high-pressure-nmr-experiments-for-detecting-protein-low-lying

High-Pressure NMR Experiments for Detecting Protein Low-Lying Conformational States

High-pressure is a well-known perturbation method that can be used to destabilize globular proteins and dissociate protein complexes in a reversible ...

Iowa State University

Using high-pressure NMR spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry, we investigate the folding landscape of the mature HIV-1 protease homodimer. The cooperativity of unfolding was measured in the absence or presence of a symmetric active site inhibitor for the optimized wild type protease (PR), its inactive variant PRD25N, and an extremely multidrug-resistant mutant, PR20. The individual fit of the pressure denaturation profiles gives rise to first order, ∆GNMR, and second order, ∆VNMR (the derivative of ∆GNMR with pressure); apparent thermodynamic parameters for each amide proton considered. Heterogeneity in the apparent ∆VNMR values reflects departure from an ideal cooperative unfolding transition. The narrow to broad distribution of ∆VNMR spanning the extremes from inhibitor-free PR20D25N to PR-DMP323 complex, and distinctively for PRD25N-DMP323 complex, indicated large variations in folding cooperativity. Consistent with this data, the shape of thermal unfolding transitions varies from asymmetric for PR to nearly symmetric for PR20, as dimer-inhibitor ternary complexes. Lack of structural cooperativity was observed between regions located close to the active site, including the hinge and tip of the glycine-rich flaps, and the rest of the protein. These results strongly suggest that inhibitor binding drastically decreases the cooperativity of unfolding by trapping the closed flap conformation in a deep energy minimum. To evade this conformational trap, PR20 evolves exhibiting a smoother folding landscape with nearly an ideal two-state (cooperative) unfolding transition. This study highlights the malleability of retroviral protease folding pathways by illustrating how the selection of mutations under drug pressure remodels the free-energy landscape as a primary mechanism. 

Evolution under Drug Pressure Remodels the Folding Free-Energy Landscape of Mature HIV-1 Protease.

The transitioning of the ectodomain of gp41 from a pre-hairpin to a six-helix bundle conformation is a crucial aspect of virus-cell fusion. To gain insight into the intermediary steps of the fusion process we have studied the pH and dodecyl phosphocholine (DPC) micelle dependent trimer association of gp41 by systematic deletion analysis of an optimized construct termed 17-172 (residues 528 to 683 of Env) that spans the fusion peptide proximal region (FPPR) to the membrane proximal external region (MPER) of gp41, by sedimentation velocity and double electron-electron resonance (DEER) EPR spectroscopy. Trimerization at pH 7 requires the presence of both the FPPR and MPER regions. However, at pH 4, the protein completely dissociates to monomers. DEER measurements reveal a partial fraying of the C-terminal MPER residues in the 17-172 trimer while the other regions, including the FPPR, remain compact. In accordance, truncating nine C-terminal MPER residues (675-683) in the 17-172 construct does not shift the trimer-monomer equilibrium significantly. Thus, in the context of the gp41 ectodomain spanning residues 17-172, trimerization is clearly dependent on FPPR and MPER regions even when the terminal residues of MPER unravel. The antibody Z13e1, which spans both the 2F5 and 4E10 epitopes in MPER, binds to 17-172 with a Kd of 1 ± 0.12 μM. Accordingly, individual antibodies 2F5 and 4E10 also recognize the 17-172 trimer/DPC complex. We propose that binding of the C-terminal residues of MPER to the surface of the DPC micelles models a correct positioning of the trimeric transmembrane domain anchored in the viral membrane. 

Insights into the Conformation of the Membrane Proximal Regions Critical to the Trimerization of the HIV-1 gp41 Ectodomain Bound to Dodecyl Phosphocholine Micelles.

We report structural analysis of HIV protease variant PRS17 which was rationally selected by machine learning to represent wide classes of highly drug-resistant variants. Crystal structures were solved of PRS17 in the inhibitor-free form and in complex with antiviral inhibitor, darunavir. Despite its 17 mutations, PRS17 has only one mutation (V82S) in the inhibitor/substrate binding cavity, yet exhibits high resistance to all clinical inhibitors. PRS17 has none of the major mutations (I47V, I50V, I54ML, L76V and I84V) associated with darunavir resistance, but has 10,000-fold weaker binding affinity relative to the wild type PR. Comparable binding affinity of 8000-fold weaker than PR is seen for drug resistant mutant PR20, which bears 3 mutations associated with major resistance to darunavir (I47V, I54L and I84V). Inhibitor-free PRS17 shows an open flap conformation with a curled tip correlating with G48V flap mutation. NMR studies on inactive PRS17 D25N unambiguously confirm that the flaps adopt mainly an open conformation in solution very similar to that in the inhibitor-free crystal structure. In PRS17, the hinge loop cluster of mutations, E35D, M36I and S37D, contributes to the altered flap dynamics by a mechanism similar to that of PR20. An additional K20R mutation anchors an altered conformation of the hinge loop. Flap mutations M46L and G48V in PRS17/DRV complex alter the Phe53 conformation by steric hindrance between the side chains. Unlike the L10F mutation in PR20, L10I in PRS17 does not break the inter-subunit ion pair or diminish the dimer stability, consistent with a very low dimer dissociation constant comparable to that of wild type PR. Distal mutations A71V, L90M and I93L propagate alterations to the catalytic site of PRS17. PRS17 exhibits a molecular mechanism whereby mutations act synergistically to alter the flap dynamics resulting in significantly weaker binding yet maintaining active site contacts with darunavir.

Structural Studies of a Rationally Selected Multi-Drug Resistant HIV-1 Protease Reveal Synergistic Effect of Distal Mutations on Flap Dynamics.

High-pressure is a well-known perturbation method used to destabilize globular proteins and dissociate protein complexes or aggregates. The heterogeneity of the response to pressure offers a unique opportunity to dissect the thermodynamic contributions to protein stability. In addition, pressure perturbation is generally reversible, which is essential for a proper thermodynamic characterization of a protein equilibrium. When combined with NMR spectroscopy, hydrostatic pressure offers the possibility of monitoring at an atomic resolution the structural transitions occurring upon unfolding and determining the kinetic properties of the process. The recent development of commercially available high-pressure sample cells greatly increased the potential applications for high-pressure NMR experiments that can now be routinely performed. This review summarizes the recent applications and future directions of high-pressure NMR techniques for the characterization of protein conformational fluctuations, protein folding and the stability of protein complexes and aggregates.

High-pressure NMR techniques for the study of protein dynamics, folding and aggregation.

Using fine-tuned hydrogen bonding criteria, a library of coiled peptide fragments has been generated from a large set of high-resolution protein X-ray structures. This library is shown to be an improved representation of ϕ/ψ torsion angles seen in intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). The ϕ/ψ torsion angle distribution of the library, on average, provides good agreement with experimentally observed chemical shifts and  J coupling constants for a set of five disordered proteins. Inspection of the coil library confirms that nearest-neighbor effects significantly impact the ϕ/ψ distribution of residues in the coil state. Importantly,  J coupling constants derived from the nearest-neighbor modulated backbone ϕ distribution in the coil library show improved agreement to experimental values, thereby providing a better way to predict  J coupling constants for IDPs, and for identifying locations that deviate from fully random behavior.

Prediction of nearest neighbor effects on backbone torsion angles and NMR scalar coupling constants in disordered proteins.

High-pressure is a well-known perturbation method used to destabilize globular proteins. It is perfectly reversible, which is essential for a proper thermodynamic characterization of a protein equilibrium. In contrast to other perturbation methods such as heat or chemical denaturant that destabilize protein structures uniformly, pressure exerts local effects on regions or domains of a protein containing internal cavities. When combined with NMR spectroscopy, hydrostatic pressure offers the possibility to monitor at a residue level the structural transitions occurring upon unfolding and to determine the kinetic properties of the process. High-pressure NMR experiments can now be routinely performed, owing to the recent development of commercially available high-pressure sample cells. This review summarizes recent advances and some future directions of high-pressure NMR techniques for the characterization at atomic resolution of the energy landscape of protein folding.

Monitoring protein folding through high pressure NMR spectroscopy.

The development of computational efficient models is essential to obtain a detailed characterization of the mechanisms underlying the folding of proteins and the formation of amyloid fibrils. Structure-based computational models (Go-model) with Cα or all-atom resolutions have been able to successfully delineate the mechanisms of folding of several globular proteins and offer an interesting alternative to computationally intensive simulations with explicit solvent description. Here, we explore the limits of Go-model predictions by analyzing the folding of the nonglobular repeat domain proteins Notch Ankyrin and p16 and the formation of human islet amyloid polypeptide (hIAPP) fibrils. Folding trajectories of the repeat domain proteins revealed that an all-atom resolution is required to capture the folding pathways and cooperativity reported in experimental studies. The all-atom Go-model was also successful in predicting the free-energy landscape of hIAPP fibrillation, suggesting a "dock and lock" mechanism of fibril elongation. We finally explored how mutations can affect the co-assembly of hIAPP fibrils by simulating a heterogeneous system composed of wild-type and mutated hIAPP peptides. Overall, this study shows that all-atom Go-model-based simulations have the potential of discerning the effects of mutations and post-translational modifications in protein folding and association and may help in resolving the dichotomy between experimental and theoretical studies on protein folding and amyloid fibrillation.

Pushing the Limits of Structure-Based Models: Prediction of Nonglobular Protein Folding and Fibrils Formation with Go-Model Simulations.

Although it is now relatively well understood how sequence defines and impacts global protein stability in specific structural contexts, the question of how sequence modulates the configurational landscape of proteins remains to be defined. Protein configurational equilibria are generally characterized by using various chemical denaturants or by changing temperature or pH. Another thermodynamic parameter which is less often used in such studies is high hydrostatic pressure. This review discusses the basis for pressure effects on protein structure and stability, and describes how the unique mechanisms of pressure-induced unfolding can provide unique insights into protein conformational landscapes.

Lessons from pressure denaturation of proteins.

Protein conformational landscapes define their functional properties as well as their proteostasis. Hence, detailed mapping of these landscapes is necessary to understand and modulate protein conformation. The combination of high pressure and NMR provides a particularly powerful approach to characterizing protein conformational transitions. First, pressure, because its effects on protein structure arise from elimination of solvent excluded void volume, represents a more subtle perturbation than chemical denaturants, favoring the population of intermediates. Second, the residue-specific and multifaceted nature of NMR observables informs on many local structural properties of proteins, aiding in the characterization of intermediate and excited states.

Exploring Protein Conformational Landscapes Using High-Pressure NMR.

In addition to encoding RNA primary structures, genomes also encode RNA secondary and tertiary structures that play roles in gene regulation and, in the case of RNA viruses, genome replication. Methods for the identification of functional RNA structures in genomes typically rely on scanning analysis windows, where multiple partially-overlapping windows are used to predict RNA structures and folding metrics to deduce regions likely to form functional structure. Separate structural models are produced for each window, where the step size can greatly affect the returned model. This makes deducing unique local structures challenging, as the same nucleotides in each window can be alternatively base paired. We are presenting here a new approach where all base pairs from analysis windows are considered and weighted by favorable folding. This results in unique base pairing throughout the genome and the generation of local regions/structures that can be ranked by their propensity to form unusually thermodynamically stable folds. We applied this approach to the Zika virus (ZIKV) and HIV-1 genomes. ZIKV is linked to a variety of neurological ailments including microcephaly and Guillain-Barré syndrome and its (+)-sense RNA genome encodes two, previously described, functionally essential structured RNA regions. HIV, the cause of AIDS, contains multiple functional RNA motifs in its genome, which have been extensively studied. Our approach is able to successfully identify and model the structures of known functional motifs in both viruses, while also finding additional regions likely to form functional structures. All data have been archived at the RNAStructuromeDB (www.structurome.bb.iastate.edu), a repository of RNA folding data for humans and their pathogens.

ScanFold: an approach for genome-wide discovery of local RNA structural elements-applications to Zika virus and HIV.

The small heat-shock protein HSP27 is a redox-sensitive molecular chaperone that is expressed throughout the human body. Here, we describe redox-induced changes to the structure, dynamics, and function of HSP27 and its conserved α-crystallin domain (ACD). While HSP27 assembles into oligomers, we show that the monomers formed upon reduction are highly active chaperones in vitro, but are susceptible to self-aggregation. By using relaxation dispersion and high-pressure nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, we observe that the pair of β-strands that mediate dimerisation partially unfold in the monomer. We note that numerous HSP27 mutations associated with inherited neuropathies cluster to this dynamic region. High levels of sequence conservation in ACDs from mammalian sHSPs suggest that the exposed, disordered interface present in free monomers or oligomeric subunits may be a general, functional feature of sHSPs.

Local unfolding of the HSP27 monomer regulates chaperone activity.

Disrupted-in-schizophrenia-1 () is a scaffold protein of significant importance for neuro-development and a prominent candidate protein in the etiology of mental disorders. In this work, we investigate the role of conformational heterogeneity and local structural disorder in the oligomerization pathway of the full-length  and of two truncation variants. Through extensive coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations with a predictive energy landscape-based model, we shed light on the interplay of local and global disorder which lead to different oligomerization pathways. We found that both global conformational heterogeneity and local structural disorder play an important role in shaping distinct oligomerization trends of . This study also sheds light on the differences in oligomerization pathways of the full-length protein compared to the truncated variants produced by a chromosomal translocation associated with schizophrenia. We report that oligomerization of full-length  sequence works in a nonadditive manner with respect to truncated fragments that do not mirror the conformational landscape or binding affinities of the full-length unit.

Disorder Mediated Oligomerization of  Proteins Revealed by Coarse-Grained Molecular Dynamics Simulations.

We have investigated the pressure- and temperature-induced conformational changes associated with the low complexity domain of hnRNP A1, an RNA-binding protein able to phase separate in response to cellular stress. Solution NMR spectra of the hnRNP A1 low-complexity domain fused with protein-G B1 domain were collected from 1 to 2500 bar and from 268 to 290 K. While the GB1 domain shows the typical pressure-induced and cold temperature-induced unfolding expected for small globular domains, the low-complexity domain of hnRNP A1 exhibits unusual pressure and temperature dependences. We observed that the low-complexity domain is pressure sensitive, undergoing a major conformational transition within the prescribed pressure range. Remarkably, this transition has the inverse temperature dependence of a typical folding-unfolding transition. Our results suggest the presence of a low-lying extended and fully solvated state(s) of the low-complexity domain that may play a role in phase separation. This study highlights the exquisite sensitivity of solution NMR spectroscopy to observe subtle conformational changes and illustrates how pressure perturbation can be used to determine the properties of metastable conformational ensembles.

Thermodynamic stability of hnRNP A1 low complexity domain revealed by high-pressure NMR.

Enzyme I (EI) is a phosphotransferase enzyme responsible for converting phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) into pyruvate. This reaction initiates a five-step phosphorylation cascade in the bacterial phosphotransferase (PTS) transduction pathway. Under physiological conditions, EI exists in an equilibrium between a functional dimer and an inactive monomer. The monomer-dimer equilibrium is a crucial factor regulating EI activity and the phosphorylation state of the overall PTS. Experimental studies of EI's monomeric state have yet been hampered by the dimer's high thermodynamic stability, which prevents its characterization by standard structural techniques. In this study, we modified the dimerization domain of EI (EIC) by mutating three amino acids involved in the formation of intersubunit salt bridges. The engineered variant forms an active dimer in solution that can bind and hydrolyze PEP. Using hydrostatic pressure as an additional perturbation, we were then able to study the complete dissociation of the variant from 1 bar to 2.5 kbar in the absence and the presence of EI natural ligands. Backbone residual dipolar couplings collected under high-pressure conditions allowed us to determine the conformational ensemble of the isolated EIC monomeric state in solution. Our calculations reveal that three catalytic loops near the dimerization interface become unstructured upon monomerization, preventing the monomeric enzyme from binding its natural substrate. This study provides an atomic-level characterization of EI's monomeric state and highlights the role of the catalytic loops as allosteric connectors controlling both the activity and oligomerization of the enzyme.

Article	Year
Evolution under Drug Pressure Remodels the Folding Free-Energy Landscape of Mature HIV-1 Protease. Journal of molecular biology\| PubMed ID: 27170547	2016
Insights into the Conformation of the Membrane Proximal Regions Critical to the Trimerization of the HIV-1 gp41 Ectodomain Bound to Dodecyl Phosphocholine Micelles. PloS one\| PubMed ID: 27513582	2016
Structural Studies of a Rationally Selected Multi-Drug Resistant HIV-1 Protease Reveal Synergistic Effect of Distal Mutations on Flap Dynamics. PloS one\| PubMed ID: 27992544	2016
High-pressure NMR techniques for the study of protein dynamics, folding and aggregation. Journal of magnetic resonance (San Diego, Calif. : 1997)\| PubMed ID: 28363306	2017
Prediction of nearest neighbor effects on backbone torsion angles and NMR scalar coupling constants in disordered proteins. Protein science : a publication of the Protein Society\| PubMed ID: 28884933	2018
Monitoring protein folding through high pressure NMR spectroscopy. Progress in nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy\| PubMed ID: 29157491	2017
Pushing the Limits of Structure-Based Models: Prediction of Nonglobular Protein Folding and Fibrils Formation with Go-Model Simulations. The journal of physical chemistry. B\| PubMed ID: 29425042	2018
Lessons from pressure denaturation of proteins. Journal of the Royal Society, Interface\| PubMed ID: 30282759	2018
Exploring Protein Conformational Landscapes Using High-Pressure NMR. Methods in enzymology\| PubMed ID: 30611428	2019
ScanFold: an approach for genome-wide discovery of local RNA structural elements-applications to Zika virus and HIV. PeerJ\| PubMed ID: 30627482	2018
Local unfolding of the HSP27 monomer regulates chaperone activity. Nature communications\| PubMed ID: 30842409	2019
Disorder Mediated Oligomerization of Proteins Revealed by Coarse-Grained Molecular Dynamics Simulations. The journal of physical chemistry. B\| PubMed ID: 31614085	2019
Thermodynamic stability of hnRNP A1 low complexity domain revealed by high-pressure NMR. Proteins\| PubMed ID: 33550645	2021
Structure elucidation of the elusive Enzyme I monomer reveals the molecular mechanisms linking oligomerization and enzymatic activity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America\| PubMed ID: 33975952	2021

Julien Roche

Biography

JoVE Journal Publications

Other Publications