Here, we describe the induction of a novel mouse model of preterm birth and neonatal morbidity via bacterial vaginal ascension. We chose E. coli K1 as it is a common cause of neonatal sepsis and meningitis and is vertically transmitted from the mother to the fetus38,39,40. Key to the success of this model is the use of Pluronic thermosensitive gel, which prevents the leakage of the bacterial suspension from the vagina, allowing for infection to establish and ascend to the uterus. As this model uses live bacteria derived from a septicemia isolate, it is crucial to monitor the dams closely27. If the animals refuse to move or eat or do not care for their pups (e.g., neglect nesting and feeding), they must be humanely sacrificed immediately.
Mostly, symptoms associated with infection dissipate within 24 h of delivery. It is also essential to be aware that different serotypes of E. coli and other strains of bacteria will have varying effects on gestational length, the extent of infection/inflammation, and neonatal outcome. We suggest performing preliminary dose experiments with different CFUs when using new bacterial serotypes/strains to determine the minimum concentration needed for the desired phenotype and setting strict humane end points to prevent suffering. Extreme caution should be used when delivering a live pathogen; allow the literature to guide the appropriate use of these organisms when modeling ascending infection.
The mouse strain is also important, as their immune systems differ. For example, the timing and CFUs used in this model do not have the same outcomes when performed in C57BL/6 mice. We chose to use the C57BL/6 Tyrc-2J mice as time course experiments showed significantly more infection in this strain compared to CD-1, BALB/c, and C57BL/6. In addition, there is evidence of black fur quenching bioluminescent signals, which is a useful measurable outcome in this model29. The optimal gestational day for bacterial administration may also differ with pathogen and mouse strain. There is huge heterogeneity in preclinical PTB models; therefore, it is important to consider these variables in order to develop reproducible results17.
Another consideration is the length of time the animals are exposed to anesthesia. As excessive exposure during pregnancy is associated with neurotoxicity in pups, it is essential to keep the time spent under anesthesia to a minimum (e.g., maximum 5 min) and to always include controls exposed to the same environment and treated with a vehicle substance41,42,43. Additional control groups useful for this model include untreated, intravaginal delivery of Pluronic gel only, and anesthesia only.
Immunohistochemistry is widely used as an experimental tool to identify different proteins and cells, and it can be used to characterize structure and connectivity in the brain. Here, we describe how to analyze key cells of the central nervous system that are associated with neuroinflammation and neurological injury. We also present methods to assess cellular apoptosis and histological stains that are useful for measuring brain and lung morphology. Important considerations to ensure the success of these protocols begin with the careful use of the PAP pen; if the PAP pen touches the tissue, the staining will fail but if the parameter is too wide, the sections could dry out overnight. Similarly, the humidity chamber must be kept damp to avoid drying out the sections.
When performing the Nissl staining, the glacial acetic acid step is the most critical; the sections need to be checked constantly. When the main structures of the brain become visible, the sections need to be moved immediately into EtOH to stop the reaction. We chose to assess the cortex and the hippocampus, as reduced cortical thickness and reduced hippocampal volume have been reported in human premature neonates and other animal models but other regions could be assessed for morphology changes44,45,46,47. Close attention must also be paid to the development of DAB staining. This should be timed and kept consistent between experiments.
Data analysis is the most common limitation of immunohistochemistry due to the difficulty in quantifying the results, which are often considered to be subjective. While GFAP analysis is performed using computer-assisted optical luminosity measurements, inconsistent staining can affect these measurements. In addition, the brain and lung morphology assessments involve manual, freehand measurements relying on the observer's judgment. To avoid inconsistency, we repeat these assessments twice and in a short period of time. To further reduce any bias, it is important that the assessor is blinded to the treatment groups. Low immunoreactivity can also be a limiting factor. Lack of signal could suggest that the antigen of interest is absent or it could be due to a protocol failure. To address this, we include a tissue sample that can act as a positive control where possible and repeat the staining procedure when we observe a low or absent signal to ensure this was not the result of an experimental error.
In addition to the protocols described, immunological analyzes of the maternal, fetal, and neonatal tissues can be performed by qPCR and ELISA. We have observed increased inflammatory mRNA and protein levels in animals exposed to infection25,31,48. We hypothesize that the neonatal neuropathology we demonstrate histologically could be the result of fetal brain, lung, and gut inflammation25,31. Other neuropathology assessments we have performed include myelin basic protein (MBP) to investigate myelination and NeuN to stain neuronal nuclei25,31. Further to this, other markers can be assessed for neutrophils and microglia to better understand the phenotype and behavior of these cells following exposure to infection in utero49,50. Additionally, behavioral tests could be performed to determine the long-term impact on offspring.
This model is not without limitations. For example, we see variation in pathology both between and within litters. This could be the result of using a live bacterium, where the spread of infection cannot be controlled. Consequently, the pattern and reach of ascending infection into the uterine horns vary and are often asymmetrical. Another limitation is the pathogenicity of the E. coli, which can sometimes cause the dams to become too unwell to care for their pups. Mice are also not the best model of lung injury, due to alveologenesis taking place postnatally, rather than prenatally, as in humans51. We failed to inflate our lung tissues when the samples were collected, which could have impacted on our results. However, our results are consistent with the changes observed in neonatal BPD animal models52,53.
This model recapitulates the postulated human condition whereby bacterial infection ascends from the vagina into the uterus, stimulating early delivery. Following our initial publication of this model, others have replicated or produced similar models, further emphasizing the reproducibility and relevance of this methodology19,54. Crucially, this model exhibits the common morbidities experienced by premature neonates, where other models have failed. This could be due to the use of a bacterial strain that is specifically associated with neonatal sepsis. LPS, which is most commonly used to induce preterm labor in animal models, is lethal to pups, so neonatal outcomes cannot be measured18. Other models of ascending infection have also struggled with producing surviving pups or in demonstrating neonatal morbidity19,20,21,22,23,24,55,56. Clinically relevant animal models, like the one we describe, are fundamental for understanding the pathophysiology of preterm birth and for developing innovative interventions that will improve neonatal outcomes.