18.17
Directing and Steric Effects in Disubstituted Benzene Derivatives
When disubstituted benzenes undergo electrophilic substitution, the product distribution depends on the directing effect of both substituents. When th…
Electrophilic substitution of a disubstituted benzene ring depends on the directing effect of the individual substituents.
If the directing effects of the substituents reinforce each other, the substitution gives a single product.
For example, bromination of p-nitrotoluene is directed at the same position—ortho to the methyl group and meta to the nitro group, giving a single product.
Alternatively, if the directing effects of the substituents compete, the more powerful activating group dominates.
For instance, nitration of p-methylphenol occurs ortho to the hydroxy group because it is a stronger activator than the methyl group.
Substituents having similar activating properties give a mixture of products.
The steric effect also plays an important role in determining product distribution.
For example, nitration of p-tert-butyltoluene occurs at the less hindered position—ortho to the methyl group.
Notably, substitution between two groups in a meta-disubstituted ring is not preferred due to the steric hindrance. For example, the nitration of m-chlorotoluene.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What happens when directing effects of substituents reinforce each other on a disubstituted benzene?
When both substituents direct electrophilic substitution to the same position, a single product forms. For example, bromination of p-nitrotoluene gives one product because the methyl group directs ortho while the nitro group directs meta—the same location. This predictable outcome simplifies product distribution and makes the reaction highly selective.
Q2: How does activating power determine product distribution when directing effects compete?
The stronger activating group dominates when substituents direct to different positions. In nitration of p-methylphenol, the hydroxyl group is a stronger activator than the methyl group, so substitution occurs ortho to the hydroxyl group. This principle helps predict which product predominates in competing scenarios.
Q3: What product mixture results from disubstituted benzenes with similar activating properties?
Substituents with comparable activating strength produce a mixture of isomeric products because neither group dominates the directing effect. The competing electronic effects direct electrophiles to multiple positions with similar reactivity, resulting in multiple products rather than a single selective outcome.
Q4: How does steric hindrance influence substitution position on disubstituted benzenes?
Electrophilic substitution preferentially occurs at less hindered positions. In nitration of p-tert-butyltoluene, the bulky tert-butyl group blocks nearby sites, so substitution occurs ortho to the methyl group instead. Steric effects can override or modify electronic directing effects to determine final product distribution.
Q5: Why is substitution between two groups in a meta-disubstituted benzene unfavorable?
The position between two substituents in a meta-disubstituted ring experiences significant steric hindrance from both groups, making it sterically unfavorable for electrophilic attack. This steric blocking effect prevents substitution at that crowded site, even if electronic effects might otherwise direct the electrophile there.
Q6: What role does steric effect play relative to electronic directing effects in product selectivity?
Steric effects work alongside electronic directing effects to determine product distribution. While electronic effects guide electrophiles based on substituent activation, steric hindrance can redirect substitution to less crowded positions. Together, these factors explain why certain positions are favored or avoided in disubstituted benzene reactions.
Q7: How can you predict the major product when disubstituted benzenes undergo electrophilic aromatic substitution?
Analyze both electronic directing effects and steric hindrance. First, identify each substituent's directing preference using electronic effects. If effects reinforce, expect one product. If they compete, the stronger activator dominates. Finally, consider steric blocking—substitution avoids crowded positions. This systematic approach predicts major products reliably.