16.18
The Optimal Level of Public Goods
Public goods are services or commodities that are non-rival, meaning all members of society can consume the good without diminishing the quality or av…
In finding the optimal level of public goods, consider national defense as an example.
Suppose a nation has two individuals, John and Jane. The graph shows their marginal benefit curves for national defense. Their combined benefit is shown by the total marginal benefit curve, which is simply John's and Jane's marginal benefits added together vertically rather than horizontally, as it would be in a private market. This is because the public good is non-rivalrous, and additional units of the public good need not be produced to combine their benefits.
The marginal cost curve shows the cost of providing each additional unit of national defense.
The most efficient quantity of national defense is found where the total marginal benefit equals the marginal cost.
In a private market, however, each person would only be willing to pay up to the point where their individual marginal benefit equals the marginal cost. This would be at quantities Q1 for John and Q2 for Jane, which are less than the efficient quantity.
This discrepancy occurs because individuals in a market account only for the benefit they receive from their consumption.
As a result, in a private market, national defense would be underprovided. This is one reason why governments often provide such public goods.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Business videos
Q1: Why is the total marginal benefit curve for public goods calculated differently than for private goods?
Public goods are non-rivalrous, meaning one person's consumption doesn't reduce availability for others. Therefore, total marginal benefit is calculated by adding individual marginal benefits vertically rather than horizontally. This reflects that society receives the combined benefit of all individuals consuming the same unit simultaneously, unlike private goods where consumption is divided among consumers.
Q2: How do you determine the socially optimal quantity of a public good?
The efficient quantity of a public good occurs where total marginal benefit equals marginal cost. This point balances the additional cost of providing one more unit against the benefit it delivers to society. At this intersection, the government provides the socially optimal level, ensuring the good is available at the quantity that maximizes overall social welfare.
Q3: What causes public goods to be underprovided in private markets?
In private markets, individuals only pay for benefits they personally receive. Each person is willing to pay only up to their individual marginal benefit equals marginal cost. Since private consumers ignore benefits others receive, the quantity supplied falls below the socially optimal level, resulting in underprovision of public goods like national defense.
Q4: Why do governments typically provide public goods instead of private firms?
Public goods exhibit non-excludability, making it economically infeasible for private firms to prevent non-paying consumers from benefiting. Governments can collect payment from all potential consumers through taxes and provide public goods at socially optimal quantities. This ensures adequate provision of essential services like national defense, public parks, and street lighting.
Q5: How do marginal benefit and marginal cost differ for public goods?
Marginal benefit is the additional satisfaction an individual receives from one more unit; different people value public goods differently. Marginal cost is the government's expense to produce that additional unit. For public goods, society's total marginal benefit combines all individual benefits, while marginal cost remains the provider's production expense.
Q6: What does non-excludability mean for public goods provision?
Non-excludability means it is not economically feasible for private firms to exclude non-paying consumers from benefiting from a public good. Once provided, everyone can access it regardless of payment. This characteristic, combined with non-rivalry, prevents private markets from supplying public goods efficiently, necessitating government intervention.
Q7: How does the efficient quantity of a public good compare to what a private market would supply?
The efficient quantity, where total marginal benefit equals marginal cost, exceeds what private markets supply. Private consumers only account for their individual marginal benefit, leading to underprovision. Government provision at the efficient quantity ensures society receives the full social benefit, making public goods available at socially optimal levels rather than insufficient private market quantities.