derivatization-protein-crystals-with-i3c-using-random-microseed

Derivatization of Protein Crystals with I3C using Random Microseed Matrix Screening

Protein structure elucidation using X-ray crystallography requires both high quality diffracting crystals and computational solution of the diffraction ...

The University of Adelaide

The CII protein of bacteriophage 186 is a transcriptional activator of the helix-turn helix family required for establishment of the lysogenic state. DNA binding by 186 CII is unusual in that the invertedly repeated half sites are separated by 20 base pairs, or two turns of the DNA helix, rather than the one turn usually associated with this class of proteins. Here, we investigate quantitatively the DNA binding properties of CII and its interaction with RNA polymerase at the establishment promoter, p(E). The stoichiometry of CII binding was determined by sedimentation equilibrium experiments using a fluorescein-labeled oligonucleotide and purified CII. These experiments indicate that the CII species bound to DNA is a dimer, with additional weak binding of a tetrameric species at high concentrations. Examination of the thermodynamic linkages between CII self-association and DNA binding shows that CII binds to the DNA as a preformed dimer (binding free energy, 9.9 kcal/mol at 4 degrees C) rather than by association of monomers on the DNA. CII binding induces in the DNA a bend of 41 (+/- 5) degrees. The spacing between the binding half sites was shown to be important for CII binding, insertion or removal of just 1 base pair significantly reducing the affinity for CII. Removal of 5 or 10 base pairs between binding half sites eliminated binding, as did insertion of an additional 10 base pairs. CII binding at p(E) was improved marginally by the presence of RNA polymerase (DeltaDeltaG = -0.5 (+/- 0.3) kcal/mol). In contrast, the binding of RNA polymerase at p(E) was undetectable in the absence of CII but was improved markedly by the presence of CII. Thus, CII appears to recruit RNA polymerase to the promoter. The nature of the base pair changes in mutant phage, selected by their inability to establish lysogeny, are consistent with this mechanism of CII action.

Establishment of lysogeny in bacteriophage 186. DNA binding and transcriptional activation by the CII protein.

The CI protein of coliphage 186 is responsible for maintaining the stable lysogenic state. To do this CI must recognize two distinct DNA sequences, termed A type sites and B type sites. Here we investigate whether CI contains two separate DNA binding motifs or whether CI has one motif that recognizes two different operator sequences. Sequence alignment with 186-like repressors predicts an N-terminal helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif, albeit with poor homology to a large master set of such motifs. The domain structure of CI was investigated by linker insertion mutagenesis and limited proteolysis. CI consists of an N-terminal domain, which weakly dimerizes and binds both A and B type sequences, and a C-terminal domain, which associates to octamers but is unable to bind DNA. A fusion protein consisting of the 186 N-terminal domain and the phage lambda oligomerization domain binds A and B type sequences more efficiently than the isolated 186 CI N-terminal domain, hence the 186 C-terminal domain likely mediates oligomerization and cooperativity. Site-directed mutation of the putative 186 HTH motif eliminates binding to both A and B type sites, supporting the idea that binding to the two distinct DNA sequences is mediated by a variant HTH motif.

The helix-turn-helix motif of the coliphage 186 immunity repressor binds to two distinct recognition sequences.

Genomic DNA is bound by many proteins that could potentially impede elongation of RNA polymerase (RNAP), but the factors determining the magnitude of transcriptional roadblocking in vivo are poorly understood. Through systematic experiments and modeling, we analyse how roadblocking by the lac repressor (LacI) in Escherichia coli cells is controlled by promoter firing rate, the concentration and affinity of the roadblocker protein, the transcription-coupled repair protein Mfd, and promoter-roadblock spacing. Increased readthrough of the roadblock at higher RNAP fluxes requires active dislodgement of LacI by multiple RNAPs. However, this RNAP cooperation effect occurs only for strong promoters because roadblock-paused RNAP is quickly terminated by Mfd. The results are most consistent with a single RNAP also sometimes dislodging LacI, though we cannot exclude the possibility that a single RNAP reads through by waiting for spontaneous LacI dissociation. Reducing the occupancy of the roadblock site by increasing the LacI off-rate (weakening the operator) increased dislodgement strongly, giving a stronger effect on readthrough than decreasing the LacI on-rate (decreasing LacI concentration). Thus, protein binding kinetics can be tuned to maintain site occupation while reducing detrimental roadblocking. 

Road rules for traffic on DNA-systematic analysis of transcriptional roadblocking in vivo.

The lysogeny promoting protein CII from bacteriophage 186 is a potent transcriptional activator, capable of mediating at least a 400-fold increase in transcription over basal activity. Despite being functionally similar to its counterpart in phage λ, it shows no homology at the level of protein sequence and does not belong to any known family of transcriptional activators. It also has the unusual property of binding DNA half-sites that are separated by 20 base pairs, center to center. Here we investigate the structural and functional properties of CII using a combination of genetics, in vitro assays, and mutational analysis. We find that 186 CII possesses two functional domains, with an independent activation epitope in each. 186 CII owes its potent activity to activation mechanisms that are dependent on both the σ(70) and α C-terminal domain (αCTD) components of RNA polymerase, contacting different functional domains. We also present evidence that like λ CII, 186 CII is proteolytically degraded in vivo, but unlike λ CII, 186 CII proteolysis results in a specific, transcriptionally inactive, degradation product with altered self-association properties. 

Promoter activation by CII, a potent transcriptional activator from bacteriophage 186.

Transcriptional interference (TI), where transcription from a promoter is inhibited by the activity of other promoters in its vicinity on the same DNA, enables transcription factors to regulate a target promoter indirectly, inducing or relieving TI by controlling the interfering promoter. For convergent promoters, stochastic simulations indicate that relief of TI can be inhibited if the repressor at the interfering promoter has slow binding kinetics, making it either sensitive to frequent dislodgement by elongating RNA polymerases (RNAPs) from the target promoter, or able to be a strong roadblock to these RNAPs. In vivo measurements of relief of TI by CI or Cro repressors in the bacteriophage λ PR-PRE system show strong relief of TI and a lack of dislodgement and roadblocking effects, indicative of rapid CI and Cro binding kinetics. However, repression of the same λ promoter by a catalytically dead CRISPR Cas9 protein gave either compromised or no relief of TI depending on the orientation at which it binds DNA, consistent with dCas9 being a slow kinetics repressor. This analysis shows how the intrinsic properties of a repressor can be evolutionarily tuned to set the magnitude of relief of TI.

The role of repressor kinetics in relief of transcriptional interference between convergent promoters.

Clonetegration is a method for site-specific insertion of DNA into prokaryotic chromosomes, based on bacteriophage integrases. The method combines DNA cloning/assembly and chromosomal integration into a single step, providing a simple and rapid strategy for inserting DNA sequences into bacterial chromosomes.

Clonetegration Using OSIP Plasmids: One-Step DNA Assembly and Site-Specific Genomic Integration in Bacteria.

Protein-DNA interactions are central to the control of gene expression across all forms of life. The development of approaches to rigorously model such interactions has often been hindered both by a lack of quantitative binding data and by the difficulty in accounting for parameters relevant to the intracellular situation, such as DNA looping and thermodynamic non-ideality. Here, we review these considerations by developing a thermodynamically based mathematical model that attempts to simulate the functioning of an Escherichia coli expression system incorporating two of the best characterised prokaryotic DNA binding proteins, Lac repressor and lambda CI repressor. The key aim was to reproduce experimentally observed reporter gene activities arising from the expression of either wild-type CI repressor or one of three positive-control CI mutants. The model considers the role of several potentially important, but sometimes neglected, biochemical features, including DNA looping, macromolecular crowding and non-specific binding, and allowed us to obtain association constants for the binding of CI and its variants to a specific operator sequence.

Aspects of protein-DNA interactions: a review of quantitative thermodynamic theory for modelling synthetic circuits utilising LacI and CI repressors, IPTG and the reporter gene lacZ.

Bacterial sigma54 (σ) promoters are the DNA-binding motif for σ-containing RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzymes. A recent study using a combination of synthetic oligonucleotide library screening, biochemical characterization, and bioinformatics has uncovered a new and unexpected role for σ promoters, encoding a form of bacterial 'insulator sequence' to dampen unwanted translation.

Hidden Secrets of Sigma54 Promoters Revealed.

DNA looping is a ubiquitous and critical feature of gene regulation. Although DNA looping can be efficiently detected, tools to readily manipulate DNA looping are limited. Here we develop CRISPR-based DNA looping reagents for creation of programmable DNA loops. Cleavage-defective Cas9 proteins of different specificity are linked by heterodimerization or translational fusion to create bivalent complexes able to link two separate DNA regions. After model-directed optimization, the reagents are validated using a quantitative DNA looping assay in E. coli. Looping efficiency is ~15% for a 4.7 kb loop, but is significantly improved by loop multiplexing with additional guides. Bivalent dCas9 complexes are also used to activate endogenous norVW genes by rewiring chromosomal DNA to bring distal enhancer elements to the gene promoters. Such reagents should allow manipulation of DNA looping in a variety of cell types, aiding understanding of endogenous loops and enabling creation of new regulatory connections.

Programmable DNA looping using engineered bivalent dCas9 complexes.

Antisense transcription is common in naturally occurring genomes and is increasingly being used in synthetic genetic circuitry as a tool for gene expression control. Mutual influence on the expression of convergent genes can be mediated by antisense RNA effects and by transcriptional interference (TI). We aimed to quantitatively characterize long-range TI between convergent genes with untranslated intergenic spacers of increasing length. After controlling for antisense RNA-mediated effects, which contributed about half of the observed total expression inhibition, the TI effect was modeled. To achieve model convergence, RNA polymerase processivity and collision resistance were assumed to be modulated by ribosome trailing. The spontaneous transcription termination rate in regions of untranslated DNA was experimentally determined. Our modeling suggests that an elongating RNA polymerase with a trailing ribosome is about 13 times more likely to resume transcription than an opposing RNA polymerase without a trailing ribosome, upon head-on collision of the two.

Characterizing Transcriptional Interference between Converging Genes in Bacteria.

Enhancers are ubiquitous and critical gene-regulatory elements. However, quantitative understanding of the role of DNA looping in the regulation of enhancer action and specificity is limited. We used the Escherichia coli NtrC enhancer-σ54 promoter system as an in vivo model, finding that NtrC activation is highly sensitive to the enhancer-promoter (E-P) distance in the 300-6,000 bp range. DNA loops formed by Lac repressor were able to strongly regulate enhancer action either positively or negatively, recapitulating promoter targeting and insulation. A single LacI loop combining targeting and insulation produced a strong shift in specificity for enhancer choice between two σ54 promoters. A combined kinetic-thermodynamic model was used to quantify the effect of DNA-looping interactions on promoter activity and revealed that sensitivity to E-P distance and to control by other loops is itself dependent on enhancer and promoter parameters that may be subject to regulation.

Positive and Negative Control of Enhancer-Promoter Interactions by Other DNA Loops Generates Specificity and Tunability.

Convergent promoters exert transcriptional interference (TI) by several mechanisms including promoter occlusion, where elongating RNA polymerases (RNAPs) block access to a promoter. Here, we tested whether pausing of RNAPs by obstructive DNA-bound proteins can enhance TI by promoter occlusion. Using the Lac repressor as a 'roadblock' to induce pausing over a target promoter, we found only a small increase in TI, with mathematical modelling suggesting that rapid termination of the stalled RNAP was limiting the occlusion effect. As predicted, the roadblock-enhanced occlusion was significantly increased in the absence of the Mfd terminator protein. Thus, protein roadblocking of RNAP may cause pause-enhanced occlusion throughout genomes, and the removal of stalled RNAP may be needed to minimize unwanted TI.

RNA polymerase pausing at a protein roadblock can enhance transcriptional interference by promoter occlusion.

Two commonly encountered bottlenecks in the structure determination of a protein by X-ray crystallography are screening for conditions that give high-quality crystals and, in the case of novel structures, finding derivatization conditions for experimental phasing. In this study, the phasing molecule 5-amino-2,4,6-triiodoisophthalic acid (I3C) was added to a random microseed matrix screen to generate high-quality crystals derivatized with I3C in a single optimization experiment. I3C, often referred to as the magic triangle, contains an aromatic ring scaffold with three bound I atoms. This approach was applied to efficiently phase the structures of hen egg-white lysozyme and the N-terminal domain of the Orf11 protein from Staphylococcus phage P68 (Orf11 NTD) using SAD phasing. The structure of Orf11 NTD suggests that it may play a role as a virion-associated lysin or endolysin.

Combining random microseed matrix screening and the magic triangle for the efficient structure solution of a potential lysin from bacteriophage P68.

The Apl protein of bacteriophage 186 functions both as an excisionase and as a transcriptional regulator; binding to the phage attachment site (att), and also between the major early phage promoters (pR-pL). Like other recombination directionality factors (RDFs), Apl binding sites are direct repeats spaced one DNA helix turn apart. Here, we use in vitro binding studies with purified Apl and pR-pL DNA to show that Apl binds to multiple sites with high cooperativity, bends the DNA and spreads from specific binding sites into adjacent non-specific DNA; features that are shared with other RDFs. By analysing Apl's repression of pR and pL, and the effect of operator mutants in vivo with a simple mathematical model, we were able to extract estimates of binding energies for single specific and non-specific sites and for Apl cooperativity, revealing that Apl monomers bind to DNA with low sequence specificity but with strong cooperativity between immediate neighbours. This model fit was then independently validated with in vitro data. The model we employed here is a simple but powerful tool that enabled better understanding of the balance between binding affinity and cooperativity required for RDF function. A modelling approach such as this is broadly applicable to other systems.

A quantitative binding model for the Apl protein, the dual purpose recombination-directionality factor and lysis-lysogeny regulator of bacteriophage 186.

Article	Year
Establishment of lysogeny in bacteriophage 186. DNA binding and transcriptional activation by the CII protein. The Journal of biological chemistry\| PubMed ID: 10871623	2000
The helix-turn-helix motif of the coliphage 186 immunity repressor binds to two distinct recognition sequences. The Journal of biological chemistry\| PubMed ID: 11700308	2002
Road rules for traffic on DNA-systematic analysis of transcriptional roadblocking in vivo. Nucleic acids research\| PubMed ID: 25034688	2014
Promoter activation by CII, a potent transcriptional activator from bacteriophage 186. The Journal of biological chemistry\| PubMed ID: 25294872	2014
The role of repressor kinetics in relief of transcriptional interference between convergent promoters. Nucleic acids research\| PubMed ID: 27378773	2016
Clonetegration Using OSIP Plasmids: One-Step DNA Assembly and Site-Specific Genomic Integration in Bacteria. Methods in molecular biology (Clifton, N.J.)\| PubMed ID: 27671938	2017
Aspects of protein-DNA interactions: a review of quantitative thermodynamic theory for modelling synthetic circuits utilising LacI and CI repressors, IPTG and the reporter gene lacZ. Biophysical reviews\| PubMed ID: 28510022	2016
Hidden Secrets of Sigma54 Promoters Revealed. Trends in biochemical sciences\| PubMed ID: 29126750	2017
Programmable DNA looping using engineered bivalent dCas9 complexes. Nature communications\| PubMed ID: 29158476	2017
Characterizing Transcriptional Interference between Converging Genes in Bacteria. ACS synthetic biology\| PubMed ID: 30717589	2019
Positive and Negative Control of Enhancer-Promoter Interactions by Other DNA Loops Generates Specificity and Tunability. Cell reports\| PubMed ID: 30811991	2019
RNA polymerase pausing at a protein roadblock can enhance transcriptional interference by promoter occlusion. FEBS letters\| PubMed ID: 30892685	2019
Combining random microseed matrix screening and the magic triangle for the efficient structure solution of a potential lysin from bacteriophage P68. Acta crystallographica. Section D, Structural biology\| PubMed ID: 31282476	2019
A quantitative binding model for the Apl protein, the dual purpose recombination-directionality factor and lysis-lysogeny regulator of bacteriophage 186. Nucleic acids research\| PubMed ID: 32789491	2020

Keith E. Shearwin

Biography

JoVE Journal Publications

Other Publications