Capture of Environmental DNA (eDNA) from Water Samples by Flocculation

Summary

Environmental DNA (eDNA) is typically captured from water samples using alcohol precipitation, filtration, or flocculation. Presented here is an alternative protocol that uses lanthanum chloride to enable collection of dissolved and particulate-bound nucleic acids from water samples containing eukaryotic cells, prokaryotic cells, and virus.

Abstract

The analysis of environmental DNA (eDNA) has become a widely used approach to problem solving in species management. The detection of cryptic species including invasive and (or) species at risk is the goal, typically accomplished by testing water and sediment for the presence of characteristic DNA signatures. Reliable and efficient procedures for the capture of eDNA are required, especially those that can be performed easily in the field by personnel with limited training and citizen scientists. The capture of eDNA using membrane filtration is widely used currently. This approach has inherent issues that include the choice of filter material and porosity, filter fouling, and time required on site for the process to be performed. Flocculation offers an alternative that can be easily implemented and applied to sampling regimes that strive to cover broad territories in limited time.

Introduction

Before the mid-2000s, the term “environmental DNA” was generally used to refer to DNA obtained from water and soil microbes although some use for the detection of human and animal DNA for purposes of fecal source tracking or non-native species detection had begun^1,2,3. Presently, environmental DNA is generally used to describe DNA from cells sloughed from eukaryotic organisms, and the analysis of this DNA has become a widely used management tool. The detection of cryptic species including those that are invasive or species at risk is the goal, typically accomplished by testing water or sediment for the presence of the characteristic DNA signatures of the target species. Studies may focus on a single species of interest using a specific PCR assay (active sampling), or many species may be detected simultaneously using metabarcoding and massively parallel sequencing.

Many improvements in sample collection, sample processing, and data analysis associated with eDNA research have been made during the last two decades. Early studies employed alcohol precipitation to capture DNA from water samples³. While tried and true, the need to analyze large water volumes to increase assay sensitivity make this method unattractive due to the typical requirement for two volumes of ethanol for each volume of water sample.

Later studies have generally used membrane filtration, rationalizing that eDNA is present in a continuum of states from cellular-bound to freely dissolved, but that dissolved DNA is subject to rapid degradation and therefore that cellular-bound DNA represents the most significant fraction. Filter material and pore size optimization is widely discussed and debated as is the optimal method(s) for extraction of captured eDNA from the filter^4,5,6.

A third approach to eDNA capture is flocculation, a process that has been used for centuries to clarify liquids including, water, beer, and wine. Several studies have used flocculation to capture virus from natural or potable water sources^7,8,9,10,11. These studies have typically used pre-flocculated skim milk or iron chloride as capture agents. Iron chloride methods typically result in downstream analysis molecular problems due to PCR reaction inhibition^12,13. Methods using pre-flocculated skim milk require the advance preparation of the flocculant, pH control, and thus far have only been applied to the capture of virus^7,8,9.

Recently, flocculation capture of bacteria and virus based on the use of lanthanum (III) chloride has been studied^12,13,14,15. The authors demonstrated that viable pathogens could be collected by this method as the binding of lanthanum chloride was effective at low concentration (0.2 mM). Furthermore, lanthanum flocculation is reversible via chelation under mild conditions in contrast to that of iron chloride.

Thus, flocculation using lanthanum chloride to capture biological particulates is attractive given that only a small amount of added concentrated flocculating agent is required, no strict pH control is needed, and sample volumes are scalable from milliliters to gallons. As applied to the capture of eDNA, cellular, sub-cellular (mitochondria and chloroplasts) as well as dissolved DNA are readily recovered. Bacteria and virus are collected simultaneously allowing for pathogen testing and (or) additional ecological studies from a single water sample. A flocculation protocol using lanthanum chloride is presented that enables collection of dissolved and particulate-bound nucleic acids from water samples.

Protocol

1. Decontamination of equipment and flocculation reagent preparation

1. Thoroughly wash all bottles, tubing, and other previously used equipment with dishwashing detergent and hot water.
2. Spray all bottles, tubing, and other previously used equipment with 6% citric acid solution to remove mineral deposits, let stand 20 minutes, and rinse with tap water.
3. Add a solution of 10-fold diluted household bleach (0.5-0.6% final concentration of sodium hypochlorite) to all bottles (approximately 10% of the container volume), shake, let it stand at least 1 h, then drain and rinse with tap water until no trace of bleach remains. Then rinse once with deionized water.
4. Dry all bottles.
5. Place all collection bottles and caps in a biological safety cabinet and irradiate using ultraviolet germicidal lamps for 2 h rotating each bottle and cap a quarter turn every half hour.
6. Place caps onto bottles and screw down loosely. Weigh each bottle and record its empty weight on the bottle.
7. Prepare a 100 mM solution of lanthanum (III) chloride heptahydrate by dissolving 3.71 g in 100 mL deionized water. To minimize exposure of the chemical to air, as lanthanum chloride is hygroscopic, seal the bottle with tape between uses.
   CAUTION: Lanthanum chloride carries the signal word warning hazard statement(s). H315 causes skin irritation. H319 causes serious eye irritation. H335 may cause respiratory irritation. Use personal protective equipment. See the material’s SDS for further information.
8. Prepare a 1 M solution of sodium bicarbonate by dissolving 84.01 g sodium bicarbonate in 1 L deionized water. Filter sterilize and store at room temperature.

2. Sample collection and flocculation

1. Collect samples from each site plus one field blank (a sample containing drinking water filled on site to control for contamination) by filling appropriately sized bottles. Adjust the number of samples taken according to the experimental design and intended purpose. Do not overfill bottles beyond the shoulder of the bottle to allow for the expansion if samples are to be frozen.
2. Record pertinent metadata including date, time, and GPS location. Label sample containers.
3. Add 1 M sodium bicarbonate solution to each sample and field blank. Add 10 mL per 500 mL sample.
4. Cap the bottles and mix.
5. Add 100 mM lanthanum chloride to each sample and field blank. Add 1 mL per 500 mL sample.
6. Cap and mix thoroughly. Use electrical tape to secure the cap.
7. Store on ice until returning to the field laboratory, then the samples may either be stored overnight refrigerated and standing upright to allow the flocs to settle to the bottom of the container or frozen at -20 °C for shipment to a second laboratory for further processing. Samples must be frozen standing upright to allow for the liquid expansion and to prevent container rupture.

3. Processing of flocs

1. Thaw frozen samples at room temperature in a cooler or move samples that were not frozen to a suitable workbench area that includes a peristatic pump and tubing setup for aspiration of sample supernatants. Ensure that the tubing running through the peristaltic pump discharge into a large bucket on the floor. The intake should be equipped with a clean, plastic drinking straw for controlling the intake.
2. Use the peristaltic pump to remove the supernatant by using the drinking straw to direct suction first just below the liquid surface and moving the straw intake down with the liquid level. Remove the last of the supernatant by carefully moving the intake to rest on the pontil (raised dimple in the bottom of the bottle). This allows maximum liquid removal while flocs collect around the periphery (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: Collection of flocs settled at unit gravity. Flocs containing cellular material and eDNA are settled at the bottom of the sample bottle and are ready to be recovered after the supernatant is removed. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

3. Attach a clean drinking straw and repeat the supernatant removal for each sample.
4. Use a clean 20 mL pipette and pipette controller to transfer the floc suspension completely to a 50 mL centrifuge tube. Use low volume deionized water rinses (approximately 5 mL) to ensure that any residual flocs are recovered from the sample bottle.
5. Adjust all 50 mL tubes to equal volumes with deionized water and collect the flocs by centrifugation at 2,500 x g for 20 min.
6. Pour off the supernatant and make tubes stand inverted on a clean paper towel to drain.
7. Resuspend flocs in 1 mL of 0.5 M EDTA, pH 8.0 by vortex mixing and then add 4 mL 1x TE solution, pH 8.0 and mix again. Transfer the resuspended flocs to a 15 mL conical centrifuge tube, add 50 µL of 10% linear polyacrylamide and vortex. Add 5 mL 100% isopropanol, mix, and let it stand on ice for 20 min.
8. Centrifuge at 6,000 x g for 20 min to collect DNA and cellular particulates. Pour off supernatants and let it stand inverted on clean paper towels to drain. Allow to dry slightly, but do not over dry.
9. Begin the floc DNA extraction process using a commercial kit that employs bead beating and spin column binding with a capacity of 25 µg.
   1. First, resuspend the flocs in 800 µL of the lysis buffer provided with the kit and completelly transfer the suspension to a bead beating tube. Bead beat the floc suspension in short durations with cooling between. Homogenates may be stored frozen at this point or continue with the kit protocol.
   2. Elute the DNA from the spin column first with 100 µL, then recycle the eluate through the spin tube.
   3. Finally, elute the residual DNA from the column with an additional 100 µL aliquot of elution buffer to make a total volume of 200 µL. This maximizes the recovery.
10. Collect, prepare, and analyze eDNA to demonstrate the performance of this protocol and its performance relative to the widely used filtration method.
    1. Prepare reactions that contain 1x qPCR master mix, 25 μg/mL bovine thrombin^14,16, 0.4 μM forward and reverse primers, and 2 μL of template (1% of recovered sample DNA). Construct standard curves using serial dilutions of purified and quantified PCR amplicons generated using voucher DNA. Alternatively, targets can be synthesized commercially.
    2. Use a comparative quantification method if no standard is available. For this example, conduct thermocycling using reaction conditions of 95 °C for 10 min followed by 40 cycles of 95 °C for 10 s, 57 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 30 s, although these conditions must be adjusted for other assays. Analyze the data using the manufacturer's software.

Results

Eight 500 mL water samples (450 mL each) taken from an aquarium housing two Eastern painted turtles (Chrysemys picta picta) were used to prepare eDNA using the described protocol. Another eight 500 mL water samples were filtered over 47 mm glass fiber filters of 1.5 µm porosity containing no binder and eDNA was extracted using the same extraction method as used for the flocculation protocol. DNA prepared using both methods was analyzed using quantitative PCR that targets the mitochondrial control region of the t...

Discussion

Although this technique is straightforward, some steps are critical to success. The collection and transfer of the flocs must be done completely so as not to lose DNA. Residual material must be gathered using strategic rinses. The described protocol uses a commercial DNA extraction kit for the final processing of flocculated material. Other extraction methods may perform similarly or may be superior in performance, but modifications of this part of the protocol have not been exhaustively tested.

Materials

List of materials used in this article

Name	Company	Catalog Number	Comments
0.5M EDTA, pH 8.0	Available from several commercial sources
1 x TE Buffer, pH 8.0	Available from several commercial sources
15 ml Conical Centrifuge Tubes	Single use
16 oz. PET Clear Square Bottles	Reusable with cleaning and decontamination
38/400 Polypropylene Cap with Pressure Sensitive Liner	Leave caps loosely attached until use. Cap tightly to seal pressure sensitive liner.
50 mL Conical Centrifuge Tubes	Single use
6% Citric Acid Solution	Use to remove mineral deposits from reusable sample bottles.
Fecal/Soil Microbe Kit	Use inhibitor removal resin or column
Lanthanum (III) chloride heptahydrate	100 mM Stock Solution
Peristaltic DC Pump	Any peristaltic pump will do, or can be syphoned
Polyacryl Carrier	10% linear polyacrylamide
Sodium Bicarbonate	1 M, filter sterilized and stored at room temperaruture