Here we present a time-lapse morphometric protocol to follow the intensity of blastocyst shrinkage and re-expansion during previtrification interventions and post-warming recovery. The application of the protocol is possible in in vitro fertilization laboratories equipped with time-lapse microscopes and is recommended in the development of an optimal blastocyst vitrification method.
This article describes the noninvasive method of blastocyst morphometry based on time-lapse microphotography for the accurate monitoring of a blastocyst's volume changing during individual phases before and after vitrification. The method can be useful in searching for the most optimal timing of blastocyst exposure to different concentrations of cryoprotectants by observing blastocyst shrinkage and re-expansion in different pre- and post-vitrification phases. With this methodology, the blastocyst vitrification protocol can be optimized. For a better demonstration of the usefulness of this morphometric method, two different blastocyst preparation protocols for vitrification are compared; one with using an artificial blastocoel collapsing and one without this intervention before vitrification. Both blastocysts' volume changes are followed by time-lapse microphotography and measured by photo-editing software tools. The measurements are taken every 20 seconds in previtrification phases and every 5 minutes in the post-warming period. The changes of the blastocyst dimensions per time unit are presented graphically in line diagrams. The results show a long equilibration previtrification phase in which the intact blastocyst first shrinks and then slowly refills the blastocoel, entering vitrification with a fluid-filled blastocoel. The artificially collapsed blastocyst remains in its shrunken stage through the entire equilibration phase. During the vitrification phase, it also does not change its volume. Since the blastocyst morphometry shows a constant volume of the artificially collapsed blastocysts during the previtrification step, it seems that this stage could be shorter. The described protocol provides many additional comparative parameters of blastocyst behavior during and after cryopreservation on the basis of the speed and intensity of the volume changes, the number of partial blastocoel contractions or total blastocyst collapses, and the time to a total blastocoel re-expansion or the time to hatching.
Cryopreservation of human preimplantation embryos from the in vitro fertilization program (IVF) is nowadays a routine practice in most IVF laboratories. The slow embryo freezing method began to be clinically used in 1985, with the introduction of specific cryoprotectants and computer-controlled freezers, which enabled the controlled cooling of embryos down to -7 °C, when ice nucleation (seeding) was induced in the surrounding cryoprotective medium1. By continuous cooling, the ice crystals would grow, causing the hyperosmolality of the remaining liquid fraction and, consequently, the dehydration and shrinkage of the embryonic cells. At -30 °C or -80 °C, the embryos would be plunged into the liquid nitrogen for longer storage. What was happening with the embryos or oocytes during cooling could be observed only by specially adapted cryomicroscopes, which helped to improve cryopreservation protocols2. The freezing of blastocysts, a higher-volume and more fluid-contained embryonic stage, gave less promising clinical results in those days3.
The breakthrough in the cryopreservation of the blastocyst was the introduction of the vitrification method, in which the dehydration of the cells took place before cooling by using high concentrations of cryoprotectants4. The removal of the fluid from the blastocoel before vitrification can also be achieved by making a mechanical opening between two trophectoderm cells5. Although the immediate blastocyst survival rate after vitrification and warming is above 90%, and the clinical outcome following the transfer of vitrified/warmed blastocyst into the uterine cavity is almost comparable to results after the transfer of fresh embryos, this cryopreservation method has not yet been standardized6,7. Vitrification protocols vary according to (a) the type and concentration of the cryoprotectants, (b) the number of previtrification steps, (c) the duration of individual steps, (d) the use of an artificial blastocoel collapsing before vitrification or not, (e) collapsing methods, (f) the blastocyst expansion stage, and (g) the equilibration/vitrification temperature at which the embryos should be vitrified8. Since cryoprotectants can be toxic for cells, the blastocyst exposure time to these solutions has to be well defined. However, some cryopreservation media manufacturers allow very flexible protocols.
The interest of scientists is usually focused on studying the blastocyst re-expansion ability with the aim to find new biomarkers with a better prediction of implantation6,9,10. How human blastocysts dehydrate at different steps of adding cryoprotectants before vitrification and what happens with blastocysts after vitrification and warming, when cryoprotectants have to be removed from the cells, and how the blastocysts rehydrate and re-expand after warming, is not well described nor understood. The development of a methodology for the objective and quantified monitoring of blastocyst behavior during different cryopreservation steps is, thus, rationale.
With time-lapse microscopes of various manufacturers, it is now possible to monitor the behavior of the blastocyst in pre- and post-vitrification phases. By including additional computer tools, measurements of their size (morphometry) can also be performed. By measuring the decrease or increase in embryo size at a given time, it is possible to objectify the evaluation of morphodynamics of embryos during dehydration and rehydration.
All methods described here have been approved by the National Medical Ethics Committee on 19 April 2016 (No. 0120–204/2016–2).
1. Set-up of the Microscope Recording System
2. Selection and Prepreparation of Blastocysts for Vitrification
3. Preparation of Cryoprotectant and a Petri Dish for the Equilibration Phase
4. Transfer of the Blastocyst in Equilibration Solution
5. Recording of the Blastocyst at the Equilibration Phase
6. Vitrification of the Blastocyst
7. Video Editing of the Recorded Blastocyst During the Equilibration Phase
8. Measurements of the Blastocyst’s Cross-sectional Area from Images Created During the Equilibration Phase
9. Editing of the Data File with the Recorded Blastocyst’s Cross-sectional Areas from Images Created During the Equilibration Phase
10. Warming of the Blastocyst
11. Time-lapse Recording of the Blastocyst Re-expansion During Recovery Post-warming
12. Video Editing of the Recorded Blastocyst During the Re-expansion Post-warming
13. Setting of a Measurement Scale in Video Analysis Software for the Images Created with the Time-lapse Recording Software
14. Measurements of the Blastocyst’s Cross-sectional Area from Images Created During the Re-expansion Post-warm
15. Editing of the Data File with the Recorded Blastocyst’s Cross-sectional Areas from Images Created during the Re-expansion Post-warm
16. Creation of a Line Diagram
In a demonstration, we showed blastocyst morphodynamics in only one previtrification and one post-warming phase. A difference in the blastocyst's volume at the end of the equilibration phase and at the beginning of recovering in culture medium showed the intensity of embryo shrinkage, which is, in fact, the intensity of embryo preservation against ice crystallization.
As it can be noticed from Figure 1 and Video 1, the intact blastocyst did not collapse completely in equilibration solution. The blastocoel contracted only partially, but within 10 minutes, it slowly reached the re-expansion size of 70%. Contrary to this, the artificially collapsed blastocyst completely emptied the blastocoel immediately after laser treatment, but in equilibration solution, its volume did not change any more (Figure 2, Video 2). The presentation of blastocoel re-expansion in recovery medium (Figure 3 and Figure 4) with microphotographs and with line diagrams shows different patterns of blastocoel growth. A display of a single measurement of the cross-sectional area of the blastocyst is shown in Figure 5.
In vitrification medium with a higher concentration of cryoprotectants, intact blastocysts intensively shrunk once again, while the collapsed blastocyst's volume remained almost unchanged. From a graphical presentation, by using the protocol presented here, it is evident that the intact blastocyst undergoes a stepwise reduction of the blastocoel (Figure 6), once in the equilibration solution and once in the vitrification medium, while the collapsed blastocyst reached a shrunken stage at the beginning of the intervention with a laser (Figure 7). This poses the question whether 10 minutes of equilibration phase is really necessary for collapsed blastocysts, or whether this period could be shortened.
The presentation of blastocoel re-expansion can be linear or interrupted with several bigger or smaller contractions (Figure 8).
Figure 1: Time-lapse microphotography of the changes of an intact blastocyst during exposure to equilibration solution. Single images were recorded every 20 seconds. The scale bar is 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Time-lapse microphotography of the changes of an artificially collapsed blastocyst during exposure to equilibration solution. Single images were recorded every 20 seconds. The scale bar is 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Time-lapse microphotography of the changes of an intact blastocyst during recoverypost-warming. Single images were recorded every 5 minutes. The scale bar is 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Time-lapse microphotography of the changes of a collapsed blastocyst during recoverypost-warming. Single images were recorded every 5 minutes. The scale bar is 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Display of a single measurement of the cross-sectional area of a blastocyst. The blastocyst is carefully encircled with the appropriate selection tool in video analysis software. The zona pellucida is always excluded from the measurement. The scale bar is 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Representation of the changes in the cross-sectional area of an intact blastocyst. These panels show the representation of changes in the cross-sectional area of an intact blastocyst during exposure to equilibration solution (A) at vitrification and (B) during recovery post-warming. The units of the cross-sectional area are relative to the initial blastocyst's cross-sectional area before vitrification. The dashed line connecting panels A and B is imaginary, representing the changes during vitrification, cooling to -196 °C, and warming to 37 °C. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Representation of the changes in the cross-sectional area of a collapsed blastocyst. These panels show the representation of changes in the cross-sectional area of (A) a collapsed blastocyst during exposure to equilibration solution (B) at vitrification and (C) during recovery post-warming. The units of the cross-sectional area are relative to the initial blastocyst's cross-sectional area before collapsing and vitrification. The dashed line at panel A is imaginary and represents the starting and ending point during the blastocyst collapse. Also the imaginary dashed line between panels B and C, represents the changes during vitrification, cooling to -196 °C, and warming to 37 °C. Only the solid lines in panels B and C are the result of actual measurements of the cross-sectional area during the equilibration and recovery process. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: Graphical presentation of different patterns of blastocyst recovery after warming. The scale bar is 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Video 1: Time-lapse video of the changes of an intact blastocyst during exposure to equilibration solution. The video represents the changes, which last almost 10 minutes in real-time. Please click here to view this video. (Right-click to download.)
Video 2: Time-lapse video of the changes of a collapsed blastocyst during exposure to equilibration solution. The video represents the changes, which last almost 10 minutes in real-time. Please click here to view this video. (Right-click to download.)
The protocol for the observation of blastocyst morphodynamics during and after cryopreservation can also be carried out by using similar instruments and software tools from other manufacturers. Time-lapse systems adjusted for embryology allow the continuous monitoring of embryo development. The purpose of this work was to introduce the quantification of blastocyst behavior during the preparation of blastocysts for vitrification and after their warming. This was done by the objective measurement of changes in the morphology on a timescale. Obtained results of these measurements can be mathematically analyzed and compared with other results. Among the parameters that can be followed by the described protocol are changes in the size of the blastocyst, its inner cell mass, the blastocoel, or the zona pellucida within a certain period of time. The size can be displayed as the surface area in the largest blastocyst cross-section, the blastocyst circumference or diameter, and, after calculation, even as its volume.
In previous studies using time-lapse systems, blastocoel expansion velocity measurements were made only on fresh embryos11. In vitrified/warmed blastocysts, only the blastocysts' sizes were measured immediately after warming and before the embryo transfer, or the time period was analyzed at which warmed blastocysts re-expanded to the zona pellucida9,10. More detailed blastocyst re-expansion dynamics were analyzed only in our previous study8. In this study, the morphometric protocol has already been used to track the speed and pattern of blastocyst re-expansions after warming. Although these blastocyst growth biomarkers have shown not to have a high predictive value for implantation, they can be used for the comparison of blastocyst recovery potential after vitrification and warming with different cryopreservation media and protocols. Namely, the greater contractions of the blastocyst during blastocoel re-expansion suggest the weakness of the trophectodermal layer that could be caused during cryopreservation, and its inability to withstand the pressure made by the fluid-filled blastocoel.
The described morphometric protocol can provide many additional comparative analyses of blastocyst behavior, not only after cryopreservation, by measuring the speed and intensity of the changes in volume, the number of partial blastocoel contractions or total blastocyst collapses, the time to total blastocoel re-expansion, or the time to hatching. Moreover, it can also be used during previtrification phases for determining the most optimal timing of blastocyst exposure to different concentrations of cryoprotectants, as was presented in the results. Vanderzwalmen et al. showed on mice oocytes that vitrification can also be successful if intracellular osmotic pressure does not reach an equilibrium with external cryoprotectant solution12. The only problematic phase for the recording of blastocysts during preservation is the period in vitrification solution due to limited time; the embryo has to be exposed to a higher concentration of cryoprotectants and packed into the straw in less than 90 seconds. For these measurements, it would be recommended to use only blastocysts that are donated for research. Nevertheless, clinically available blastocysts can be recorded and measured again immediately after warming, with the aim to observe how they behave in dilution and washing solutions. Immediately after a blastocyst transfer from the washing solution to the recovery medium, blastocysts tend to float off the bottom. This can represent a difficulty in keeping the embryo in the same focal plane during recording. To solve this problem, it is recommended to prepare a dish with flattened drops of medium. A similar problem has been observed by Vanderzwalmen et al.12.
In further research, it would be useful to explore whether the length of exposure of artificially collapsed blastocysts to cryoprotectants could be reduced, consequently minimizing the toxic effect of these chemicals.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work is a part of research program P3-0327 and research project J3-7177, founded by the Slovenian Research Foundation.
Inverted microscope Eclipse TE2000-U | Nikon, Japan | / | |
Saturn 5 Laser System | Research Instruments, Origio, Denmark | / | |
Digital camera DC1 | Research Instruments, Origio, Denmark | / | |
Digital camera DC2 | Research Instruments, Origio, Denmark | / | |
Cronus 3.7 | Research Instruments, Origio, Denmark | / | microscope recording software |
Incubator with 6% CO2, 5% O2 | Binder, Germany | / | |
Primo Vision microscope | Vitrolife, Sweden | 16600 | |
Primo Vision Capture software | Vitrolife, Sweden | 16608 | time-lapse recording software |
Adobe Photoshop CS6 Extended software | Adobe Systems Incorporated, USA | / | video analysis software |
VirtualDub | Avery Lee | / | video editing software |
Microsoft Office Excell | Microsoft, USA | / | spreadsheet editor |
PrimoVision culture dish | Vitrolife, Sweden | 16604 | |
G2-plus medium | Vitrolife, Sweden | 10132 | cultivation medium for blastocyst stage embryos |
Human Serum Albumins | Vitrolife, Sweden | 10064 | |
Paraffin oil | Vitrolife, Sweden | 10029 | |
Equilibration solution medium | Irvine Scientific, Ireland | 90131 | |
Vitrification solution medium | Irvine Scientific, Ireland | 90132 | |
Thawing solution medium | Irvine Scientific, Ireland | 90134 | |
Dilution solution medium | Irvine Scientific, Ireland | 90135 | |
Washing solution medium | Irvine Scientific, Ireland | 90136 | |
HSV Vitrification straws | CryoBio System, France | 025246, 025249, 025250, 025248 | |
Liquid nitrogen | / | ||
Cryo vessel Biosafe 120 MD β | Cryotherm, Germany | 229286 | |
Cryo tank | Cryotherm, Germany | ||
Forceps | / | / | |
Scisors | / | / | |
Pippete for blastocyst manipulation | Gynetics, Belgium | ID275/10 | diameter 275 µm |
Pipette for oocyte denudation | Vitromed, Germany | V-DEN-135 | diameter 135 µm |
Pipettor EZ-Grip | Research Instruments | 7-72-2802 | |
Digital interval timer Assistent | Glaswarenfabrik Karl Hecht | 41977010 | |
IBM SPSS Statistics 21 | IBM, USA | / | statistical analysis software |
Self adjusting wire stripper | Knipex, Germany | 1262180 |