The Ussing chamber method was first developed by the Danish scientist Hans Ussing. Ussing first used it to measure the short-circuit current of sodium transport across frog skin after it was observed that NaCl could be transported across the skin against a steep concentration gradient1. His system consisted of the frog skin mounted between two chambers with access to either side of the skin. Each chamber contained Ringer's solution which was circulated and aerated. Two narrow agar ringer bridges situated near the skin and connected to saturated KCl-calomel electrodes measured the potential difference as read by a potentiator. A second pair of agar ringer bridges were situated at the opposite end of each chamber connected to beakers with saturated KCl saturated with AgCl to apply an electromotive force provided by a battery. A potential divider was used to adjust the voltage so that the potential difference across the skin remained zero, thus creating short-circuit conditions. A microampere meter was also connected to read the current passing through the skin (see the figure in ref.1 for original chamber design).
Over the past 70 years, this technique has been applied to many different tissues, particularly intestinal tissue, to study nutrient and ion transport. For example, the mechanism of cholera-induced diarrhea was studied by mounting rabbit ileum in these chambers, and it was found that cholera toxin-induced diarrhea is mediated by cAMP2. In addition, these chambers were also used to study the mechanism underlying glucose transport via Na+-Glucose cotransporter 1 (SGLT1)3. Our lab focuses on transcellular and paracellular transport in intestinal epithelial cells. Using the Ussing chamber method, peptide transport was assessed in Claudin 15 knockout mice, which have impaired paracellular sodium transport, using Ussing chambers to measure the absorption of the nonhydrolyzable dipeptide glycylsarcosine. It was found that luminal Na+ homeostasis is important for proton-coupled peptide transport4. In addition, these chambers were also used to investigate anion secretion in the murine cecum in response to submucosal activation of proteinase activated receptor 1 by the serine protease trypsin5.
Ussing chambers have also recently been used to assess the paracellular pathways in epithelial tissue. Paracellular pathways are regulated by tight junctions, which are complexes of proteins that form at the point where two or more cells meet6. The barrier function and ion selectivity (whether anions or cations are selectively able to pass through the tight junction) is determined by the presence of claudin family proteins; some of which act as barriers (claudin 3 and 7), anion pores (claudin 10a), or cation pores (claudin 2, 10b, and 15)7. Other methods have been used to assess the paracellular pathway, such as oral gavage of FITC accompanied by blood plasma FITC concentration8, or EDTA-Cr9; however, these techniques are of lower resolution and cannot assess ion selectivity or a specific section of the sections of the intestinal tract. Ussing chambers, however, can be used to assess the dilution potential of target ions, and, therefore, determine the ion selectivity of the tight junctions. For example, with NaCl, the selectivity of the tight junctions for Na+ and Cl- can be calculated by diluting one side of the membrane (usually the mucosal side) and measuring the change in transepithelial potential difference. The relative permeabilities of Na+ and Cl- can be estimated by the Goldman-Hodgkin-Katz equation10 and the selectivity of the tight junction can be estimated using the Kimizuka-Koketsu equation11. These chambers, therefore, have the advantage of measuring the electrophysiological parameters of tissue and as a result provide more information about the passage of ions through the tight junctions than other lower resolution methods.
The Ussing chamber method is not only limited to the intestinal tract, although it is widely used in studies concerning the intestine, it has many other applications as well. For example, these chambers have been used to study Cystic Fibrosis, and specifically the chloride channel cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR)12. Cystic Fibrosis is caused by a mutation in CFTR13, which results in impaired chloride secretion and fluid transport by respiratory epithelial cells, and a resulting thicker, drier mucous layer14. Study of airway epithelial CFTR has been performed with these chambers to not only understand the disease, but to discover ways to treat the disease. For example, in patients with rare mutations causing Cystic Fibrosis, analysis of patient respiratory epithelial cells has been used to test therapies such as Orkambi and an amplifier co-therapy15.
Ussing chambers have also been used to study routes of drug delivery, such as with human biopsy tissue to study drug uptake and pharmacokinetics16. Intestinal uptake is not the only route of drug delivery. These chambers have also been used to study nasal drug delivery systems17. Drug delivery studies with Ussing chambers have also been performed for the eye. In the rabbit cornea, permeability and uptake studies were conducted with Labrasol, a drug that is designed to increase the absorption of drugs across tissues18. Another study examined the effect of benzylalkonium chloride on transscleral drug delivery in the rabbit sclera19.
The Ussing chamber method is useful because native tissue can be used. As such, it is preferable over in vitro models such as Caco-2 cell lines. However, the technique requires skill and time to prepare specimens, so it is not suitable for high throughput applications. The electrophysiological properties of cell monolayers can be studied using cell culture inserts in these chambers. Recent discoveries have allowed for the culture of organoids which are mini-organs grown in culture from the harvest of epithelial or endothelial stem cells20. Organoid culture can be manipulated to be grown in a monolayer, thereby making it possible to mount organoids in an Ussing chamber21. Organoids of various epithelial and endothelial tissues can be studied, lowering the number of animals required, as organoid culture can be maintained long term. This will also increase the throughput since time consuming and laborious tissue dissection and preparation steps will not be needed. In the future, Ussing chamber studies will continue to be very useful for studying tissue transport and they will be especially important in the field of personalized medicine.
The following protocol demonstrates the application of the Ussing chamber method to assess the permselectivity and barrier function of the tight junctions in the small intestine of Claudin 15 knockout (Cldn15-/-) mice and wild type (WT) controls by measuring the dilution potential of NaCl. Tight junctions (TJ) are formed at the point where two or more cells meet in epithelial and endothelial tissue. Bicellular tight junctions (bTJ), particularly the claudin family proteins found within the bTJ, are thought to determine the barrier function and permselectivity of TJ7. Cldn15-/- mice have a mega small intestine22 and reduced nutrient uptake capability due to the loss of intestinal Na+ recycling that occurs via claudin 154,23,24. Cldn15-/- mice have impaired Na+ homeostasis, which makes them an interesting model for studying the permselectivity of the TJ. The following protocol assesses the permeability of the TJ to NaCl by measuring the dilution potential of NaCl (PNa/PCl) in the middle small intestine. Briefly, the change in membrane potential difference that occurs by diluting one side of the membrane (M side or S side, both are measured in the below protocol) can be used to calculate the permeability of Na+ (PNa) and Cl- (PCl), and the dilution potential (PNa/PCl) will show whether the tight junction has a cationic or anionic selectivity.
The experiments in this protocol were conducted using a customized Ussing chamber (Figure 1A), which consists of two halves, between which the intestinal preparation is mounted vertically, voltage clamp amplifier, electrical recorder, electrodes, salt bridges, Ringer's solution, HEPES buffer (150 mM NaCl), diluted HEPES buffer (75 mM NaCl), intestinal preparation (for details about equipment see the Table of Materials).