In this manuscript, two methods were used to detect LPS and ATP-induced death of PMA-differentiated THP-1 macrophages. Annexin V/7-AAD double staining was used, and the results were analyzed by flow cytometry from overall staining. As with other flow cytometric analysis, a group of unstained cells and two groups of single-stained cells were set up to exclude false positive and false negative results. The results show that after LPS/ATP stimulation, several cells lost membrane integrity, indicating that cell death may have occurred. This detection method allows us to evaluate the cell death from whole cells. It is worth noting that the Annexin V/7-AAD double staining is not sufficient to distinguish between pyroptosis, apoptosis, and necroptosis. In the early stages of these three forms, PS will be exposed outside the plasma membrane, and Annexin V staining is positive. The integrity of membrane is lost during the late stage of these three forms, and the staining results show double-positive staining. Therefore, we used SEM to further observe the possible forms of cell death that might occur.
In apoptosis, BAX/BAK pore formation on the mitochondrial outer membrane, subsequent cell shrinkage and cell membrane blebbing occurs. Necroptosis employs MLKL to open pores in the cell membrane, while pyroptosis signal activates gasdermin to form pores in the cell membrane. It is worth noting that both pyroptosis and necroptosis are accompanied by cell membrane rupture in the final stage. However, gasedermin pores are much larger than MLKL pores, so gasdermin pores do not have ion selectivity. Necroptotic cells exhibit significant swelling in morphology15. They ultimately end in membrane rupture. Regardless of the signaling pathway upstream of cell membrane permeability activation, changes in the cell membrane accompany these three forms of cell death. We used SEM to further observe the cell membrane, which provide an intuitive way to examine cell death. We observed the characteristics of pyroptosis, including membrane blebbing and the rupture membrane, and necroptosis, including cell swelling and the rupture membrane, consistent with characteristics studied by previous researchers15. We observed membrane blebbing and cell shrinkage, consistent with the characteristics of apoptosis studied by previous researchers16.
In previous studies, the combination of LPS and ATP was often used to induce pyroptosis. Interestingly, we observed features of apoptosis and necroptosis. Although all three forms may occur in LPS/ATP-induced cell death, previous studies have shown that pyroptosis remains the dominant mode of death. LPS is one of the most characterized pathogen-associated molecular patterns. ATP released from dying cells, has a high concentration within the cell. Extracellular ATP is one of the danger-associated molecular patterns17. LPS/ATP is a classic two-step stimulation method to induce pyroptosis. Research has shown that the addition of ATP to LPS-stimulated cells can rapidly activate caspase-118 while silencing the caspase-1 gene can significantly reverse LPS/ATP-induced cell death19. In previous studies, we have also found LPS/ATP-induced activation of apoptotic and necroptotic target proteins20,21. Although LPS/ATP is a classic pyroptosis inducer, it may also induce apoptosis and necroptosis.
In fact, these three forms often do not exist independently, and crosstalk between signal stages. For example, gasdermin proteins target the mitochondria to promote cytochrome c release to enhance the mitochondrial apoptotic pathway22. Activation of caspase-3 can cleave gasdermin E and then trigger pyroptosis23. A study suggests that MLKL/PIPK3 signaling is involved in the activation of NLRP3 inflammasomes24. This complex cross-talk led to the concept of PANoptosis, defined as an inflammatory programmed cell death pathway regulated by the PANoptosome complex with key features of pyroptosis, apoptosis, and/or necroptosis that cannot be accounted for by any of these programmed cell death pathways alone25. As the concept of PANoptosis was proposed, scientists described the occurrence of programmed cell death more comprehensively, this also highlights the complexity of programmed cell death. Meanwhile, this also indicates the limitations of this research method. Although pyroptosis is considered dominant in LPS/ATP-induced cell death, one cannot determine the proportion of these death forms or whether they all exist, even involving other forms of programmed death. This can be an area to investigate in the future.
This protocol is based on LPS and ATP-induced death of macrophages. We have described a method of testing from the whole to the individual, which is also applicable to other models and cells. The results indicate that cells may have undergone pyroptosis, apoptosis, or necroptosis, which is not limited to pyroptosis, helping researchers better understand cell death after LPS and ATP stimulation and choose a better experimental method. In previous studies, Annexin V/7-AAD or Annexin V/PI double staining was commonly used to indicate the occurrence of apoptosis26, 27, some researchers have also used it to study apoptosis28. In fact, we cannot distinguish between the three types of cell death through these double staining. This protocol reminds researchers, especially beginners, that Annexin V/7-AAD or Annexin V/PI double staining cannot qualitative the type of cell death. It can only show cell damage and death as a whole or indicate that the cell may have undergone some form of death. In more targeted research, it is necessary to introduce a control group that inhibits other deaths to show that conclusively program death is at hand. Similarly, further mechanistic research will investigate the critical targets of different programmed deaths.
In addition, during the preparation of the experiment, we found that there are currently many detailed experimental procedures for SEM of adherent cells, with little description of suspended cells. Here, we provide a more detailed description of the sample preparation method for suspended cells. Step 5.5 is a necessary step to assist in immobilizing suspended cells onto cell slides. Subsequent operations must be performed gently to prevent cell detachment. In addition to the chromium alum solution, poly-L-lysine can also immobilize cells.