The transition from raw empirical data to actionable architectural intelligence requires rigorous deductive reasoning. To maintain scientific transparency, the following discussion explicitly delineates between direct behavioral observations measured in our eye-tracking and mixed-reality paradigms, and theoretical extrapolations based on established neurocognitive literature. The primary theoretical discovery of this research is the behavioral manifestation of the "Compensation Ceiling" effect. To understand the elevated AV scores in the elderly cohort, this study applies the Compensation-Related Utilization of Neural Circuits Hypothesis (CRUNCH) developed by Reuter-Lorenz. The CRUNCH model posits that the aging brain attempts to counteract declining neural efficiency by over-recruiting cortical resources at lower levels of task demand. In airport wayfinding, this likely manifests as heightened oculomotor activity; visually impaired older subjects exhibited elevated spatial sampling rates (driving AV higher), which may reflect a combination of active compensatory scanning and increased visual uncertainty when attempting to synthesize a coherent map from a degraded sensory environment. However, this compensatory mechanism hits a strict functional plateau. In corridors with acute-angle intersections, younger cohorts scaled their exploration upward to meet the structural demand, whereas the elderly group failed to do so. This drop in adaptability implies a cognitive breakdown; when the environment's complexity exceeds the brain's remaining "reserve," spatial disorientation occurs21.
This suggests that aging navigators may struggle to construct stable structural anchors in complex hubs, potentially leading them to rely on more dispersed and less efficient visual search strategies. Consequently, the elevated gaze AV observed in the visually impaired elderly group suggests an intensified, yet potentially fragmented, visual search strategy to acquire environmental cues, which may accelerate cognitive fatigue and contribute to subsequent decision errors22.
Furthermore, the data revealed a phenomenon of "Attentional Lock-in." Tracking dynamic pedestrians consumed the limited divided-attention capacity of the elderly (quantified by lower UFOV scores), causing them to miss peripheral signage. This is explained by the concept of "foveal load" in visual psychology (the cognitive demand placed on central, high-resolution vision). High cognitive foveal load has been associated with a functional constriction of the peripheral visual field (often referred to as cognitive "tunnel vision," where individuals fail to perceive peripheral spatial cues when central attention is heavily taxed). This dynamic may contribute to a "Search Paradox": as older navigators engage in resource-intensive sampling (higher AV) to compensate for central vision loss, their effective rate of holistic information acquisition appears to decrease. They are looking harder, but seeing less23. It is critical to note, however, that while elevated AV is interpreted here primarily within the framework of compensatory exploration, this behavioral metric inherently confounds multiple underlying states, including localized environmental unfamiliarity, search inefficiency, and cognitive distraction.
While the integration of mobile eye-tracking and MR simulations provides high ecological validity, several methodological limitations must be explicitly acknowledged. Technically, the physical weight of the MR headsets and their constrained field of view (FOV) may introduce artificial biomechanical movement constraints, potentially altering natural gait. Experimentally, simulating pathological visual impairment in healthy young adults assesses acute sensory deprivation, which does not fully replicate the long-term neurocognitive adaptations and compensatory strategies developed by actual visually impaired individuals over the years. Interpretively, as previously noted, AV remains a composite behavioral metric that cannot definitively isolate active compensatory scanning from baseline cognitive disorientation without concurrent subjective self-reporting. Regarding practical implementation and scalability, the extensive calibration requirements and high hardware costs currently limit the rapid deployment of this protocol across larger, more diverse architectural layouts. Future research should prioritize optimizing the reproducibility of these MR paradigms through standardized, open-source shader libraries and the adoption of lighter-weight spatial computing hardware.
These behavioral findings align with existing theoretical frameworks of spatial disorientation. When peripheral vision is eliminated (as in RP simulations), participants lose the continuous optical flow traditionally associated with anchoring internal spatial maps, which may contribute to the observed navigational errors and spatial memory loss. The navigator cannot subconsciously calculate their trajectory and must rely entirely on immediate, redundant visual cues. Therefore, the architectural environment must be systematically simplified to stay below the user's CRUNCH point, acting as an external cognitive prosthesis23.
Based on the empirical findings of this study (e.g., the specific impact of acute-angle intersections and high visual scanning burdens) and established ergonomic literature, this study proposes an inclusive framework. The following recommendations explicitly differentiate between our direct experimental outcomes and supplementary literature-supported guidelines. This framework aims to reduce the "navigational tax" imposed on fragile cognitive systems through standardized environmental interventions.
While the heatmap data highlights the severe negative impact of central scotomas on text recognition, existing accessibility literature suggests that spatial designers should implement verified contrast standards to mitigate this effect. For instance, established guidelines recommend enforcing a Light Reflectance Value (LRV) difference of ≥70% between navigational text and its background. This specific threshold ensures that symbols can be detected by rod cells in the peripheral retina without requiring foveal fixation, which is often obstructed in elderly populations. Furthermore, character height (H) must be scaled according to the viewing distance (D) using the formula H ≥D/100, with a minimum character size of 200 mm for primary directional signs to account for reduced visual acuity24.
To counteract the "Search Paradox" and ensure information is accessible under high cognitive load, critical junction points should introduce dynamic or animated graphics. The human visual system's motion-detection pathways remain highly preserved even when static object recognition fails, allowing a "flickering" arrow or high-saliency symbol to trigger an orienting response24. Additionally, informational signage should be simplified to contain no more than 3 to 4 units of information per panel to prevent the "choice overload" that destabilizes mental maps in aged navigators25.
To address the "Attentional Lock-in" caused by foveal load and the physical constraints of scanning overhead gantries, transportation hubs must mandate a "Dual-Height" wayfinding architecture. Primary 3 m overhead signs must be supplemented with auxiliary identifiers mounted at the 1.4 m to 1.6 m eye-level. This vertical zoning intersects the natural downward-resting gaze vector of an elderly pedestrian, ensuring information is absorbed passively without demanding high-cost saccadic vertical scanning. This redundancy is particularly critical near stairs and elevators, where the visual focus is primarily occupied by ground-level obstacles and physical balance.
Furthermore, to keep cognitive demands below the CRUNCH compensation ceiling, fundamental floorplan geometries must be standardized to right-angle (orthogonal) intersections. This approach eradicates the severe wide-angle scanning burden imposed by acute junctions, which this study identified as a primary failure point for elderly navigators. Standardizing nodes to a symmetric tree-branch structure rather than complex circular layouts fosters environmental legibility and reduces the frequency of "stops" required for spatial re-orientation. Designers should also prioritize "Geometric Polarization", the use of high-contrast pavement markings and large-scale architectural walls, to provide the hippocampal system with stable structural anchors26.
Finally, to compensate for failing medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) grid-cell networks and prevent spatial "memory leaks," wayfinding must transition from discrete checkpoints to continuous, multisensory guidance vectors. Navigational systems should establish an unbroken "wayfinding chain" where each decision point is logically linked to the next. The integration of Augmented Reality (AR) path projection, projecting high-contrast navigational arrows directly onto the physical floor via MR head-mounted displays, dramatically reduces the spatial scanning burden (AV) by providing a persistent egocentric cue27.
For passengers with severe visual impairment, these visual cues must be coupled with acoustic and tactile redundancy. Acoustic beacons utilizing directional sound or chimes at elevator banks can announce location arrivals, effectively bypassing damaged visual cortices28. High-contrast Tactile Walking Surface Indicators (TWSI) should be deployed at primary nodes to provide uninterrupted physical grounding, supporting "path integration" through proprioceptive and vestibular feedback. By aligning environmental "press" with the remaining functional "competence" of the elderly, these mandates fulfill the Universal Design vision of a hub that moves before the people do.
This study highlights the substantial navigational burden placed on visually impaired older adults in complex transportation hubs. By utilizing mixed-reality simulations and real-world eye-tracking, we demonstrated that spatial disorientation in this population primarily manifests as more dispersed and less efficient visual search patterns (elevated AV), rather than merely prolonged navigation times. Furthermore, the current empirical data emphasizes the critical need for clearer, geometrically simpler wayfinding systems, specifically, the implementation of orthogonal intersections and dual-height signage architectures. Future design interventions should prioritize these data-driven geometric and visual simplifications to effectively support the independent mobility of aging populations, avoiding over-reliance on complex theoretical cognitive reserves.