The Tibial Fracture-Pin Model: A Clinically Relevant Mouse Model of Orthopedic Injury

Summary

The tibial fracture-pin model is a clinically relevant model of orthopedic trauma comprising a unilateral open tibial fracture with intramedullary nail internal fixation and simultaneous injury to the tibialis anterior muscle. Thermal sensitivity in this model can be measured using a 45 s hot plate paradigm.

Abstract

The tibial fracture-pin model is a mouse model of orthopedic trauma and surgery that recapitulates the complex muscle, bone, nerve, and connective tissue damage that manifests with this type of injury in humans. This model was developed because previous models of orthopedic trauma did not include simultaneous injury to multiple tissue types (bone, muscle, nerves) and were not truly representative of human complex orthopedic trauma. The authors therefore modified previous models of orthopedic trauma and developed the tibial fracture-pin model. This modified fracture model consists of a unilateral open tibial fracture with intramedullary nail (IMN) internal fixation and simultaneous tibialis anterior (TA) muscle injury, resulting in mechanical allodynia that lasts up to 5 weeks post injury. This series of protocols outlines the detailed steps to perform the clinically relevant orthopedic trauma tibial fracture-pin model, followed by a modified hot plate assay to examine nociceptive changes after orthopedic injury. Taken together, these detailed, reproducible protocols will allow pain researchers to expand their toolkit for studying orthopedic trauma-induced pain.

Introduction

Orthopedic trauma accounts for 25% of all injuries sustained by nearly 500 million people each year worldwide^1,2,3. Orthopedic trauma can be associated with complex muscle, bone, nerve, and connective tissue damage, necessitating hospitalization and surgery to ensure adequate recovery^3,4. Acute and chronic pain after orthopedic trauma can result in significant physical, psychological, and financial burdens that affect a patient's quality of life^1,4. Additionally, orthopedic surgery to stabilize and fix fractures is also associated with severe acute and chronic post-surgical pain^5,6,7,8,9.

The mechanisms underlying acute and chronic trauma-related pain need to be better understood to develop better treatments. To achieve this, reliable, reproducible, and clinically relevant preclinical models are required. Since most animal models of orthopedic trauma did not involve simultaneous injury to multiple tissue types (bone, muscle, nerves), they were not truly representative of human complex orthopedic trauma, for example, trauma after falls, motor vehicle crashes, or war-related injuries^10,11. Therefore, we developed the tibial fracture-pin mouse model to examine the major manifestations of such injury, including bone and muscle tissue damage and acute and chronic pain¹¹. The tibial fracture-pin model consists of a unilateral open tibial fracture with IMN internal fixation and simultaneous TA muscle injury. Histological sections of the TA show injury to the muscle in which dense fibrosis develops with associated loss of large, mature muscle fibers as early as 2 weeks post injury. Moreover, the fracture callus is apparent on microcomputer tomography (microCT) 4 weeks post injury and continues to undergo remodeling¹¹.

Various reflexive and nonreflexive behavior assays can be used to evaluate the sensory and affective components of pain in the tibial fracture-pin model. For example, one can use the Von Frey filaments to demonstrate mechanical hypersensitivity in this model. In fact, mice develop long-lasting mechanical hypersensitivity in the ipsilateral hind paw after tibial fracture-pin surgery¹¹. Another particularly useful behavioral paradigm is the hot plate assay, which traditionally measures the latency to paw withdrawal to a thermal stimulus. While this assay has been used for decades¹², truly a gold standard in preclinical pain research, measuring reflexive behavior alone has its limitations¹³. As a result, we have developed a modified hot plate paradigm that can capture elements of both reflexive and nonreflexive responses in the setting of a thermal stimulus¹⁴.

This modified hot plate assay determines the initial response latency as in the original hot plate test and an extended observation period to record additional nocifensive behaviors. By categorizing these extended behaviors into distinct categories (flinching, licking, guarding, jumping), the nonreflexive response to the thermal stimulus can be captured. Flinching is the rapid removal of the paw and/or splaying of digits, but the limb is quickly returned to the hot plate. Licking and biting of the hind and front paws are both defined as licking for analysis. Guarding is the continued raising of the limb beyond when afferent nociceptive information ends. Finally, jumping is the removal of all four limbs from the hot plate surface. These behaviors can be analyzed individually and grouped together with special care to still note the initial response latency.

Protocol

All methods used while conducting this research were performed in compliance and with approval by the Stanford University Administrative Panel on Laboratory Animal Care (APLAC #33114) in accordance with American Veterinary Medical Association guidelines and the International Association for the Study of Pain. Mice (C57BL/6J, 9-11 weeks old upon arrival, 11-12 weeks old at study initiation) were housed 2-5 per cage and maintained on a 12 h light/dark cycle in a temperature-controlled environment with ad libitum access to food and water. Male mice weighed approximately 25 g at the start of the study. See the Table of Materials for details regarding all materials used in this study.

1. Baseline behavior measurements

1. As mice learn quickly on the hot plate assay, do not record a baseline for mice in this assay. Instead, compare the mice to uninjured controls.

2. Anesthesia/preparation

1. Anesthetize the mouse with inhalational isoflurane 2%-4%.
2. Pinch the toe with forceps and use the loss of the toe pinch reflex to confirm the depth of anesthesia.
3. Apply eye lubricant generously to the mouse's eyes to prevent dryness while under anesthesia.
4. Place a piece of gauze under the mouse and use clippers to remove hair from the right leg of the mouse up to the knee joint.
5. Clean the hair from the surgical area using the gauze, and then discard the gauze.
6. Disinfect the surgical area using a cotton swab dipped in iodine solution.

3. Surgery

1. After cleaning the surgical area and confirming the depth of anesthesia, use a scalpel to make a skin incision on the medial surface of the right leg from the distal tibia to the proximal tibia, stopping at the level of the inferior knee joint (Figure 1A).
2. Dry the area using a cotton swab with particular attention to the proximal tibia.
3. Using a drill with a 0.6 mm round burr drill bit, drill a hole at the proximal end of the tibia at the level of the tibial tuberosity, ~2 mm distal to the joint line (Figure 1B).
4. Then, insert a 27 G needle through this hole/osteotomy down the medullary axis of the bone to establish a channel, and then remove the needle (Figure 1B).
5. Next, use a bone saw to score the tibia at the junction of the middle and distal thirds (~5-6 mm distal to the osteotomy site) from the lateral aspect causing trauma to the tibialis anterior muscle (Figure 1D).
   CRITICAL: A medial approach to the fracture will not produce muscle injury.
6. Clamp the proximal end of the tibia, hold the distal end of the tibia between the thumb and forefinger, and use counter pressure to complete the bone fracture (Figure 1C).
7. Reinsert the 27 G needle into the intramedullary space, through the proximal tibia, and advance it across the fracture site to the distal segment of the bone to align the fracture.
   NOTE: A similarly sized ceramic implant may be inserted instead of a 27 G needle in imaging applications where metal is undesirable. Although not performed here, a possible implant to consider is a ceramic screw (see the Table of Materials).
8. Then, cut the needle/plastic implant flush with the tibial cortex using cutting pliers.
9. Clean up any blood and confirm that the bleeding has stopped before proceeding.
10. Once bleeding has stopped, close the wound using an interrupted 5-0 silk suture.
    CRITICAL: Do not leave the animal unattended at any point in the surgery. Observe the animal until it is able to mobilize independently and return it to its cagemates only once it has fully recovered.

4. After surgery

1. After surgery, administer buprenorphine 0.05 mg kg^-1 by subcutaneous injection to the mice twice daily for two days per local protocols.
2. Monitor the mice in the post-anesthesia period and for the length of the study as follows: twice daily for the first 2 days, and then daily up to 3 weeks, and weekly thereafter.
3. Assess the mice for behavioral changes indicative of severe stress or sickness such as lethargy, ruffled hair coat, or >20% weight loss. Take note of any issues related to mobility and access to food or water.
   ​NOTE: Surgical and post-care logs must be filled after surgery and at each check and maintained indefinitely for Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee auditing.

5. Hot plate testing

NOTE: Postinjury measurements can begin 7 days after tibial fracture-pin surgery. To avoid the effect of learning in this paradigm, perform the test once after surgery and compare to uninjured controls.

1. Setup
   1. Place the hot plate in a configuration where the lighting is overhead, and the plastic cylinder is centered on the plate.
   2. Set the temperature to 50 °C and place a camera in front of the plate with care to keep the entirety of the enclosed area in view.
      CRITICAL: A standard 8-bit color industrial camera, which records up to 76 fps, was used in this study.
2. Assay
   1. Place the mice inside the testing room for at least 30 min to habituate.
      NOTE: Make sure the testing room is not too hot or cold to avoid skewing the results.
   2. Place the mouse in the cylinder and begin recording.
   3. Record movements for 45 s after the mouse's feet first make contact.
   4. Repeat steps 5.2.1-5.2.3 with the rest of the cohort while maintaining temperature for each subsequent trial.
   5. Measure latency (in seconds) to first response (usually flinching), which is the classic hot plate outcome.
      NOTE: The following protocol developed in this laboratory additionally scores both reflexive (flinching) and nonreflexive (licking, guarding, and jumping).
3. Analysis
   1. Score the hot plate sessions using a viewing program that provides a time stamp with milliseconds.
      1. Consider using NCH Prism Software on a Mac OS. Download this software for free online (see Figure 2 and Table of Materials).
      2. Once downloaded, open the program and click on the option to Continue to Use the Demo Version. Next, click on the large green plus sign to upload the hot plate recordings.
      3. Once uploaded, double-click on an individual file to open in video format. Utilize the cursor at the bottom of the window to slowly drag through the length of the video and begin scoring.
         ​CRITICAL: Regardless of the software used, make sure to watch the videos in the largest window possible to avoid losing time resolution when dragging the time stamp cursor through the video.
   2. Format a spreadsheet as follows.
      1. To properly run the R scripts provided, write the column titles exactly as listed below with no capitalization or spaces and in the order listed: mouseid, behavior, start, end.
      2. Enter the data into the start and end columns in time in s to three decimal places with no leading zeros or colons (e.g.: 2.001)
   3. For each video, record each instance of a pain behavior (to ms). Note that only instances of pain behavior by the two hind paws are recorded. Do not record the behavior of the two front paws.
      1. Record flinching/flicking simply as "flinching," including rapid withdrawal of the paw and/or splaying of digits, but the limb is quickly returned to the hot plate, so long as they are not exploring/walking. Count splaying of the digits without actually lifting the entire paw also as flinching. Do not record flinching/flicking behavior for longer than 500 ms. If recorded as such, drag the cursor through this behavior as slowly as possible as it is likely that several flinches and/or guarding occurred in this span.
      2. Look for prolonged elevation/protection of a limb beyond when afferent nociceptive information ends and record it as guarding.
      3. Record licking/biting of a hind paw as licking.
      4. Record the removal of all four limbs from the hot plate at once as jumping.
         NOTE: If a mouse flinches, and then with the paw up, continues to attend by licking/guarding, and then split the behavior without any time stamp overlap. Create a separate spreadsheet for each experimental group.
   4. Utilize the provided R scripts to begin analyzing the data.
      1. Use "Behavior_Raster_v2.R" to generate a raster plot (as shown below) for visualizing the overall behavior.
      2. Use "Behavior_duration.R" to write a spreadsheet containing five sheets to the working directory.
         NOTE: The first sheet provides the total duration of all pain behaviors, the latency to the first pain behavior, and the total number of pain behaviors. Each subsequent sheet provides this information for individual pain behaviors.
      3. Use "Behavior_bins.R" to write two spreadsheets; one with 500 ms bins showing cumulative duration of behavior at each time point, and the other with the area under the curve for the durational behavior profile of each mouse.
      4. Finally, use "Cumulative_Sums.R" to write two spreadsheets but for cumulative summation of a behavior.

Results

The tibial fracture-pin orthotrauma model reproduces the bone, muscle, and pain-like behaviors seen in complex human injury. As shown in Figure 1C, the tibial fracture heals over time, forming a callus at the fracture site that is still seen at 4 weeks post injury. As a result of the lateral approach with the bone saw described above (step 3.5), the tibialis anterior muscle is injured, becoming extensively fibrotic, as seen by increased collagen deposition throughout the tissue (

Discussion

Critical steps within the protocol
It is crucial to maintain sterile conditions throughout the surgery. Moreover, proper animal care before, during, and after the surgery is paramount for the successful generation of the model. As mentioned earlier in the protocol, when performing the surgery, fracture the bone from the lateral side to ensure muscle injury. Take care not to fracture the tibia too low (below the advised junction between the middle and distal thirds of the tibia) because this will af...

Materials

List of materials used in this article

Name	Company	Catalog Number	Comments
27 G needles	Medsitis	305136	https://medsitis.com/products/bd-precisionglide-27-g-x-1-1-4-hypodermic-needles-305136?variant=39724583299
5-0 suture	esuture	SN5668	https://www.esutures.com/product/0-in-date/2-/132-/16552-medtronic-monosof-black-18-p-11-cutting-SN5668/
Alcohol swabs	Amazon	B00VS4F91W	https://www.amazon.com/Dynarex-Alcohol-Prep-Sterile-Medium/dp/B00VS4F91W
Alternative drill bits	Rio Grande	341602	https://www.riogrande.com/product/BuschTungstenVanadiumRoundBur Set0314mm/341602
Bone saw drill attachment	Amazon	B07DSXR3NY	https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DSXR3NY
Buprenorphine	Fidelis Pharmaceuticals		https://ethiqaxr.com/ordering/
Ceramic implant (alternative to pin)	RISystem	RIS.221.103	https://risystem.com/platefixation/mousescrew
Chux (Absorbent Underpad)	Fisher Scientific	NC0059881	https://www.fishersci.com/shop/products/underpad-17x24-chux-300-cs/nc0059881#?keyword=true
C57BL/6J mice	The Jackson Laboratory	Jax #00664	https://www.jax.org/strain/000664
Cotton swabs	Uline	S-18991	https://www.uline.com/Product/Detail/S-18991/First-Aid/Cotton-Tipped-Applicators-Industrial-6
Cutting pliers	Amazon	B076XYVS6Y	https://www.amazon.com/iExcell-Diagonal-Cutting-Nippers-Chrome-Vanadium/dp/B076XYVS6Y
Drill	Chewy	129044	https://www.chewy.com/dremel-cordless-dog-cat-rotary-nail/dp/156127
Drill bits	Amazon	B00HVIGSX2	https://www.amazon.com/Universal-Diamond-Dremel-Rotary-Tool/dp/B00HVIGSX2
Electric shaver	Kent Scientific	CL9990-KIT	https://www.kentscientific.com/products/trimmer-combo-kit/
Eye lube	Amazon	B07H2NLCX5	https://www.amazon.com/OptixCare-Lube-Plus-Hyaluron-Horses/dp/B07H2NLCX5
Gauze pads 2" x 2"	Amazon	B07GHDTB53	https://www.amazon.com/Covidien-Curity-Sterile-Peel-Back-Package/dp/B07GHDTB53
Gauze pads 4" x 4"	Amazon	B00KJ6YFTC	https://www.amazon.com/Covidien-6309-Curity-Gauze-Pads/dp/B00KJ6YFTC
High definition video camera	The Imaging Source	DFK 22AUC03	https://www.theimagingsource.com/products/industrial-cameras/usb-2.0-color/dfk22auc03/?adsdyn&gclid=Cj0KCQiA3-yQBhD3ARIsAHuHT64uIIlImBvh_ toh-3GFSgBcL_fRc1gQTDyXlqDEa Qu4n2_VbWEiRuIaAiueEALw_wcB
Inhalational anesthesia system	Kent Scientific		https://www.kentscientific.com/products/vaporizer-with-vetflo-single-channel-anesthesia-stand/
Iodine solution	Amazon	B005FR7XIK	https://www.amazon.com/Dynarex-Povidone-Iodine-Scrub-Solution/dp/B005FR7XIK
Iodine swab sticks	Amazon	B001V9QKMG	https://www.amazon.com/POVIDONE-IODINE-SWAB-1202-25Box/dp/B001V9QKMG
Isoflurane	California pet pharmacy		https://www.californiapetpharmacy.com/fluriso-isoflurane-250ml.html
NCH Prism Software			https://www.nchsoftware.com/prism/index.html
Plastic Cylinder	Amazon	B08R5KM5B6	https://www.amazon.com/FixtureDisplays-Acrylic-Diameter-Thickness-15140-8-NPF/dp/B08R5KM5B6
Saline	Fisher Scientific	NC9054335	https://www.fishersci.com/shop/products/saline-injection-0-9-10ml/NC9054335
Scalpel	Fisher Scientific	12-000-162	https://www.fishersci.com/shop/products/high-precision-10-style-scalpel-blade/12000162#?keyword=
Scalpel handle	Amazon	B0056ZX1R8	https://www.amazon.com/Swann-Morton-Scalpel-Handle-blades/dp/B0056ZX1R8
Thermal place preference apparatus	BIOSEB	BIO-T2CT	https://www.bioseb.com/en/pain-thermal-allodynia-hyperalgesia/897-thermal-place-preference-2-temperatures-choice-nociception-test.html