The goal of the protocol is to reliably measure membrane mechanical properties of giant vesicles by micropipette aspiration.
Giant vesicles obtained from phospholipids and copolymers can be exploited in different applications: controlled and targeted drug delivery, biomolecular recognition within biosensors for diagnosis, functional membranes for artificial cells, and development of bioinspired micro/nano-reactors. In all of these applications, the characterization of their membrane properties is of fundamental importance. Among existing characterization techniques, micropipette aspiration, pioneered by E. Evans, allows the measurement of mechanical properties of the membrane such as area compressibility modulus, bending modulus and lysis stress and strain. Here, we present all the methodologies and detailed procedures to obtain giant vesicles from the thin film of a lipid or copolymer (or both), the manufacturing and surface treatment of micropipettes, and the aspiration procedure leading to the measurement of all the parameters previously mentioned.
Giant vesicles obtained from phospholipids (liposomes) have been widely used since the 1970s as the basic cell membrane model1. In the late 1990s, vesicular morphologies obtained from the self-assembly of copolymers, named polymersomes in reference to their lipid analogs2,3, rapidly appeared as an interesting alternative to liposomes that possess weak mechanical stability and poor modular chemical functionality. However, their cell biomimetic character is rather limited compared to liposomes since the latter are composed of phospholipids, the main component of the cell membrane. Furthermore, their low membrane permeability can be an issue in some applications like drug delivery where controlled diffusion of species through the membrane is required. Recently, the association of phospholipids with block copolymers to design hybrid polymer-lipid vesicles and membranes has been the subject of an increasing number of studies4,5. The main idea is to design entities that synergistically combine the benefits of each component (bio-functionality and permeability of lipid bilayers with the mechanical stability and chemical versatility of polymer membranes), which can be exploited in different applications: controlled and targeted drug delivery, biomolecular recognition within biosensors for diagnosis, functional membranes for artificial cells, development of bio-inspired micro-/nano-reactors.
Nowadays, different scientific communities (biochemists, chemists, biophysicists, physico-chemists, biologists) have increasing interest in development of a more advanced cell membrane model. Here, our goal is to present, as detailed as possible, existing methodologies (electroformation, micropipette aspiration) to obtain and characterize the mechanical properties of giant vesicles and the recent "advanced" cell membrane models that are hybrid polymer lipid giant vesicles4,5.
The purpose of these methods is to obtain reliable measurement of the area compressibility and bending moduli of the membrane as well as their lysis stress and strain. One of the most common techniques existing to measure bending rigidity of a giant vesicle is fluctuation analysis6,7, based on direct video microscope observation; but this requires large visible membrane fluctuation, and is not systematically obtained on thick membranes (e.g. polymersomes). Area compressibility modulus can be experimentally determined using the Langmuir Blodgett technique but most often on a monolayer8. The micropipette aspiration technique allows the measurement of both moduli on a bilayer forming giant unilamellar vesicle (GUV) in one experiment.
The following method is appropriate for all amphiphilic molecules or macromolecules able to form bilayers and, consequently, vesicles by electroformation. This requires a fluid character of the bilayer at the temperature of electroformation.
1. Fabricating micropipettes
NOTE: Here, micropipettes with an inner diameter ranging from 6 to 12 µm and a taper length around 3-4 mm are necessary. A detailed method of manufacturing micropipette is described in the following.
2. Coating pipette tips with BSA (bovine serum albumin)
3. Formation of GUVs and GHUVs by electroformation
NOTE: Electroformation is a commonly used technic developed by Angelova9. The procedures to obtain an electroformation chamber, deposit a lipid or polymer film (or both for GHUVs (Giant Hybrid Unilamellar Vesicles)) and hydrate the film under an alternative electric field are described in the following. The procedure to collect the GUV obtained is also described.
4. Micromanipulation set up
NOTE: The principle of micropipette aspiration is to suck a single vesicle through a glass micropipette by applying a depression. The length of the tongue inside the pipette is measured as a function of the suction pressure. The pipette coating with BSA, described previously, is essential to prevent or minimize any adhesion between vesicles membranes and the pipette.
The protocol is illustrated below.
With the protocol aforementioned, we have studied different synthetic giant unilamellar vesicle (GUV), obtained from a phospholipid: 2-oleoyl-1-palmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC), a triblock copolymer: Poly(ethyleneoxide)-b-Poly(dimethylsiloxane)-b-Poly(ethyleneoxide) (PEO12–b-PDMS43–b-PEO12) synthesized in a previous study13, and a diblock copolymer Poly(dimethylsiloxane)-b-Poly(ethyleneoxide) (PDMS27–b-PEO17). It has been previously shown by our group that the association of triblock copolymer PEO8–b-PDMS22–b-PEO8 with phospholipid POPC leads to a huge decrease of membrane toughness of the resulting GHUVs (Giant Hybrid Unilamellar Vesicles)15. The measurement has been repeated for this study and extended to GUVs obtained from diblock copolymer and GHUV obtained from the association of this diblock copolymer and POPC.
The results are illustrated in Figure 10 and Table 1. The area compressibility modulus and lysis strain for POPC are in perfect agreement with literature16. The measurement of the bending moduli of the hybrid vesicle has not yet been performed in the laboratory. Typical values are given for the polymersomes obtained. It is worth to mention that the toughness of membrane (Ec) obtained from diblock copolymers is far beyond those obtained with triblock copolymer. More interestingly, with the diblock copolymer it is possible to obtain giant hybrid unilamellar lipid/polymer vesicles that present higher toughness than the liposomes, which is the main interest of such association.
Figure 1: Microforge for polishing pipette tips. The picture shows the different parts of the device: the metal pipette holder (a), the glass capillary (b), the micromanipulator heater zone (c), the light source (d), the 10x, 32x, 40x objectives (e), and the microscope oculars (f). In the insert, the pipette tip, immersed in a glass bead, is observed through a 32x objective with reticle. The level of the molten glass into the tip has been fixed at an intermediate height (H) after cooling. Pulling the tip away causes a sharp break. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Experimental set up for coating and filling pipette tips. (A) A 500 μL glass syringe equipped with a flexible silica capillary is mounted to fill the micropipette with a glucose solution. (B) Magnification of the capillary lower part. During overnight immersion, the BSA solution level rises by capillary action up to 1 cm in length. The pipette is then filled with glucose by inserting a flexible capillary to remove unadsorbed BSA. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Materials to build an ITO based electroformation device. The device is composed of two glass slides coated on one side with indium tin oxide (a). A rubber O-ring has been cut on one side to allow loading of solution inside the chamber and harvest of the GUVs suspension (b). The rubber O-ring is used as a spacer to separate the two slides. The slides are connected to the voltage generator via electric wires (c) and attached to the surface by adhesive tape (d). Silicon-free grease is used to seal the spacer with the slides (e). Ohmmeter is used to identify the ITO coated sides and check the conductivity (f). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Electroformation set up. (A) The amphiphile solution is deposited using a glass capillary on the ITO coated sides of the glass plates. (B) After the assembly and the drying step, the chamber is connected to the voltage generator (10 Hz, 2 V) and then filled with sucrose solution. (C) After electroformation, an air bubble is created inside the chamber to help the GUVs to detach from the surface. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Micropipette Aspiration Set Up. (A) Components description: Fluorescence microscope (1), water filled tank and micrometer sliding on an aluminum optical rail (2), silicone tubing conducting water flow from the reservoir to the micropipette (3), micromanipulator control panel (4), motor unit of the micromanipulator which allows X, Y and Z displacement (5), vibration isolation table (6). (B) Magnification showing the homemade aluminum stage equipped with two glass slides (7), pipette (8) and pipette holder (9) mounted on the motor unit of the micromanipulator and fixed by clamping knob (10). Note that the pipette tip is immersed at the center of glucose meniscus. (C) Glass slides glued with vacuum grease on each side allowing the formation of glucose meniscus (Side view). (D) Glucose meniscus surrounded by mineral oil to prevent water evaporation (Top view). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Image of a GUV under tension using micropipette aspiration. The red channel collecting the fluorescence from the rhodamine tagged lipid and the transmission channel (DIC) have been merged. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Images of a GUV at different suction pressure. (A) The lowest applied tension that induces a tongue formation is used as reference to determine the initial tongue length (L0) and the vesicle radius (Rv). (B) Intermediate applied tension value with the associated tongue length (L). (C) Very high applied tension. (D) Image just after the membrane rupture where the pipette radius is measured (Rp). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: Representative stress-strain plot of GUVs obtained by micropipette aspiration. The same data set has been used to plot ln(σ) = f(α) and σ = f(α). In the low tension regime, ln(σ) varies linearly with α (green linear fit) and gives access to the Bending Modulus (Kc); whereas in the high tension regime, σ varies linearly with α (red linear fit) and gives access to the Area Compressibility Modulus (Ka). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 9: Representative stress-strain plot of GUV obtained by micropipette aspiration in the stretching regime. From the experimental curve several mechanical parameters of the GUVs can be determined. The Area Compressibility Modulus (Ka) corresponds to the initial slope and is measured by fitting linearly the curve. The last measured point gives the Lysis Strain (αL) and the Lysis Stress (σL) values. Finally, the Cohesive Density Energy (Ec) can be estimated by integrating the area under the curve (orange area). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 10: Representative stress-strain plots obtained for Liposome, Polymersome and Hybrid Polymer/Lipid vesicle. GUVs composed of POPC (red triangles), triblock copolymer (green circles), diblock copolymer (blue squares), triblock-based hybrid (light green circles) and diblock-based hybrid (light blue squares). The curves were obtained by averaging the measurements on at least 15 GUVs for each system. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Ka | αL | σL | Ec | Kb | |
(mN.m-1) | (%) | (mN.m-1) | (mN.m-1) | (kT) | |
POPC | 194 ± 15 | 4 ± 1 | 8 ± 2 | 0.17 ± 0.09 | 21.1±0.4 |
PDMS27–b-PEO17 | 121 ± 8 | 16 ± 4 | 15 ± 3 | 1.37 ± 0.67 | 10.6 ± 3.5 |
PDMS27–b-PEO17 | 132 ± 13 | 9 ± 4 | 10 ± 3 | 0.50 ± 0.38 | – |
+ 5 wt.% POPC | |||||
PEO12–b-PDMS43–b-PEO12 | 84 ± 13 | 7 ± 1 | 6 ± 2 | 0.50 ± 0.38 | – |
PEO12–b-PDMS43–b-PEO12 | 91 ± 11 | 3 ± 1 | 2 ± 1 | 0.03 ± 0.01 | – |
+ 5 wt.% POPC |
Table 1: Mechanical parameters determined using micropipette aspiration techniques on GUVs composed of phospholipid, copolymers or both.
The coating of the micropipette is one of the key points to obtain reliable measurements. Adhesion of the vesicle to the micropipette must be prevented, and a coating is commonly used in literature17,18,19,20,21, with BSA, β-casein or surfasil. Details of the coating procedure are rarely mentioned.
Dissolution of the BSA should be performed for at least 4 hours under agitation in order to achieve good solubilization. Nevertheless, the filtration step is still required to remove any aggregates that may obstruct the micropipette tip. If BSA is not well dissolved, most of it will be removed by filtration, and coating will be ineffective. The ideal concentration and dissolution time are respectively 0.8-1 wt. % and 4 h.
Another critical point is to insure a constant osmotic pressure inside and outside the vesicle during measurement. An increase of glucose concentration due to water evaporation during the experiment can lead to deflation of the vesicle and perturb the measurement (underestimation of Ka, etc.). The deposition of an oil layer is mandatory to prevent this phenomenon (Figure 3D). To check the efficiency of the oil layer, a constant aspiration pressure of few mN∙m-1 can be applied on a vesicle for 5 min, and the length L of the tongue inside the capillary should be constant.
The last critical point is the pre-stress step (section 3.3), rarely mentioned in literature20. This step is necessary to remove the buds, the tubes and the excess surface area of the vesicle and get reproducible results from a vesicle to another.
The micropipette aspiration method can be applied on all GUVs, as long as they present a fluid membrane (e.g., Telectroformation >Tm of lipids) and possess a bending modulus below 100 kT. In case of a thick and viscous membrane, even in the fluid state, two pipettes can be used to measure the moduli22. The micropipette aspiration technique presents a great advantage to give access to several parameters (bending and area compressibility moduli) and this is the only technique available to directly access the area compressibility modulus of a GUV's membrane.
Although this technique has been well known for a long time it is still commonly used by numerous scientific communities (biophysicists, physico-chemists, chemists, etc.). The micropipette aspiration method will continue to be a significant technique in the future, especially to investigate further membrane properties of advanced synthetic cell (e.g. Hybrid Polymer/Lipid Vesicles and protocells).
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the ANR for financial support (ANR Sysa).
Required equipment and materials for micropipette design | |||
Borosilicate Glass Capillaries | World Precision Instruments | 1B100-4 | external and internal diameter of 1mm and 0.58 mm respectively. |
Filament installed | Sutter Instrument Co. | FB255B | 2.5mm*2.5mm Box Filament |
Flaming/Brown Micropipette Puller | Sutter Instrument Co. | Model P-97 | |
Microforge | NARISHGE Co. | MF-900 | fitted with two objectives (10x and 32x) |
Materials for coating pipette tips with BSA | |||
Bovine Serum Albumin Fraction V (BSA) | Sigma-Aldrich | 10735078001 | |
Disposable 1 ml syringe Luer Tip | Codan | 62.1612 | |
Disposable 10 ml syringe Luer Tip | Codan | 626616 | |
Disposable 5 ml syringe Luer Tip | Codan | 62.5607 | |
Disposable acetate cellulose filter | Cluzeau Info Labo | L5003SPA | Pore size: 0.22µm, diameter: 25mm |
Flexible Fused Silica Capillary Tubing | Polymicro Technologies. | TSP530660 | Inner Diameter 536µm, Outer Diameter 660µm, |
Glucose | Sigma-Aldrich | G5767 | |
Syringe 500 µL luer Lock GASTIGHT | Hamilton Syringe Company | 1750 | |
Test tube rotatory mixer | Labinco | 28210109 | |
Micromanipulation Set up | |||
Aluminum Optical Rail, 1000 mm Length, M4 threads, X48 Series | Newport | ||
Damped Optical Table | Newport | used as support of microscope to prevent external vibrations. | |
Micromanipulator | Eppendorf | Patchman NP 2 | The module unit (motor unit for X, Y and Z movement) is mounted on the inverted microscope by the way of an adapter. |
Micrometer | Mitutoyo Corporation | 350-354-10 | Digimatic LCD Micrometer Head 25,4 mm Range 0,001 mm |
Plexiglass water reservoir (100 ml) | Home made | ||
TCS SP5 inverted confocal microscope (DMI6000) equipped with a resonant scanner and a water immersion objective (HCX APO L 40x/0.80 WU-V-I). | Leica | ||
X48 Rail Carrier 80 mm Length,with 1/4-20, 8-32 and 4-40 thread | Newport | ||
Materials for sucrose and amphiphile solution preparation | |||
2-Oleoyl-1-palmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine | Sigma-Aldrich | ||
Chloroform | VWR | 22711.244 | |
L-α-Phosphatidylethanolamine-N-(lissamine rhodamine B sulfonyl) | Sigma-Aldrich | 810146C | Rhodamine tagged lipid |
Sucrose | Sigma-Aldrich | S7903 | |
Electroformation set up | |||
10 µL glass capillary ringcaps | Hirschmann | 9600110 | |
Disposable 1 ml syringe Luer Tip | Codan | 62.1612 | |
H Grease | Apiezon | Apiezon H Grease | Silicon-free grease |
Indium tin oxide coated glass slides | Sigma-Aldrich | 703184 | |
Needle | Terumo | AN2138R1 | 0.8 x 38 mm |
Ohmmeter (Multimeter) | Voltcraft | VC140 | |
Toluene | VWR | 28676.297 | |
Voltage generator | Keysight | 33210A |