7.3
Trait and State Self-Esteem
The term self-esteem is often used generically, to refer to how people feel about themselves. However, according to research, there are three distinct…
People may constantly assess themselves based on their general feelings, their various abilities and attributes, and their successes and failures.
Such associations relate to the broad concept of self-esteem—an overall measure of how someone feels about and evaluates themselves, which can range from low to high.
For example, a college football player has consistently displayed high self-esteem. This type of overarching self-esteem is called trait self-esteem—an individual’s self-opinion over long periods, which typically remains stable.
This general evaluation may be partly due to how a person views themselves in relation to specific attributes, which is termed domain self-esteem. For example, the football player believes he’s athletically talented, as peers and coaches frequently praise his performance. Consequently, his self-opinion is contingent on this trait.
However, day-to-day incidents can cause temporary fluctuations in self-esteem. For instance, if the player throws an incomplete pass during a game and his team loses, the mood shifts, and he may now view himself as a useless failure and fear that he’ll be ostracized at his school—especially if he receives criticism from friends.
Since the quarterback’s assessment is dependent on valued qualities—here, perceived athleticism—his self-esteem decreases dramatically. In this context, the experience is described as an individual’s state self-esteem—a person’s self-evaluation in a particular moment, due to a specific situation.
Fortunately, state self-esteem can change often. Here, the athlete shifts back to seeing himself positively after he scores the winning touchdown at the next game and is congratulated by others.
Thus, while one part of someone’s self-esteem is relatively stable across time and situations, other parts can fluctuate to correspond with different domains and social circumstances.
View the full transcript and gain access to JoVE Core videos
Q1: What is the difference between trait self-esteem and state self-esteem?
Trait self-esteem is an individual's self-opinion over long periods, which typically remains stable throughout adulthood. State self-esteem, by contrast, is a person's self-evaluation in a particular moment due to a specific situation. For example, an athlete may have high trait self-esteem but experience low state self-esteem after making a critical error during competition.
Q2: How does domain self-esteem relate to overall self-evaluation?
Domain self-esteem is a general evaluation based on how a person views themselves in relation to specific attributes or abilities. While trait self-esteem represents overall self-opinion, domain self-esteem reflects confidence in particular areas. For instance, someone might have high artistic domain self-esteem but low chemistry domain self-esteem, yet maintain moderate trait self-esteem overall.
Q3: Why does state self-esteem fluctuate more than trait self-esteem?
State self-esteem fluctuates because it depends on immediate situations and valued qualities in specific moments. Day-to-day incidents, social feedback, and performance outcomes trigger temporary shifts in self-evaluation. For example, receiving criticism from peers after a poor performance can dramatically decrease state self-esteem, whereas praise following success can restore it quickly.
Q4: What role do social circumstances play in shaping self-esteem?
Social circumstances significantly influence state self-esteem through feedback, praise, and criticism from others. When peers and coaches recognize accomplishments, individuals evaluate themselves more positively in those domains. Conversely, social rejection or negative feedback can lower state self-esteem. The sense of self reflected self appraisal and social comparison helps explain how external social interactions shape self-perception.
Q5: How are trait self-esteem, state self-esteem, and domain self-esteem related?
While trait, state, and domain self-esteem are conceptually distinct constructs, they are highly correlated. High trait self-esteem individuals tend to evaluate themselves more positively across domains and experience higher state self-worth. Domain self-esteem contributes to trait self-esteem, which influences how people respond to specific situations and temporary setbacks.
Q6: Can someone have high trait self-esteem but low state self-esteem simultaneously?
Yes, someone can have high trait self-esteem but experience low state self-esteem in specific moments. A generally confident person may feel temporarily inadequate after failure or criticism in a valued domain. This demonstrates that stable, long-term self-opinion differs from momentary self-evaluation, which responds to immediate social circumstances and performance outcomes.
Q7: What factors contribute to the stability of trait self-esteem?
Trait self-esteem remains relatively stable across time and situations because it reflects an individual's enduring self-opinion. Research suggests it has a genetic component related to temperament and neuroticism. Unlike state self-esteem, which fluctuates with specific situations, trait self-esteem persists as a consistent measure of how someone generally feels about and evaluates themselves.