Respiratory ECs provide not only a physical barrier to protect the human body from exogenous stimuli20, but also act as a switchboard to initiate and regulate respiratory immune defense responses1-3 via secretion of soluble mediators or direct receptor-ligand cell-cell interactions. In order to further study the role of ECs in the immune response, to examine potential differences among ECs from diseased populations, or to study the effects of exogenous stressors on ECs, it is important to recapitulate the in vivo situation. The human airways contain more than 40 different cell types20 including different epithelial cells, such as ciliated cells, goblet cells and basal cells20. Our protocol describes how a superficial nasal scrape biopsy can be processed to yield NECs that can be expanded and cultured to undergo re-differentiation, yielding NEC cultures, which largely mimic the nasal epithelium in vivo.
The use of this in vitro model of organotypic primary human differentiated NECs provides unique possibilities for various applications. It allows studying disease specific differences of NECs (e.g. cystic fibrosis, asthma, smoking), underlying mechanisms of a disease, as well as controlled exposures to air pollutants (e.g. ozone, diesel exhaust, cigarette smoke)18,21-23. In addition, differentiated NECs grown on tissue culture inserts lend themselves to co-culture with other cells types (e.g. dendritic cells, natural killer cells, or macrophages)10,11, allowing to examine cell-cell interactions in a controlled setting.
We describe the culturing and re-differentiating of NECs, and not bronchial epithelial cells, which have been used in many previously published studies24-27. We see various reasons why the use of NECs can be advantageous as compared to the use of bronchial ECs. First, obtaining superficial nasal scrape biopsies is less expensive than performing a bronchoscopy to obtain brush biopsies. Second, for a variety of pre-existing diseases (e.g. sever asthmatics) it is unrealistic to carry out a research-related bronchoscopy to obtained lower airway epithelial cells. However, the less invasive procedure of scraping the inferior surface of the inferior nasal turbinate with a Rhino Probe can be performed in these subjects. Third, nasal scrape biopsies can be performed on the same individuals multiple times (usually about 4 weeks in between biopsies) without any significant side effects28-30 . Fourth, NECs are among the first cells to be exposed to inhaled environmental stressors, such as air pollutants, pathogens or allergens and therefore represent valuable in vitro models to study the effects of these stressors on airway epithelial cells.
Various cell culture systems of re-differentiated human ECs are commercially available (e.g. EpiAirway model from MatTek, Ashland, MA , Clonetics from Lonza, Basel, Switzerland, MucilAir from Epithelix Sars, Geneva Switzerland). Those commercially available cell cultures remain stable for a long time period and are well characterized. However, they are expensive and the studies are usually limited to a low number of samples from different individuals. Additionally, it is difficult to control the donor population, which depends on the availability presented by the supplier. Freshly obtaining NECs with superficial scrape biopsies allows the investigator to control subject characteristics (such as age, gender, race, weight, body mass index, disease status, medication use, etc.) and to re-call volunteers back for a potential follow-up.
In general, all published protocols for re-differentiating human airway (either bronchial or nasal) ECs at the ALI include similar procedures: obtaining ECs, expanding the cells in tissue culture flasks, and transferring them to porous cell culture inserts for the differentiation at the ALI. The protocols vary in the type of media, the growth factor supplements, the number of passaging, the coating of the inserts, and the activation of the NECs before establishing the ALI. While in one protocol, after obtaining and digesting, the cells are seeded directly on uncoated inserts and only kept a few days at the ALI before use13; other protocols include culturing for several weeks to re-differentiate at the ALI12,14,15. There is no consistency about coating the inserts with collagen or other extracellular matrix components: while some protocols require coating12,15 others use uncoated inserts13,14. However, culture conditions are of great importance, especially the incubator settings. The relative humidity, which needs to be >90%, and the CO2, which should be adjusted at 5% are very important factors to avoid drying out of the ALI cell culture and help buffer the media. In order to share our experience, we want to mention here that there is no 100% success rate. Some nasal scrape biopsy samples do not adhere to the tissue culture plate, while some NEC samples will not adhere to the inserts or will never reach confluency. Over the years, our overall success rate using the protocol described here is approximately 80%. Our experience shows that culturing of NECs from defined diseased populations, such as smokers, is more challenging than NECs from healthy non-smokers
Our protocol for culturing of primary human NECs incorporates several key steps which we optimized over the years: 1. The NECs are only expanded twice before they are seeded on the tissue culture inserts. 2. The inserts are used uncoated. 3. Once seeded on tissue culture plates, the amount of NuSerum is stepwise reduced to avoid that the cells lift off from the tissue culture plates. 4. The NECs are kept at least 25-28 days at the ALI before using them in experiments to assure complete re-differentiation. In summary, the protocol described here includes an optimized protocol to culture and re-differentiate human NECs at the ALI.