$$\rightleftharpoonup{xx}$$
$$\longleftharp{xx}$$,
$$\longrightharp{xx}$$,
The efficient and precise genetic manipulation of human primary HSPCs represents a great opportunity to explore and understand the processes influencing normal hematopoiesis, and most importantly, the leukemic transformation of hematopoietic cells.
In this protocol, an efficient strategy to engineer human HSPCs to express recurrent heterozygous GOF mutations was described. This procedure took advantage of CRISPR/Cas9 technology and rAAV6 vectors as donors for DNA templates to precisely insert WT and mutant DNA sequences into their endogenous gene loci. Coupling the engineered cDNAs (WT and mutant) with separated fluorescent reporter proteins allows for the enrichment and tracking of cells with a definitive heterozygous state.
This strategy presents several advantages in comparison to the frequently used lentiviral (LV)-based methods. One main advantage is that the CRISPR/Cas9-based system allows for precise editing in the endogenous loci, resulting in the preservation of the endogenous promoters and regulatory elements. This leads to homogeneity in the expression of the edited gene in the cells, a goal hardly achievable when an LV-based method is used. Gene transfer with LV vectors leads to semi-random integration of the gene with preference for transcriptionally active sites34. This can translate into overexpression of the transferred gene and heterogeneity between the edited cells, eventually resulting in difficulties to investigate and analyze the role of mutations and gene interactions. A second advantage is that the described system, being a site-specific editing system, eliminates the risks of insertional mutagenesis35.
The dual fluorescent reporter strategy allows for the precise enrichment and tracking of cells that were successfully edited on both alleles, with one allele integrating the WT cDNA and the other allele integrating the mutated cDNA sequences. Cells only expressing a single reporter represent either only monoallelic integration or biallelic integration of HDR templates with the same fluorescent reporter. Both scenarios can only be precisely distinguished if single cell-derived clones are produced and individually analyzed. However, HSPCs have only limited proliferative capacity in vitro, and when kept in culture for extended periods of time, HSPCs start differentiating into more mature progeny and lose their self-renewal and engraftment capacity. This makes selecting and expanding single-cell clones harboring the desired heterozygous mutation unfeasible. The application of the dual fluorescent protein strategy and enrichment by flow cytometry for cells bearing the heterozygous mutation allows for bypassing the problems induced by extended in vitro culture.
In this specific example, it was successfully demonstrated that HSPCs could be efficiently engineered and sorted in order to obtain pure populations of HSPCs carrying the heterozygous CALRDEL/WT mutation.
However, this system is not limited to engineering heterozygous frameshift mutations but can also easily be adopted to create other mutation types, including missense and nonsense mutations. By applying different combinations of AAVs containing WT or mutated sequences with different fluorescent reporter proteins, this system can also be utilized for the introduction of homozygous mutations (simultaneous transduction with two rAAVs both carrying mutant cDNA but different fluorescent reporters) or even the correction of mutations (simultaneous transduction with two AAVs both carrying WT cDNA but different fluorescent reporters). Additionally, it is important to mention that this strategy is not limited to the introduction of oncogenic GOF mutations. In fact, the described protocol can be utilized for multiple alternative strategies including gene knock-out, gene replacement36,37, targeted knock-in of transgenes (i.e., chimeric antigen receptors)38, and even for the correction of disease-causing mutations11,39.
The strategy of combining CRISPR/Cas9 and AAV6 with multiple fluorescent reporters has also been shown to be applicable in many other cell types including T-cells, plasmacytoid dendritic cells, induced pluripotent stem cells, neuronal stem cells, and airway stem cells24,38,40,41,42,43,44. This strategy can be implemented for the production of superior chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells. For example, it was recently published that CRISPR/Cas9-mediated knock-out of the TGFBR2 gene in CAR T cells greatly increases their function in the suppressive TGF-β rich tumor microenvironment45. Such an approach could provide a one-step protocol to both engineer the T cells to express the CAR and to knock out the TGFBR2 gene by site specifically inserting the CAR into both alleles of the TGFBR2 gene. Moreover, this approach could also be useful to generate universal CAR T cells by integrating the CAR in the T cell receptor alpha constant (TRAC) gene46,47.
To increase the reproducibility and to guarantee efficient editing of the cells, some important considerations need to be taken care of. The main critical points for ensuring successful editing of the cells reside in (i) the selection of the sgRNA, (ii) the design of the HDR template, and (iii) the rAAV6 production.
The selection of a good-performing sgRNA is crucial as it will determine the maximum number of alleles in which the HDR template can be integrated. Due to numerous software that are now available, the search for candidate sgRNAs has been simplified. By selecting the region of interest, the software can propose a series of sgRNAs with an on-target score and an off-target score that indicate the chances for editing at the desired locus and unwanted loci, respectively. These scores are calculated based on previously published scoring models48,49. Although this is a good starting point for selecting a good-performing sgRNA, the performance of the sgRNA needs to be confirmed as its predicted performance in silico does not always correspond to an efficient sgRNA in vitro. Therefore, it is highly recommended to design and test out at least three sgRNAs to increase the chances of finding the best sgRNA. Once a true good-performing sgRNA has been identified, then it is suggested to proceed with the design of the HDR template.
Precautions should be taken into consideration when designing the HDR template. The left and right homology arms (LHA and RHA, respectively) should each span 400 bp upstream and downstream of the sgRNA cut site, respectively, as shorter HAs could result in reduced HDR frequencies. The size of the cDNA that can be introduced via HDR is dependent on the packaging capabilities of AAVs, which is roughly 4.7 kb. Due to the numerous elements mandatory within the HDR template (LHA, RHA, SA, PolyA, promoter, and fluorescent reporter sequence), the remaining space for the mutated or WT cDNA is limited. This is unproblematic if the desired mutation is located near the 3' end of a gene or in genes with an overall short CDS. However, in cases where the mutation is located near the transcriptional start side (TSS) of the genes with a long CDS (exceeding the remaining packing space of the AAV), this described approach may not be feasible. To circumvent this problem, a strategy that relies on splitting the HDR template into two AAVs has been recently developed by Bak and colleagues. This strategy relies on two separate HDR-mediated integrations to obtain the final seamless integration of a large gene50.
The quality of the virus and its titer are additional factors that can make or break the successful genome engineering of the cells. For an optimal yield, it is important to not let the HEK293T reach full confluency while being maintained in culture. Ideally, the HEK293T cells should be split when 70%-80% confluency is reached. Additionally, the HEK293T should not be cultured for long periods of time as this can decrease their ability to produce virus. New HEK293T cells need to be thawed after 20 passages. Obtaining high virus titers is important for increasing the efficiency and reproducibility of the experiments. Low viral titers will translate to large volumes of rAAV solution required for the transduction of the HSPCs. As a general rule, the rAAV solution added to the nucleofected cells should not exceed 20% of the total volume of the HSPC retention medium. Higher volumes of AAV solution may lead to increased cell death, lower proliferation, and impaired transduction efficiencies. In the case of low virus titers, it is, therefore, recommended to further concentrate the virus.
In summary, this protocol offers a reproducible approach to manipulate human HSPCs precisely and efficiently through the simultaneous use of CRIPSR/Cas9 and rAAV6 donor templates with additional dual fluorescent reporters. This approach has proven to be a great tool in studying normal hematopoietic stem cell biology and the contributions that mutations make to leukemogenesis.