Caenorhabditis elegans is one of the main model species in biology, yet almost all research is performed in the absence of its naturally associated microbes. The methods described here will help to improve our understanding of the diversity of associated microbes as a basis for future functional C. elegans research.
The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans interacts with a large diversity of microorganisms in nature. In general, C. elegans is commonly found in rotten plant matter, especially rotten fruits like apples or on compost heaps. It is also associated with certain invertebrate hosts such as slugs and woodlice. These habitats are rich in microbes, which serve as food for C. elegans and which can also persistently colonize the nematode gut. To date, the exact diversity and consistency of the native C. elegans microbiota across habitats and geographic locations is not fully understood. Here, we describe a suitable approach for isolating C. elegans from nature and characterizing the microbiota of worms. Nematodes can be easily isolated from compost material, rotting apples, slugs, or attracted by placing apples on compost heaps. The prime time for finding C. elegans in the Northern Hemisphere is from September until November. Worms can be washed out of collected substrate material by immersing the substrate in buffer solution, followed by the collection of nematodes and their transfer onto nematode growth medium or PCR buffer for subsequent analysis. We further illustrate how the samples can be used to isolate and purify the worm-associated microorganisms and to process worms for 16S ribosomal RNA analysis of microbiota community composition. Overall, the described methods may stimulate new research on the characterization of the C. elegans microbiota across habitats and geographic locations, thereby helping to obtain a comprehensive understanding of the diversity and stability of the nematode’s microbiota as a basis for future functional research.
In nature, C. elegans is commonly found in rotten plant matter, especially rotten fruits like apples or on compost heaps1. It is also associated with certain invertebrate hosts such as slugs and woodlice2,3. These habitats are rich in microbes, which not only serve as food for the worm, but may also form stable associations with it. Information on the diversity of naturally associated microorganisms was only published in 20164,5,6. Since then, these and only a few more recent studies have revealed that C. elegans is associated with a variety of bacteria and fungi, most commonly including bacteria of the genus Pseudomonas, Enterobacter, Ochrobactrum, Erwinia, Comamonas, Gluconobacter, and several others6,7,8. Several associated bacteria can stably colonize the worm gut, although not all6,9,10,11,12. They are likely to be of key importance for our understanding of C. elegans biology because they can provide nutrition, protect against pathogens and possibly other stressors, and affect central life-history traits such as reproductive rate, development, or behavioral responses.
As an example, naturally associated isolates of the genera Pseudomonas, Ochrobactrum, and also Enterobacter or Gluconobacter can protect the worm from pathogen infection and killing in distinct ways5,6,11,13,14. A specific isolate of the genus Comamonas influences nematode dietary response, development, lifespan, and fertility15,16,17. Providencia bacteria produce the neuromodulator tyramine and thereby modulate host nervous system activity and resulting behavioral responses18. A set of different naturally associated bacteria were demonstrated to affect population growth rate, fertility, and behavioral responses5,6,9,11,19.
To date, the exact diversity and consistency of the native C. elegans microbiota across habitats and geographic locations are not fully understood, and further associations between the worm and microbes from its environment remain to be uncovered. Several previous studies used bacterial strains isolated from some soil environment, natural C. elegans habitats, or from mesocosm experiments (i.e., lab-based environments that recreate natural habitats) with C. elegans laboratory strains4,5,20. Even though these studies obtained new insights into the influence of microbes on specific nematode traits (e.g., nematode metabolism21), the relevance of these interactions for C. elegans biology in nature is unclear. Therefore, this manuscript describes the methods to directly isolate C. elegans from nature and to isolate and subsequently characterize the naturally associated microbes from both single worms and groups of worms. The described methods are an updated and improved version of the procedures used previously for the isolation and characterization of natural C. elegans and its native microbiota2,6,7. Considering that C. elegans is widely found in decomposing plant matter across the globe (especially in rotting fruits, temperate regions, and in autumn)1,2,22,23,24,25, this protocol can be applied by any lab whenever there is interest in relating C. elegans traits to naturally associated microbes and thus a more naturally relevant context. The latter is pivotal for a full understanding of the nematode's biology because it is known from a diversity of other host systems that the associated microbiota can affect diverse life history characteristics26, an aspect which is currently largely neglected in the multitude of C. elegans studies across almost all life science disciplines.
1. Preparation of buffers and media
2. Preparation of environmental samples (Figure 1)
Figure 1: Isolation of nematodes from substrates. Substrate samples are placed in empty Petri dishes and covered with viscous medium to flush out nematodes. Nematodes are transferred to M9-T and repeatedly washed to remove bacteria from the outside. Individual nematodes can be used for DNA isolation, isolation of associated bacteria, or placed on agar plates to culture worm populations. Figure created with BioRender.com. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
3. Isolation of Caenorhabditis nematodes (Figure 1)
4. Preparation of the worms for molecular identification of C. elegans and microbes
5. Isolation and cultivation of nematode-associated bacteria (Figure 2)
Figure 2: Species identification and isolation of individual bacteria. Individual nematodes are broken up using a bead homogenizer, and DNA is isolated for species determination via PCR or sequencing. Alternatively, the broken-up nematode material is serially diluted and plated onto growth medium plates. Plates are incubated until bacterial colonies appear, and single colonies are streaked to new plates to obtain pure cultures. Single colonies of the pure cultures are used to grow liquid bacterial cultures for the preparation of bacterial stocks for long-term storage at -80 °C. Figure created with BioRender.com. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The nematode C. elegans is frequently found in decomposing fruits, such as apples, and also compost samples. In Northern Germany, C. elegans as well as congeneric species (particularly C. remanei but also C. briggsae) are mainly found from September until November2. The nematodes are most commonly found in decomposing plant matter, especially rotting fruits such as apples or pears, and also compost, particularly material that shows a high grade of decomposition. The fruit and compost samples can be taken into the lab (Figure 3A,B), distributed in Petri dishes (Figure 3C,D), and subsequently submerged in a liquid or viscous medium to force the worms to leave the substrate material and swim to the medium's surface (Figure 3E,F). Thereafter, the worms can be collected, transferred onto agar plates or microcentrifuge tubes, and the species identity determined using diagnostic PCRs2,6,7,22.
Figure 3: Preparation of apples for isolation of nematodes. (A,B) Nematodes can be isolated from environmental samples like compost or rotten fruits and additionally be attracted by placing apples on compost. (C,D) The samples are divided, and small pieces are placed in a Petri dish. (E,F) Viscous medium is added to the samples, which usually leads to nematodes leaving the substrate material and swimming to the surface of the medium. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
PCR using the C. elegans specific primers nlp30-F and nlp30-R results in a PCR product of 154 bp length for C. elegans and no product for other nematodes (Figure 4). To confirm the successful performance of the PCR, DNA of a laboratory strain such as N2 should be run as positive control concurrently with the DNA of the isolated nematodes. Small amounts of biological material, such as small larval stages, can result in weak PCR bands (Figure 4A). The visibility of the PCR bands can be improved by using more DNA in the PCR (note that this will minimize the amount of DNA left for bacterial 16S rDNA amplicon sequencing, e.g., 2 µL of DNA instead of 1 µL), by applying a larger amount of the PCR product to the gel (e.g., 10-15 µL), or by increasing the number of PCR cycles. In comparison to single worms, worm populations consisting of at least 50 worms usually yield a larger amount of DNA, and the bands in the electrophoresis gel are clearly visible (Figure 4B).
Figure 4: PCR product of C. elegans-specific PCR. (A,B) The C. elegans-specific primers nlp30-F and nlp30-R produce a PCR product of 154 bp length. As an example, PCRs were performed on (A) single worms and (B) worm populations (e.g., 300-500 individuals), all isolated with the described protocol from rotting plant matter from the compost of the Botanical Garden in Kiel, Germany. (A) DNA of single worms and, in particular, of small larval stages often results in weak PCR bands. (B) DNA isolated from worm populations (e.g., 300-500 individuals) results in clearer bands. DNA of C. elegans N2 was used as positive control (+), no template was used as negative control (-). The smears below PCR bands are gel artifacts. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The microbes, which are associated with C. elegans, can be isolated from worms and also the worm-containing substrate samples. Microbe isolation follows general microbiology standards, including isolation of pure cultures from agar plates, their growth in liquid media, and their subsequent characterization (e.g., using the sequences of the 16S ribosomal RNA gene for bacteria). It is critical that the microbes are isolated as pure single colonies from plates, using standard microbiology procedures (Figure 5). This is important because some of the C. elegans-associated bacteria can form biofilms and/or easily aggregate, resulting in multi-species cultures (Figure 5C,D). The purity of the isolated bacterial cultures can be confirmed through the sequences of the 16S rRNA gene, as done for previously isolated C. elegans-associated microbes6,7. The obtained microbes can subsequently be used in experiments with C. elegans.
Figure 5: Bacterial isolates on agar plates. Individual bacterial isolates are streaked out onto agar plates, in this case, tryptic soy agar (TSA) plates, showing as examples an isolate of (A) Pseudomonas lurida, (B) Pseudomonas fluorescens, and an example with several bacterial species, shown as an (C) overview of the entire plate and (D) magnification of a section of this plate, in which distinct colony types are visible. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Table 1: List of primers used in this study Please click here to download this Table.
The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans is one of the most intensively studied model organisms in biological research. It was introduced by Sydney Brenner in the 1960s, originally for understanding the development and the function of the nervous system29. Since then, C. elegans has become a powerful model for studying fundamental processes across all biological disciplines, including behavioral biology, neurobiology, aging, evolutionary biology, cell biology, developmental biology, and immunology. Its success is based on a unique combination of advantageous properties, including a short generation time of approximately 3 days, ease of cultivation, transparent body (permitting efficient phenotyping), survival of freezing, efficient sterilization and developmental synchronization, and also efficient methods for genetic manipulation by mutagenesis, CRISPR-Cas, or RNAi. Today, C. elegans is studied in approximately 1,500 laboratories worldwide. When Sydney Brenner first established C. elegans as a model system in the laboratory, he grew the bacterivore nematode on the Gram-negative bacterium Escherichia coli OP50 as a food source. Ever since, C. elegans has been maintained in monoxenic culture on E. coli OP50 in laboratories all over the world29. Moreover, C. elegans populations are habitually synchronized or de-contaminated by a bleaching procedure that is only survived by sterile eggs and no associated microbe. It is thus easy to generate sterile animals that then can be exposed to individual bacteria under highly controlled conditions. However, as a result of these standardized C. elegans laboratory maintenance protocols, almost all studies on C. elegans biology were done in the absence of its naturally associated bacteria. In fact, information on the diversity of naturally associated microorganisms was only published in 20164,5,6, and the exact diversity of associated microbes is still not fully explored.
The described methods will help to further characterize the diversity of microbes which are associated with C. elegans in nature. These microbes are likely important determinants of the nematode's life history and should thus be an essential resource for future work with this worm. The described methods are an updated version of the only previously published methods for isolating microbes from natural C. elegans samples collected directly from the field6,7. The protocol takes advantage of the fact that C. elegans inhabits decomposing plant matter in nature. Such rotting material is rich in microbes, which serve as food for C. elegans and are likely to fulfill other functions, such as immune protection (i.e., protection against pathogens)5,6,11,13,14. The first key step is thus to obtain suitable substrates for worm isolation. Suitability may depend on the time of the year; in Northern Germany, C. elegans is primarily found from September until November2. This is the time when fruits like apples or pears become available and start rotting on the ground. The exact time is likely to vary among geographic regions23,24,25,30. Any plant material appears suitable for C. elegans, as long as it shows a high degree of decomposition and thus bears a rich microbial community-except for material dominated by fungi, which often are pathogenic to C. elegans1. Moreover, C. elegans is usually particularly common when general humidity is not too low2. To date, systematic information is lacking on whether Caenorhabditis nematodes vary in abundance in plant material from industrial versus organic farming or surface versus deeper layer of detritus or dependence on rain or not.
Once the samples have been collected and transferred to the lab, worms need to be "lured" out of their substrates. This has been achieved with a couple of different approaches, for example, by worm extraction through Baermann funnels31 or the placement of samples on an agar plate containing the E. coli laboratory food as an attractant in the middle27. In our experience, the protocol described here is generally faster and more efficient. It is based on the idea that the substrate samples are submerged in a liquid or viscous solution, which efficiently forces the worms out of the substrate and up to the surface of the liquid, from where they can be easily collected. The viscosity of the medium is not absolutely needed, but it slows down the movement of the worms and thus may make it easier to collect them. The efficient collection of worms is facilitated when the liquid is added carefully to the substrate, thereby avoiding solubilization of any humous substances, which can darken the liquid and may make it difficult to see the nematodes.
The next challenge is to identify C. elegans. Some morphological features can help to distinguish Caneorhabditis worms from other nematodes27, yet are insufficient for precise species identification. Rotting plant matter often contains other similar-looking nematodes, including congeneric species, such as C. briggsae or C. remanei2,6,23,25, which are impossible to distinguish at first sight. Therefore, C. elegans can best and most reliably be identified with the help of diagnostic PCR using species-specific primers2,6,7, as described in the protocol. In this context, it can be useful to establish a proliferating population of the isolated natural C. elegans in the lab, for example, on standard NGM plates. The natural C. elegans usually bring along associated bacteria, which are shedded onto the NGM plates, where the bacteria usually grow, subsequently serving as food for the worms6,7. Although the exact composition of the associated microbes changes during C. elegans proliferation on plates, it is still comparable to that of immediately characterized natural nematode samples6,7, and thus is a useful compromise that allows the isolation of both C. elegans and the associated microbes.
Once C. elegans is successfully identified, then the nematodes or the associated substrate samples can be used for the isolation and characterization of the associated microbes. To ensure that the microbes are truly associated with C. elegans in nature, it is of prime importance to avoid contaminations across all steps of the protocols. Collection of compost and fruit samples in the field should be done with particular care by the researcher, using sterilized material. All processing of material in the laboratory must ensure a high level of hygiene and again sterilized plastic ware and buffers. To reduce the contamination risk, all laboratory work should ideally be performed in a separate laboratory room, which is exclusively dedicated to the isolation of the microbes. As an alternative, all work with open plates, tubes, or other containers should be done in a laminar flow cabinet. To assess the contamination risk, appropriate control samples (e.g., without samples or without worms) should be processed in parallel. Moreover, a variety of different media could be used to ensure that all different types of bacteria with their different growth requirements can be cultivated and isolated. Nevertheless, previous work indicated that all thus far isolated bacteria, which are associated with natural C. elegans isolates, readily grow on NGM and TSA plates. Thus, it may be sufficient to focus on these media.
The isolated and characterized microbes will contribute to an improved understanding of the natural history of C. elegans. More importantly, to date, it is not well understood how C. elegans responds to its naturally associated microbes, which molecular processes are involved, and which functions mediate the worm's interaction with its microbial associates. One of the main exceptions is the comprehensive work by the Walhout group on the interaction between C. elegans and Comamonas DA 1877. It revealed vitamin B12 as a central metabolite provided by the bacterium, which influences worm gene expression, fertility, lifespan, and development15,16,17. The Walhout group further demonstrated that the vitamin B12 effect on fertility and development depends on the methionine/S-Adenosylmethionine cycle and is influenced by several transcription factors, such as the nuclear hormone receptor NHR-2315,16,17. Moreover, bacterial vitamin B12 contributes to the breakdown of the potentially toxic short-chain fatty acid propionate acid, which in the absence of vitamin B12 can be compensated through metabolic network rewiring, apparently through the production of 3-hydroxypropionate16,32. A different example is the neuro-modulatory effect of Providencia, discovered by the Sengupta lab, where bacterial tyramine is converted by the C. elegans tyramine β-hydroxylase to octopamine, which subsequently influences worm behavior through its interaction with the OCTR-1 octopamine receptor in specific sensory neurons18. Yet another example is immune protection, which is provided by various bacteria, especially those of the genus Pseudomonas. This occurs either through the production of antimicrobial compounds or through an indirect effect, possibly via the activation of specific host responses6,11,14. Additional microbes and especially the use of naturally associated microbial communities will help to obtain a more realistic understanding of the biology of this model nematode.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We acknowledge financial support from the German Science Foundation (projects A1.1 and A1.2 of the Collaborative Research Center 1182 on the Origin and Function of Metaorganisms). We thank the members of the Schulenburg lab for their advice and support.