Here, we present a protocol to standardize the operation of acupuncture in the treatment of myopia with dry eye.
Most patients with myopia have dry eye, which has been shown to adversely affect ocular symptoms, myopia progression, and quality of life in patients with myopia. Needle prickling has been shown to be effective in providing symptom relief in patients with myopia and dry eye. Press needle is a long-lasting, easy-to-operate, and inexpensive traditional Chinese medicine treatment. The standard practice of needle insertion is very important for the treatment of myopia and dry eye. The specific steps include selecting the appropriate acupoints, piercing them with appropriate needles, and fixing them in the skin or subcutaneously at the acupoints, burying them for 2 days, resting for 1 day; the course of treatment lasts for 2 weeks. Specifically, the following indicators were assessed: uncorrected visual acuity and the ocular surface disease index. This article will explain how to standardize the operation of a press needle in the treatment of myopia and dry eye.
Myopia is a refractive error; when the eye is in a relaxed state of adjustment, parallel light rays are focused in front of the retina after passing through the refractive retina, resulting in a clear image on the retina, which is called myopia. The main manifestations of this disease are clear vision of near objects and blurred vision of distant objects1. When the normal eye adjusts to a relaxed state, the parallel light rays from 5 m away pass through the refractive system of the eye, and the focus falls on the retina, forming a clear image. However, when a myopic patient sees a distant object 5 m away, the parallel light rays are focused in front of the retina after passing through the refractive system of the eyeball, so the vision will be blurred. If you look at a near object within 5 m, the parallel light rays will be focused on the retina after passing through the refractive system of the eyeball, and it will be clearer. Due to the rapid changes in the socio-economic environment in recent years, the widespread use of electronic screens, and the increase of refined eye use methods, the incidence of myopia has increased rapidly, and it is showing a trend of younger age, which has a serious impact on social health.
According to statistics, the number of myopic people in the world will reach nearly 5 billion in 2050. With the spread of computers and smartphones, coupled with the impact of the previous novel coronavirus outbreak, more and more myopic patients are beginning to have comorbid dry eye symptoms2. Nearly 400 million people in China suffer from dry eye, and the prevalence of dry eye in myopia is significantly higher than that in emmetropia and hyperopia, and the incidence of dry eye in myopic adolescents is about 20%. Tear deficiency and tear film instability are key factors that lead to dry eye, and changes in the cornea and increased eyelid space during eye elongation in myopia patients can cause uneven tear film distribution, resulting in decreased tear film stability, which increases the risk of dry eye.
Dry eye syndrome is characterized by an imbalance of tear film and eye discomfort. It is a chronic inflammatory reaction of corneal conjunctival dryness, which is mainly manifested by sensitivity to the external environment, insufficient tear fluid, and foreign eye sensation. It can lead to corneal conjunctival lesions and visual impairment, and then affect the quality of life and vision of patients3. The etiology of dry eye is complex; the main cause is the abnormal quality, quantity, and dynamics of tears, resulting in tear film instability or imbalance of ocular surface microenvironment. The specific onset of the disease is related to the patient's ocular surface tear film osmotic pressure changes, immune inflammatory response, tear film hyperoxidation, neuroparesthesia, and apoptosis, and the pathological process involves MAPK, NF-κB, Wnt, TLR, PI3K/AKT, and other signaling pathways4,5.
Traditional Chinese medicine believes that the main pathogenesis of dry eye in myopia patients is liver and kidney insufficiency. In the Yellow Emperor's Neijing-Su Wen, it is recorded that "the five internal organs and six internal organs are infiltrated into the eyes", which shows that the dysfunction of the internal organs, the insufficient production of the fluid to moisturize the eyes, or the poor infusion are important pathogeneses. Yinhai Subtlety clearly states: "Tears are less responsible for the deficiency of liver and kidney"-the main blood of the liver is the outer part of the eye, the liver blood is enough, and the liver qi is regulated, and the subtle substances are injected on the surface of the eye for tears. The main water of the kidney is the source of the fluid, and the kidney is sufficient, the kidney qi is full, and the source of the whole body is sufficient. The liver and kidney essence and blood are homologous and interconnected, so liver and kidney insufficiency is an important pathogenesis6. At present, the clinical treatment of dry eye is mainly based on artificial tears, vitamins, nerve growth factor, and thermal pulse therapy, which has good short-term effects, but the long-term effects are still limited. Traditional Chinese medicine treatment is mainly based on the internal administration of traditional Chinese medicine, acupuncture, hot compress fumigation, auricular pressure pills, etc. The durability of the curative effect is good, but the operation is more complicated, and the patient's compliance is not strong.
Press needle is a kind of intradermal acupuncture, which is widely used in clinical practice, mainly used for the treatment of facial paralysis, insomnia, dysmenorrhea, and other diseases, and has gradually expanded to ophthalmic diseases in recent years, with the characteristics of long-lasting effect, easy operation, low cost, and good patient compliance7. Specifically, a special small needle (0.2-0.3 cm long) is inserted and fixed in the acupoint area or subcutaneously for a long period of burial. There is no need to immediately produce a sense of air when burying the needle, and the air can be adjusted only after the needle is buried. This therapy combines the theory of acupoints and the skin theory of traditional Chinese medicine, adopts the ancient idea of "staying still for a long time", combines the advantages of traditional acupuncture and thread embedding, and has a long period of continuous stimulation of the skin, to achieve the purpose of preventing and treating diseases.
Press needles can improve unaided distance vision, improve the state of visual fatigue, reduce refraction, and delay the axial growth of myopia patients, which has been confirmed by clinical studies8,9,10. Press needle can improve dry eye and is better than sodium hyaluronate eye drops alone in improving the stability of the tear film, tear secretion, and the degree of corneal epithelial damage in patients with dry eye11,12,13. The effect of press needle combined with auricular pressure beans, traditional Chinese medicine atomization fumigation, and massage in the treatment of dry eye is more significant, which may be related to the regulation of multiple signaling pathways such as MAPK, NF-kB, Wnt, TLR, and PI3K/AKT.
Based on the theory of acupoints and dermatozoa in traditional Chinese medicine, this study was treated with a press needle (Figure 1), aiming to improve the symptoms of dry eye, improve visual function, and quality of life. A press needle is a long-lasting, easy-to-operate, and inexpensive traditional Chinese medicine treatment. To sum up, it is necessary to propose a standard scheme on how to correctly operate acupuncture for the treatment of myopia with dry eye. This article explains how to properly use a press needle to treat dry eye in patients with myopia.
This protocol has been approved for clinical trial ethics in the Department of Ophthalmology, Affiliated Hospital of Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine (ethics record number: KY2023001). Ensure that the environment is clean and pollution-free, with plenty of light and quiet surroundings. Informed consent was obtained from the patients to use and publish data shown in this paper.
1. Doctor preparation
2. Patient examination
3. Identification and disinfection of acupuncture points
4. Acupuncture procedures
In this study, a total of 8 patients who met the criteria participated and completed the trial, and none of them were discharged or excluded during the process. The OSDI and UCVA scores were used as the primary evaluation indicators for this trial, with data derived from the scores on the scales completed by patients before and after treatment. Self-control before and after treatment was compared using a paired t-test.
The OSDI scores of patients before and after treatment were compared in Table 1. The OSDI score ≤ 20 was divided into mild symptoms, 21~45 was divided into moderate symptoms, and ≥46 was divided into severe symptoms. After treatment, the OSDI score of patients was significantly lower than that of patients before treatment, and the difference was statistically significant (P < 0.05). It indicates that the treatment is effective, but the score is still higher than 46 points, indicating that the effect needs to be improved, and it takes longer treatment.
The comparison of UCVA scores of patients before and after treatment is shown in Table 2. The international standard eye chart is used to measure visual acuity, i.e., the decimal recording method. After treatment, the UCVA score of the left eye was lower than before treatment, and the difference was statistically significant (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference in the right eye UCVA score before and after treatment (P > 0.05). Myopia takes a long time to develop, and short-term acupuncture treatment can improve some vision, but it is more difficult to significantly improve vision, and it takes longer treatment.
The above studies have shown that acupuncture can effectively improve dry eye symptoms in patients. There may be some improvement in unaided vision.
Figure 1: Image of press needle. A press needle with dimensions 0.22 mm x 1.5 mm was used here. (A) A plate of press needles, including 10 press needles, a total length of about 5 cm, a width of about 2 cm; the lower left corner is a torn press needle. (B) Press needle with the needle face up, and the needle body protruding from the middle is about 1.5 mm long, which is used for piercing the skin; The flesh-colored part is a tape, about 1 cm long and 1 cm wide, used to fix the needle body. (C) A press needle with the adhesive tape facing up, the needle body is hidden under, and the adhesive tape is about 1 cm long and 1 cm wide. Press the needle into the skin and put the tape up to ensure a smooth surface without damage. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Schematic diagram of acupoint location. On the left is a hand-drawn map showing the acupuncture points used in acupuncture treatment. On the right is the model acupoint location map, showing the location of acupoints on real people's faces. The two images are used for comparative reference to demonstrate the visual representation of acupoint positioning. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Acupuncture BL2 point operation. This diagram illustrates the specific positioning and manipulation of the needle insertion into BL2. This diagram only demonstrates one acupuncture point, and the other acupuncture point is the same technique. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Acupuncture Ex-HN04 point operation. This diagram illustrates the specific positioning and manipulation of the needle insertion into Ex-HN04. This diagram only demonstrates one acupuncture point, and the other acupuncture point is the same technique. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Acupuncture ST2 point operation. This diagram illustrates the specific positioning and manipulation of the needle insertion into ST2. This diagram only demonstrates one acupuncture point, and the other acupuncture point is the same technique. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Average Value | Standard Deviation | Mean Difference | t• | p• | |
Before treatment | 64.49 | 5.85 | 17.67 | 4.092 | 0.005** |
After treatment | 46.82 | 11.49 | |||
* p < 0.05 ** p < 0.01 |
Table 1: OSDI score before and after treatment. After treatment, the OSDI score of 8 patients was significantly lower than that of patients before treatment, and the difference was statistically significant (P < 0.05). N=8.
Average Value | Standard Deviation | Mean Difference | t• | p• | ||
Before treatment (Left Eye) | 0.34 | 0.15 | -0.04 | -2.497 | 0.041* | |
After treatment (Left Eye) | 0.38 | 0.17 | ||||
Before treatment (Right Eye) | 0.32 | 0.23 | -0.04 | -2.036 | 0.081 | |
After treatment (Right eye) | 0.36 | 0.23 | ||||
* p < 0.05 ** p < 0.01 |
Table 2: UCVA score before and after treatment. After treatment, the UCVA score of the left eye was lower than before treatment, and the difference was statistically significant (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference in the right eye UCVA score before and after treatment (P > 0.05). N=8.
As an ancient traditional treatment method in China, the efficacy of acupuncture has been verified in the long history of development, and various research results in recent years have further proved the effectiveness of acupuncture in improving the vision and dry eye symptoms of myopia patients. The effectiveness of this therapy depends mainly on the acupuncture points chosen. The studies of Gao Hui14 and others have confirmed that acupuncture therapy can significantly improve the symptoms of dry eye and increase the amount of tear secretion. As for the efficacy of acupuncture in the treatment of myopia patients with dry eye, many clinical reports have been confirmed in China. According to the classical theory of traditional Chinese medicine, the twelve meridians and their complexions have corresponding distribution areas on the skin surface. With the method of shallow piercing skin, combined with the theory of skin theory and meridians and acupoints, the press needle can be stimulated for a long time under the skin to achieve internal regulation of zang-fu organs, improve qi and blood, so that the essence is transfused to the purpose. In recent years, with the innovation of medical technology and the widespread application of TCM-appropriate technology, the clinical application value of acupuncture in eye diseases is getting higher and higher15.
The three acupoints selected in this formula include BL2, Ex-HN04, and ST2. BL2, Ex-HN04, and ST2 were determined by referring to a number of clinical studies16,17 and combining them with the data mining results of the researchers. The research shows that BL2 and ST2 are the core acupoints for the treatment of dry eye18,19. Considering the dry eye condition and pathogenesis of myopia patients, we added ST2 points on the basis of the above two points. According to the theory of Zangfu meridians, ST2 points are closely related to the function of the spleen and stomach, and good spleen and stomach function can improve the symptoms of dry eye. Modern research shows that the above points can promote tear secretion, stimulate the nerve center, and regulate the blood circulation of the eye, which supports the traditional view20.
BL2
Located on the face, when the brow is in, at the supraorbital notch, is the foot sun bladder meridian point. It has the effect of clearing heat and brightening eyes, dispelling wind and clearing collaterals, regulating qi and lowering Qi, dredging the qi of the bladder channel, and then achieving the function of regulating the whole body's Zangfu organs, making the channels unobstructed and Qi and blood harmonizing21. In the Compendium of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, the ST2 point is recorded as "the main visual object is unknown." In modern times, it is found that there are supratrochlear nerve stimulation points under the BL2 point, and stimulation of this point can effectively improve tear secretion.
Ex-HN04
Located on the face, when the eyes are level, the pupil meets the eyebrow directly above. It has the effect of dispersing wind and dredging collaterals, relieving pain and calming nerves. It first appeared in Yin hai Jing wei of the Yuan Dynasty. This point is also the place where the channels of all yang channels in the head and face exchange and converge, and has the effect of regulating all the yang channels21. Stimulation of the Yuyao-point can directly regulate ocular nerves, promote blood flow around the eye, and reduce aseptic inflammation.
ST2
Located on the face, the pupil is straight down, and the infraorbital foramen is depressed. Return foot Yangming stomach channel. Dongyuan Li's "Spleen and Stomach" once recorded: "The nine orifices, the five viscera master, the five viscera all stomach qi can circulate", "stomach qi a deficiency, eyes, eyes, mouth, and nose are the disease" theory. The application of this point reflects the close relationship between the stomach and the eye. Normal operation of the spleen and stomach, orderly rise and fall, the qi of clear Yang transport in the eyes, the eye system to nourish to see things clearly.
The acupoints selected in this study are covered with abundant blood vessels and nerves, so acupuncture points around the eyes can expand local capillaries, accelerate blood circulation around the eyes, and increase blood supply22. Modern studies have shown that stimulation of acupoints around the eyes can inhibit ocular inflammatory response, protect visual function, improve meibomian gland function, and promote the secretion of lipid components in tears, thus prolonging the rupture time of tear film, stabilizing tear film, and also play a certain role in repairing corneal damage14,23.
To promote the clinical application of the needle and ensure efficacy, it is especially necessary to standardize the operation. The main purpose of this paper is to develop a standardized and effective surgical protocol for the treatment of myopia with dry eye. Through the acupuncture treatment, we are expected to find a simple operation, high safety, fewer side effects, and lasting treatment, to alleviate the symptoms of myopia patients' dry eye, and improve their quality of life. The operation method in this paper repeats and optimizes the previous methods24,25,26. On the basis of the previous studies, we elaborated the precautions and operation nursing, formulated a more standardized treatment plan, reduced the risk of adverse reactions, and provided methodological reference for related studies.
The focus of this therapy is the location of acupoints, the operation of acupuncture, and the cooperation of patients. To avoid adverse effects as much as possible and improve efficiency, the accuracy of positioning should be paid attention to during operation. It is important to note that patient cooperation also plays a crucial role in the development and effectiveness of treatment. If the patient does not follow the doctor's advice and does not stimulate the acupuncture points according to the guidance, the expected effect may not be achieved, and the risk of adverse reactions such as hematoma and infection may be increased. If patients bury the needle for too long, it may cause infection or pain; If patients bury the needle for too short a time, the treatment may be ineffective. Therefore, detailed communication with the patient, improving compliance, and obtaining the cooperation of the patient are some of the important aspects of treatment.
There are a few things worth noting about this therapy: During surgery, avoid shaking or sudden movement, so as not to increase the patient's pain or injury. After the procedure is complete, place the needle in a designated container and avoid disposing of it carelessly to avoid injury or risk of infection. If the patient cannot tolerate the pain or has other abnormalities during the acupuncture process, the treatment should be stopped, and the relevant medical staff should be reported in time. Some countermeasures are often taken when the following risks are encountered: (1) Infection risk: Needle operation may lead to cross infection, and the operating procedures should be strictly observed to keep the operating environment clean and sterile. (2) Bleeding risk: Pinching operation may lead to bleeding. After the operation, apply a cotton swab to gently press the needle insertion point to avoid bleeding. (3) Pain risk: Needle withdrawal may cause pain to the patient, and the operation should be gentle and smooth to reduce the patient's discomfort.
The limitations of the current method are mainly manifested in the following three aspects: First, the acupuncture itself is not suitable for patients with skin damage; Second, the efficacy of acupuncture alone is weaker than that of other therapies. Third, the evaluation index of curative effect can be further improved. To improve the treatment, the following points must be noted. First, to avoid secondary damage to the patient's skin, carefully check the patient's skin status before treatment to rule out skin damage. Next, to ensure the treatment effect, patients should be regularly reminded to press the acupuncture site and supervised to retain the acupuncture time. Follow-up researchers can cooperate with ear point pressure pill treatment. Lastly, to improve the objectivity of efficacy evaluation, tear film rupture time and tear secretion test can be increased to evaluate corneal fluorescein sodium staining test.
In addition to the above shortcomings, this study has the advantages of lasting effect, simple operation, low cost, and few adverse reactions, which are worthy of further research and promotion. For patients who are ineffective to other treatments and have a heavy economic burden, this study, as an alternative therapy as effective as traditional Chinese medicine27, provides patients with an effective non-drug treatment measure to improve the ocular symptoms and quality of life of myopia patients and has broad application prospects.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by the Xinglin Scholar Research Promotion Project of the Chengdu University of TCM (MPRC2022012 and QJJJ2023004).
75% Alcohol disinfectant | Kangpai (Jiangsu) Medical Technology Co., Ltd. | 20230926 | |
Disposable surgical masks | Hunan Kefu Medical Equipment Co., Ltd | 20220401 | |
Disposable treatment towels | Chengdu Mingsen medical equipment Co.,Ltd | 20230824 | |
Fingertip pulse oximeter | Jiangsu Yuyue Medical Equipment Co., Ltd | 20172201070 | |
Medical disposable hat | Qingdao Hairun Medical Technology Co., Ltd | 20190576 | |
Medical tweezers | Hunan Kefu Medical Equipment Co., Ltd | P0402311003 | |
Mercury sphygmomanometer | Jiangsu Yuyue Medical Equipment Co., Ltd | 20152070947 | |
Sterile medical disposable sterilized cotton swabs | Hunan Kefu Medical Equipment Co., Ltd | 20210014 | |
Sterile press needles for single-use | Suzhou Medical Supplies Factory Co., Ltd | 233126 | |
SPSS | Data analysis software |