In this study, a novel in planta gene expression and gene editing method mediated by Agrobacterium was developed in bamboo. This method greatly improved the efficiency of gene function validation in bamboo, which has significant implications for accelerating the process of bamboo breeding.
A novel in planta gene transformation method was developed for bamboo, which avoids the need for time-consuming and labor-intensive callus induction and regeneration processes. This method involves Agrobacterium-mediated gene expression via wounding and vacuum for bamboo seedlings. It successfully demonstrated the expression of exogenous genes, such as the RUBY reporter and Cas9 gene, in bamboo leaves. The highest transformation efficiency for the accumulation of betalain in RUBY seedlings was achieved using the GV3101 strain, with a percentage of 85.2% after infection. Although the foreign DNA did not integrate into the bamboo genome, the method was efficient in expressing the exogenous genes. Furthermore, a gene editing system has also been developed with a native reporter using this method, from which an in situ mutant generated by the edited bamboo violaxanthin de-epoxidase gene (PeVDE) in bamboo leaves, with a mutation rate of 17.33%. The mutation of PeVDE resulted in decreased non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) values under high light, which can be accurately detected by a fluorometer. This makes the edited PeVDE a potential native reporter for both exogenous and endogenous genes in bamboo. With the reporter of PeVDE, a cinnamoyl-CoA reductase gene was successfully edited with a mutation rate of 8.3%. This operation avoids the process of tissue culture or callus induction, which is quick and efficient for expressing exogenous genes and endogenous gene editing in bamboo. This method can improve the efficiency of gene function verification and will help reveal the molecular mechanisms of key metabolic pathways in bamboo.
The investigation of gene function in bamboo holds great promise for the advanced understanding of bamboo and unlocking its potential for genetic modification. An effective way of this can be achieved through the process of Agrobacterium-mediated infection in bamboo leaves, whereby the T-DNA fragment containing exogenous genes is introduced into the cells, subsequently leading to the expression of the genes within the leaf cells.
Bamboo is a valuable and renewable resource with a wide range of applications in manufacturing, art, and research. Bamboo possesses excellent wood properties such as high mechanical strength, toughness, moderate stiffness, and flexibility1, which is now widely used in a variety of household and industrial supplies, including toothbrushes, straws, buttons, disposable tableware, underground pipelines, and cooling tower fillers for thermal power generation. Therefore, bamboo breeding plays a crucial role in obtaining bamboo varieties with excellent wood properties for replacing plastics and reducing plastic usage, protecting the environment, and tackling climate change, as well as generating significant economic value.
However, traditional bamboo breeding faces challenges due to the lengthy vegetative growth stage and uncertain flowering period. Although molecular breeding techniques have been developed and applied to bamboo breeding, the process of bamboo gene transformation is time-consuming, labor-intensive, and complicated due to the callus induction and regeneration processes2,3,4,5. Stable genetic transformation often requires Agrobacterium-mediated methods, which involve tissue culture processes such as callus induction and regeneration. However, bamboo has a low ability for callus regeneration, greatly limiting the application of stable genetic transformation in bamboo. After Agrobacterium infects plant cells, the T-DNA fragment enters the plant cells, with the majority of T-DNA fragments remaining non-integrated in the cells, resulting in transient expression. Only a small portion of T-DNA fragments randomly integrate into its chromosome, leading to stable expression. The transient expression levels show an accumulation curve that can vary for each gene expressed from an Agrobacterium-delivered T-DNA. In most cases, the highest expression levels occur 3-4 days after infiltration and quickly decrease after 5-6 days6,7. Previous studies have shown that more than 1/3rd of mutations in gene-edited plants obtained without selection pressure for resistance come from the transient expression of CRISPR/Cas9, while the remaining less than 2/3rd come from stable expression after DNA integration into the genome8. This indicates that T-DNA integration into the plant genome is not necessary for gene editing. Moreover, selection pressure for resistance significantly inhibits the growth of non-transgenic cells, directly affecting the regeneration process of infected explants. Therefore, by using transient expression without selection pressure for resistance in bamboo, it is possible to achieve non-integrated expression of exogenous genes and study gene function directly in plant organs. Hence, an easy and time-saving method can be developed for exogenous gene expression and editing in bamboo9.
The developed exogenous gene expression and gene editing method is characterized by its simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and the absence of expensive equipment or complex procedures9. In this method, the bamboo endogenous violaxanthin de-epoxidase gene (PeVDE) was used as the reporter for exogenous gene expression without selection pressure. This is because the edited PeVDE in bamboo leaves reduces the photoprotection ability under high light and demonstrates a decrease in the non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) value, which can be detected through chlorophyll fluorescence imaging. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this method, another bamboo endogenous gene, the cinnamoyl-CoA reductase gene (PeCCR5)9, was knocked out using this system and successfully generated mutants of this gene. This technique can be used for the functional characterization of genes that have functions in bamboo leaves. By overexpressing these genes transiently in bamboo leaves, their expression levels can be enhanced, or by gene editing, their expression can be knocked down, allowing for the study of downstream gene expression levels, leaf phenotypes, and product contents. This provides a more efficient and feasible approach for gene function research in bamboo. This technique can be applied to the functional characterization of genes that function in bamboo leaves. By overexpressing these genes transiently in bamboo leaves, their expression levels can be enhanced, or by gene editing, their expression can be knocked down, allowing for the study of downstream gene expression levels, leaf phenotypes, and product contents. Additionally, it is important to note that, due to extensive polyploidization, the majority of commercially important genes in bamboo genomes are present in multiple copies, resulting in genetic redundancy. This poses a challenge for performing multiplex genome editing in bamboo. Prior to the application of stable genetic transformation or gene editing techniques, it is crucial to quickly validate gene functions. In addressing the issue of multiple gene copies, one approach is to analyze transcriptome expression profiles to identify genes that are actively expressed during specific stages. Furthermore, targeting the conserved functional domains of these gene copies allows for the design of common target sequences or the incorporation of multiple target sites into the same CRISPR/Cas9 vector, enabling the simultaneous knockout of these genes. This provides a more efficient and feasible approach for gene function research in bamboo.
1. Preparation of bamboo seedlings
2. Preparation of plasmids and Agrobacterium
3. Agrobacterium -mediated in planta transformation system
4. Designing single guide RNAs (sgRNAs) for gene editing
5. Primer design and PCR
6. DNA extraction, endonuclease enzyme digestion, and sequencing
7. Measurement of chlorophyll fluorescence of NPQ values in leaves
Agrobacterium-mediated in planta gene expression in bamboo leaves
The RUBY reporter gene has been demonstrated to be effective in visualizing transient gene expression due to its ability to produce vivid red betalain from tyrosine10. In this study, Agrobacterium-mediated transformation was utilized to transiently express the exogenous RUBY gene in bamboo leaves (Figure 1). At the 3rd days after infection, red coloration was observed in the immature folded leaves, which became more vivid on the 5th day once the leaves had unfolded (blue triangle, Figure 1C). These results demonstrate that Agrobacterium successfully mediated the expression of the exogenous RUBY gene in bamboo leaves and that betalain synthesis occurred.
Furthermore, four strains of Agrobacterium (AGL1, LBA4404, EHA105, and GV3101) were compared and found that the GV3101 strain caused the most significant betalain accumulation in infected bamboo leaves, with the highest percentage of 85.2% of seedlings accumulated betalain after being infected, followed by AGL1 (76.9%) and then EHA105 (49.1%) and LBA4404 (31.3%; Figure 1D). This suggests that GV3101 is the most suitable strain for this purpose. High-fidelity PCR was conducted to detect whether the Agrobacterium-mediated T-DNA fragment had integrated into the bamboo chromosome. After 40 cycles of PCR, no bands of the RUBY gene were detected, indicating that the T-DNA fragment did not integrate or was integrated in such a low number that it could not be detected. Thus, these results conclude that this gene expression is transient.
Overall, these findings demonstrate the feasibility of Agrobacterium-mediated transient in planta gene expression in bamboo using the RUBY reporter gene. However, the red betalain color was found to be unstable and disappeared after 3 months of infection, indicating that the transient expression system is not stable for long-term observation.
In planta gene editing of bamboo violaxanthin de-epoxidase gene (PeVDE)
Agrobacterium-mediated in planta gene expression is a transient method of gene expression in bamboo. To investigate whether a transient CRISPR/Cas9 system could achieve gene editing in bamboo leaves, the key enzyme in bamboo's xanthophyll cycle, violaxanthin de-epoxidase (PeVDE), was selected as a target for trial gene editing. Single guide RNAs (sgRNAs) were designed on the first exon of the PeVDE gene (sgRNA-1), which contains restriction sites of AgeI upstream of the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) to facilitate gene editing validation (Figure 2A).
The CRISPR/Cas9 construct carrying sgRNA-1 was transfected into Agrobacterium to transform bamboo leaves. After infection of the Agrobacterium containing the CRISPR/Cas9 constructs carrying sgRNA-1 for 5 days, bamboo seedlings were subjected to high light treatment, and subsequently, chlorophyll fluorescence parameter detection was conducted. Certain areas of leaf blades were found that had lower non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) values (Figure 2B), indicating that the photoprotection ability of these areas was reduced under intense light. As PeVDE gene has the capacity to dissipate excess absorbed light energy13, these areas with lower NPQ values are likely to be the regions where the PeVDE gene was edited. Then, enzyme digestion and sequencing analysis were performed of the PeVDE gene fragment in these areas of the leaf blades (Figure 2C-D) and it was found that the mutation rate of sgRNA-1 was 17.33%, indicating that gene editing was successful in these areas of the PeVDE gene.
In addition, another sgRNA targeting site, sgRNA-2, containing an XbaI restriction site, was designed on the first exon of PeVDE. To investigate the possibility of long fragment deletion with dual sgRNA targeting, gene editing at both target sites was performed, resulting in long fragment deletion (Figure 2E).
Edited PeVDE mutant used as a reporter in the transient gene editing system
Whether the PeVDE sgRNA could serve as a reporter in the transient gene editing system was investigated. The cinnamoyl-CoA reductase (PeCCR5) gene (Gene ID: PH02Gene42984.t1) was randomly selected, to evaluate the PeVDE reporter. One sgRNA target for PeCCR5 was designed in its conserved motif on the fourth exon. The CRISPR/Cas9 construct carrying both sgRNAs, PeVDE, and PeCCR5, was transformed into bamboo leaves (Figure 3A).
After Agrobacterium infection for 30 days, the seedlings were treated with high-intensity light for 20 min. It was observed that only the leaf areas edited for the PeCCR5 gene had no effect on NPQ values, while the leaf areas transfected by sgRNAs of both PeVDE and PeCCR5 exhibited lower NPQ values (Figure 3B).
Subsequently, the PeCCR5 fragment from the leaf areas with lower NPQ values was amplified and sequenced and found a mutation efficiency of 8.3% using deep sequencing. Therefore, the PeVDE reporter successfully served as a transient gene editing reporter and can be used to screen for gene editing of other endogenous bamboo genes.
Overall, these results demonstrate the feasibility of bamboo gene editing using CRISPR/Cas9 in bamboo.
Figure 1: In planta expression of RUBY gene and betalain accumulation in moso bamboo leaves. (A) Moso bamboo seedlings wrapped in tin foil and ready for Agrobacterium infection, with red triangles indicating positions that were wounded by a sharp needle from a syringe. (B) Vacuum infiltration process of bamboo seedlings. (C) Betalain accumulation in bamboo leaves after 3 days of infection observed through phenotypic changes. (D) Here, four Agrobacterium strains, AGL1, LBA4404, EHA105, and GV3101 mediated RUBY gene transformation in bamboo leaves was performed. GV3101 harboring the GFP construct was used as a negative control. This figure has been modified from9. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: In planta expression and gene editing of PeVDE gene in bamboo leaves. (A) Location and target sequence information of sgRNA in the PeVDE gene. Red triangles indicate forward and reverse primers' positions for fragment amplification. (B) NPQ and raw imaging of bamboo leaves after infection. Numbers in the NPQ image represent NPQ values in the imaging software monitor. (C) Electrophoresis results of PeVDE fragment before and after AgeI digestion. WT denotes the wild-type non-infected leaves, and + and – represent PeVDE fragments with or without AgeI digestion, respectively. (D) Deep sequencing results of the PeVDE fragment in lower NPQ value leaves. The red, blue, and grey fonts in the sequences represent the target sites, PAM, and insertions, respectively. The red dashes indicate deleted nucleotides. (E) Sanger sequencing results of the PeVDE fragment after editing by both sgRNA-1 and sgRNA-2. This figure has been modified from9. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: PeVDE sgRNA as a reporter for screening gene editing of PeCCR5. (A) Schematic representation of CRISPR/Cas9 constructs containing PeVDE and PeCCR5 sgRNAs. (B) NPQ and raw images of bamboo leaves after infection with the constructs in (A). White triangles indicate areas with lower NPQ values. The rainbow color represents the value of NPQ/4, where red corresponds to the minimum value and purple corresponds to 1. (C) The red, blue, and grey fonts in the sequences represent the target sites, PAM, and insertions, respectively. The red dashes indicate deleted nucleotides. This figure has been modified from9. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Gene name | Primer sequence (5'-3') | Application | ||
RUBY | F: ATGGATCATGCGACCCTCG | For PCR amplification in infected bamboo leaves | ||
R: GTACTCGTAGAGCTGCTGCAC | ||||
PeVDE | F: TGTGGCTTCTAAAGCTCTGCAATCT | For gene cloning and sequencing | ||
R: TGTCAATGCTACAAGTCCTGGCA | ||||
PeVDE-Target1 | F: GGCATAGCCCTCACGCAGCACCGG | For designing PeVDE sgRNA-1 target | ||
R: AAACCCGGTGCTGCGTGAGGGCTA | ||||
PeVDE-Target2 | F: GGCACTCCACGGTCCCAAATCTAG | For designing PeVDE sgRNA-2 target | ||
R: AAACCTAGATTTGGGACCGTGGAG | ||||
PeCCR5-Target | F: GGCACTGGTACTGCTACGCTAAGA | For designing PeCCR5 sgRNA target | ||
R: AAACTCTTAGCGTAGCAGTACCAG |
Table 1: The sequence information of primers.
This method significantly reduces the time required compared to traditional genetic transformation methods, which typically take 1-2 years, and achieves transient expression of exogenous genes and gene editing of endogenous genes within 5 days. However, this method has limitations as it can only transform a small proportion of cells, and the gene-edited leaves are chimeric and lack the ability to regenerate into complete plants. Nevertheless, this in planta gene expression and gene editing technology provides a powerful approach for the functional verification of endogenous bamboo genes.
Currently, in planta gene expression and gene editing technology can only be performed in immature (curled) leaves, not in mature leaves. As the leaves unfold and enlarge, the number of gene-edited cells undergoing division increases, allowing for gene editing in specific leaf regions. However, the Agrobacterium-mediated transformation method used does not result in insertion of the exogenous T-DNA into the bamboo chromosome, making it difficult to use stable marker genes in bamboo6,9. Therefore, it is challenging to determine the exact locations of these regions. To address this, the PeVDE gene was edited, and the edited area exhibited a decreased photoprotection ability under high light treatment, as indicated by lower NPQ values, which can be easily detected using a chlorophyll fluorometer imaging-PAM. Thus, PeVDE was developed as a marker in bamboo to detect the occurrence of exogenous gene expression and gene editing. Due to the high conservation of this gene across different species 13, it can also be widely applied to other plants.
Due to the deposition of a cuticular wax layer on the epidermis of bamboo leaves, coupled with the characteristic curled and tightly wrapped morphology of immature leaves, the accessibility of Agrobacterium to leaf cells is significantly hindered. In order to improve the effectiveness of Agrobacterium infection, physical approaches, including wound and vacuum infiltration, have been utilized to promote the ingress of Agrobacterium into the enclosed curled bamboo leaves. This process enables close proximity between Agrobacterium and the leaf cells, thereby enhancing the efficiency of genetic transformation. Meanwhile, this gene editing system has so far been limited to bamboo leaves and cannot be expressed in organs with reproductive ability, such as seeds and lateral buds that can be inherited by the next generation. Future applications of the technique will be optimized to achieve in-planta gene expression and gene editing technology in organs with reproductive ability, aiming to obtain stably inheritable regenerating plants.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors would like to thank the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2021YFD2200502), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 31971736) for the financial support.
35S::RUBY | Addgene, United States | 160908 | Plamid construct |
Agrobacterium competent cells of GV3101, EHA105,LBA4404, and AGL1 | Biomed, China | BC304-01, BC303-01, BC301-01, and BC302-01 | For Agrobacterium infection |
CTAB | Sigma-Aldrich, United States | 57-09-0 | DNA extraction |
Imaging-PAM fluorometer | Walz, Effeltrich, Germany | Detect chlorophyll fluorescence of bamboo leaves | |
ImagingWin | Walz, Effeltrich, Germany | Software for Imaging-PAM fluorometer | |
Paq CI or Aar I | NEB, United States | R0745S | Incorporate the target sequence onto the CRISPR/Cas9 vector. |
PrimeSTAR Max DNA polymerase | Takara, Japan | R045Q | For gene cloning |
T4 DNA ligase | NEB, United States | M0202V | Incorporate the target sequence onto the CRISPR/Cas9 vector. |