The simulation of bacterial interaction with mechanosensitive host proteins such as VWF requires a perfusable cell culture system that enables the generation of a defined, unidirectional, and continuous flow of liquids, thereby generating reliable shear stress. Several microfluidic pump systems have already been described. A comprehensive review from Bergmann et al. summarizes the key aspects of different two- and three-dimensional cell culture models17.
The microfluidic technology is a very young technique started in the early 1990s with the development of controllable, reproducible, and perfusable microenvironments in a micrometer and even in a nanometer scale18. The presented microfluidic approach can also be applied to study the broad range of bacterial adhesion mechanisms and involved proteins. It is best suitable for any interaction that involves mechanoresponsive adhesion components such as VWF, which in general are not approachable using standard cell culture techniques. For example, it is known that the conformation of several extracellular matrix proteins differs depending on their location. Within the blood system, glycoproteins like fibronectin circulate in a globular conformation, whereas in the extracellular matrix the proteins appear as multiconnected di- and multimerized scaffold19,20. Moreover, several distributors of microfluidic equipment offer standardized channel slides precoated with different types of collagen (e.g., subendothelial collagens or other plasma-derived proteins). These channel slides are suitable for visualization and quantitative analyses of bacterial adhesion to specific extracellular matrix proteins in different flow situations.
Different microfluidic systems can be categorized based on the different materials used for microdevice production. In this regard, the glass/silicone-based platforms differ from the polymer-based and the paper-based platforms21. Polymer-based channel slides are produced with an elastically supported surface (ESS), generally require a surface coating for cell attachment during flow experiments. As an alternative to a coating with adhesion-supporting components such as collagen, the surface of some commercially available channel slides is physically modified, which creates a hydrophilic and adhesive surface suitable for most cell types. Moreover, some channel slides are generated using substrates like polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), which is oxygen-permeable and also enables the culture of blood vessel cells on the inner surface of microchannels in fluidic pump systems22,23.
The microfluidic system that was used in these studies served as an efficient and reliable system that was applied for the analysis the interaction of Staphylococcus aureus with multimerized VWF fibers after culture of human endothelial cells in flow24,25. This microfluidic system was a closed circular perfusion system that enabled the analysis of infection by pathogenic bacteria under biosafety 2 conditions. Moreover, the channel slides were suitable for microscopic monitoring during flow and are available with different precoatings (e.g., gelatin, poly-L-lysine, or collagen-IV) that ensure cell adhesion and a high degree of experimental reproducibility. This protocol uses a microfluidic system (see Table of Materials) for the establishment of a perfusable infection model for S. pneumoniae, thereby mimicking the flow situation within the human vascular system8.
The described general procedure of bacterial cell attachment in this microfluidic system can also be conducted with other types of pump systems generating a defined and continuous flow in a sterile environment. For microfluidic purposes, mainly four types of flow control systems are used: i) peristaltic pumps and recirculation pumps, which are used in this protocol, ii) syringe pumps, iii) pressure controllers, and iv) pressure controllers with flow switch matrices. Each kind of flow control system has advantages and drawbacks depending on the specific microfluidic application and the ability to carry out microscopic visualization in real time. In most applications requiring a continuous circulation of the samples, recirculation pumps are combined with software-based pressure controllers to ensure a defined flow situation. This is also optimized in the pump system demonstrated here. The syringe-based pump systems can be subdivided into “classic” syringe pumps, which generate flow oscillation, and “pulseless” microfluidic syringe pumps. These syringe pump-based systems are generally easy to use, but flow control in dead-end channels is challenging using syringe pumps. Moreover, flow changes inside the chip might take some time, and a flow meter is required to determine the flow rate. Even pulseless syringe pumps might generate periodic pulsation on the flow rate due to the step-by-step motor of the syringe pump. Another two syringe pump device is able to generate an “infuse and withdraw”-based fluidic movement that applies defined shear forces on cell surfaces and is suitable for microdialysis applications even in a PC-independent manner. This system must be combined with microtubing for connection of chambers or channel slides for cell cultivation followed by microscopic analyses.
The abovementioned pressure controllers are flow control systems that pressurize the tank containing the sample, which is smoothly injected in a microfluidic chamber or on a chip. The pressure controllers can establish a pulseless flow and also provide flow rates in combination with flow meters. A combination of pressure controllers with flow switch matrices enable a fast flow switch with no back flows. The recirculating system presented here enabled the generation of shear stress values typically reported for the human vascular system26. In vivo vascular wall shear stress has been estimated from wall shear rates as derived from non-invasively recorded velocity profiles, and whole blood viscosity in large arteries and plasma viscosity in arterioles26. Reneman and Hoeks recorded velocity profiles in large arteries by using a specially designed ultrasound system and in arterioles via optical techniques using fluorescent flow velocity tracers26. An average shear stress of 11-13 dyn/cm2 is reached in the carotid artery, as opposed to only 4-5 dyn/cm2 in the brachial artery. Peak values of up to 25-70 dyn/cm2 have been monitored for the carotid artery. The shear stress values of small and middle veins ranges between 0.1 and 0.5 dyn/cm2. In the microfluidic system described here, the applicable shear stress value depends on the selected perfusion tubing diameter, the height of the channel slide, and the viscosity of the fluidic medium used. The selected fluidic setting was composed of a slide with 0.4 cm in height (volume of 100 µl) in combination with a perfusion set of 50 cm in length and 1.6 mm in diameter and the medium viscosity was 0.0072 [dyn·s]/cm2. This setting is appropriate for a shear stress range between 3.5 and 31.2 dyn/cm2 at flow rates of 3.8−33.9 mL/min. In addition, the pressure pump software control can apply a pulsed medium flow that could mimic a pulsed arterial blood flow.
The successful, reliable, and reproducible use of this combined microfluidic infection method requires some precautions that must be kept in mind. During the infection process under microfluidic conditions, the cell layer might be exposed to cytotoxic or cytolytic bacterial compounds such as pneumolysin, which affect the eukaryotic cell viability and weaken the cell adherence to the slide surface. Therefore, keeping a constant flow is required throughout the whole course of the experiment and the integrity of the cell morphology must be frequently monitored. Moreover, the flow culture medium should provide all essential nutrients to the endothelial cells to ensure a tight surface attachment of the cells throughout the infection experiment. Nevertheless, it must be noted that medium supplements contain substances that might interfere or inhibit the interaction between the bacteria and specific host proteins. In studies of pneumococcus-VWF interaction for example, heparin must be depleted from the cell culture medium, because it inhibits the binding of pneumococci to VWF8.
Another critical step in flow culture of endothelial cells is the maintenance of tight cell adhesion, which depends on the overall cell vitality and on the level of differentiation. Shear flow-resistant cell adhesion of primary endothelial cells was only achieved when cells were strictly kept in subconfluency before exposure to shear stress. On the other hand, the production of WPB directly depends on the confluency of the endothelial cell layer promoting tight cell-cell-contacts13. The benefit of the microfluidic cell culture of primary endothelial cells covers the strongly induced cell proliferation that quickly leads to the formation of a confluent cell layer under flow conditions. The cells are tightly attached to each other, are collectively oriented in the direction of flow, and represent a highly differentiated phenotype that is required to produce secretory WPB. These WPB serve as storage vesicles for VWF, vasodilation activators, and cytokines that are exocytosed as protein bursts upon histamine stimulation or pneumolysin activity27,13. Therefore, the generation of a highly adhesive, confluent cell layer of differentiated primary endothelial cells in low proliferation passages is an indispensable prerequisite for efficient VWF release and the formation of VWF strings on the cell surface and the analyses of bacteria-VWF-interaction in flow conditions. Thus, it has to be noted that the differentiation of the endothelial cells took 48 h of flow cultivation at a minimum and required a constant shear flow without any variations in the pump pressure. Any variations might lead to a sudden medium blast, which would flush the cells out of the slide. Moreover, during microscopic visualization the microfluidic slide and the medium reservoirs of the pump system needed to be kept at a temperature of 37 °C as this represents the temperature optimum of the human cells.
Immortalized human cell lines are suitable for many scientific experiments and are often employed in cell culture infection studies. These cell lines share some general technical advantages, such as low or moderate culture requirements and unlimited proliferation, which enables passaging several hundred times without significant changes in morphology or receptor profiles. However, these cell lines represent a solitary monoculture and are subjected to artificial two-dimensional growth conditions.28 The missing physiological source tissue environment results in substantial changes of functional and morphological cell phenotype with every passage of the culture29. Prior to other bacterial adhesion experiments, the profile of surface-exposed cell-type specific marker proteins and receptors of human primary lung endothelial cells at different cell culture passages was determined. The flow cytometry analysis revealed a strongly reduced expression of specific surface proteins such as the platelet endothelial cell adhesion molecule 1 (PECAM1) within eight rounds of cell passaging. Moreover, the expressed integrin receptor profile was significantly changed in higher cell passages in favor of a cell type-unspecific integrin receptor pattern and a reduced cell type-specific integrin receptor pattern (Bergmann et al., unpublished data). These results are particularly relevant for analyses of pathogen-host interactions in infection biology studies. With the aim of sustaining the phenotypic cell characteristics and a high level of functional differentiation during microfluidic cell culture at the time of bacterial infection, primary endothelial cells from multiple donors were chosen in this case and used only up to five passages at maximum in order to keep the phenotypic characteristics as specific as possible8.
The combined visualization of bacteria and specific cell surface structures during flow requires an optimized fluorescence staining protocol. Using different combinations of directly labelled proteins, fluorescence protein-expressing bacteria, and fluorescence-conjugated antibodies, immunofluorescence staining procedures can be specifically adapted to the visualization targets. These procedures enable a defined and clear microscopic visualization and also a differentiation and quantification of bacterial adherence and internalization3,13,30,31. The immunofluorescence-based detection of internalized bacteria requires a cell permeabilization step such as a short Triton X-100 incubation, which might lead to cell detachment. Therefore, the detection of bacterial internalization processes occurring in a flow culture should be visualized after flow incubation using PFA-crosslinked samples. For real time visualization of bacteria in flow, the use of genetically modified bacteria expressing fluorescence proteins enables a quick and targeted microscopic detection. RFP-expressing pneumococcus strains that were generated using an efficient genetic construct designed by Kjos and Veening16,8 were used in this experimental study. For detection of VWF strings in flow, different VWF-specific fluorescein-labelled antibodies were tested and could be used. To obtain an optimal signal response at a minimized unspecific background, the adequate antibody concentration was consistently titrated for each applied antibody.
For microscopic live cell imaging, the fluidic unit and the channel slide are removed from the CO2 incubator and placed into a chamber prewarmed to 37 °C at the microscope. This chamber could not be adjusted to 5% CO2. Without a carbonate-buffered atmosphere, HUVEC morphology and bacterial fitness remained intact for up to 180 min, which is enough for analysis of VWF-mediated bacterial adherence. If longer infection times and microscopic monitoring outside of a CO2 incubator are required, a buffered cell culture medium should be used in order to compensate for pH shifts due to inadequate CO2 concentration. Alternatively, the whole system could be placed back into the CO2 incubator in between the steps of a time series of microscopic visualization.
In addition to the fluorescence detection in real time, the bacterial infection of the endothelium within the channel slide can be stopped and preserved by medium exchange with paraformaldehyde (PFA) as a fixation substance. After fixation in the flow, the optimized and stepwise immunofluorescence staining of the cell surface within the channel slide enables the generation of valuable microscopic snapshot visualizations and provides a versatile combined structure detection of specific cellular compounds involved in the interaction between bacteria and host cells. The scientific benefit of this combined method is that the PFA-treated channel slide can be stored and used for a post-flow immunofluorescence staining of the structures of interest. The PFA treatment inactivates the bacteria and thus arrests the expression of RFP-protein. Therefore, a pneumococcus-specific antiserum was generated in rabbit for bacterial immune detection and visualization was performed using a rabbit-specific AlexaFluor568-conjugated secondary antibody8. As already mentioned, the use of different antibody combinations requires an exact optimization of antibody amounts and the blocking buffer composition. Otherwise, unspecific background signals and cross-detection effects might lead to artificial staining results. An optimized immunofluorescence staining procedure can easily be used for the detection of many different cellular targets such as the actin cytoskeleton or endosomal markers13,31.
This procedure can be adapted to create a more complex tissue environment that mimics physiology from a histologic, physiological, and functional point of view. The presented infection analyses can be efficiently used to answer several scientific questions at the same time by using an in line-connection of several channel slides to one perfusion set. This extended set up would facilitate the analyses of different cell types, cell confluences, and different slide-coatings within the same flow setting in parallel and allow a direct comparison of bacterial infections of different cell types. Moreover, the serial in line connection and combined analyses of several channel slides also provides the possibility of time series experiments, which can be applied for gene expression profiling (e.g., the analysis of infection time-dependent virulence factor gene expression).
The infection analyses can also be extended to a constant laminar flow condition lasting several days or even weeks in order to analyze cellular response in conditions mimicking a long-term chronic infection phase. In addition to the presented single-cell type culture, some examples of heterotypic cell culture in microfluidic cell culture devices have already been reported32,33. This allows for high throughput pharmacological studies and might ultimately result in using microfluidic cell culture systems for regenerative purposes as well34.
In summary, the microfluidic system in combination with immune staining procedures served as a valuable model for the analysis of pathomechanisms between bacteria and host cells in an environment that simulates the conditions within the vascular system.