Blood-brain barrier dysfunction is associated with a number of neurological disorders, including primary and secondary brain tumors or stroke. BBB breakdown is often associated with life-threatening CNS edema. The elucidation of the molecular mechanisms that trigger the opening or closure of the BBB is therefore of therapeutic significance in neurological disorders and commonly investigated by researchers. However, methods to investigate BBB permeability in vivo reported in the literature, are often associated with technical difficulties that depend on tedious and subjective quantification of fluorescence images17,18,19. Furthermore, some of the methods include whole brain fluorescence imaging that is fallacious as it more indicative of permeability of superficial brain vessels that do not form a tight barrier. Even when quantification has been performed based on the objective brain tissue absorbance (e.g. evans blue permeability assessment) the animals are often not perfused leading to erroneous interpretation due to significant blood fraction. Brain weight is another variable that is often not included in permeability calculations but needs to be as edema resulting from vascular permeability can increase the weight and alter the net permeability. Furthermore, sex and animal-to-animal brain weight variations can cloud permeability differences. Radioactive tracers such as 14C sucrose and [3H] inulin have been successfully applied for brain permeability index but do not offer the wide range of size and charge based permeability investigation as with fluorescently labeled tracers20.
For the above reasons, we adopted a method that is simple, objective and quantitative in estimating blood-brain barrier permeability in vivo in mice using fluorescently labeled tracers. Dextrans are hydrophilic polysaccharides characterized by their moderate-to-high molecular weight (3-200 kD) and can be obtained as charged or uncharged molecules based on the conjugated fluorophore. Endothelial tight junctions formed by mainly claudins (1, 3, 5 and 12) and occludin, together determine the paracellular size and charge selectivity by the charge pore residues present on their first extracellular loop (reviewed in21). Permeability across blood-brain barrier in vivo is also dependent upon glycocalyx and the basal lamina, two structures that are present on either side of the BBB22,23. Luminally present glycocalyx is a gel like structure formed by negatively charged oligosaccharides (heparin sulfates) that also acts as a barrier to blood-borne macromolecules such as albumin. Changes in the glycocalyx thickness or composition are also associated with vascular permeability changes as we observed in angiopoietin-2 gain of function mice compared to wild type mice10. The basement membrane on the other hand is present on the abluminal side of the endothelial cells comprising both the vascular basement membrane made by endothelial cells and pericytes whereas the parenchymal basement membrane or astrocytic basement membrane made by astrocytes. These basement membranes are also negatively charged and thus also have capacity to serve as charge barriers. In this regard, conjugated dextrans offer investigation of both size and charge-based permeability. For example, TMR-dextran 3 kD is anionic whereas TXR-dextran 3 kD is neutral, combining one of these tracers with a conjugated high molecular weight dextran such as FITC dextran 70 kD in the same mix injected to the mice, one could assess the size-based permeability. We further take advantage of the lysine-fixable nature of fluorescent-labeled dextrans to explore the regional differences in permeability in standard immunofluorescence staining. Dextrans also generally exhibit low immunogenicity and thus serve as good tracers. Lucifer yellow, cadaverine, fluorescein-5-thiosemicarbazide (FTSC), are among other tracers that are in the low molecular weight range (0.4-0.8 kD) and are fixable.
In our method, the tracers were injected by i.p route followed by perfusing the mice and obtaining the fluorescence of brain homogenates normalized to the wet weight and the serum fluorescence. This is a simple yet highly quantitative and objective method as there is no selection of sections/images as in quantification by immunofluorecence method that is classically used. We utilize only one hemi-brain for the permeability assay and utilize the other hemibrain for immunofluorescence staining by analyzing sagittal sections providing regional differences in the same animal. The use of each hemi-brain for distinct concurrent measurements is one of the main advantages in our protocol. Also, permeability of other organs such as kidneys, liver, etc. serves as a good internal control as the basal permeability is high in these organs. In order to compare 2 groups, one would have to first subtract the sham animal (that did not receive tracer injection) autofluorescence from all the animals in both groups and all the tissue types (kidney, brain, and serum) for each tracer and then proceed to normalized calculations comparing the 2 groups. The permeability index (PI) is presented that is obtained as a ratio of tissue to serum fluorescence normalized to tissue weight and serum volume. Our calculations yield an absolute value for the tracer permeability that can be compared between experiments and tissue types. These values however, can be easily expressed as ratios or percent between the 2 groups being compared as we have also done previously12. This can be achieved by dividing the PI of each animal in both the groups with the mean PI of all animals in the control group. This would drive the control group PI through 1 yet keeping the error between the animals and for the experimental group give values that are relative to the control group mean of 1.
Injection of tracers by i.p is easier, but more cost intensive compared to i.v injection, as the amount of tracer needs to be increased. Our data (not shown) in this regard indicates that nearly 2-fold higher amount in the tracer is required by i.p injection compared to i.v to obtain similar serum fluorescence values. Also, the time of circulation is higher in i.p route compared to i.v due to the time taken for tracer absorption into the blood stream. In this regard, serum fluorescence values at 15 min post i.p injection were comparable to 5 min post i.v injection for tracers in the low and medium molecular weight range between 0.4-4 kD (data not shown). We suggest a short circulation time because paracellular permeability is linear and if considerable tissue fluorescence is detected post perfusion after a short circulation time (15 min), it already indicates a permeability phenotype as we have reported in our previous publications10,12,13,14. Yet at the same time one could obtain the serum fluorescence for normalization. At longer circulation times, tissue clearance is considerable, which reduces serum fluorescence considerably and thus might impact permeability values normalized to serum. While the time of circulation in relation to the size/charge of the tracer has to be optimized for each scenario, we suggest a short circulation time as the starting point. This also applies to higher molecular weight solutes such as plasma IgGs and fibrinogen (150-400 kD) whose permeability characteristics are unlike inert dextran tracers due to their extremely large size and specific interaction with cellular receptors such as Fc receptors that change their half-life24. Dextrans on the other hand do not have any specific transport system at the endothelial level25 and as brain endothelial cells do not undergo pinocytosis to significant levels due to very low levels of plasmalemma vesicle associated protein (PLVAP)26, the main route of transport of dextrans is paracellular. We have applied the above method successfully in several scenarios such as permeability in transgenic mice compared to wild-type littermates and also assessed permeability changes in wild type mice after therapeutic intervention10,12,13,14. In summary, combined with the immunofluorescence staining, the permeability assay described here is a simple and a robust method to assess the permeability of mice in vivo that can be also applied to other small animals.