The deciding step is formation of the carbocation intermediate during protonation. The orientation that places the positive charge on the more stable, more substituted carbon is favored, so that pathway leads to the major constitutional isomer. This intermediate-based reasoning explains why product prediction depends on comparing possible carbocations rather than simply counting the alkene’s carbon atoms.
The number of hydrogens already attached to each alkene carbon determines where protonation is favored. Hydrogen adds to the carbon that already bears more hydrogen atoms, leaving the developing carbocation at the more substituted position. A nucleophile can then bond at that position, establishing the preferred regiochemical arrangement of the product.
Its two alkene carbons are not equivalent, so the reagent can add in two different orientations. These alternatives place hydrogen and the incoming nucleophile on opposite carbon frameworks and therefore create different constitutional isomers. Markovnikov regioselectivity identifies which arrangement is favored under typical ionic conditions by evaluating the resulting carbocation stability.
First, identify the two carbons of the unsymmetrical alkene and compare how many hydrogens each bears. Place hydrogen on the carbon with more hydrogens, then place the halide or hydroxyl-containing nucleophile on the more substituted carbon. Finally, compare the resulting structure with the possible constitutional isomer to select the favored product.
The principle is especially useful for hydrohalogenation and acid-catalyzed hydration of unsymmetrical alkenes. In hydrohalogenation, the halide favors the more substituted carbon; in acid-catalyzed hydration, hydroxyl occupies that position. Recognizing the reaction class tells you which incoming group to track after determining the preferred orientation of addition.
It helps chemists anticipate product identity before carrying out a reaction, particularly when an unsymmetrical alkene could produce more than one constitutional isomer. The predicted placement of a halide or hydroxyl group also supports comparison with anti-Markovnikov pathways. This distinction is useful when selecting or interpreting an addition reaction for a desired structure.