This study presents a simple two-dimensional angiographic method to examine fine vascular structures using a silicone rubber injection compound and soft tissue X-ray system.
Angiography is an essential tool for the study of vascular structures in various research fields. The aim of this study is to introduce a simple angiographic method for examining the fine vascular structure of unfixed, fresh tissue using a silicone rubber injection compound and soft tissue X-ray system. This study is especially focused on flap territories used in reconstructive surgery. This study employs angiography with a silicone rubber injection compound in various experimental conditions using Sprague-Dawley rats. First, 15 mL of MV compound and 15 mL of diluent is mixed. Then, 1.5 mL of the curing agent is prepared, and a 24G catheter is cannulated in the common carotid artery of the rat. A three-way stopcock is then connected to a catheter, and the radiopaque agent, after being mixed with the prepared curing agent, is injected immediately without spillage. Finally, as the agent solidifies, the specimen is harvested, and an angiographic image is obtained using a soft tissue X-ray system. This method indicates that high-quality angiography showing fine vascular structures can be easily and simply obtained within in a short period of time.
Examining vascular structures such as arteries and veins is an important area of interest, particularly in reconstructive surgery. In this field, flap surgery is widely performed. Therefore, angiographic imaging is actively used to study the flap territory, angiosome, and vascular supply of fresh tissue1. Specifically, there have been continuous efforts to observe the fine vasculature, including fine vessels such as perforators (vessels emerging from deep vessels reaching the skin), and choke vessels (connecting vessels between adjacent angiosomes)2. These two types of vessels are important in the perforator flap reconstruction field and are the main focus of the research3,4.
Various materials are used in angiography. First, there is India ink, which is helpful in observing the gross anatomy of blood vessels. However, it is radiolucent, so angiographic images cannot be obtained. The more commonly-used radiopaque materials are lead oxide and barium. However, toxicity is a crucial drawback of lead oxide, and it is inconvenient to use when mixed with water because of its powdered form. Barium is free from toxicity; however, it is not very feasible, as it should be used after dilution. Both of these radiopaque materials cannot cross capillaries; therefore, if a whole vascular structure must be analyzed, it is necessary to inject them into the artery and vein separately5. In addition, the two materials cause dye leakage during anatomical dissection, so they should be combined with gelatin. Lead oxide-gelatin and barium-gelatin mixtures take at least one day to solidify1,6,7.
Computed tomography (CT) angiography is another widely-used method and can aid in viewing three-dimensional (3D) structures8. However, veins cannot be visualized effectively5. In this modality, clear visualization of the fine vasculature such as choke veins is difficult, except when using specific equipment. The need for more expensive equipment can be a disadvantage, so CT angiography cannot be utilized in all laboratories. By contrast, the soft tissue X-ray system is relatively cheap and can operate more easily. This system is optimal for viewing soft tissues and can provide higher quality soft tissue images than the simple X-ray system. Although the soft tissue X-ray system itself cannot show 3D images, it can help visualize fine vascular structures more clearly than CT angiography. Therefore, we have used the soft tissue X-ray system in many experiments, particularly in various flap models and basic anatomy2,9.
Finally, the use of silicone rubber injection compound angiography has numerous advantages. Because various color agents are prepared, it can be injected and display distinguishable colors such as India ink. Therefore, simultaneously studying the gross anatomy and angiography is possible. It can both pass through capillaries and allow veins to be visualized, making examinations of fine vascular structures possible. Unlike the gelatin mixture, the silicone rubber injection compound solidifies within a short time period, approximately 15 minutes, without any additional procedures. The entire process is summarized in the schematic image in Figure 1.
All procedures, including animal subjects, have been approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees of Seoul National University Hospital (IACUC No. 10-0184). This protocol is optimized for research on flap vasculature. This example is based on a four-territory flap model in our previous reports.
1. Establishing a Flap Condition
NOTE: It is important to generate a vascular change in a rat flap model 4 to 5 days before visible estimation6,7.
2. Preparation of the Instruments
3. Rat Artery Preparation
4. Cannulation
5. Injection
6. Harvesting of Specimen
7. Capturing the Angiographic Image
8. Analyzing the Image6,7,11
Through following this protocol, the flap vascularity of the Sprague-Dawley rat was examined. A circumferential skin flap from the lower abdomen to the back that measured 4 x 12 cm was marked based on our previous reports. Each specimen was in a different vascular condition.
All the flaps were elevated based on the deep circumflex iliac artery (DCIA) and vein and then supercharged with arteries from various locations. Group 1 was the control, group 2 was supercharged with the ipsilateral superficial inferior epigastric artery (SIEA), group 3 was supercharged with the contralateral SIEA, and group 4 was supercharged with the contralateral DCIA. As a result, angiographs of each flap showed different patterns. If the entire flap was divided into four zones as the standard with the main vessel charging the flap territory, the angiographic agent has reached the main vessel that charges the next distal zone beyond the supercharging artery. The dilated choke vein was also observed, but not seen in normal skin angiography (Figure 2).
In other instances, silicone rubber injection angiography clearly showed fine vascular structures. Here, the method is advantageous because the rat vein is so thin and not easily visualized with angiography. High-quality angiographic images displayed dilated choke veins even in specific conditions looking at arterial supply and venous drainage from different sources (e.g., an artery such as the ipsilateral DCIA or vein such as the contralateral superficial inferior epigastric vein) (Figure 3).
Figure 1: Schema of the entire procedure. This panel shows the preparation of the desired flap condition beforehand and the performance of angiography 4 – 5 days later, using the following process: angiographic agent preparation, injection, specimen harvesting, and image capturing. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Typical angiography of flaps on postoperative day 4 in the rat skin flap. The normal skin represents the original four vascular territory flaps in the lower trunk area. The flap includes four vascular territories, including the bilateral deep circumflex iliac (DCI) and superficial inferior epigastric (SIE) vessel territories (yellow square). All groups have a common vascular pedicle, the deep circumflex iliac artery and vein (DCIA&V). Additionally, each flap has a different supercharging artery. Group 2 is supercharged with the ipsilateral superficial inferior epigastric artery (SIEA), group 3 is supercharged with the contralateral SIEA, and group 4 is supercharged with the contralateral DCIA. Group 4 shows different survived flap areas and angiographic patterns. Because the supercharging artery is distal to the original vascular pedicle (DIEA&V), the more distally located major vessel is contrasted by the agent (yellow arrow). Finally, the dilated choke veins that connect the vascular territories are visible (white arrowhead). i = ipsilateral; c = contralateral. Scale bar = 1 cm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Other representative results. The flap shown is supplied by the ipsilateral deep circumflex iliac artery (DCIA) and drained by the contralateral superficial inferior epigastric vein (SIEV). (Upper left) This panel shows the gross photography of the harvested flap. The ipsilateral side shows congestive change, but flap necrosis does not occur. The mid-portion and distal two-thirds of the flap show a complete survival. (Lower left) Angiography shows detailed fine vascular structure including the dilated choke vein, which connects the adjacent vascular territory. (Right) Magnified angiography distinguishes arteries (red arrowheads) and veins (blue arrowheads) by the continuity and diameter of vessels. In general, veins show larger diameters than arteries. DCIA = the deep circumflex iliac artery; SIEV = the superficial inferior epigastric vein; the white arrowhead = the dilated choke vein. Scale bar = 1 cm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Silicone rubber injection compound angiography can be performed easily, does not require expensive equipment, and offers many advantages. In contrast to the preoperative and intraoperative evaluations of patients, experiments using animals and cadavers can provide details on specific conditions, enabling more diverse and in-depth studies. The flap model using rats is particularly valuable to clinicians because changes in various contexts can be observed before clinical applications6,7,11. For example, when supercharging or superdrainage is applied to a long flap, which can resolve distal ischemic necrosis, predicting the outcome in the flap territory is possible; hence, it is possible to increase the survival of flaps by applying these techniques to clinical practice (Figure 2). In the case of cadaver dissection, gross anatomic and angiographic evaluations can be performed simultaneously, maximizing the cadaver's use12.
The silicone rubber injection compound is easier to handle than other radiopaque materials. Mixing the silicone rubber injection compound and diluent beforehand and adding the curing agent directly before injection are the primary processes involved. As with other imaging methods, care should be taken to avoid spillage during injection. To avoid spillage, we recommend using a secure tie and a three-way stopcock with a catheter after cannulation. If there is spillage, the specimen may become contaminated with the radiopaque agent, lowering its quality as an angiographic image. As discussed, the silicone rubber injection compound is advantageous in that it solidifies quickly after mixing it in, after about 15 min. However, the experiment is typically finished within this time. Therefore, we recommend mixing in only the amount needed for one rat at a time, even when performing multiple experiments. Performance of X-ray imaging after compound solidification should be done before the denaturation of the fresh tissue.
The molecular size of the silicone rubber injection compound is small enough to pass through the capillaries; therefore, there is no need to inject the agent into the vein separately, which is another advantage. On the contrary, the lead oxide-gelatin mixture or barium-gelatin mixture must be injected into veins separately for venous visualization. However, they cannot pass through valves in the veins, so it is necessary to perform serial cannulations and injections. The physiologic antegrade flow from artery to vein can be observed when using silicone rubber injection compounds, yet this characteristic is not observed when using other contrast agents.
Both arteries and veins can be contrasted with the silicone rubber injection compound and can be distinguished according to the continuity of flow and diameter (Figure 3). In general, veins show a relatively larger diameter.
One of the disadvantages of performing a 3D analysis using the soft tissue X-ray system is that it is more difficult than using CT angiography8. Although stereoscopic radiography can be achieved using the soft tissue X-ray system, it does not produce the high-quality 3D images seen in CT angiography13. However, it is still superior for visualizing fine vascular structures. This is particularly noticeable when using the soft tissue X-ray system rather than the plain X-ray system (Figure 3). At present, real-time CT angiography is used to observe 3D changes with time flow14,15. 3D real-time images cannot be achieved using only the soft tissue X-ray system, but real-time angiography can be achieved through serial imaging using the mobile C-arm system during the injection. Although its image quality is weaker than that of the soft tissue X-ray system for visualizing fine vascular structures, it can enable evaluation of dynamic changes in real time. We actively recommend this method to researchers who cannot utilize micro-CT or wish to conduct basic research on fine vascular structures such as small veins that are not effectively visualized by micro-CT.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work (2017R1A2B1006403) was supported by the Mid-Career Researcher Program through a National Research Foundation grant funded by the Korean government (Ministry of Science and ICT).
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-112 | White color agent |
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-117 | Orange color agent |
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-120 | Blue color agent |
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-122 | Yellow color agent |
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-130 | Red color agent |
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-132 | Clear agent |
MICROFIL Silicone Rubber Injection Compounds | Flow Tech Inc. | MV-Diluent | Diluent |
MICROFIL CP-101 For Cast Corrosion Preparations | Flow Tech Inc. | CP-101 | Curing agent |
SOFTEX X-ray film photographing inspection equipment | SOFTEX | CMB-2 | Soft tissue x-ray system |
Film | Fujifilm | Industrial X-ray Film (FR 12×16.5cm) | |
Automatic Development Machine | Fujifilm | FPM 2800 | |
Rat | Sprague-Dawley rat weighing 200-250 g | ||
Three-way stopcock | |||
24-guage catheter | |||
Image J | National Institutes of Health | https://imagej.nih.gov/ij/ |