$$\rightleftharpoonup{xx}$$
$$\longleftharp{xx}$$,
$$\longrightharp{xx}$$,
This article provides a detailed protocol to apply the LBN model in mice. This model is an important tool for understanding how an ethologically and translationally relevant form of chronic stress in early life contributes to the development of neuropsychiatric disorders in the offspring13. It is also useful for studying maternal behavior and any changes in the dams' brain from a molecular, neuroendocrine, or circuit-based perspective24. For these types of questions, multiparity may be a more important variable to consider. We have observed that maternal behavior entropy scores remain consistent across multiple litters within the same dam (Figure 2C), suggesting that entropy may be a somewhat stable trait for each dam. This finding may justify the use of multiparous female mice when it is not feasible to use only nulliparous females, such as in the case of costly or rare transgenic mice. Due to the possible unintended effects of multiparity on other variables (e.g., intrauterine environment), it is recommended that the experimenter statistically control for the use of multiparous females during data analysis.
It is important to note that this model is highly sensitive to environmental disturbances. Multiple factors can disrupt the animals, causing problems and suboptimal results, such as cage flooding or loud noises such as from nearby construction. Usually, these disturbances will result in Control animals becoming stressed, and therefore, there will be no differences between the Control and LBN conditions. An indicator of these problems may be similar weights in Control and LBN pups at P10 and similar entropy values in maternal care behavior. Because of this, the ideal setup is a maternal care room that is only used for this purpose, quiet and away from the colony and other laboratory personnel. Disturbances can also lead to cannibalism of pups, especially in dams younger than P75. The risk of losing pups to cannibalism is lower in dams after P75 and often after the first litter. An alternative version of this method shifts the timing of the experimental manipulation to P4-P11 in order to decrease the risk of cannibalism even further25,26; although this is not necessary in the present laboratory conditions. Another version of LBN does not employ a mesh divider but still limits the amount of bedding and nesting material for the entire pre-weaning postnatal period27. It is important to note that changing the timeline may lead to different results, such as abusive maternal behavior, which may, in turn, result in different offspring outcomes, such as anxiety-like behaviors25,28. Other common problems include losing maternal behavior data due to the camera angle and large nest size; to help with this, it is advised to put a mirror in the back of the cage and be sure to only provide a single nestlet in the control condition in order to prevent the nest from becoming too large and concealing the pups from the camera. Finally, ensuring the mesh fits properly in the cage to prevent pups from getting stuck or hurt is essential.
An advantage of the LBN model is that it is easily customized and combined with other experimental factors. Examples of the variables that can be added to this protocol are diet29,30, immune challenges30,31, different transgenic lines32,33, and chemogenetics19. Moreover, some versions of this model employ a P10-P17 time frame and combine it with maternal separation (MS)34,35,36. This paradigm has also been adapted as a prenatal stressor, where dams are housed in the LBN environment from E14 to E1937,38, but the pups are never exposed to the stress directly. Finally, some studies use a two-hit model that involves ELA combined with different stress tests on the offspring when they reach adulthood19,39.
One of the limitations of this method is that it does not have a high throughput. The amount of data it produces is limited by the number of cameras and space available at one time, although the litters can easily be staggered over time. The manual scoring of maternal behavior is especially time-consuming and may introduce observer bias, but automated scoring is currently being developed40, thanks to the advent of machine learning-based approaches. If data are hand-scored, it is recommended that the same person scores all of the videos for one experiment in order to decrease inter-observer variability. Another limitation is that this model is designed for rodents that rely primarily on maternal care, making it difficult to study biparental care. However, some groups have adopted paternal deprivation as an alternative to MS in biparental species such as the California mouse41,42, so it is conceivable that LBN could also be adapted for these species.
Aside from LBN, maternal separation is the other most prominent model for ELA, because other forms of stress employed in adults (i.e., restraint stress) are not ethologically relevant and do not affect pups the same way. LBN differs from MS because it is a form of chronic stress that induces fragmented and unpredictable maternal behavior, whereas, in MS, deprivation is intermittent and usually occurs at predictable times each day43. Interestingly, both models can cause changes in the HPA axis and depressive-like behaviors in rodents, although LBN may be a more reproducible protocol with less experimenter interaction and higher consistency across laboratories1,11,13,16. Although this protocol is useful in mitigating some sources of variability (such as experimenter-related), other aspects like differences in animal facilities, origin of the animals, or strain can influence the results. For example, it is known that BALB/c mice have a more pronounced response to chronic restraint stress and may be differentially sensitive to ELA than C57BL/6J27,44.
In conclusion, the LBN model employs a low-resource environment with unpredictable maternal care and is a useful approach to understanding how early-life stress affects a wide variety of processes, such as physiological adaptations to stress, maternal behavior, and brain development. Notably, this model has been employed to understand how and why ELA is a risk factor for neuropsychiatric disorders1,5,9,12. In the future, the use of LBN will enhance our understanding of the biological basis of both mental and physical disorders and help elucidate novel therapeutic targets to treat the effects of stress during the sensitive perinatal period.