relatively lower concentration of oligoECM (200-500 μg/mL) than P-IA-VN1 hydrogels, which necessitated using a high concentration of oligoECM (>1000 μg/mL) to maintain the pluripotency of human iPS and ES cells28,32.
Human ES cells maintained on mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) were shifted to culture on other synthesized coating materials (e.g., Synthemax II) coated dishes and P-IA-24h-VN1 hydrogel dishes (Figure 2)28. Human ES cells cultured on commercially available coating dishes were found to more easily differentiate, especially at the edge of the colonies (Figure 2a and 2c), whereas human ES cells could maintain their pluripotency on P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 hydrogel dishes because the differentiated cells could not be observed from the morphology of human ES cells on P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 hydrogel dishes (Figure 2b and 2d)28.
The pluripotency of human ES (Figure 3A) and iPS (Figure 3B) cells cultured on P-IA-24h hydrogels grafted with oligoECM (P-IA-24h-VN1-1000, P-IA-24h-VN1G-1000, P-IA-24h-VN2C), as well as conventional recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-coated dishes, was evaluated based on the expression of pluripotent maker proteins (Nanog, Sox2, and Oct3/4) after the cells were cultured on each dish in xeno-free conditions using Essential 8 media for 10 passages32. These pluripotency proteins were satisfactorily expressed on human iPS and ES cells cultured on P-IA hydrogels grafted with oligoECM, as well as on rVitronectin-coated dishes in xeno-free conditions.
Evaluation of the differentiation ability into the cells derived from three germ layers in vitro (EB formation) and in vivo (teratoma formation) is essential to verify the pluripotency of human ES and iPS cells after cultivation on synthetic biomaterials. Therefore, human ES cells (Figure 4) and human iPS cells (Figure 5) were cultivated on P-IA-oligoECM hydrogel dishes and recombinant vitronectin-coated dishes for 10 passages, and subsequently, the cells were cultured in suspension to form EBs. The EBs were further cultivated on gelatin-coated dishes for a few weeks to observe the ability of the cells to spread on the dishes (Figure 4A and Figure 5A)32. Differentiated human ES (Figure 4B) and iPS (Figure 5B) cells were immunostained for proteins derived from three germ layers: alpha-fetoprotein (AFP, endoderm), smooth muscle actin (SMA, mesoderm), and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP, ectoderm)32. Both human iPS and ES cells were found to differentiate into the cells derived from all three germ layers, indicating another verification of the pluripotency of human iPS and ES cells, even after cultivation on P-IA hydrogels grafted with oligoECM in xeno-free conditions for the long term (passage >10 passages).
The differentiation ability of human ES cells into the cells originated from three germ layers in vivo (teratoma formation assay) was also evaluated. Human ES cells, which were cultivated on P-IA-VN1-1000 (Figure 6A) and P-IA-VN2C-1000 (Figure 6B) in xeno-free culture conditions for 10 passages, were injected subcutaneously into NOD-SCID mice32. The teratomas were isolated from the mice, and teratoma tissue sections were fixed and stained with H & E (Figure 6A and 6B)32. The teratomas displayed the existence of cells originating from all three germ layers: endoderm (intestinal epithelium, Figure 6A(b) and 6B(b)), mesoderm (cartilage, Figure 6A(c) and 6B(c)), and ectoderm (neuroepithelium, Figure 6A(d); retinal pigment epithelium, Figure 6B(d)). These results suggest that human ES cells cultured on P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 and P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 in xeno-free conditions for 10 passages can differentiate into cells originating from three germ layers, indicating that their pluripotency is maintained in vivo.
Human AFS cells were also cultured in unmodified P-IA hydrogel, P-IA-oligoECM hydrogel, and TCP dishes in expansion media. Figure 7 shows the morphologies of human AFS cells cultivated after four days of culture in P-IA and P-IA-oligoECM hydrogel dishes with elasticities (E') of 12.2 (crosslinking time = 6 h), 18.3 (crosslinking time = 12 h), 25.3 (crosslinking time = 24 h), and 30.4 kPa (crosslinking time = 48 h) using an oligoECM concentration of 0 or 50 μg/mL as well as TCP dishes with 3-12 GPa of stiffness30.
Human AFS cells could not proliferate on P-IA hydrogel dishes with or without oligoECM when the stiffness of the P-IA hydrogels was less than 11 kPa (PV-2h, PV-2h-Y, PV-4h, and PV-4h-Y), whereas human AFS cells could proliferate with or without oligoECM when E' was greater than 12 kPa, with the exception of the P-IA-6h and PV-IA-6h-COL1 hydrogel dishes. P-IA-6h and P-IA-6h-COL1 seem not to be favorable for the culture of human AFS cells because the soft cell culture biomaterials halt the cell cycle progression30.
The above results suggest that P-IA hydrogel dishes are an optimal material for long term stem cell cultivation and maintain the pluripotency of the stem cells by selection of specific stiffness and oligoECM, as well as the optimal reaction concentration of oligoECM (surface density of oligoECM).

Figure 1: Preparation of P-IA hydrogels grafted with oligoECM or ECM. (A) Scheme of the reaction for P-IA hydrogels grafted with ECM and ECM-derived oligopeptide (oligoECM)29. Copyright 2015. Adapted with permission from The Royal Society of Chemistry. (B) Design and sequence of oligopeptides grafted on P-IA hydrogels. Single chain oligopeptides (P-IA-BSP, P-IA-VN1, and P-IA-HBP1), single chain oligopeptides with a joint segment (P-IA-VN1G), and dual chains (P-IA-VN2C and P-IA-HBP2C) and ECM (P-IA-ECM) were grafted on P-IA hydrogels32. Adapted under a Creative Commons Attribution License. (C) Stiffness of P-IA hydrogels prepared by different periods of crosslinking29. Copyright 2015. Adapted with permission from The Royal Society of Chemistry. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 2: Comparison of human ES cell cultures on P-IA-24h-VN1 hydrogels and commercially available coating dishes. Morphology of human ES cells (WA09) cultivated on commercially available coating dishes (a, b) and P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 (c, d) dishes at passage 1 when human ES cells were shifted from cultivation on mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) into cultivation on commercially available coating dishes or PVA-24h-VN1-1000 dishes. Red arrows show the differentiated human ES cells. The scale bars indicate 50 µm (a, b) and 100 µm (c, d)28. Adapted under a Creative Commons Attribution License. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 3: Characterization of the pluripotency of human ES and iPS cells on P-IA hydrogels grafted with different oligopeptide designs. (A) Expression of pluripotency proteins Nanog (red), Sox2 (green), and Oct3/4 (green) on human ES (H9) cells analyzed by immunostaining with dual staining with Hoechest33342 for nuclear labeling (blue) after culturing on (a) P-IA-24h-VN1-1000, (b) P-IA-24h-VN1G-1000, and (c) P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogels, and on (d) recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-coated dishes under xeno-free conditions for 10 passages. (B) Expression of pluripotency proteins Nanog (red), Sox2 (green), and Oct3/4 (green) on human iPS cells analyzed by immunostaining with dual staining with Hoechest33342 for nuclear labeling (blue) after culturing on (a) P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 hydrogel, (b) P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogel, and (c) recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-hydrogels coated dishes under xeno-free conditions for 10 passages32. The scale bars indicate 50 µm. Adapted under a Creative Commons Attribution License. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 4: Characterization of the differentiation ability of human ES cells on P-IA hydrogels grafted with different oligopeptide designs. (A) Morphology of cells from EBs differentiated from human ES (H9) cells after culturing on (a) P-IA-24h-VN1-1000, (b) P-IA-24h-VN1G-1000, and (c) P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogels, and (d) recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-coated dishes under xeno-free conditions for 10 passages. The scale bars indicate 100 µm. (B) Expression of an ectoderm protein (GFAP, red), mesoderm protein (SMA, green), and endoderm protein (AFP, green) in human ES (H9) cells evaluated by immunostaining with dual staining with Hoechest33342 for nuclear labeling (blue) after culturing on P-IA-24h-VN1-1000, P-IA-24h-VN1G-1000, and P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogels, and on recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-coated dishes under xeno-free conditions for 10 passages32. The scale bars indicate 50 µm. Adapted under a Creative Commons Attribution License. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 5: Characterization of the differentiation ability of human iPS cells on P-IA hydrogels grafted with different oligopeptide designs. (A) Morphology of cells from EBs differentiated from human iPS (HPS0077) cells after culturing on (a) P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 hydrogels, (b) P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogels, and (c) recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-coated dishes under xeno-free conditions for 10 passages. The scale bars indicate 100 µm. (B) Expression of an ectoderm protein (GFAP, red), mesoderm protein (SMA, green), and endoderm protein (AFP, green) in human iPS (HPS0077) cells analyzed by immunostaining with dual staining with Hoechest33342 for nuclear labeling (blue) after culturing on (a) P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 hydrogels, (b) P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogels, and (c) recombinant vitronectin (rVitronectin)-coated dishes under xeno-free conditions for 10 passages32. The scale bars indicate 50 µm. Adapted under a Creative Commons Attribution License. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 6: Characterization of the differentiation ability of human ES (H9) cells in vivo after culturing on P-IA-24h-VN1 and P-IA-24h-VN2C hydrogels. (A)(a) Picture of a teratoma by injection with human ES cells after culturing on P-IA-24h-VN1-1000 hydrogels under xeno-free cell culture conditions after 10 passages. Tissues including (b) intestinal epithelium (endoderm), (c) cartilage (mesoderm), and (d) neuroepithelium (ectoderm) can be observed. (B)(a) Picture of a teratoma by injection with human ES cells after culturing on P-IA-24h-VN2C-1000 hydrogels under xeno-free cell culture conditions after 10 passages. Tissues including (b) intestinal epithelium (endoderm), (c) cartilage (mesoderm), and (d) retinal pigment epithelium (ectoderm) can be observed32. The scale bars indicate 100 µm. Adapted under a Creative Commons Attribution License. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 7: Morphology of human AFS cells cultivated on TCP dishes and P-IA hydrogel dishes immobilized with or without ECM-derived oligopeptides after 4 days of culture. (A) Morphology of human AFS cells on TCP dishes. (B) Morphology of human AFS cells on P-IA-6h and P-IA-6h-Z hydrogel dishes (P-IA-6h, P-IA-6h-COL1-50, P-IA-6h-FN1-50, P-IA-6h-VN1-50, P-IA-6h-HBP1-50, and P-IA-6h-cRGD-50). (C) Morphology of hAFCs on P-IA-12h and P-IA-12h-Z hydrogel dishes (P-IA-12h, P-IA-12h-COL1-50, P-IA-12h-FN1-50, P-IA-12h-VN1-50, P-IA-12h-HBP1-50, and P-IA-12h-cRGD-50). (D) Morphology of human AFS cells on P-IA-24h and P-IA-24h-Z hydrogel dishes (P-IA-24h, P-IA-24h-COL1-50, P-IA-24h-FN1-50, P-IA-24h-VN1-50, P-IA-24h-HBP1-50, and P-IA-24h-cRGD-50). (E) Morphology of human AFS cells on P-IA-48h and P-IA-48h-Z hydrogel dishes (P-IA-48h, P-IA-48h-COL1-50, P-IA-48h-FN1-50, P-IA-48h-VN1-50, P-IA-48h-HBP1-50, and P-IA-48h-cRGD-50). The scale bars indicate 100 μm30. Copyright 2017. Adapted with permission from The Royal Society of Chemistry. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
| Name of Material/ Equipment | Abbreviation |
| GTPGPQGIAGQRGVV | COL1 |
| GACRGDCLGA | Cyclic RGD (cRGD) |
| KGGAVTGRGDSPASS | FN1 |
| EILDVPST | CS1 |
| KGGPQVTRGDVFTMP | VN1 |
| GKKQRFRHRNRKG | HBP1 |
| CGGGKKQRFRHRNRKG | HBP2C |
| GGGGKGGPQVTRGDVFTMP | VN1G |
| GCGGKGGPQVTRGDVFTMP | VN2C |
| Vitronectin | rVN |
| Fibronectin | FN |
Table 1: ECM-derived oligopeptide sequences and ECM used in this study.
| Antibodies | Concentration (dilution rate) |
| Nanog | 1:200 |
| SSEA4 | 1:200 |
| OCT3/4 | 1:200 |
| Sox2 | 1:200 |
| Smooth Muscle Actin | 1:200 |
| (α-SMA) | 1:200 |
| AFP | 1:200 |
| GFAP | 1:200 |
| Alexa Fluor 555 – conjugated Goat anti-Mouse | 1:200 |
Table 2: Antibodies used for immunostaining in this study.