12.7
Controls in Experiments
When conducting an experiment, it is crucial to have control to reduce bias and accurately measure the dependent variables. It also marks the results…
Controls in an experiment are elements that are held constant and not affected by independent variables. Controls are essential for unbiased and accurate measurement of the dependent variables in response to the treatment.
For example, patients reporting in a hospital with high-grade fever, breathing difficulty, cough, cold, and severe body pain are suspected of COVID infection. But it is also possible that other respiratory infection causes the same symptoms. So, the doctor recommends a COVID test.
The patient's nasal swabs are collected, and the COVID test is performed. In addition, a control sample is maintained that does not have COVID viral RNA. This type of control is also called negative control. It helps to prevent false positive reports in patients' samples.
A positive control is another commonly used type of control in an experiment. Unlike the negative control, the positive control contains an actual sample - the viral RNA. This helps to match the presence of viral RNA in the test samples, and it validates the procedure and accuracy of the test.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What is the purpose of controls in an experiment?
Controls are elements held constant and unaffected by independent variables, enabling unbiased and accurate measurement of dependent variables in response to treatment. They reduce bias and make results more reliable by allowing researchers to isolate the relationship between variables and distinguish treatment effects from other factors.
Q2: How does a negative control differ from a positive control?
A negative control lacks the main ingredient or treatment but includes everything else, preventing false positives by showing what happens without the treatment. A positive control contains the actual sample or ingredient, validating test accuracy and confirming the procedure works as expected by demonstrating the expected result.
Q3: Why are positive and negative controls used in diagnostic tests?
Positive and negative controls prevent false positive and false negative reports in diagnostic procedures. In COVID RT-PCR testing, a negative sample without viral RNA confirms the test doesn't produce false positives, while a positive sample with viral RNA validates the test's ability to detect the target accurately.
Q4: What role does a control group play in randomized experiments?
In randomized experiments, a control group receives an inactive treatment but is managed identically to other groups. This helps researchers balance the effects of being in an experiment with the effects of active treatments, ensuring that observed differences result from the treatment itself rather than experimental participation.
Q5: How do controls help establish relationships between variables?
By sorting data into control and experimental conditions, researchers can draw clear relationships between dependent and independent variables. Controls ensure that changes in the dependent variable result from the independent variable alone, not from confounding factors or experimental bias affecting the study design.
Q6: What is an example of controls in a clinical diagnostic scenario?
In COVID testing, when a patient's nasal swab is collected, a control sample without COVID viral RNA is maintained alongside the patient sample. This negative control prevents false positive diagnoses, while a positive control containing viral RNA validates the test procedure and confirms the accuracy of results.
Q7: Why are controls essential for reliable experimental results?
Controls ensure that experimental results accurately reflect the effect of the independent variable by holding all other factors constant. Without controls, researchers cannot distinguish between treatment effects and effects from other variables, making it impossible to draw valid conclusions about cause-and-effect relationships.