Following the protocol describe above, the sensitivity of the pan-lyssavirus RT-PCR was demonstrated on a dilution series of the control standard virus (CVS) (Figure 1) and a range of other lyssaviruses (Figure 2 and Figure 3). SYBR Green I dye was utilized as a universal one-step RT-PCR, where cDNA synthesis and PCR amplification are carried out in a single tube. As the amplification of the specific target occurs, more dye is bound, resulting in real-time increased levels of fluorescence. All dye intercalating real-time assays must be interpreted in two phases: amplification and dissociation. The amplification phase is identical to any real-time amplification (Figure 1A). There is a linear ‘early phase’ during the early cycles where DNA amplification cannot be calculated due to insufficient signal in relation to the background. The length of this is directly related to the amount of target in the sample. Subsequently, there is an exponential phase where the doubling of DNA molecules is detected and recorded. Finally, the plateau phase is reached (apart from the highly diluted samples which may not reach this phase before the end of the program). In this phase, the intensity of fluorescence levels out, due to the exhaustion of reagents. The amplification plots observed using a 10-fold serial dilution of CVS, conformed to the expected plots (Figure 1A,C) where the lyssavirus assay demonstrated a higher sensitivity than the ß-actin assay. The dissociation curve was calculated after amplification, where the dsDNA was dissociated into ssDNA by an incremental increase in temperature and the fluorescence monitored as a function of temperature (Figure 1B, D-F). The threshold temperature at which the specific amplicon dissociates into ssDNA, caused a release of fluorescence, which was measured by the thermocycler software (Tm). This dissociation phase provided data on the amplicon size, enabling the user to interpret the result in comparison to a positive control, resulting in a negligible likelihood of false-positive results. The Tm observed for CVS using the pan-lyssavirus assay (Figure 1B) and ß-actin assay (Figure 1D) are distinct, and aided the user to confirm the correct assay analysis by noting the Tm obtained (Figure 1E). Furthermore, the Ct and Tm values between runs and operators was assessed and shown to be reproducible (Table 5). The threshold used to calculate the Ct value was calculated automatically by the software and dependent on many factors, including the reaction mix or instrument used. Over the 12 independent runs the mean Ct was 20.66 (SD 0.63) for the lyssavirus assay and 27.5 (SD 1.13) for the ß-actin assay. In contrast the variation observed in the Tm values was markedly lower, due to the lack of external influences on this measurement. For example, the mean Tm for the CVS lyssavirus assay was 78.92 (SD 0.16) (Table 5), when compared to the mean of all lyssaviruses 78.81 °C (SD 0.531) (Table 6 and Figure 1F). This lack of variation in the Tm across the Lyssavirus genus is advantageous as the same control RNA can be used irrespective of the lyssavirus in the sample, however differentiating between the lyssavirus species using the Tm is not possible, particularly because different RABV sub-lineages spanned the range of Tm values observed (Table 6). Non-specific amplification plots are rarely observed with this assay; however, specific parameters to define a positive result vs. a non-specific negative result are required. The SD observed across all lyssaviruses (0.531) was applied to the lowest (77.34 - LBVa) and highest (79.67 - IKOV) observed Tm values to set a range 76.8 °C - 80.2 °C for positive specific bands. Therefore, Tm values outside this range were considered non-specific and therefore a negative result. Occasionally multiple peaks are observed for a sample. If the dominant peak is at the correct Tm (for each replicate) then the sample is considered positive. The most common reason a non-specific peak is observed is due to primer-dimers, the assay has been optimized to minimize primer dimers. Primer dimers typically result in an amplicon smaller than that of the target sequence, therefore would have a Tm lower than the specific product.
A 10-fold serial dilution of three lyssavirus positive brain sample RNAs extracted using TRIzol, were run in parallel and plotted (Figure 2). The limit of detection for the three lyssaviruses varied, but none exceeded Ct 36. The R2 coefficient values for the viruses plotted in Figure 2 ranged from 0.9637 and 0.996. For all viruses analyzed (Table 6) the range did not exceed this, furthermore, 7 of the 29 lyssavirus had R2 >0.99 (data not shown). Taking into account that the preparation of the dilution series is from total RNA extractions, the linearity observed provides evidence that the assay is robust. Finally, detection of all lyssavirus species (particularly the most diverse phylogroup III viruses) was investigated using a panel of RNAs spanning all three phylogroups in the Lyssavirus genus. RNA extracted from either original, or experimentally infected mice, brain material, was utilized using the protocols described above. The results confirm that the primers amplify all lyssavirus species, including the divergent phylogroup III lyssaviruses IKOV, WBCV and LLEBV (Table 6 and Figure 3). A diverse panel of non-lyssavirus rhabdoviruses, originally collected and analyzed antigenically16, and more recently genetically17 were screened and no-cross reactivity was detected, indicating that the primers are specific for members of the Lyssavirus genus only (data not shown). The pan-lyssavirus real-time assay has been included in the EURL (EU Reference Laboratory) inter-laboratory proficiency schemes since 2013, demonstrating 100% concordance with other molecular assays such as the pan-lyssavirus TaqMan assay and the conventional RT-PCR assay in addition to the FAT (Fluorescent Antibody test).

Figure 1: 10-fold serial dilution of CVS positive control RNA, run on the pan-lyssavirus RT-PCR assay, visualized as the amplification plot (A), and dissociation curve (B), and run on the ß-actin RT-PCR assay visualized as the amplification plot (C), and dissociation curve (D). NTC = no template control. Comparison of the CVS control RNA run on both the pan-lyssavirus RT-PCR assay (blue) and the ß-actin RT-PCR assay (red) demonstrating the difference in dissociation curves (E) — see Table 5 for mean values; and finally dissociation curves for LBVa (blue) and IKOV (red) demonstrating the range of Tm values observed across the Lyssavirus genus (F). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 2: 10-fold serial dilutions for three lyssavirus species: RABV (RV108), DUVV (RV131) and ARAV (RV3379). R2 = 0.996, 0.9962 and 0.9637 respectively. Data points at 10-7 (0.0001 ng/µL) reached the limit of detection (where a value was obtained). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 3: Representative 10-fold serial dilution data from across the Lyssavirus genus (see individual legends for lyssavirus identity and Table 6 for tabulated results in comparison to other lyssaviruses). Panels A, C, E, G amplification plots and B, D, F, H dissociation curves for A, C, E, and G respectively. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
| Reagent | μL/Reaction |
| Molecular grade water | 7.55 |
| 2x Universal RT PCR reaction mix | 10 |
| Primer Forward [20 μM] | 0.6 |
| Primer Reverse [20 μM] | 0.6 |
| RT enzyme mix | 0.25 |
| Total per reaction | 19 |
Table 1: Pan-lyssavirus real-time RT-PCR master mix reagents.
| Assay | Primer name | Primer role | Sequence 5’-3’ | Position1 |
| Lyssavirus | JW12 | RT-PCR | ATG TAA CAC CYC TAC AAT G | 53-73 |
| N165 | PCR | GCA GGG TAY TTR TAC TCA TA | 165-146 |
| ß-actin | ß-actin intronic | PCR | CGA TGA AGA TCA AGA TCA TTG | 1051-1072 |
| ß-actin reverse | RT-PCR | AAG CAT TTG CGG TGG AC | 1204-1188 |
| Primer positions are given in relation to Pasteur virus sequence (M13215) and mouse ß-actin gene sequence (NM_007393) |
Table 2: Pan-lyssavirus real-time RT-PCR primer details.
| Stage | Cycles | Temperature | Time | Data Collection |
| Reverse Transcription | 1 | 50 °C | 10 min | |
| RT inactivation/initial denaturation | 1 | 95 °C | 5 min | |
| Amplification | 40 | 95 °C | 10 s | |
| 60 °C | 30 s | end point |
| Dissociation curve analysis | 1 | 9 °C | 1 min | |
| 55 °C | 1 min | |
| 55 - 95 °C | 10 s | all points |
Table 3: Pan-lyssavirus real-time RT-PCR cycling conditions.
| Test Result | Internal ß-actin control | Overall result |
| Negative | Negative1 | Invalid. Repeat extraction and assay2 |
| Negative | Positive | Negative result reported |
| Positive | Positive | Positive result reported |
| Positive | Negative1 | Repeat extraction and assay3 |
| 1Use of heterologous external control would be beneficial during repeat extraction. |
| 2 If a second negative result is obtained for the internal control, the sample will be reported as untestable by this assay. |
| 3 If a second negative result is obtained for the internal control, alongside a positive test result a secondary rabies |
| diagnostic test should be undertaken to confirm this result. |
Table 4: Summary of outcomes and overall results for pan-lyssavirus real-time RT-PCR. Negative is designated to a sample with no Ct value (amplification) and no melt temperature (dissociation), or a melt temperature which is outside of the Tm range for positive lyssaviruses (76.8 °C - 80.2 °C). Positive is designated to a sample with a Ct value (amplification) and a melt temperature (dissociation) which is inside of the Tm range for positive lyssaviruses.
| Lyssavirus assay | ß-actin assay |
| Ct | Tm | Ct | Tm |
| Mean | 20.66 | 78.92 | 27.5 | 85.26 |
| SD | 0.63 | 0.16 | 1.13 | 0.35 |
| LCL (95%) | 19.39 | 78.59 | 25.23 | 84.56 |
| UCL (95%) | 21.93 | 79.25 | 29.76 | 85.96 |
Table 5: Inter-run analysis of CVS positive control across 12 independent runs including multiple operators.
| Phylogroup | Species | Virus ID | Lineage | Limit of detection | Tm |
| I | RABV | RV50 | US bat | 10-5 | 79.5 |
| I | RABV | RV51 | US Fox | 10-7 | 77.6 |
| I | RABV | RV108 | Chile bat | 10-7 | 78.63 |
| I | RABV | RV313 | European Fox | 10-9 | 78.53 |
| I | RABV | RV437 | European RacDog | 10-7 | 78.09 |
| I | RABV | RV1237 | European Deer | 10-8 | 78.76 |
| I | RABV | RV334 | Chinese Vaccine | 10-8 | 79.03 |
| I | RABV | RV102 | Africa 2 | 10-7 | 78.58 |
| I | RABV | RV995 | Africa 3a | 10-8 | 79.66 |
| I | RABV | RV410 | Africa 3b | 10-7 | 79.03 |
| I | RABV | RV2324 | Africa 4 | 10-7 | 79.17 |
| I | RABV | RV2417 | Sri Lanka Dog | 10-9 | 78.71 |
| I | RABV | CVS-11 | | 10-7 | 79.17 |
| I | EBLV-1 | RV20 | Germany | 10-6 | 79.05 |
| I | EBLV-2 | RV1787 | UK | 10-7 | 78.76 |
| I | BBLV | RV2507 | Germany | 10-9 | 78.71 |
| I | ABLV | RV634 | | 10-8 | 78.25 |
| I | DUVV | RV131 | | 10-5 | 79.03 |
| I | GBLV | RV3269 | | 10-7 | 79.15 |
| I | ARAV | RV3379 | | 10-7 | 79.46 |
| I | KHUV | RV3380 | | 10-7 | 78.97 |
| I | SHIBV | RV3381 | | 10-7 | 78.59 |
| I | IRKV | RV3382 | | 10-3 | 78.59 |
| II | LBVa | RV767 | | 10-5 | 77.34 |
| II | LBVd | RV3383 | | 10-7 | 78.59 |
| II | MOKV | RV4 | | 10-3 | 78.81 |
| III | IKOV | RV2508 | | 10-5 | 79.67 |
| III | LLEBV | RV3208 | | 10-4 | 79.15 |
| III | WCBV | RV3384 | | 10-3 | 79 |
Table 6: Summary of pan-lyssavirus real-time RT-PCR specificity, sensitivity and Tm for representative lyssaviruses across all three phylogroups. The mean Tm across lyssaviruses was 78.81 (SD 0.531).