8.9
Framing Effects
Information is everywhere and its presentation—such as how and when items are presented—can impact our perceptions and decisions surrounding the info.…
The presentation of information—both how and when items are presented—may disproportionately influence peoples’ perceptions and decisions.
For instance, on a trip to the grocery store, a woman observes several ads on her way in. Apparently, the initial one influenced her thoughts about the subsequent displays as she’s heading towards the section that positively promotes the product.
In this situation, she’s swayed by the primacy effect—one type of order effect whereby information that’s presented first has more impact on judgment than information arranged later.
Down the aisle, another shopper glances at the same store ads. He seems focused on the last entry, evidently forgetting about the previous ones. As a result, he’s repulsed and quickly moves along to avoid buying the item.
This latter case highlights the recency effect—another type of order effect whereby information that’s presented later has more impact than information given earlier. In other words, the most recently encountered material is more likely to be remembered.
Both of these effects can also be classified as framing effects—influences that occur due to the way information is framed in its appearance, whether it’s purely the order or the specific wording of a message.
For example, as the two approach the checkout line, they pass by different brands of phone-battery boosters: one states “Retains 95% charge!” while the other label says, “Loses 5% charge.”
Here, the former portrays a positive frame, whereas the latter describes a negative frame. Consequently, more customers are likely to buy the positively worded version, even though they both essentially say the same thing!
This example fits into a particular category called spin framing—framing effects that involve varying the content of what is presented.
Nearby, another example can be found in the media section. One paper uses the term “illegal aliens,” whereas the other headlines “undocumented workers” to refer to the same group of farm workers. In general, spin framing can be worded to deliberately influence attention and how strongly people react and make decisions.
After checking out, the woman receives a text: Her friend reminds her that she volunteered to babysit tonight. In her mind, she wonders what she was thinking when she said yes.
Helping a friend last week sounded nice as an abstract thought when the act of generosity seemed so far-off. Now, she’s processing the concrete details of the offer, and the last thing she wants to do is cook dinner for a picky teenager, encourage him to do his homework, and tell him to brush his teeth before bed!
This last example highlights that the temporal framing—whether the situation occurs near or far in time or even distance—also affects how someone interprets occasions.
In the end, the concept of framing reveals how people’s judgments are prone to change, depending on factors such as the specific language used, the order of processing content, and the perspective of time and space.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What is the difference between the primacy effect and recency effect?
The primacy effect occurs when information presented first has more impact on judgment than later information. Conversely, the recency effect happens when information presented last has greater influence and is more easily remembered. Both are order effects where only the sequence of identical information changes, not the content itself.
Q2: How does positive versus negative framing influence consumer choices?
Positive frames emphasize gains or benefits, while negative frames highlight losses or drawbacks. Even when two messages convey identical information—like "retains 95% charge" versus "loses 5% charge"—consumers prefer positively framed options. This attribute framing effect demonstrates how wording alone shapes purchasing decisions without changing the actual product value.
Q3: What is spin framing and how does it affect decision-making?
Spin framing involves varying the content or wording of presented information to influence perception and decisions. For example, calling a group "illegal aliens" versus "undocumented workers" uses different terminology to shape reactions, even though both refer to the same people. Negative terminology typically attracts more attention and creates longer-lasting psychological impacts than positive wording.
Q4: How does temporal framing change how people perceive future commitments?
Temporal framing refers to whether an event is perceived as occurring in the near or distant future. When commitments feel abstract and far away, people view them favorably. However, as the event approaches and concrete details become salient, perceptions shift negatively. This explains why someone might enthusiastically agree to babysit weeks ahead but dread it when the date arrives.
Q5: What is risky-choice framing and why do people make different decisions with it?
Risky-choice framing presents identical scenarios using either positive language about gains or negative language about losses. When framed as saving lives, people prefer certain outcomes over risky ones. When framed as preventing deaths, people choose riskier options. This demonstrates how the same problem's presentation fundamentally alters risk preferences and decision-making behavior.
Q6: How does goal framing differ from other types of valence framing?
Goal framing focuses on whether messaging emphasizes achieving positive consequences or avoiding negative ones. For instance, credit card messaging stressing losses from surcharges proved more persuasive than messaging highlighting discount gains. This contrasts with attribute framing, which manipulates a single product characteristic, and shows how the motivational frame shapes persuasive communication effectiveness.
Q7: Why does the order of information presentation matter more than the content itself?
Order effects demonstrate that when identical information is presented in different sequences, judgment changes based solely on position. Whether information appears first or last influences which details people remember and prioritize. This pure framing effect reveals that people's judgments depend not just on what they learn, but critically on when they encounter it. Understanding these effects connects to broader decision-making patterns explored through the representativeness heuristic decision making and biases.