The successful establishment of an orthotopic neurofibromas cell line-derived xenograft (CDX) model in NSG mice represents a significant advancement in NF1 research, addressing key limitations of existing models. The protocol confirms that human immortalized NF1-associated Schwann cells (ipNF04.4)14,15,16 can be efficiently engrafted into the sciatic nerve of immunodeficient mice, leading to reproducible tumor development within a physiologically relevant microenvironment. Orthotopic xenografts of Schwann cell lines were mentioned in the original studies establishing human Schwann cell lines14,15, and a detailed protocol is provided here.
Key to the success of this protocol was the meticulous preparation and monitoring of both the cellular components and the host animals. During the procedure, anesthesia was carefully managed, ensuring that the mice were kept in an appropriate state of anesthesia without significant stress. To minimize any potential damage, the sciatic nerve was not stretched with clamps or forceps, and great care was taken to avoid mechanical stress on the tissues. The use of luciferase-based BLI allowed for non-invasive, longitudinal monitoring of tumor growth, providing quantitative and reproducible data. This imaging strategy not only confirmed graft viability but also allowed for the identification of early deviations in tumor dynamics. The absence of significant weight loss (Supplementary Figure 1), motor dysfunction, or other signs of distress in the mice highlights the compatibility of this protocol with the ethical principles of animal welfare and the 3Rs (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement).
Compared to GEMMs, which rely on conditional Nf1 inactivation6,7,9, this approach offers several distinct advantages. GEMMs require specific genetic modifications, but they may not fully replicate the complex tumor-stroma interactions observed in human neurofibromas1,17. This model allows for the direct study of human Schwann cells in their native nerve niche, preserving cell-extrinsic factors4. Unlike GEMMs, where tumors develop unpredictably over time, the xenograft model allows precise spatiotemporal control over tumor formation. This model provides a rapid and reproducible platform for testing candidate therapies, with BLI enabling real-time monitoring of tumor progression and treatment response.
Furthermore, these findings align with previous studies on MPNSTs, where orthotopic xenografting has been shown to enhance the fidelity of tumor models5. However, benign neurofibromas pose unique challenges, as their growth is highly dependent on specific nerve interactions, which conventional subcutaneous grafting methods fail to recapitulate6. The results confirm that intraneural injection provides an optimal environment for sustained neurofibroma development.
Thus, this in vivo model can be considered a relevant complementary alternative to GEMMs, for preclinical therapeutic testing. However, there are limitations to the model. Human Schwann cells derived from neurofibromas have been immortalized and exhibit a tumor phenotype that could be considered more aggressive than that of a plexiform neurofibroma, with dense cell proliferation (Figure 2). No evidence of distant dissemination has been observed in animals, and complete malignant transformation has not been demonstrated. Further studies are needed to show whether the cell phenotype could correspond to the "intermediate" phenotype reminiscent of atypical neurofibroma, like atypical neurofibromatous neoplasms with unknown biological potential (ANNUBP)18. Another critical limitation of the model lies in its dependence on immunodeficient mice. The absence of an adaptive immune system in NSG mice limits the study of immune-tumor interactions, which are increasingly recognized as key contributors to neurofibroma biology7,19,20,21. Future refinements could incorporate humanized mouse models or alternative strategies to better capture the immunological aspects of the disease. Additionally, the reliance on luciferase expression for tumor monitoring, while highly effective, may limit the applicability of this protocol to experimental setups lacking access to BLI equipment. While BLI is a sensitive and non-invasive method, it does not provide direct insights into histopathological changes. Complementary analyses, such as MRI or advanced histology, could further improve the characterization of neurofibroma progression.
Several procedural steps may require optimization to ensure successful tumor engraftment. Injection failure can result from improper needle positioning or excessive leakage of the cell suspension. To mitigate this, the needle must be carefully inserted parallel to the sciatic nerve and withdrawn slowly after injection. Variability in bioluminescence signals may arise from inconsistent luciferin dosing or misalignment during imaging. It is recommended that the timing of the post-luciferin injection (10 min) be standardized and that identical imaging settings be maintained across all animals. If variability in tumor growth remains high, confirm cell viability before injection and minimize animal stress during handling.
In conclusion, this study establishes a novel and reproducible orthotopic neurofibroma xenograft model, offering an effective preclinical platform for studying NF1-associated benign tumors. By leveraging human Schwann cells in their natural nerve microenvironment, this model closely mimics human neurofibroma biology while enabling real-time tumor monitoring and controlled therapeutic interventions. This model represents an essential step between GEMMs and patient-derived models (PDXs), paving the way for more clinically relevant approaches to neurofibroma research and treatment.
Future refinements should aim to integrate immune components, such as humanized mouse models, to study the role of the tumor microenvironment6. Expanding imaging modalities, including MRI or PET scans, could complement BLI with structural and metabolic insights22. Extending experimental timelines will be essential to investigate long-term neurofibroma development and potential malignant transformation risks. By bridging the gap between GEMMs and PDX models, this platform enhances translational research in NF1, offering new opportunities for therapeutic innovation in benign peripheral nerve sheath tumors.