$$\rightleftharpoonup{xx}$$
$$\longleftharp{xx}$$,
$$\longrightharp{xx}$$,
The results demonstrated in this study provide valuable insights into the establishment and characterization of the NHDF 3D organoid model for studying T/L tissues. The 3-step protocol led to the formation of 3D rod-like organoids that exhibit typical features of T/L niche. This model was previously reported in Kroner-Weigl et al. 20237 and demonstrated in great detail here.
The phase-contrast images presented in Figure 2 showed the progression of the NHDF confluence and sheet formation during the expansion and stimulation steps. The 3D maturation process was performed by manually rolling the cell sheets into 3D rod-like organoids, which were then cultured under static tension for 14 days. The organoids displayed a glistening white appearance and increased density by day 14, suggesting contraction and structural reorganization within the organoids. This indicated that the maturation period is critical for achieving a more organized and T/L tissue-mimicking structure.
Furthermore, weight analysis revealed a significant decrease in the wet weight of organoids between days 0 and 14, yet again indicating significant contraction and ECM reorganization within the organoids during the maturation process. Importantly, wet weight measurements may vary between experiments due to handling and residual medium within the organoid or in the dishes. Moreover, the organoid might contain more medium at the beginning because, as discussed below, at day 0, the layers formed by the cell sheet rolling are segregated and not fused. With time, the layers joined and became more compact, and thus, the medium might be extruded.
Morphological evaluation by H&E staining provided additional insights into the organoid structural characteristics. On day 1, the organoids exhibited disconnected layers, primarily composed of cells with round nuclei surrounded by thin peri-cellular ECM. The lack of cell alignment parallel to the axis of the tensile load suggested that further maturation is needed to achieve a more organized cellular and ECM architecture of the organoids. Despite the contraction and organoid weight and dimension reduction between days 1 and 14, the H&E staining showed an increase in eosin-positive areas, suggesting augmented ECM deposition. Moreover, there were no longer visible layers, and occasionally, the cells had elongated nuclei and were positioned in parallel cell rows. This pointed out that the cells within the organoids undergo self-organization by changing their own arrangement as well as ECM deposition, structure, and alignment, thus mimicking the behavior of the native T/L tissue formation.
Overall, these findings highlight the potential of the NHDF organoid model as a valuable tool for studying T/L biology, in vitro tenogenesis, and even for the further development of scaffold-free T/L engineering. However, there are three critical steps for the successful handling of the 3D organoid model: 1) The formation of a tight cell sheet during 2D stimulation stage of the protocol. When using primary cells, this predominantly depends on the donor cell properties; therefore, it is important to assess multiple donors in parallel; 2) The manual rolling of the cell sheet. This requires rolling quickly, but at the same time gently, the cell sheet using a cell scraper. Therefore, it is advisable to plan initial organoids to first train this procedure; and 3) The stable fixation of the pins at the organoid edges. This fixation ensures the organoid axial elongation and prevents deformities as well as collapsing into lump-like structure. Moreover, during the 3D maturation stage, since the organoids experience remodeling of the ECM, the pins can suddenly detach, therefore, it is important to frequently monitor each organoid and to re-fix the pins.
The current model has not yet reached the level of in vivo mimicry to T/L tissue and harbors a number of limitations. For example, it requires a large number of cells per organoid as well as 35 days for the procedure to be completed, while most differentiation protocols, such as 3D chondrogenic pellet model, are set to 21 days22. The washing steps in the protocol procedure should preferably be carried out with physiologically-balanced wash buffer, for example, Hanks Balanced Salt Solution (HBSS) or Earles Balanced Salt Solution (EBSS), rather than PBS which might have metabolic consequences for primary human cells cultivated in vitro. Regarding the culture medium used in the 2D stimulation and 3D maturation stages in the organoid, it has been chosen DMEM plus 10% FBS formulation because such is the foundation of widely accepted differentiation protocols as well as with the intention to standardize and compare between different cell types for their organoidogenic properties23. Reproduction of the 3-step organoid protocol across different laboratory settings might be influenced by cell type used, cell quality and passage, as well as donor-dependent cell properties. Variations in the equipment, especially in the quality of the 10 cm cell culture dishes24 used during the 2D stimulation stage, could potentially impact the robustness of the cell sheet formation. Moreover, due to ECM contraction over the 3D maturation, the axial fixation of the organoids via pins might loosen up; therefore, as mentioned above, frequent monitoring is recommended. Testing and selecting different pins in terms of diameter and strength can also reduce the risk of pin detachment25. However, using pins for manual stretching is not robust, and it is prone to handling variability; hence, it is very important to develop in follow-up research a clamping mechanism for holding the organoid edges, which can result not only in standardization of this step, but also can permit dynamic stretching of the organoids. In general, it will be of interest to investigate two ways of organoid model modification, one downscaling - to reduce the number of cells per organoid and procedure time, thus making it more user-friendly, especially for in vitro studies; and the second upscaling - to increase the dimensions of the organoids in order to test their behavior in large animal models as potential tendon replacement strategy.
The model demonstrated here can provide a platform for investigating the mechanisms underlying tendon development, pathophysiology, and perhaps repair and regeneration if the organoids are combined with different cell types and subjected to micro-ruptures. It is important to mention that the study of Kroner-Weigl et al. 20237 identified several limitations regarding the NHDF cell type, namely, the NHDFs formed organoids are larger and more cellular than those derived from T/L cells, making it challenging to control cell proliferation and behavior. With regards to cell apoptosis, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL)-based assay showed no evidence of dead cells throughout the organoid at day 147, suggesting appropriate diffusion of nutrients, waste, and oxygen during the 3D maturation step. Interestingly, despite the morphological differences, pilot screening by quantitative PCR of a number of T/L-related genes (including different collagen types, Scleraxis (SCX), Mohawk (MKX), etc.) suggested comparable gene expression between NHDF and T/L organoids7, a finding that should be further investigated as well as should be validated at the protein level. Hence, for this cell type, further optimization is required in order to support T/L differentiation and can be based on adjusting the medium used in 2D stimulation and 3D maturation steps (e.g., serum concentration, growth factors, vitamins), extending the time of maturation or even subjecting the organoids to dynamic mechanical stretch. Evolving the protocol could further improve the organoid compositional, structural, and functional properties, thus enabling the model to better mimic the complex in vivo T/L tissue niche. Moreover, alternative cell sources can be investigated for their capacity to form T/L organoids and whether they can undergo T/L differentiation. Yan et al. 20209, employed the 3D organoid model by using young/healthy and aged/degenerative tendon stem/progenitor cells (Y-TSPCs and A-TSPCs) to investigate cellular behavior in 3D as well as whether tendon-forming capacity changes with T/L aging. They reported that A-TSPC 3D organoids exhibit poor tissue morphology, and the cells within have a lower proliferation rate but higher apoptosis paralleled with elevated levels of senescence-related markers9. Hence, the T/L 3D organoid model is a promising platform for studying molecular and cellular mechanisms involved in tendon aging and further can be used to test novel pharmacological therapies for tendon repair and regeneration. In a different approach, Chu et al. 2021 implemented dental follicle cells (DFCs) in the 3D organoid model in order to assess their ligamentogenic differentiation. This cell type formed very well-organized organoids, thus suggesting DFCs as an attractive cell source to differentiate in periodontal ligament (PDL) tissue, which could, in turn, develop a promising therapeutic strategy for periodontitis8.
In the future, the model could become even more complex by including different cell types (e.g., myofibroblasts, macrophages), which may offer novel insights into cell-specific behaviors and cellular crosstalk within organoids and contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of T/L biology, physiology and pathophysiology8,9,16,26.
The 3D organoid models hold several advantages for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine applications. They mimic closely the cellular composition and organization as well as cell-to-cell and cell-to-matrix interactions of human tissues, thereby offering a physiologically relevant platform for studying disease mechanisms and drug responses27. Organoids can be used as a high-throughput screening platform to assess the effectiveness but also potential side effects of different drugs and provide a reliable and low-cost alternative to animal testing. Furthermore, they enable direct comparisons between healthy and diseased conditions, allowing the discovery of key molecular and cellular changes associated with diverse pathologies, identification of biomarkers for early disease detection as well as facilitation of ascended understanding of disease mechanisms, and the development of targeted therapies28,29.
Taken together, we demonstrated in great detail the steps of the previously established 3D T/L organoid model that provides a promising platform for studying T/L tissue biology and in vitro tenogenic processes of various cell types. Further implementation, optimization, and research of this model are strongly encouraged as they may lead to advancing scaffold-free T/L engineering strategies, which, in turn, can contribute to improving T/L therapy.