33.6
Convergent Evolution
Evolution shapes the features of organisms over time, ensuring that they are suited for the environments in which they live. Sometimes, selection pres…
Bats and most birds share the ability to fly by flapping their wings. At first glance, it may seem that these two groups evolved from a common ancestor with wings.
In fact, bats and birds are not closely related, and their last common ancestor was a ground-dwelling animal with four limbs. The evolution of wings is an example of convergent evolution, where similar features evolve independently to perform similar functions.
The ability to fly evolved multiple times. We can see this when we look closely at the structure of wings in birds and bats.
The hand and wrist bones of birds are fused, and feathers create a large surface area that helps generate lift during flight.
Birds keep their hindlimbs tucked under their bodies during flight, which reduces drag.
On the other hand, the finger bones of bats are elongated and support a large membrane of skin that forms the wing. A membrane connecting the hindlimbs and tail also helps with flight control.
Another example of convergent evolution appears in whales and fish.
Whales are warm-blooded mammals that nurse their young and breathe air using lungs, while most fish are cold-blooded animals that lay eggs and use gills for gas exchange.
Life in water placed similar demands on whales and fish. This led to the evolution of similar, or analogous, features. Both groups have fins and streamlined bodies that help them move easily through water.
Whales and fish do not share a recent common ancestor with aquatic body plans, yet they have analogous features with similar functions because of convergent evolution.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What is convergent evolution and how does it differ from shared ancestry?
Convergent evolution occurs when similar features evolve independently in unrelated organisms to perform similar functions. Unlike shared ancestry, where organisms inherit traits from a common ancestor, convergent evolution produces analogous structures—features that are similar in function but arise separately. For example, bats and birds both evolved wings for flight despite not sharing a recent common ancestor with wings.
Q2: How do bird and bat wings demonstrate convergent evolution?
Bird and bat wings show convergent evolution through different structural designs serving the same function. Birds have fused hand and wrist bones with feathers creating lift, while bats have elongated finger bones supporting a skin membrane. Both groups evolved from a ground-dwelling four-limbed ancestor without wings, yet independently developed flight adaptations suited to their environments.
Q3: What are analogous structures and how do they relate to convergent evolution?
Analogous structures are features similar in function but different in structure, arising from convergent evolution in unrelated organisms. They result from similar environmental pressures rather than shared ancestry. Butterfly wings are analogous to bird and bat wings—all serve flight—but evolved independently. Analogous structures can contain homologous features, such as forelimb bones shared by distant ancestors.
Q4: Why do whales and fish have similar body features despite being distantly related?
Whales and fish evolved similar streamlined bodies and fins through convergent evolution driven by aquatic life demands. Although whales are warm-blooded mammals breathing air with lungs while fish are cold-blooded and use gills, both groups developed analogous aquatic adaptations. Their last common ancestor lacked these aquatic features, making their similarities a result of independent adaptation to water environments.
Q5: How can scientists determine if traits are analogous or homologous?
Scientists examine DNA sequences to distinguish analogous from homologous traits. The Prestin gene, which encodes high-frequency hearing proteins, evolved convergently in dolphins and some bats despite their distant relationship. Similarly, structurally similar toxins and venoms in different species require DNA analysis to confirm whether they arose from convergent evolution or shared ancestry.
Q6: What role does selection pressure play in convergent evolution?
Selection pressure drives convergent evolution by favoring similar adaptations in organisms facing comparable environmental challenges. Life in water placed similar demands on whales and fish, leading both to evolve fins and streamlined bodies. These analogous features increased survival and reproduction in aquatic environments, demonstrating how environmental conditions shape the evolution of unrelated organisms.
Q7: Can organisms share both analogous and homologous structures?
Yes, organisms can possess both analogous and homologous structures simultaneously. Bird and bat wings are analogous in function but contain homologous forelimb bones inherited from their distant four-limbed ancestor. This combination shows how convergent evolution can modify inherited structures for new purposes, blending shared ancestry with independent adaptation.