$$\rightleftharpoonup{xx}$$
$$\longleftharp{xx}$$,
$$\longrightharp{xx}$$,
To achieve very high ncAA incorporation efficiencies, the auxotrophy-based SPI method relies on the use of metabolically engineered host cells, which are not able to synthesize the corresponding natural counterpart of the ncAA. For E. coli, such strains are readily available. Even the simultaneous incorporation of multiple ncAAs into the same protein is feasible using multiauxotrophic strains. The residue-specific mode of replacement and the chemical repertoire being restricted to similar chemical analogs can be seen as drawbacks. Nevertheless, a large number of protein variants can be produced as the natural bacterial translation apparatus tolerates numerous amino acid analogs. For example, more than 50 ncAAs could be incorporated into proteins using in vitro translation, accounting for about 73% of all codons of the genetic code to be available for reassignment40. Furthermore, SPI can also allow efficient multisite labelling of the target protein41. In principle, the SPI methodology is not restricted to E. coli, but can work in any other host and for each of the canonical 20 amino acids, provided that auxotrophic strains and defined cultivation media are available. For example, two methionine analogs, azidohomoalanine (Aha) and homopropargylglycine (Hpg), are commercially available and used for labeling proteins and proteomes in diverse organisms. In addition, Aha can be produced intracellularly and subsequently incorporated into protein42. This ncAA is especially suitable for bioorthogonal conjugations such as click chemistry as developed by Tirrel and coworkers: For example, in plant tissue of Arabidopsis thaliana, in Bombyx mori larvae43, Drosophila cells44, larval zebrafish45 as well as mammalian cells including neurons46, proteins can be labelled with Aha47,48. Similarly, Trp analogs were successfully incorporated into antimicrobial peptides in Trp-auxotrophic Lactococcus lactis strains49. SPI is also useful for the field of Xenobiology50,51, which explores alternatives to the basic chemical make-up of life. For example, based on previous works on E. coli52 and B. subtilis53, an E. coli strain was developed recently by an evolutionary strategy with selective pressure to utilize thienopyrrole instead of indole, resulting in proteome-wide substitution of tryptophan by thienopyrrole-alanine in the genetic code54. Generally, the canonical amino acid Trp, which is encoded by a single triplet (UGG), presents a promising target for protein engineering due to the rich facets of indole chemistry, which offers numerous chemical variations. Recently, and as an alternative to SPI-based incorporation, a novel SCS platform capable to incorporate Trp analogs site-specifically in both bacterial and eukaryotic hosts has been reported55. This further broadens the toolbox of in vivo ncAA-based protein engineering, including the alteration of spectral properties.
Besides the use of auxotrophic expression hosts, the SPI protocol requires strict fermentation conditions, both in terms of target expression timing and the composition of the medium in order to reach high ncAA incorporation efficiency and target protein yield56. Cultivation is conducted using chemically defined minimal media, which essentially contain besides major salts the sources for nitrogen (ammonium salt) and carbon (D-glucose), vitamins and trace elements. Although not strictly required in the absence of further auxotrophies, the remaining amino acids (20-n, if n amino acids are to be replaced) are commonly added to promote the bacterial growth57. During an initial growth phase before induction of target protein expression, the n canonical amino acids to be replaced are added in limiting concentrations. Cellular growth proceeds until the targeted essential amino acids are depleted, as experimentally indicated by a stationary OD600. Subsequently, the culture medium is replaced by fresh medium that lacks the depleted amino acid and contains the ncAA in abundant concentrations. For the ribosomal incorporation of tryptophan analogs as shown in this protocol, an indole analog is fed, which becomes intracellularly converted to the corresponding tryptophan derivative by tryptophan synthase58. Next, target protein expression is induced. At this stage, the cells are close to the end of logarithmic growth, as a balance between total cell number and fitness. As the presence and incorporation of the canonical amino would lead to wild-type protein production, it is critical to ensure that the essential amino acid is fully depleted prior to induction. Likewise, it is mandatory to examine the efficiency of ncAA incorporation into the target protein, commonly by mass spectrometry. In case of substantial presence of the canonical amino acid, the cultivation conditions need to be adjusted, e.g., by altering the concentration of the essential amino acid(s) for the initial growth phase or the duration of the latter. In case of low aaRS activity towards the ncAA, the overexpression of the endogenous enzyme or co-expression of a different aaRS, which is more active towards the ncAA, can be conducted59.
The canonical amino acid Trp is endowed with three remarkable features: (i) its natural abundance in proteins is low; (ii) its biophysical and chemical properties are unique (e.g., it is usually the dominant origin of the intrinsic fluorescence of proteins and peptides), and (iii) it contributes to a variety of biochemical interactions and functions including π-stacking, H-bonding and cation-π interactions. All these features are radically changed upon Trp → 4-amino-Trp substitution in GdFP. Beyond doubt, the design of a "gold" class of avGFPs is a remarkable example for engineering tailor-made autofluorescent proteins. With distinct spectral properties, FPs can be tuned towards certain spectral windows via mutagenesis and ncAA incorporation. In case of GdFP, this is accomplished by a simple chemical exchange H → NH2 in the frame of the indole ring contained in the ECFP chromophore triad. Figure 5 displays the effects of ncAA incorporation within the chromophore. The introduction of the electron-donating group originating from 4-amino-indole (intracellularly converted to 4-amino-Trp) enables a variety of mesomeric structures that can explain a stabilized excited state. Spectroscopically, its enlarged Stokes shift and red-shifted fluorescence emission result from these distinct properties of the extended conjugated system. As reported earlier, the enhanced intramolecular charge transfer within the GdFP chromophore is inherently sensitive to pH (Figure 4B) and accompanied by a larger change in dipole moment between the S0 ground and S1 excited state relative to ECFP33. As alternative electron-donating groups, tryptophan analogs bearing an indole ring substituted with hydroxy groups could be used, as reported in a comparative study with the model protein barstar41.
The absorption and fluorescence spectra of GdFP are broadened compared to ECFP and EGFP (Figure 3C and D). Homogeneous broadening of the absorption and fluorescence bands is generally caused by vibrational modes in the chromophore and, additionally, by coupling of the chromophore to further vibrational modes present in the protein60. The coupling to the local protein environment is supported by charges localized on the chromophore. As the structural inhomogeneity of the protein leads to local variations of the vibronic spectrum, such coupling between the vibronic spectra of the chromophore and the rest of the protein are supported by charge delocalization and mesomeric states as indicated in Figure 5. This coupling also supports the large Stokes shift and necessarily reduces the fluorescence quantum yield. In comparison to other red-shifted FPs, GdFP even exhibits improved protein stability and a low tendency for aggregation33,61,62. It not only differs in color from other FP variants but also exhibits a substantially increased thermostability and enhanced cooperative folding33. Its fluorescence intensity is at least 90% preserved upon heating to 60 °C, while ECFP fluorescence is reduced to about 30%. In proteins, aromatic amino acids often contribute to networks of interacting side chains, which commonly have a stabilizing effect on the protein's tertiary structure. avGFP harbors such a side chain network, which consists of the chromophore itself, as well as Phe-165, His-148, and Tyr-145. These side chains are not only quite rigid in the GdFP structure33, but importantly, they form hydrophobic contacts with the chromophore. The most prominent novel feature identified in GdFP is that the aminated chromophore is more proximal to Phe-165. This interaction is a feature not observed in other known avGFPs. As the two residues are 3.2-4.5 Å apart, amino-aromatic interactions might be also present. Together with the amination-induced resonance stabilization of the chromophore, these most likely stabilize this hydrophobic network of amino acids in a cooperative fashion. A more effective intramolecular charge transfer might be supported by these interactions in the excited state in comparison to the ground state of the chromophore, and it at least partly accounts for the 108 nm Stokes shift33,62.
In rational design of fluorophore properties, an increase in the size of the delocalized π-system is predicted to result in a red-shifted excitation wavelength. This rule of thumb is obeyed by the series of amino acids in position 66 leading to neutral chromophores: Phe (λmax = 355 nm) < His (λma x= 386 nm) < Tyr (λmax = 395 nm) < Trp (λmax = 436 nm)63. In nature, this extension of the chromophore's conjugated system of π-bonds has been achieved by different strategies. For DsRed from Discosoma striata, it is extended by the integration of an additional amino acid, thus shifting λmax to 573 nm64. The chromophore of asFP595 (λmax = 595 nm) from Anemonia sulcata was extended by an imino group, enlarging its π-system65. Since the chromophore of GdFP and other avFPs is of the same size, a different principle must entail an emission wavelength in the range of the expanded DsRed and asFP595 chromophores. The profound Stokes shift of 108 nm is attributed to the distinct structure of the GdFP chromophore, which reveals a new photophysical principle in the design of autofluorescent proteins. Preliminary calculations (as reported in 62) have shown that the dipole moment of the excited-state chromophore of GdFP is substantially larger than in the ground state, in contrast to the respective values of ECFP. Whereas the dipole moment of GdFP increases from ~3 D (Debye) in the S0 state to ~15 D in S1, the change for the ECFP chromophore was rather moderate (from ~4 D to ~6 D). Thus, the unique golden fluorescence of GdFP is caused by substantial intramolecular charge transfer within the chromophore, which increases the variety of possible mesomeric structures (see Figure 5) that allow for resonance stabilization. This reduces the energy level from which emission occurs. As a consequence of the profound change in the dipole moment upon excitation, the intramolecular charge separation is the principal reason for the changes in the electrostatic potential of the chromophore environment. The surrounding protein matrix, in turn, adjusts to the changes in the charge distribution after chromophore excitation. The subsequent structural relaxation lowers the energy level of the excited chromophore, which shifts the fluorescence spectrum to the red due to its charge transfer character. For the same reason, as a consequence of the large Stokes shift and enhanced rates of radiationless processes, the fluorescence quantum yield of GdFP is reduced compared to ECFP33.
The high quantum yield and small Stokes shift of ECFP and EGFP are usually ascribed to a rigid protein environment of the chromophore, which reduces the degrees of freedom and, consequently, internal conversion to favor the radiative relaxation of the excited state66. Consequently, the molecular design of more rigidly embedded chromophores with reduced coupling to the remaining protein matrix might serve as a guide to produce farther red-shifted GFP derivatives with high fluorescence quantum yield. Therefore, for further engineering approaches to produce red-shifted autofluorescent proteins, enlargement of the π-electron system and a rigid chromophore structure with weak coupling to the protein environment is highly desirable. Such modifications could also be introduced either directly into GFP-based chromophores or by placement of desired ncAAs in the chromophore vicinity.