This protocol describes the assembly and operation of a low-cost acoustofluidic device for rapid molecular delivery to cells via sonoporation induced by ultrasound contrast agents.
Efficient intracellular delivery of biomolecules is required for a broad range of biomedical research and cell-based therapeutic applications. Ultrasound-mediated sonoporation is an emerging technique for rapid intracellular delivery of biomolecules. Sonoporation occurs when cavitation of gas-filled microbubbles forms transient pores in nearby cell membranes, which enables rapid uptake of biomolecules from the surrounding fluid. Current techniques for in vitro sonoporation of cells in suspension are limited by slow throughput, variability in the ultrasound exposure conditions for each cell, and high cost. To address these limitations, a low-cost acoustofluidic device has been developed which integrates an ultrasound transducer in a PDMS-based fluidic device to induce consistent sonoporation of cells as they flow through the channels in combination with ultrasound contrast agents. The device is fabricated using standard photolithography techniques to produce the PDMS-based fluidic chip. An ultrasound piezo disk transducer is attached to the device and driven by a microcontroller. The assembly can be integrated inside a 3D-printed case for added protection. Cells and microbubbles are pushed through the device using a syringe pump or a peristaltic pump connected to PVC tubing. Enhanced delivery of biomolecules to human T cells and lung cancer cells is demonstrated with this acoustofluidic system. Compared to bulk treatment approaches, this acoustofluidic system increases throughput and reduces variability, which can improve cell processing methods for biomedical research applications and manufacturing of cell-based therapeutics.
Viral and non-viral platforms have been utilized to enhance molecular delivery to cells. Viral delivery (transduction) is a common technique utilized in cell-based therapies requiring genomic modification. Limitations with viral delivery include potential insertional mutagenesis, limited transgenic capacity, and undesired multiplicity of infection1,2. Therefore, non-viral molecular delivery techniques are in development for a broad range of biomedical and research applications. Common techniques include mechanical, electrical, hydrodynamic, or the use of laser-based energy to enhance uptake of biomolecules into cells 3. Electroporation is a commonly used non-viral molecular delivery platform which has the ability to induce transient perforation in the plasma membrane for intracellular delivery of molecular compounds4,5,6,7,8,9. However, the transient perforation of the plasma membrane is a stochastic process and molecular uptake via electroporation is generally dependent on passive diffusion across the transient membrane pores4,7,8.
An alternative method is the utilization of ultrasound for enhanced intracellular molecular delivery via cavitation of ultrasound contrast agents (i.e., gas-filled microbubbles). Microbubble cavitation induces microstreaming effects in the surrounding media which can cause transient perforation of nearby plasma membranes ("sonoporation") allowing rapid intracellular uptake of biomolecules via passive or active transport mechanisms10,11,12. Sonoporation is an effective technique for the rapid molecular delivery to cells, but this approach often requires expensive equipment and bulk treatment methods which are limited by lower throughput and higher variability in ultrasound exposure conditions13. To address these limitations, acoustofluidic devices, which enable consistent sonoporation of cells in suspension, are currently in development.
Acoustofluidics is an expanding field that integrates ultrasound and microfluidic technologies for a wide variety of applications. This approach has previously been used for particle separation by applying continuous ultrasound energy to induce standing acoustic waves within the fluidic channels14,15,16,17. Particles are sorted toward different parts of the device based on a variety of properties such as particle size, density, and compressibility relative to the medium16. Acoustofluidic technologies are also in development to enable rapid molecular delivery to a variety of cell types for research applications and manufacturing of cell therapies18. Recently, we demonstrated enhanced molecular delivery to erythrocytes using a PDMS-based acoustofluidic device19. In the acoustofluidic platform, cell and microbubble dynamics can be manipulated to induce physical interactions that enable enhanced delivery of biomolecules. The efficiency and consistency of intracellular molecular delivery can potentially be increased by optimizing the distance between cells and microbubbles.
One important application for acoustofluidic-mediated sonoporation involves transport of biomolecules into primary human T cells. Immunotherapies based on adoptive T cell transfer, such as Chimeric Antigen Receptor T cell (CAR T) therapy, are rapidly emerging for treatment of various diseases, including cancer and viruses such as HIV20. CAR T therapy has been particularly effective in pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) patients, with complete remission rates of 70-90%21. However, T cell manufacturing for these therapies generally depends on viral transduction which is limited by potential insertional mutagenesis, long processing times, and challenges of delivering non-genetic biomolecules such as proteins or small molecules1. Acoustofluidic-mediated molecular delivery methods can potentially overcome these limitations and improve manufacturing of T cell therapies.
Another important application for acoustofluidic-mediated sonoporation involves intracellular delivery of preservative compounds, such as trehalose, which protect cells during freezing and desiccation. Trehalose is produced by some organisms in nature and helps them tolerate freezing and desiccation by protecting their cellular membranes22,23. However, trehalose is not produced by mammalian cells and is impermeable to mammalian cell membranes. Therefore, effective molecular delivery techniques, such as sonoporation, are necessary in order to achieve sufficient intracellular trehalose levels required to protect internal cellular membranes. This approach is currently in development for dry preservation of various cell types.
This protocol provides a detailed description of the assembly and operation of a relatively low-cost acoustofluidic system driven by a microcontroller. Ultrasound contrast agents are utilized to induce sonoporation within the fluidic channels and enable rapid molecular delivery to various cell types, including T cells and cancer cells. This acoustofluidic system can be used for a variety of research applications and may also be useful as a prototype system to evaluate sonoporation methods for improved cell therapy manufacturing processes.
Whole blood donations were collected from healthy donors following protocols approved by the institutional review board at the University of Louisville.
1. Fabrication of acoustofluidic device
2. Assembly and operation of acoustofluidic system
3. Preparation of ultrasound contrast agents
NOTE: Ultrasound contrast agents significantly enhance acoustofluidic delivery of molecular compounds by transiently increasing permeabilization of nearby cellular membranes19. Molecular delivery is very limited without ultrasound contrast agents in this system.
4. Preparation of primary Tcells
5. Preparation of A549 lung cancer cells
An image of the acoustofluidic system assembled inside a 3D-printed case is shown in Figure 1. This protocol produces an acoustofluidic system that can be used to enhance intracellular molecular delivery in multiple cell lines using ultrasound contrast agents.
Figure 2 demonstrates enhanced intracellular delivery of a fluorescent compound, fluorescein, to primary human T cells with acoustofluidic treatment compared to an untreated control group (p<0.05, n=3/group). T cells were suspended at a concentration of 1 million/mL in PBS with 100 µg/mL fluorescein solution and 25 µL/mL ultrasound contrast agent solution, and the mixture was passed through the acoustofluidic device for ultrasound treatment. Intracellular fluorescein delivery and cell viability were measured with flow cytometry after washing cells via centrifugation to remove extracellular fluorescein. T cells in the untreated control group were also suspended at 1 million/mL in PBS with 100 µg/mL fluorescein solution, but ultrasound contrast agent solution was not added and cells were not passed through the acoustofluidic device. The fluorescence intensity of T cells increased by 5-fold after acoustofluidic treatment relative to the fluorescence intensity of T cells in the untreated control group, indicating enhanced delivery of fluorescein. Cell viability decreased slightly after acoustofluidic treatment but remained above 80% (p<0.05, n=3/group).
Figure 3 demonstrates enhanced intracellular delivery of a preservative compound, trehalose, to human A549 lung carcinoma cells with acoustofluidic treatment compared to flow alone (no ultrasound contrast agents or ultrasound exposure) and compared to cells in the untreated control group (ANOVA p<0.05, n=3/group). A549 cells were suspended at a concentration of 100,000/mL in PBS with 200 mM trehalose solution and 25 µL/mL ultrasound contrast agent solution, and the mixture was passed through the acoustofluidic device for ultrasound treatment. A549 cells in the control groups ("Flow Only" and "No Treatment") were also suspended at 100,000/mL in PBS with 200 mM trehalose, but ultrasound contrast agent solution was not added and cells were not exposed to ultrasound treatment. Intracellular trehalose was quantified using a trehalose assay kit and normalized to the untreated control group. Cell viability was measured with trypan blue assay. There was no statistical difference in cell viability between groups (n=3-7/group).
Figure 1: Photo of acoustofluidic system. The acoustofluidic flow system contains a PDMS-based flow chamber with an integrated PZT transducer driven by a microcontroller. A 3D-printed case with an LED indicator and on/off push button are optional additional features. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Acoustofluidic treatment enhances fluorescein delivery to human T cells. (A) Fluorescence intensity in primary T cells increased after acoustofluidic treatment with fluorescein compared to the untreated control group (no acoustofluidics and no microbubbles) (p<0.05, n=3/group). (B) Cell viability decreased slightly after acoustofluidic treatment but remained above 80% as measured by flow cytometry (p<0.05, n=3/group). (C) Representative flow cytometry histogram indicating higher fluorescence in the acoustofluidic treatment group. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Acoustofluidic treatment enhances trehalose delivery to human lung cancer cells. (A) Trehalose uptake increased in A549 lung carcinoma cells compared to flow only (no ultrasound and no microbubbles) and the untreated control group (ANOVA p<0.05, n=3/group). (B) Cell viability remained above 90% after acoustofluidic treatment as measured by trypan blue assay (n=3-7/group). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplemental files. Please click here to download this file.
This protocol describes the assembly and operation of a low-cost acoustofluidic system which enhances intracellular delivery of biomolecules for research applications. There are several important factors to consider when assembling and operating this system. The acoustofluidic device is fabricated in PDMS, which is a biocompatible material that can easily be molded with consistent channel dimensions27.The device channels can be rinsed with 15 mL of 70% ethanol solution prior to acoustofluidic processing in order to increase sterility when working with cultured cells. Following ethanol cleaning, 15 mL of deionized water can be used to rinse the device to remove residual ethanol from the channels prior to adding cell solutions. Small acoustofluidic channels can easily become blocked by debris or cell aggregates, making this a limitation for the frequent use of the device. Thoroughly rinsing the channels between each sample will help prevent problems with channel blockage. In addition, multiple PDMS devices can be fabricated in each batch so that devices can be quickly replaced if necessary. For ultrasound-based applications, it is important to produce PDMS devices with a consistent thickness, as differences in PDMS thickness can affect the ultrasound pressures within the fluidic channels. Ultrasound waves propagate continuously through the device and transmitted waves interact with reflected waves to form standing acoustic wave patterns that are very sensitive to differences in PDMS thickness17.The PDMS thickness is primarily determined by the amount of PDMS added to the mold (step 1.7) and this protocol yields a PDMS thickness of 3.5 mm.
The maximum output frequency of the microcontroller (8 MHz) was selected to produce the smallest acoustic wavelength within the fluidic channel. The microcontroller output is typically a square wave but oscilloscope measurements revealed that the output at 8 MHz becomes more similar to a sinusoid waveform due to slew rate limitations. A limitation of this system is that the maximum voltage output of the microcontroller is 5V and an external RF amplifier is required if higher voltage outputs are desired. The free-field pressure output of the transducer in this system was 18 kPa at 1 cm as measured with a needle hydrophone (Precision Acoustics, Dorchester, United Kingdom). Although this pressure is relatively low, standing waves within the channels can increase the acoustic pressures which samples are exposed to as they pass through the ultrasound beam.
Ultrasound contrast agents are used to nucleate acoustic cavitation within the acoustofluidic channels which enhances delivery of biomolecules across cell membranes28,29. This protocol describes synthesis of perfluorocarbon gas-filled microbubbles encapsulated by a cationic phospholipid membrane. As previously described, this formulation consists of microbubbles primarily between 1-3 µm in diameter30. The positively charged surface of the microbubbles attracts them toward negatively-charged cell membranes, which increases sonoporation-mediated molecular delivery when the microbubbles and cells are in close proximity. The concentration of microbubbles in the cell solution is a critical factor that can influence the efficiency of molecular delivery and cell viability after acoustofluidic treatment, and the optimal microbubble concentration may be specific to each cell type 19. The concentration of gas-filled microbubbles with a lipid shell can decrease over time after synthesis so ultrasound contrast agents should be used within a few hours after synthesis.
We demonstrated delivery of a fluorescent compound (fluorescein) to primary non-activated human T cells using the acoustofluidic system in this protocol. It is important to note that the activation status of primary human T cells may affect the efficiency of intracellular molecular delivery. The fluorescence properties of fluorescein enable sensitive intracellular detection with flow cytometry, but other soluble compounds can also be delivered into cells using this acoustofluidic system. For example, we demonstrated acoustofluidic delivery of trehalose into human lung cancer cells. Acoustofluidic delivery of trehalose into cells may enable increased recovery after frozen and dry storage, which could have significant impacts on a range of biomedical and research applications 19.
Acoustofluidic delivery of other biomolecules, such as proteins or DNA plasmids, is also possible, although a limitation of this system is that the efficiency of molecular delivery may be lower for larger compounds18,31. Optimization of acoustofluidic flow rate, concentrations of ultrasound contrast agents, cell concentrations, and media may be needed for delivery of other biomolecules. In addition, optimal parameters may vary between different cell types due to factors such as cell diameter, morphology, membrane properties, and phenotype.
The acoustofluidic system described in this protocol can be easily assembled and operated at relatively low cost. Additionally, this system can be customized for other applications by connecting other signal sources or ultrasound transducers to generate specific output pressures and frequencies32,33,34. In addition, the syringe pump system described in this protocol can be replaced with peristaltic pumps if desired. At a flow rate of 50 mL/h the residence time for cells within the ultrasound beam as they pass through the acoustofluidic channel is approximately 1 s, but this residence time can be modified as needed for specific applications by adjusting the fluid flow rate.
Unlike other common transfection techniques, biomolecules can be delivered into cells within minutes instead of hours and this system does not require specialized and expensive equipment. In addition, this system is compatible with a wide range of commonly used cell culture media or other buffers. In summary, this acoustofluidic system enables rapid delivery of biomolecules to cells, which may be useful for a wide range of research applications.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported in part by funding from the National Science Foundation (#1827521, #1827521, #1450370) and the National Institutes of Health (U01HL127518). Photolithography services were provided by the University of Louisville Micro/Nano Technology Center.
Fabrication of Acoustofluidic Device | |||
DOW SYLGARD 184 SILICONE ENCAPSULANT CLEAR 0.5 KG KIT | Ellsworth Adhesives | 4019862 (SKU) | https://www.ellsworth.com/products/by-market/consumer-products/encapsulants/silicone/dow-sylgard-184-silicone-encapsulant-clear-0.5-kg-kit/ |
Harris Uni-Core (2.5 mm) | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 69039-25 | |
Microfluidic Reservoir for 15 mL Falcon Tube – S (2/4 port) | Darwin Microfluidics | LVF-KPT-S-2 (SKU) | https://darwin-microfluidics.com/products/15-ml-falcon-tube-microfluidic-reservoir-s-2-4-port |
Microscope Slide | VWR | 16004-430 | https://us.vwr.com/store/product/4646174/vwr-vistavisiontm-microscope-slides-plain-and-frosted-premium |
trichlorosilane | Gelest | 105732-02-3 (Cas. No.) | Chlorosilane is very hazaradous and flammable. Exposure causes severe burns and eye damage. |
Tygon PVC soft plastic tubing (1/16" ID, 1/8" OD) | McMaster-Carr | 5233K51 (Part #) | https://www.mcmaster.com/pvc-tubing/soft-tubing-for-air-and-water/ |
Assembly of Acoustofluidic System | |||
Arduino Uno | Arduino | 7630049200050 (Barcode) | https://store.arduino.cc/usa/arduino-uno-rev3 |
Preparation of Ultrasound Contrast Agents | |||
1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-ethylphosphocholine (DSEPC) | Avanti Lipids | 890703P-25mg (SKU) | https://avantilipids.com/product/890703 |
1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC) | Avanti Lipids | 850365P-25mg (SKU) | https://avantilipids.com/product/850365 |
1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoglycerol (DSPG) | Avanti Lipids | 840465P-25mg (SKU) | https://avantilipids.com/product/840465 |
APF-140HP (decafluorobutate gas) | FlouroMed | 355-25-9 (Cas No.) | http://www.fluoromed.com/products/perfluorodecalin/ |
DB-338 Amalgamators | COXO | https://www.coxotec.com/coxo/db-338-amalgamators/ | |
polyoxyethylene 40 stearate | Sigma-Aldrich | P3440-250G (SKU) | https://www.sigmaaldrich.com/catalog/product/sigma/p3440?lang=en®ion=US&gclid= Cj0KCQjwy8f6BRC7ARIsAPIXOjjj Jh_151mYVEUyLZRavt4re9YQMLS vID64X-1KbO3LUKGjVUwb PDAaAqvOEALw_wcB |
Q125 Sonicator | Qsonica | Q125-110 (Ref.) | https://www.sonicator.com/products/q125-sonicator?_pos=1&_sid=406df3776&_ss=r |
Preparation of Primarty T Cells | |||
autoMACs running buffer | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-091-221 (Order No.) | https://www.miltenyibiotec.com/US-en/products/automacs-running-buffer-macs-separation-buffer.html#gref |
Pan T Cell Isolation Kit, human (Pan T-Cell Biotin Antibody Cocktail & Pan T-Cell MicroBead Cocktail) | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-096-535 (Order No.) | https://www.miltenyibiotec.com/US-en/products/pan-t-cell-isolation-kit-human.html#130-096-535 |
magnetic cell sorter (autoMACS Pro Separator) | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-092-545 (Order No.) | https://www.miltenyibiotec.com/US-en/products/automacs-pro-separator-starter-kit.html#130-092-545 |
Preparation of A549 Lung Cancer Cells | |||
Trehalose Assay Kit | Megazyme | K-TREH (Cat. No.) | https://www.megazyme.com/trehalose-assay-kit |
Trypan blue (0.4% in aqueous solution Ready-to-Use, sterile) | VWR | 97063-702 (Cat. No.) | https://us.vwr.com/store/product/7437427/trypan-blue-0-4-in-aqueous-solution-ready-to-use-sterile |