Source: Lara Al Hariri and Ahmed Basabrain at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, MA, USA
In this experiment, you'll use column chromatography to separate green food coloring into its component blue and yellow dyes, called erioglaucine and tartrazine. First, you'll use 95% ethanol to elute the dye with a weaker affinity for silica gel. Then, you'll flush the second dye from the column with water. To recover the purified dyes, you will collect each band of dye as it leaves the column. These collected volumes are called fractions.
| Color | Volume (mL) | |
| Ethanol fraction | ||
| Water fraction |
In this experiment, you saw that ethanol eluted the blue erioglaucine in a timely manner, but it wasn't an effective eluent for the yellow tartrazine. Paper chromatography of the green dye shows similar results. Thus, we conclude that erioglaucine has a lower affinity for silica gel than tartrazine does.
Now, consider the advantages of using two solvents to elute the dye separately. Water is more polar than ethanol, so we assume that it would elute both dyes faster than ethanol alone would. While you also would have used less solvent overall if you had only used water, the separation would have been worse, making it harder to collect pure fractions.
Alternatively, you could have kept using ethanol after you collected the erioglaucine, but it would have taken a long time and a lot of ethanol to elute tartrazine that way. Switching the eluent to water after eluting erioglaucine saved time and minimized solvent waste without sacrificing purity.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Lab Manual videos
Q1: What is the purpose of the sand layer in column chromatography?
The sand layer, placed 0.5 cm above the cotton plug, prevents silica gel from passing through the plug into your collected fractions. This protective barrier ensures that only the separated dyes are collected in pure fractions, maintaining the integrity of your samples throughout the separation process.
Q2: Why does column chromatography use two different eluents for separating food dyes?
Using ethanol first elutes erioglaucine, which has lower affinity for silica gel, while water elutes tartrazine more effectively due to its higher polarity. This two-solvent approach saves time and minimizes solvent waste while maintaining fraction purity, compared to using a single eluent throughout the entire separation.
Q3: How do you prepare the silica gel slurry for column chromatography?
Weigh 5 grams of silica gel powder and mix it with 18 mL of 95% ethanol in a beaker. Stir with a glass rod until the texture is consistent and resembles batter with no dry patches or clumps. The slurry should flow easily to avoid clogging the funnel or trapping air bubbles in the column.
Q4: What flow rate should you maintain when eluting dyes through the column?
Adjust the stopcock so the solvent level decreases approximately 1 mL every 15 to 20 seconds. Maintain at least 1 cm of solvent above the silica gel at all times by periodically refilling the column. This controlled solvent flow rate ensures proper separation and prevents band broadening during the elution process.
Q5: How do you apply the green food dye to the silica gel column?
Use a clean pipette to gently apply 5 to 7 drops of the dye solution evenly across the top of the silica gel. If necessary, add a few drops of ethanol to keep the silica gel covered. Allow the dye to soak in before beginning the elution process with your chosen eluent.
Q6: What do the different colors of fractions tell you about dye affinity for silica gel?
The blue erioglaucine elutes with ethanol, indicating lower affinity for silica gel, while yellow tartrazine requires water, indicating higher affinity. This separation demonstrates that tartrazine binds more strongly to silica gel than erioglaucine does, which is why different solvents are needed to elute each dye effectively.
Q7: Why is it important to avoid stopping the column chromatography for extended periods?
Stopping for more than 1 minute at a time causes compound bands to start broadening, which reduces separation quality and makes it harder to collect pure fractions. Continuous flow maintains sharp band definition and ensures efficient separation of the dyes throughout the elution process.