Although fully synthetic molecules have become more prominent in drug discovery in recent decades, nearly two-thirds of all approved drugs from the last 39 years are natural products or natural-product-inspired,1,2 underscoring the continued importance of natural products research. Alkaloids, certain nitrogen-containing natural products, are especially prized for their medicinal properties. Tropane alkaloids (TAs) containing the [3.2.1.]-bicyclic nitrogen-containing system, are produced mostly by plants in the Solanaceae (nightshade), Erythroxylaceae, and Convolvulaceae families. Examples include atropine, scopolamine, and cocaine; multiple semi-synthetic or synthetic tropanes are also used clinically3. TAs and their derivatives are used to treat many conditions3,4 and several of these drugs appear on the WHO's 2023 List of Essential Medicines5. Because of their potent activities, TAs are also used recreationally (as stimulants or deliriants) and can cause poisoning upon ingestion of plants (or preparations) that contain them6,7. TAs are undesirable in human and animal food8 and can taint teas, spices, grains, honey, and herbal supplements9,10. Because of both their medicinal promise and ability to poison, analytical methods that can aid in the discovery of new TAs (and identification of known TAs) are useful.
In tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS), "mass filters" (e.g., quadrupoles, time-of-flight tubes) are coupled together physically ("in-space"), or an instrument employs additional "in-time" reaction/separation steps. In-space MS/MS uses different modes to select and fragment different ions at the different mass filters (e.g., the quadrupoles of a triple-quadrupole or QQQ instrument). These different modes can be used to determine which specific fragments are made by a given ion (product ion scan), which ions in a sample yield certain fragments (precursor ion scan or PrIS) or undergo losses of a characteristic mass (neutral loss scan or NLS), or which specific compounds possess which specific fragments (multiple reaction monitoring). MS/MS, therefore, provides fragments that are useful for proposing structures for new compounds or confirming an existing compound's presence. MS/MS is increasingly used in the drug discovery, natural products chemistry, and metabolomics fields11,12, and has been used to profile alkaloid-containing species (for phytochemical characterization or chemotaxonomic analysis) and to detect and quantify specific alkaloids in food or medicinal plants10,13,14,15,16.
Despite the many mass spectrometry techniques available, there are challenges in finding new alkaloids. In addition to finding a candidate organism to screen, a full structural confirmation of an alkaloid is an arduous process that may include many different analytical techniques. Additionally, researchers could isolate a compound that is already known, wasting labor, time, and resources. This is especially difficult for TAs, where hundreds, if not thousands of TAs, many of which are isomeric with one another, are reported. The process of "identifying the knowns and distinguishing them from the unknowns" is known as dereplication. Databases of the retention times (r.t.s) and mass fragments of different TAs and other compounds are published to aid with this process17,18. Nonetheless, dereplication is laborious; merely annotating (i.e., assigning putative structures to) the alkaloids in a sample's entire LC-MS/MS chromatogram is time-consuming. Recently, both molecular networking19,20 and manual dereplication18,21,22 have been used for benzylisoquinoline, monoterpene indole, and tropane alkaloids, and PrISs have been used for "structural filtering" of spectra to identify pyrrolizidine and solanine-type alkaloids23,24. There are no specific methods or workflows available for rapid LC-MS/MS-based dereplication of TA-containing samples, however, even though TAs possess common, easily-identifiable fragments (Figure 1). The method described here uses a combination of data-dependent (DD) product ion scans, PrISs, and NLSs to annotate and classify TA structures in plants based on both the distinct fragmentation patterns for mono-, di-, and trisubstituted tropanes (Figure 1A) and the losses of common ester groups found in these alkaloids (Figure 1B). The study organisms are several species in the nightshade genus Datura. A rich source of diverse TAs, Datura has been used throughout the world's history for medicinal and cultural purposes17- and is a challenging matrix to dereplicate because of its numerous, structurally similar TAs, providing us with appealing samples upon which to test our method.