This study was approved by the Hospital Ethics Committee (No. KY S2024-016-01). The study was registered with the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (ChiCTR2600132334).
Research object
A total of 92 patients with respiratory failure admitted to the ICU of a tertiary hospital in Chongqing from July 2024 to January 2025 were selected for the study. An independent investigator assigned random-number-table values to 92 enrollment slots and ranked them; the 46 lowest-ranked slots were assigned to the control group, and the remaining 46 to the experimental group. Study-team members enrolled participants, and assignments were concealed in sequentially numbered, opaque, sealed envelopes until allocation. Bedside outcome assessors and the statistician were not blinded. No formal prospective sample-size calculation was performed; the sample size was based on eligible admissions during the recruitment period. Inclusion criteria: In accordance with the diagnostic criteria of respiratory failure in the "Clinical Diagnosis and Treatment Guidelines · Respiratory Diseases Branch " of the Respiratory Diseases Branch of the Chinese Medical Association, and confirmed by the ICU attending physician. Exclusion criteria: age <18 or >80 years; pregnancy; EIT contraindications ( such as monitoring site skin damage ); severe intracranial hypertension; Pneumothorax, mediastinal emphysema, subcutaneous emphysema and other barotrauma manifestations, or accompanied by pulmonary bullae, emphysema, severe pulmonary interstitial disease and other high-risk pneumothorax; The clinician judged that the hemodynamics was unstable and could not tolerate pulmonary rehabilitation treatment; end-stage disease; family members did not sign the informed consent; Participate in other studies. Dropout criteria: One patient or their family voluntarily withdrew from treatment and was discharged during the study period; death due to disease progression; study termination criteria included force majeure factors such as transfer. During the study, one case in each group was terminated due to the family's abandonment of treatment and automatic discharge, and one case in each group was terminated due to death. Finally, 44 cases were completed in each group.
Research methods
A research team was set up. The team comprised all members of the respiratory intensive care group: 8 nurses, 1 doctor, and 1 rehabilitation therapist. Before the study's implementation, the team members received two days of EIT-specific training (covering basic knowledge, regional ventilation monitoring, operational procedures, image acquisition and interpretation, and clinical case analysis) and one month of clinical practice, and all passed the theoretical and operational assessments. Both groups followed the same usual-care principles, with ventilatory/oxygen support and sedative/analgesic treatment adjusted according to clinical need. Support settings were reviewed at each assessment.
Control group
The control group was treated with a routine comprehensive pulmonary physiotherapy nursing strategy: within 6 hours of the patient's diagnosis of respiratory failure in the ICU, according to the vital signs, pulmonary auscultation, arterial blood gas, respiratory mechanics, and imaging results, the early rehabilitation activities such as turning over, manual chest percussion, mechanical vibration expectoration, and position management were carried out. Specific measures: turning over every 2 hours; mechanical expectoration twice a day, 15 minutes each time. When the patient's Richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale (RASS) score was -5 to -2 points: the head of the bed was elevated to 30°–40°, supplemented by supine or left and right lateral position, passive activity 2 times a day, 10 minutes each time; RASS score -1 to 0 points: supported upright sitting in bed for 30 min twice a day, passive joint activity training twice a day; For patients with a RASS score of 0, activities progressed from sitting in bed for 30 min to sitting at the bedside for 30 min, with balloon-blowing exercises twice daily, starting with five repetitions per session and gradually increasing to ten. During the operation, if the fluctuation in vital signs exceeds 20% or the fluctuation in pulse oxygen saturation exceeds 5%, the operation was terminated immediately.
Experimental group
Based on the treatment in the control group, the members of the study group used the EIT instrument to monitor lung ventilation, communicated the EIT evaluation results to the competent doctor in a timely manner, and guided the lung physical therapy nursing strategy according to the lung ventilation information obtained via EIT. The 16-electrode band was placed at the 4th to 5th intercostal level of the patient’s chest4, connected to the EIT monitoring host, and the real-time state image was obtained after start-up. According to the need, it was divided into 'hierarchical' distribution and 'quadrant' distribution2. The 'hierarchical' distribution was divided from the ventral side to the dorsal side in parallel, and was set to a four-layer mode, followed by ventral (region of interest [ROI] 1), mid-ventral (ROI 2), mid-dorsal (ROI 3), and dorsal (ROI 4) layers. The ' hierarchical ' ventilation distribution of the healthy lung is usually dominated by ROI 2 and ROI 3 regions5, in which the reference range of ROI 1 and ROI 4 regions is 10%–15%, and the reference range of ROI 2 and ROI 3 regions is 30%–40%6. The 'quadrant' distribution was divided into four quadrants with the image center as the origin, followed by the right ventral region (ROI 1), the left ventral region (ROI 2), the right dorsal region (ROI 3), and the left dorsal region (ROI 4). The diagnostic criteria for insufficient ventilation in the four regions of ROI 1, ROI 2, ROI 3, and ROI 4 were <18%, <15%, <16%, and < 3%, respectively7. Whether it is 'level' distribution or 'quadrant' distribution, ROI 1 + ROI 2 + ROI 3 + ROI 4 = 100%8. An end-expiratory reference was used. The regional tidal-ventilation share was defined as the change in tidal impedance in an ROI, divided by the sum of the tidal impedance changes across the four ROIs, multiplied by 100%. The arithmetic mean of 10 artifact-free breaths was used at each assessment. Breaths affected by movement, electrode contact loss, or coughing were rejected; acquisition was repeated after correcting for movement or belt contact loss. These values describe relative regional ventilation distribution and do not represent absolute lung aeration or perfusion.
(1) Individualized guidance position management: The position management of critically ill patients is dynamic and complex, and its core lies in the continuous cycle of ' assessment-decision-implementation-reassessment '. EIT can clearly show the dynamic distribution images of patients ' lung ventilation in different positions9, and realize accurate position management supported by objective data. Position management and early activity in ICU patients require continuous assessment and adjustment according to the patient's physiological response10. If the ' hierarchical ' distribution of the patient's supine position showed ROI 3 <25% and ROI 4 <10%, the patient was positioned in a prone, sitting, bedside sitting, or prone position of 30°–45 ° according to the actual situation of the patient. After 15 minutes, the EIT was evaluated again. If the lung ventilation became more uniform, the selected position was continued. If the lung ventilation became less uniform, the selected position was discontinued. In the ' quadrant ' distribution, each ROI was independently judged: ROI 1 <18%, ROI 2 <15%, ROI 3 <16%, ROI 4 <13%, which was considered a lack of ventilation function. When the EIT image showed a lack of ventilation function in ROI 1 and ROI 3, the left 45° supine lateral or left 45° prone lateral position was used, as appropriate. EIT evaluation was repeated 4 hours after prone positioning. The position was continued if beneficial and stopped if no benefit was observed. If ventilation loss was confined to ROI 3, a reverse impedance change was observed in this region (decreased impedance during inspiration and increased impedance during expiration), and a purple image was observed in the enhanced image; pleural effusion was suspected. At this time, the right semi-recumbent position was used to facilitate gas exchange in the left lung and reduce the pressure of the effusion on the right lung tissue. The treating physician was assisted with ultrasonographic evaluation. After drainage, EIT was used to monitor increases in ventilation and end-expiratory lung impedance (EELI) in this area.
(2) To guide the precise positioning of vibration sputum excretion: Vibration sputum excretion is one of the common airway clearance techniques in clinical practice. By loosening bronchial secretions, reducing sputum adhesion, promoting its movement, and improving ciliary movement, thereby improving the efficiency of sputum excretion11, the manual-assisted sputum excretion method and the mechanical vibration sputum excretion method are often used. When airway obstruction leads to poor local ventilation, EIT can evaluate ventilation distribution in the lung area in real time, quickly identify abnormalities through the ventilation distribution view, provide continuous objective monitoring, and guide medical staff to dynamically adjust the physical therapy strategy based on real-time imaging data12. EIT showed that the ventilation of ROI 4 was significantly reduced when the ' quadrant ' distribution was used, and the dynamic image suggested that the local ventilation was delayed or missing. Considering the possibility of sputum retention in this area, the vibration sputum drainage treatment was intensified at the corresponding surface projection of ROI 4 to assist sputum drainage. After treatment, EIT was used for re-evaluation. Through the repeated 'evaluation-treatment-evaluation ' model of EIT, the operational method is optimized, costs are reduced, and nurses' workload is reduced13.
Early activity safety assessment
Early activity in the ICU is an important means of promoting patient rehabilitation and improving quality of life after ICU14. Early ICU activities involve gradual progression, assessment, monitoring, and intervention. Accurate assessment and quality control can help improve ICU patient management. During the implementation of early activities, nurses often evaluate the effect using the patient's vital signs, pulse oxygen saturation, or blood gas analysis results, and lack the means to directly monitor improvements in pulmonary ventilation. EIT can monitor and evaluate the pulmonary ventilation during early activity in patients15. If EIT showed that pulmonary ventilation did not improve or deteriorated after the early rehabilitation intervention, the activity mode and duration were dynamically adjusted to promote patient rehabilitation while ensuring their safety. If the ventilation shares of ROI 3 and ROI 4 in the hierarchical distribution decreased after 10 minutes of bedside sitting, the activity was suspended. For conscious patients, EIT images were used to explain the changes in lung ventilation. Two images at different times were displayed through the end-inspiratory trend view. The difference map before and after the activity was viewed by moving the cursor, and changes in the blue-orange areas were used to adjust the rehabilitation plan and explain the response to conscious patients. Immediate EIT reassessments were used only to guide individual treatment adjustments.
Methods of data collection
General information was collected by the nurses in the study group from medical records, including gender, age, body mass index (BMI), Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II (APACHE II) score, oxygen therapy, intravenous antibiotic use, nebulized medication use, complications, delirium occurrence, and so on. Study participants underwent the scheduled EIT outcome assessments at approximately 09:00 before the initial intervention (T0) and before morning rehabilitation on days 1, 2, and 3 (T1, T2, and T3). Daily rehabilitation continued beyond T3 until ICU discharge, withdrawal, death, or clinical discontinuation. The values of ROI 1–4 under ' hierarchical ' distribution and ' quadrant ' distribution were recorded, respectively. At the same time, arterial blood gases were collected to calculate the oxygenation index as PaO₂/FiO₂ (mmHg), with FiO₂ expressed as a fraction. FiO₂ was obtained from the current ventilator setting for invasive or noninvasive ventilation or from the oxygen-concentration setting for high-flow nasal oxygen. The respiratory rate and pulse oxygen saturation were read by an electrocardiogram monitor. The Confusion Assessment Method for the ICU (CAM-ICU) was administered at 09:00 and 21:00 by trained study nurses who were not blinded to group allocation. Assessments at RASS scores of −4 or −5 were recorded as unassessable and repeated later rather than scored as negative. During ICU hospitalization, if the CAM-ICU assessment was positive once, it was recorded as having occurred. The length of ICU stay was recorded on the day of discharge. All data were checked and entered by two team members. A favorable response comprised increased ventilation share in initially under-ventilated regions without clinical intolerance, higher PaO₂/FiO₂ and SpO₂, reduction of an initially elevated respiratory rate, shorter ICU stay, and absence of delirium. Changes in the opposite direction or clinical intolerance during rehabilitation were interpreted as unfavorable. ROI changes were interpreted as a redistribution because the four shares sum to 100%. The participant flow and assessment schedule are shown in Figure 1.
Statistical methods
SPSS 27.0.1.0 software was used for statistical analysis. Measurement data (age, BMI, APACHE II score, ROI 1–ROI 4 value, oxygenation index, respiratory rate, and pulse oxygen saturation) were described by mean ± standard deviation. If the data were normally distributed, a two-sample t-test was used; otherwise, a rank-sum test was used. Count data (gender, use of intravenous antibiotics, oxygen therapy, use of nebulizers, complications) were expressed as frequency and percentage, using the chi-square test (or likelihood ratio chi-square) or Fisher's exact probability test. Repeated measures analysis of variance was used to compare ROI 1–4 values, oxygenation index, respiratory rate, and pulse oxygen saturation across time points. Time-varying co-interventions were not included in the statistical model. Greenhouse-Geisser was used to adjust the degrees of freedom for those who did not meet the spherical symmetry. p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. The odds ratio for delirium (experimental versus control) was reported with a log-Wald 95% confidence interval. Partial eta-squared (ηp2) was used to describe the magnitude of repeated-measures effects.