Proximal Cadaveric Femur Preparation for Fracture Strength Testing and Quantitative CT-based Finite Element Analysis

Summary

We present a robust protocol on how to carefully preserve and prepare cadaveric femora for fracture testing and quantitative computed tomography imaging. The method provides precise control over input conditions for the purpose of determining relationships between bone mineral density, fracture strength, and defining finite element model geometry and properties.

Abstract

Cadaveric fracture testing is routinely used to understand factors that affect proximal femur strength. Because ex vivo biological tissues are prone to lose their mechanical properties over time, specimen preparation for experimental testing must be performed carefully to obtain reliable results that represent in vivo conditions. For that reason, we designed a protocol and a set of fixtures to prepare the femoral specimens such that their mechanical properties experienced minimal changes. The femora were kept in a frozen state except during preparation steps and mechanical testing. The relevant clinical measures of total hip and femoral neck bone mineral density (BMD) were obtained with a clinical dual X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) bone densitometer, and the 3D geometry and distribution of bone mineral were obtained using CT with a calibration phantom for quantitative estimations based on the greyscale values. Any possible bone disease, fracture, or the presence of implants or artifacts affecting the bone structure, was ruled out with X-ray scans. For preparation, all bones were carefully cleaned of excess soft tissue, and were cut and potted at the internal rotation angle of interest. A cutting fixture allowed the distal end of the bone to be cut off leaving the proximal femur at a desired length. To allow positioning of the femoral neck at prescribed angles during later CT scanning and mechanical testing, the proximal femoral shafts were potted in polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) using a fixture designed specifically for desired orientations. The data collected from our experiments were then used for validation of quantitative computed tomography (QCT)-based finite element analysis (FEA), as described in a different protocol. In this manuscript, we present the protocol for the precise bone preparation for mechanical testing and subsequent QCT/FEA modeling. The current protocol was successfully applied to prepare about 200 cadaveric femora over a 6-year time period.

Introduction

Determining the true cadaveric proximal femoral fracture strength with mechanical testing is a destructive method that requires a rigorous testing approach for accurate measurements. In particular, proper bone preparation methods are necessary to maintain near in vivo integrity of the bones prior to mechanical fracture testing¹. This is achieved by proper bone storage and minimizing handling at room temperature. This test data is extensively used to validate QCT/FEA models of femoral fracture which have the potential to be used clinically to understand the fracture risk, especially in osteoporotic patients. Unfortunately, there is no ....

Protocol

NOTE: All studies presented in this protocol were approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) at Mayo Clinic. The bones were obtained over a period of 6 years from various organizations. All specimens were collected within 72 hours of death, wrapped in saline saturated towels, and stored at -20 °C until preparation.

1. Measuring Bone Mineral Density Using DXA

1. Remove specimens kept at -20 °C freezer to thaw at room temperature for about 24 h; specimens do not need to be removed from original packing if most soft tissue has been removed.
2. Use two 5 lb bags of rice to account for soft tissue. Cover the two r....

Results

The cadaveric femora were shipped frozen and maintained at -20 °C until preparation began. BMD scanning was performed using a DXA scanner to measure total hip and neck BMD as well as T-score for each specimen (Figure 1). A T-score is the number of standard deviations of the measured BMD compared to average values for young healthy subjects. It can range from -2.5 or lower for osteoporotic bones, between -1 and -2.5 for osteopenic bones and higher than -1 for normal bones........

Discussion

We presented a robust bone preparation protocol for ensuring mechanical testing and QCT/FEA modeling of femoral strength in a sideways fall on the hip configuration. This method became our standard in-house protocol. Over the course of 6 years, with varying personnel, about 200 femora were successfully prepared following this protocol. The outcomes of the protocol includes classifying bone conditions using DXA, ruling out metastatic diseases, previous fractures, or implants using X-ray, and obtaining mineral distribution.......

Materials

List of materials used in this article

Name	Company	Catalog Number	Comments
CT potting container and scanning fixture	Internally manufactured	N/A	Custom designed and manufactured
CT scanner	Siemens	Somatom Definition scanner (Siemens, Malvern, PA)	CT scanning equipment
Quantitative CT Phantom	Midways Inc, San Francisco, CA	Model 3 CT calibration Phantom	Used for obtaining BMD values from Hounsfield units in the CT image
Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry scanner	General Electric	N/A	GE Lunar iDXA scanner for bone health or any similar BMD scanners
Hygenic Orhodontic Resin (PMMA)	Patterson Dental Supply	H02252	Controlled substance and can be purchased with proper approval
Freezer	Kenmore	N/A	This is a -20 °C storage for bones
X-ray scanner	General Electric	46-270615P1	X-ray imaging equipment.
X-ray films	Kodak	N/A	Used to display x-ray images
X-ray developer	Kodak X-Omatic	M35A X-OMAT	Used for developing X-ray images
X-ray Cassette	Kodak X-Omatic	N/A	Used for holding x-ray films
5-pound Rice Bags	Great Value	N/A	Used for mimicking soft tissue during the DXA scanning process
Physiologic Saline (0.9% Sodium Chloride)	Baxter	NDC 0338-0048-04	Used for keeping samples hydrated
Scalpels and scrapers	Bard-Parker	N/A	Used to clean the bone from soft tissue
Cast cutter	Stryker	810-BD001	Used to cut femoral shaft
Drilling machine	Bosch	N/A	Used to drill the femoral shaft
Fume Hood	Hamilton	70532	Used for ventilation when using making PMMA