22.7
Comparison Between Electrical And Gravitational Forces
There are four fundamental forces in nature: the gravitational force, the electromagnetic force, the strong nuclear force, and the weak nuclear force.…
The Coulomb and the gravitational interactions both depend inversely on the square of the distance between the point objects. Whereas gravitational interaction is always attractive, Coulomb interaction may be attractive or repulsive depending on the signs of the electric charges.
Gravitational interaction depends on the product of the point masses, whereas Coulomb interaction depends on the product of the point charges.
Take two electrons and consider the gravitational and electrostatic forces they exert on each other. When the magnitudes are compared, the distance dependence cancels.
The ratio depends on universal constants and the electron's mass and charge. On substitution of their numerical values in SI units, it turns out to be of the order of 1042.
This enormous number implies that electrical forces are significantly stronger than gravitational forces. For example, a rocket is propelled by electrical forces against the pull of gravity.
If there is an electrical force, charged particles move and neutralize it, making objects around us electrically neutral.
Although the gravitational force is weak, it cannot be neutralized. So, it extends over astronomical distances.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: How do electrical and gravitational forces compare in strength?
Both forces follow inverse square laws, so distance cancels when comparing their ratio. The electrical force between two electrons is approximately 10^42 times stronger than the gravitational force between them. This enormous difference depends on fundamental constants: the gravitational constant, vacuum permittivity, electron charge, and electron mass. This reveals how extraordinarily weak gravity is compared to electromagnetism.
Q2: What is the key difference between electrical and gravitational interactions?
Gravitational force is always attractive, depending on the product of masses. Electrical force depends on the product of charges and can be either attractive or repulsive based on charge signs. Both depend inversely on the square of distance between objects. This fundamental difference means electrical forces can be neutralized through charge redistribution, while gravitational forces cannot.
Q3: Why are most objects around us electrically neutral?
Electrical forces are extremely strong, causing charged particles to accelerate and redistribute until they reach configurations with minimal electrical force. This process neutralizes most objects, including astronomical bodies like Earth and the Moon. Since electrical forces are inverse square laws, they dominate at small distances. Consequently, everyday interactions are governed by electromagnetic forces rather than gravity.
Q4: Why does gravitational force persist at astronomical distances while electrical force does not?
Although gravitational force is weak, it cannot be neutralized because it is only attractive. Electrical forces are neutralized by charge redistribution, leaving no net electrical interaction. Gravity's inability to be canceled allows it to persist across interstellar, intergalactic, and cosmological distances, governing planetary orbits and large-scale universe dynamics. This makes gravity dominant at astronomical scales despite its weakness.
Q5: How do electromagnetic forces govern everyday phenomena?
All chemical forces are electromagnetic in nature, making chemistry and biology fundamentally electromagnetic phenomena. When you push the floor with your feet, electromagnetic forces act between you and the floor. Friction, essential for walking and vehicle motion, is an electromagnetic force. Small remaining charges and charge distributions govern nearly all interactions on Earth, from molecular bonding to biological processes.
Q6: What role do inverse square laws play in comparing electrical and gravitational forces?
Both electrical and gravitational forces follow inverse square laws, meaning force decreases with the square of distance. When calculating the ratio of these forces between two particles, the distance dependence cancels out. The resulting ratio depends only on natural constants and particle properties, not separation distance. This mathematical property reveals that electrical forces are intrinsically 10^42 times stronger than gravitational forces.
Q7: How do charged particles respond to electrical forces differently from massive objects responding to gravity?
Charged particles accelerate in response to electrical forces and redistribute to neutralize the force, reaching equilibrium configurations. Massive objects cannot escape gravitational attraction since gravity is always attractive and cannot be neutralized. This difference explains why rockets can overcome gravity through electrical propulsion while still remaining subject to gravitational pull. The ability to neutralize electrical forces makes them invisible in most macroscopic systems.