11.5
Ethers to Alkyl Halides: Acidic Cleavage
Ethers are generally unreactive and unsuitable for direct nucleophilic substitution reactions since the alkoxy groups are strong bases and, therefore,…
Ethers are generally unreactive towards direct nucleophilic substitutions, as the resulting alkoxide ion is a strong base, and thus, a poor leaving group.
However, when heated with strong acids, such as hydrobromic or hydriodic acids, ethers get converted into alkyl halides.
Acidic cleavage of ethers is a typical nucleophilic substitution reaction. The type of nucleophilic substitution and the conditions required for the reaction depend on the nature of the alkyl groups bonded to oxygen.
Ethers with primary alkyl groups undergo acidic cleavage in the presence of excess hot concentrated acids by an SN2 mechanism.
The reaction mechanism begins with a proton transfer from the acid catalyst to the ether oxygen, forming an oxonium ion, a better leaving group.
Next, the halide ion acts as a nucleophile and attacks the less substituted carbon of the oxonium ion in an SN2 reaction, displacing alcohol and forming the first molecule of alkyl halide.
Excess hydriodic acid subjects the alcohol molecule to another round of SN2 reaction, forming a second molecule of alkyl halide.
Ethers with tertiary, allylic, or benzylic alkyl groups undergo acidic cleavage under mild conditions, such as moderate temperatures and dilute acids, by an SN1 mechanism.
For example, when ethyl tert-butyl ether reacts with dilute hydriodic acid, protonation of ether forms a stable tertiary carbocation with the loss of primary alcohol.
Finally, the tertiary carbocation reacts with the iodide ion by an SN1 mechanism, forming a tert-butyl iodide.
The reactivity of the halogen acids towards ether cleavage increases with the nucleophilicity of the halide ions.
Therefore, both hydriodic and hydrobromic acids readily cleave ethers. Hydrochloric acid is less efficient, and hydrofluoric acid does not cleave ethers.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: Why are ethers generally unreactive toward nucleophilic substitution?
Ethers are unreactive because the alkoxy group is a strong base and therefore a poor leaving group. This makes direct nucleophilic substitution unfavorable. However, when protonated by strong acids, the ether oxygen becomes a better leaving group, enabling acidic cleavage reactions to proceed.
Q2: What is the first step in acidic cleavage of ethers?
The first step involves protonation of the ether oxygen by a strong acid like HBr or HI, forming an oxonium ion. This oxonium ion is a much better leaving group than the original ether. The halide ion then attacks the less substituted carbon in an SN2 or SN1 reaction, depending on the alkyl group structure.
Q3: How does the mechanism differ between primary and tertiary ethers during acidic cleavage?
Primary ethers undergo SN2 cleavage with excess hot concentrated acids, where the halide attacks the less hindered carbon. Tertiary, allylic, or benzylic ethers undergo SN1 cleavage under mild conditions, forming stable carbocations as intermediates. The difference reflects substrate reactivity and carbocation stability.
Q4: What happens to the alcohol produced in the first step of ether cleavage?
The alcohol produced in the first cleavage step reacts with excess strong acid in a second SN2 or SN1 reaction, forming a second molecule of alkyl halide. This two-step process converts both carbon atoms of the original ether into alkyl halides when excess acid is present.
Q5: Why does reactivity of halogen acids toward ether cleavage vary?
The reactivity of halogen acids depends on the nucleophilicity of the halide ion. Hydriodic and hydrobromic acids are highly reactive because iodide and bromide are strong nucleophiles. Hydrochloric acid is less efficient, and hydrofluoric acid does not cleave ethers due to the poor nucleophilicity of fluoride.
Q6: What role does the oxonium ion play in ether cleavage?
The oxonium ion, formed by protonation of the ether oxygen, serves as the activated intermediate in acidic cleavage. It transforms the poor leaving group into a good one, allowing the halide nucleophile to attack and displace alcohol. This activation is essential for the nucleophilic substitution to occur.
Q7: How do reaction conditions differ between SN1 and SN2 ether cleavage pathways?
SN2 cleavage of primary ethers requires excess hot concentrated acids to provide sufficient nucleophile concentration and energy. SN1 cleavage of tertiary ethers occurs under milder conditions with moderate temperatures and dilute acids, since stable carbocations form readily and require less driving force.