6.9
SN2 Reaction: Transition State
An SN2 reaction of an alkyl halide is a single-step process in which bond formation between the nucleophile and the substrate and bond breaking betwee…
An SN2 reaction follows a concerted mechanism during which a nucleophile attacks the substrate from the back-side, with simultaneous loss of the leaving group from the side opposite to it.
This occurs through a transition state, which is represented within square brackets. The structure includes an electrophilic carbon attached to five groups: three substituents, one nucleophile, and one leaving group. The nucleophile and the leaving group are partially bonded, and both groups carry a partial negative charge.
Since the transition state is not an intermediate, it cannot be isolated. It has a trigonal bipyramidal geometry with the three substituents in a planar arrangement. The nucleophile and the leaving group are placed 180° apart, perpendicular to the plane.
The substituents are at 90°angles from both the nucleophile and the leaving group. This increases crowding, leading to an unstable structure at the highest energy on the reaction pathway.
The energy of the transition state affects the rate of an SN2 reaction. The higher the transition state energy, the larger the activation energy, and hence the lower the reaction rate.
Reaction rates are also influenced by steric hindrance, meaning the ease with which the nucleophile attacks the electrophilic center.
When alkyl substitution on an alpha-carbon increases, steric hindrance and, therefore, van der Waals repulsion with the incoming nucleophile increases.
For instance, a methyl halide and any primary halide present the least steric repulsion, and the reaction proceeds faster.
In comparison, a secondary halide with two bulky groups leads to an increased steric repulsion, which consequently slows down the reaction.
In a tertiary halide, the three bulky groups impede the nucleophilic attack, making the substrate practically nonreactive by an SN2 mechanism.
Additionally, increased β-alkyl substitution of a primary halide increases steric repulsion, making the molecule incapable of undergoing an SN2 reaction.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What is the geometry of the transition state in an SN2 reaction?
The transition state has a trigonal bipyramidal geometry with three substituents arranged in a planar configuration. The nucleophile and leaving group are positioned 180° apart, perpendicular to this plane, at 90° angles from the substituents. This geometry creates significant steric crowding, making the transition state highly unstable and energetically unfavorable.
Q2: How does transition state energy affect SN2 reaction rates?
The energy of the transition state directly determines the activation energy required for the reaction. Higher transition state energy increases activation energy, which slows the reaction rate. Conversely, lower transition state energy decreases activation energy and accelerates the reaction. This relationship between energy and rate is fundamental to predicting SN2 reaction kinetics.
Q3: Why does steric hindrance slow down SN2 reactions?
Increased alkyl substitution on the alpha-carbon creates steric hindrance that impedes nucleophilic attack. Van der Waals repulsion between the incoming nucleophile and bulky groups increases crowding at the transition state, raising its energy. This elevated transition state energy requires greater activation energy, reducing reaction rate and substrate reactivity.
Q4: What is the reactivity order of alkyl halides in SN2 reactions?
Alkyl halide reactivity in SN2 reactions follows this order: methyl halide (highly reactive) > primary halide > secondary halide > beta-substituted halide > tertiary halide (practically unreactive). Methyl and primary halides present minimal steric repulsion, enabling fast reactions. Tertiary halides are essentially unreactive due to three bulky groups blocking nucleophilic access.
Q5: Why can't the transition state be isolated in an SN2 reaction?
The transition state is not an intermediate; it exists only at the highest energy point along the reaction pathway. It is an unstable, transient structure that immediately converts to products. Because it cannot be stabilized or accumulated, it cannot be isolated or directly observed experimentally.
Q6: How does beta-alkyl substitution affect SN2 reactivity?
Increased beta-alkyl substitution on a primary halide increases steric repulsion between the incoming nucleophile and the bulky groups. This heightened crowding raises the transition state energy and activation energy, making the molecule incapable of undergoing an SN2 reaction efficiently and predictably.
Q7: What bonds are forming and breaking during the SN2 transition state?
During the transition state, the nucleophile forms a partial bond with the electrophilic carbon while the leaving group simultaneously breaks its bond with the carbon. Both the nucleophile and leaving group carry partial negative charges and are represented by dotted partial bonds in the transition state structure.